7 ms·
MIT Prof Richard S. Lindzen: Global Warming Alarmists Are in Denial
- hga 17y agoClick on the results of the search for the full text if you're not a subscriber; real URL is http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704448304575196802317362416.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870444830457519...
- mnemonicsloth 17y agoHeader from the author's wikipedia profile: "Richard Siegmund Lindzen (born February 8, 1940, Webster, Massachusetts) is an American atmospheric physicist and Alfred P. Sloan Professor of Meteorology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Lindzen is known for his work in the dynamics of the middle atmosphere, atmospheric tides and ozone photochemistry. He has published more than 200 scientific papers and books.[1] He was a lead author of Chapter 7, 'Physical Climate Processes and Feedbacks,' of the IPCC Third Assessment Report on climate change. He is a well known skeptic of global warming[2] and critic of what he states are political pressures on climate scientists to conform to climate alarmism." Famous scientist and well-known critic of AGW? This is the first I've heard of him...
- hga 17y agoHmmm ... he's been well known in this field for both of the above since the late '80s, when a friend of mine interviewed him. At the time he effectively said he had been rather naive in the publication of his research (as I recall it was a study going back 200+ years on ship temperature reports, rather important data since the majority of the world is covered by the seas). He had thought that the scientific community was interested in the truth.... His problem was of course that the '80s were the period where the climate alarmists switched from global cooling/new Ice Age to global warming. As I recall his funding sources went poof, fortunately he'd already gotten tenure. Anyway, if you're interested in this topic yet haven't heard of him or, say, "atmospheric physicist" Fred Singer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Singer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Singer; e.g. he "designed the first instruments used in satellites to measure cosmic radiation and ozone" (all quotes from Wikipedia)), you might want to expand your sources of information.
- euroclydon 17y agoWhat motivates these global alarmists? And how do they get money by being so shrill? Is your average citizen just dying to be worried over the next catastrophe and willing to throw money at whomever can scare them the most?
- jdminhbg 17y ago"Is your average citizen just dying to be worried over the next catastrophe and willing to throw money at whomever can scare them the most?" You can page back through the last umpteen national election results if you doubt this is true.
- hga 17y agoI don't know, but this specific phenomena goes back to 200 AD (sic), and then you can go back to, oh, the Book of Revelations and so on. There seems to be a strong drive in at least some people towards this sort of thing. Politicians gain power by not "letting a serious crisis go to waste" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1yeA_kHHLow http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1yeA_kHHLow); how real a crisis is irrelevant. Funding naturally follows for those talking up the crisis.
- billswift 17y agoIt isn't just the politicians either, where do you think the major environmental organizations get their money? Since the major cleanup during the 1970s, they have invented "crisis" after "crisis" to keep the money coming in. The "ozone hole" and "acid rain" crises were as overblown, running toward outright fraudulent, as the AGW crap.
- cgranade 17y agoThis is why you refer to terrorists getting their hands on nuclear weapons, I'm sure.
- Kadin 17y ago> Is your average citizen just dying to be worried over the next catastrophe and willing to throw money at whomever can scare them the most? If you doubt this, I'd like to introduce you to the Department of Homeland Security.
- anamax 17y ago> This is the first I've heard of him What other atmospheric scientists have you heard of and why?
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI'd heard of him because he'd misinterpreted satellite data that apparently conflicted with the general consensus. I'd assumed that was an honest mistake but it appears that every time one of his theories gets shot down, he just moves on to the next one. The fact that they all seem to have an implicit message of "don't worry about it, everything's fine" is looking less coincidental as time passes.
- BearOfNH 17y agoevery time one of his theories gets shot down, he just moves on to the next one So ... when faced with facts that contradict his theories, he modifies his theories so as to be consistent with the facts. Isn't this what, you know, a real scientist should do?
- dgabriel 17y agohttp://logicalscience.com/skeptics/Lindzen.htm http://logicalscience.com/skeptics/Lindzen.htm
- diego_moita 17y agoThanks. That link brings a lot of perspective.
- JshWright 17y agoYeah, I especially like the bit where they "prove" he "might" have lied to congress by posting a youtube video of a completely unrelated group "lying" to congress.
- gaius 17y agoAnyone who thinks "skeptic" is a perjorative is not a scientist.
- diego_moita 17y agoDon't be silly. This is not about scientific skepticism anymore. But, in truth, Lindzen and the WSJ are not skeptics, they're deniers. Skeptic is someone not convinced that something is true. Denier is someone that believes that something is false. Lindzen (and the WSJ) are deniers.
- nsfmc 17y ago> Well for one thing Lindzen has no testable theory, no data, and no papers explaining the current temperature trend. Despite this he still manages to get his opinions published... No, but in order to be a scientist, you have to do... science, not opinion.
- hga 17y agoYou can and many do "do science" without offering alternatives, all you have to do is to point out how those you are criticizing are wrong, e.g. in interpretations of data, use of statistics, etc. Are those Canadian statisticians not doing science when they point out that you can use Mann's methods to get a hockey stick out of random noise?
- DrSprout 17y agoWhile it's true that there's no consensus on the source of the warming, it is true that the planet is warming. That's something that tends to get lost in the shuffle, and it's really scary what percentage of the American public believes that the fundamental point is false. It also seems to me that Lindzen is exaggerating the degree of dispute over the future climate trends. I do agree that there's not a lot of evidence we can prevent the climate from warming considerably over the next 50 years or so, but there is a general consensus that the climate will warm considerably over the next 50 years. It also seems there's a general consensus this is a problem, even if it's purely natural. Lindzen is doing his fellow researchers a disservice by confusing the politics and science of the issue.
- hga 17y agoHmmm, that's not my impression. The data reevaluation that resulted in 1934 being declared the hottest year in the 20th century, the "hide the decline" games, the fierce debate over the existence of the Medieval Warm Period and its extent (I think the alarmists now admit its existence, but debate its scope, e.g. there's a lack of data in the Southern Hemisphere and the oceans), they all suggest to me that the science here is not settled. The only way you're going to convince "skeptics" like myself (I only deny that the science is settled) will be to retrieve the original data sets the CRU lost and then do the science again in a totally open manner. Share the data, publish the code and methods, etc.
- DrSprout 17y ago>The data reevaluation that resulted in 1934 being declared the hottest year in the 20th century This whole argument is getting extraordinarily tired, but 1934 could well be the hottest year on record in the 20th century without invalidating the claim that the climate has warmed on average by several degrees since then. Outlying data points are in every single data set. >the "hide the decline" games As I recall there was a single game, in a single email. >the fierce debate over the existence of the Medieval Warm Period and its extent Europe? As I understand that's where the data is from. But even so, even if the temperatures have precedents, that doesn't disprove the warming trend - it just casts some doubt on the alarmism. And that's what I'm trying to get at. Warming is happening. It will continue.
- nhooey 17y agoScientific Opinion on Climate Change http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_opinion_on_climate_change http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_opinion_on_climate_c... Looks like almost everyone's in agreement, there.