6 ms·
BART janitor grossed $270K in pay and benefits last year
- sweettea 10y agoSomeone figured out how to optimize their exchange of labor for money. I'm very happy for them, and hope we can all make such great exchanges. This fellow sounds like a real go-getter, and we need more such inspirational people.
- ayuvar 10y agoThe real disappointment here is that more people aren't paid proportionally to the amount of time they put in to their jobs.
- WalterBright 10y agoPeople are more or less paid for what they produce, how much time they spend at it is immaterial. (Despite ostensibly being paid by the hour, the rate is based on the expected value they'll produce in that time.) The idea of pay for time is the Labor Theory of Value, and is discredited.
- arjie 10y agoThat's hardly a disappointment. A plumber who takes 4 days to fix my problem is a worse plumber than one who takes an hour. I can't imagine paying the first guy more.
- Johnny555 10y agoIf he were working at a private organization, I'd say "good for him" - but since he's working for an essential public agency that receives significant tax funding then it's a little less equitable when the janitor earning $40K/year at a small office in SOMA is paying taxes and BART fares to help pay someone in his same position 5 times higher salary. That doesn't mean that the employee is to blame, this is purely a problem with BART management -- instead of paying one person 4X normal salary for a job (even if he's working 100 hours/week, that's still "only" 2.5 times a single worker), they should have hired 4 workers for that job, or if it's transient work that doesn't need a full time worker, then hire a contractor(s).
- pech0rin 10y agoNot sure it's a comparable job. Working at a small office is Soma is a much better gig than Bart. You would definitely have to pay me at least 4x more to work there than a small office job.
- Johnny555 10y agoIndeed.com says the average janitor earns $28K in SF, I'm sure there are plenty of those janitors that would take a $50K+ job at BART. http://www.indeed.com/salary?q1=janitor&l1=san+francisco&tm=1 http://www.indeed.com/salary?q1=janitor&l1=san+francisco&tm=...
- kamaal 10y agoThis might be both good and bad news, based on how you look. If one can overtime their way to 2-4x avg salary, so can anybody. The question is do you want to. If the answer is no, blaming the guy working hard to make 4x the base salary is unfair. Plus there is no social contract that if one worker makes less, so should others. You can't force people to be lazy, you can't force them to be hardworking. A lot of times the world is fair, and you get what you deserve.
- sidlls 10y agoInstead of expressing a more appropriate sentiment for members of the lower class--that it's shameful somebody who is highly skilled doesn't earn as much as an unskilled laborer--many people in this thread only express anger at "waste" or "undeserved" remuneration. It's one of the best illustrations of the "temporarily embarrassed millionaire" problem in America I've seen in a while. And make no mistake: almost everybody commenting in this thread is a member of the lower classes, even those of us pulling down six-figure salaries in the high $100k-$200k range. That some of us are relatively higher than others is immaterial to the immense wealth commanded by those in the class above ours. We have far more in common with the "lowly" janitor than these elites have with us.
- eachro 10y agoThis article doesn't give us enough information. How many hours overtime did he work? How many hours a week? How much pay gets doled out to janitors? Etc.
- NhanH 10y agoWorking 100 hours week mean that he's earning at the same rate of someone working 40 hours/week for 100k. Realistically unless the job is dangerous (which it could very well be, I don't know), I think it works out to be a good deal.
- xienze 10y agoIf BART is like other public sector jobs in California, his pension will be based on some percentage of his average pay, including overtime, for his last few years of employment. Say hello to the $200K per year retired janitor. Yeah, California won't have a pension crisis in the coming years...
- greglindahl 10y agoYes, this is a common problem with "final salary" pension schemes that include overtime: coworkers and supervisors are willing to help out folks about to retire.
- pstuart 10y agoa.k.a. pension spiking
- gnopgnip 10y agoDoes it matter because all pensions are self funded?
- cobookman 10y agoIt does if they ask the tax payers to bail them out.
- prostoalex 10y agoSince when? This keeps happening every few years http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-schools-pensions-20140521-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-schools-pension...
- jiqiren 10y agoIt is not the last few years. It is whatever the highest average range was over a period of 12-36 months. Source (look at Final Compensation in the Retirement Calculation Formula subheading): https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/active-members/retirement-benefits/service-disability-retirement https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/active-members/retirement-be...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 10y agoIf you read that a CEO managed to accumulate $220K extra what would you think? Business as usual? Not worth a headline? How about $2.5 million? A $25 million golden parachute? What about an attorney or a top salesperson pocketing a little extra? I don't support corruption and it should be put to a stop, but let's focus our attention on the real money and the powerful.
- foota 10y agoIt doesn't really sound like corruption so much as mis-management that means they don't have enough janitorial staff or just need to manage how many hours people can work better.
- bpodgursky 10y agoIt's a pretty standard tactic within municipal workforces to intentionally under-hire full time employees to "force" overtime among the remaining ones. Low level corruption.
- khuey 10y agoAnd to rotate who gets to take advantage of the forced overtime to allow those about to retire to clock in a few years of inflated pay to boost their pension payouts.
- foota 10y agoInteresting, is the incentive here to undermine wage limits in place to give their employees a better living?
- candiodari 10y agoNotice how the last name of the janitor is the same as his supervisor's name. That's the nature of government jobs. Certain groups (families, friends, ...) "conquer" them. They only hire from the group and do whatever you can to make the group as a whole earn as much as possible, and "re-divide" the results (e.g. in order to get overtime you have to pay 50% of it to the supervisor).
- laluser 10y agoEven though they want to use this specific person to showcase an example, I think that it's highly inconsiderate to post this fellow's name in the news article. The way the article is written, it just sounds like they're making an example out of him, when in reality, he's literally just doing his job.
- prostoalex 10y agoThe data is available from government agencies and aggregated on transparentcalifornia.com, which the article links to. Even if they omitted his name, the discovery process would take a casual web surfer two minutes at most. Here are the top Bay Area public sector salaries for anyone whose job title includes "janitor" http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/search/?q=Janitor&y= http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/search/?q=Janitor&... BART custodians are "system service workers" in their nomenclature http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/search/?q=System+service+worker&y= http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/search/?q=System+s...
- laluser 10y agoI'm completely aware of that. My wife is actually a school teacher so her salary is freely available online. I'm only arguing that being called out like this by name in a news article, is pretty...bogus. That's all.
- fuqted 10y agoBart is consistently disgusting and a majority of their janitors make over $100k? This is what happens in a government subsidized monopoly.
- astronautjones 10y agoas opposed to everyone on here that's grossly overpaid in the bay area? at least they're providing a tangible service
- fuqted 10y ago
- cyanbane 10y agoDon't hate the player, hate the game. I hope Zhang gets to keep every penny and I hope SF comes up with a way better manage their expenditures.
- Johnny555 10y agoBART is not owned or managed by the city of San Francisco, it's managed by a 9 member elected board - SF holds 2 seats (plus one seat covers some SF and some East Bay areas) While SF may have a lot of faults, SF can't be blamed for BART's problems.
- cxseven 10y agoI don't envy him: "When work crews pulled open a broken BART escalator at San Francisco's Civic Center Station last month, they found so much human excrement in its works they had to call a hazardous-materials team. While the sheer volume of human waste was surprising, its presence was not. Once the stations close, the bottom of BART station stairwells in downtown San Francisco are often a prime location for homeless people to camp for the night or find a private place to relieve themselves..." http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Human-waste-shuts-down-BART-escalators-3735981.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Human-waste-shuts-down...
- sean_patel 10y agoThis is true. A very ugly situation in what used to be a world-class city. I have seen homeless people defecating in the BART / Subway escalators. Initial anger turned to apathy. Where would they go? There are no public toilets as far as I can tell, in the downtown / tenderloin area. I did volunteer work at San Quentin and Pelican Bay helping non-violent inmates apply for jobs outside, and almost all the ones I helped in San Quentin said they were being paroled into San Francisco. Eventually they all end up in the Tenderloin district, sleeping on the street and relieving themselves at the BART stations.
- djf1 10y agoHere's a full list of SF public toilets: http://sfpublicworks.org/sites/default/files/5196-public_toilet_by_zip.pdf http://sfpublicworks.org/sites/default/files/5196-public_toi... There are multiple 24 hour facilities in the downtown / tenderloin area (94102).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- galago 10y agoYeah, not information in the article about his hours. I'm assuming he just worked every overtime hour possible, which is some crazy sacrifice. When I lived in Oregon I remember reading about a 911 dispatcher who was one of the highest paid public employees, but he also was regularly working 80+hr weeks--7 days a week for months at a time. If there's a problem its a management issue.
- stretchwithme 10y agoDoes management decide who gets the overtime at BART? Or is the union packing the end of his career with overtime so he walks away with a massive pension?
- patmcguire 10y agoIf he's making four times his base pay as a janitor, 1x of that is base pay, and 3x is overtime. If that 3x is time and a half, he's working 2x his normal hours on top of his normal hours. Is this guy working 120 hours a week? Has to be more that time and a half overtime, 120 hours is not doable over a year.
- wadenick 10y agoThe first article I read made it clear he was doing 114 hours a week: http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/BART-Janitor-Made-270K-in-Pay-and-Benefits-Last-Year-Report-399550951.html http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/BART-Janitor-Made-270K-... The headline figure includes his benefits in order to seem worse in some way. Wages were around $230K. Reality is 114 hours of work every week makes for a dismal sort of life for most people. Perhaps this is a case of Chinese work ethic plus pension spiking?
- kamaal 10y ago>>120 hours is not doable over a year. Why do you think so? Just because some of us can't others can't? This is a bit like expressing surprise over people running miles everyday. It looks impossible until you actually start doing it.
- patmcguire 10y agoThat's 17 hours a day, every day without breaks. If he took a day off or worked only 14 hours he's got to make that up. It's more than two-thirds of the time in a year on the job. Not conscious time, total time. Looks like he did do it, but it's at the edge of physical possibility. As you get up there every hour is a much larger chunk of your available time. 114-120 is a lot more than 100.
- aphextron 10y agoIncredible mismanagement on the side of BART for allowing this to happen. I'm certain they could find all the funding they need for upgrades by cutting the waste.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- k__ 10y ago> worked an average of 114 hours a week lol, I'm not even awake 114h a week.
- joshka 10y agoThe exact numbers are found at: http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2015/san-francisco-bay-area-rapid-transit-district/liang-zhao-zhang/ http://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2015/san-francisco...
- billconan 10y agoAnd Bart is still pretty dirty.