5 ms·
First item: "How can Lindzen, a member of the National Academies be wrong about the consensus?" Which is followed by an appeal to authority. Most of the follo
by hga 17y ago
First item: "How can Lindzen, a member of the National Academies be wrong about the consensus?"
Which is followed by an appeal to authority. Most of the following is appeals to authority, attacks on his funding (necessarily from eeevil sources since "the consensus" has halted funding to "deniers"), complaints about his not have current peer reviewed papers (see previous item), etc.
Sorry, but if we're talking real science, all he needs is an inconvenient fact to demolish the consensus (which is not quite what is being argued here; his point is that there isn't really a consensus, which it demonstrably true).
There are some attempts to deal with what he says on a basis of facts and the like (although some of them are appeals to the authority of the web site, e.g. general claims without references that would allow you to judge for yourself), but the site's dishonest style doesn't exactly encourage you to bother to see if it's telling the truth in those instances.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIf someone is arguing that there is no consensus of opinion (second sentence on the page: "He is rather well known for claiming that "There's no consensus on global warming.""), then long lists of prominent institutions who have subscribed to that opinion isn't an appeal to authority, it's relevant info.
- hga 17y agoWithout lists of those on the other side, its relevance is limited. Insert, oh, the former "consensus" against heliocentrism. Relevant in a period calling for capital trials against "deniers" and HN commentators calling for their criminal prosecution (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1283240 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1283240).
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoWell at least we've established that it's not an appeal to authority. Of course if it was, then this is a fairly convincing set of authorities, being the National Academy of Science in the US and their equivalents in the 12 largest countries in the world. Who's missing that could even theoretically be on the other side? South Korea, Mexico, Spain? I have no idea who would rank up there with them but if I had to bet I'd say their national bodies representing science are going to be on the same side of the debate as those listed. Again, this is someone who denies there is a consensus. That's relatively easy to fact check. It would be like knowing whether the church was for or against the Sun orbiting the Earth. It's an entirely seperate question from whether that position is factually correct. And, if you can't get that right why trust you on anything more complex?
- hga 17y agoAn appeal to a "consensus" is by definition an appeal to authority. It has nothing to do with theory or data, it's not science, it's science policy. As Jerry Pournelle said, "Science policy is to science as birdshot is to birds."
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoWe're going in circles now. I can claim that 60% of US citizens believe in angels and cite surveys to back that claim up. You can argue about whether that fact is correct with or without a personal belief in angels. If someone (perhaps someone with an axe to grind for or against the existence of angels) simply refused to accept that evidence of 60% belief and provided nothing in return, then that alone would make them a dubious source to me. This whole thread started with your confusion of a list of prominant subscribers to global warming which was offered as proof of consensus with it being proof of the consensus position itself. Let's not end in the same place we started.
- billswift 17y agoActually, I think it was Dr Petr Beckman that originally said that in the early 1970s.
- hga 17y agoA quick check with Google indicates you're right, and that's the sort of thing he certainly would have said back in that period. Thanks for the correction.
- applicative 17y agoI was not aware that it was possible for an institution to have an opinion.
- jellicle 17y ago"his point is that there isn't really a consensus, which it demonstrably true" Not at all. You can search through the peer-reviewed papers in vain for any saying there isn't any anthropogenic climate change; there are no such papers. None. Zero. http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/306/5702/1686 http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/306/5702/1686
- hga 17y agoA 6 year old paper is limited in its utility, especially since the CRU email leak confirmed that the "alarmists" have been systematically keeping the other side out of the peer-reviewed literature.
- cgranade 17y ago[citation needed] All joking aside, the CRU e-mail hack revealed no such thing. To say otherwise is either ignorant or dishonest.
- hga 17y agoA little quality time with searches like http://www.google.com/search?q=redefine+peer+review+site%3Awww.eastangliaemails.com http://www.google.com/search?q=redefine+peer+review+site%3Aw... will provide all the citations needed. Here's the ones I can find in a few minutes with just the phrases I can remember off the top of my head and one or two leads from those: Phil Jones to Michael Mann: "I can't see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep them out somehow - even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is !" http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=419&filename=1089318616.txt http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=419&filen... From Mann (http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=295 http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=295): "The Soon & Baliunas paper couldn't have cleared a 'legitimate' peer review process anywhere. That leaves only one possibility--that the peer-review process at Climate Research has been hijacked by a few skeptics on the editorial board. [...] The skeptics appear to have staged a 'coup' at 'Climate Research'...." [...] "This was the danger of always criticising the skeptics for not publishing in the 'peer-reviewed literature'. Obviously, they found a solution to that--take over a journal! So what do we do about this? I think we have to stop considering 'Climate Research' as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal." The end result was that half the editorial board resigned, I think all "non-skeptics". Two quoted items in one email (http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=484 http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=484); first this from Mann: "It's one thing to lose 'Climate Research'. We can't afford to lose GRL. I think it would be useful if people begin to record their experiences w/ both Saiers and potentially Mackwell (I don't know him--he would seem to be complicit w/ what is going on here)." Followed by a Tom Wigley writing to I think Mann: "If you think that [GRL editor] Saiers is in the greenhouse skeptics camp, then, if we can find documentary 1evidence of this, we could go through official AGU channels to get him ousted." And then nearly a year later Mann reports Mission Accomplished: "The GRL leak may have been plugged up now w/ new editorial leadership there...." http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=591 http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=591 Saiers was in fact removed from dealing with the paper in question, although he insists he wasn't himself ousted: http://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2009/11/grl-and-james-saiers.html http://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2009/11/grl-and-james-saie... Anyway, that's what I can find from the original sources in 15 minutes. There's a lot more, "The Truth Is Out There".