5 ms·
> don't blame the exercise for that Yes, blame the exercise for that, because the exercise is fundamentally and inescapably is an attempt to assert a level of
by eropple 10y ago
> don't blame the exercise for that
Yes, blame the exercise for that, because the exercise is fundamentally and inescapably is an attempt to assert a level of power over candidates; instead of studying their Github or just talking to them hiring managers demand that they take on the time-and-effort risk of qualifying themselves to the hirer. Which is really stupid in a seller's market, BTW. But, even past that stupidity, it makes it tenable, in the mind of the evaluator, to blow off the candidate because they have, by accepting it, signaled that they will put up with at least a decent amount of shit coming down the pipe towards them without serious complaint.
It's fundamentally dehumanizing hoop-jumping, which creates predictable results, and we should be better than that.
- GrinningFool 10y agoI've been on both sides of the table. When I did these exercises I found them uncomfortable , but less so than the rest of the interview process. I've never read into it the way that you and many others are. I consider it as a means of quantifying ability. You don't have time pressure, you don't have an interviewer standing over your shoulder whiteboarding with you. I view those as positives - because while I can do those things fine in day to day work, I do horribly at them an interview. That said it's clear that our experiences with this have been very different. * And o
- eropple 10y agoI can do either; I'm a very good talker and a very good programmer, and I'm pretty good on a white board too. But, fundamentally, this is a refusal on the part of the company to invest time in the process (while expecting the candidate to invest hours of their time). You are not operating as either business partners or equals; it's a power play. And that's not humane (and it's stupid besides in a seller's market). I'm good at these tests. That doesn't mean that doing them is economically wise.