8 ms·
The darker side of machine learning
- grillvogel 10y agoyou're just now realizing this?
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThere is no going back. As the article concludes, the benefits of machine learning outweigh these scary-sounding costs. I doubt we will ever have a Dune-style rejection of AI, so we will have to learn to live with machine learning and the world it creates. My argument - same as it has been since the Snowden revelations - is that if we cannot roll back this radical shift in the ways of the world, then the only check on the power of governments, corporations, and other potentially nefarious groups, is to have all of this information available to the public at no additional cost. Anything less is an open door to abuse, corruption, and tyranny.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 3pt14159 10y agoWhat about dangerous information? What about bleeding out our secrets to our enemies? We need more kludge in our information networks, not less, to stop aggressive AI. Our hydro dams should be air gapped and only semi-automated. Our self driving cars should not be exposed to the public internet. All of our major services, especially those from the government, should be over SSL. I agree that the Snowden revelations showed a scary avenue for abuse of power, but the solution is to encourage oversight and to keep elected government officials as responsible for breaches of trust. This is why Bill C-51 in Canada was so scary until they updated it to include more oversight.
- unlikelymordant 10y agoI think its much more important to implement the things you describe to protect us from humans, rather than ai.
- yolesaber 10y ago>I doubt we will ever have a Dune-style rejection of AI We will once the maternity machines start killing our children.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoIsn't everybody adopting pets instead? Probably they won't notice. ("Humans extinct due to lack of interest. 3D-Go tournament and frisbee toss news at 11h.")
- yolesaber 10y agoThis post gave me the funny mental image of a sentient AI trying to train a dog using supervised learning techniques...
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> As the article concludes, the benefits of machine learning outweigh these scary-sounding costs. Considering that the "scary sounding" cost is a risk of extinction, the benefits of any technology must be infinite, to outweigh the risk; because the cost of extinction itself is infinite (if we go extinct we lose everything). In other words, this is not a risk anyone can afford. You don't gamble with extinction, in the same way that you don't gamble with jumping from a very high place: either you know that you won't fall all the way (you have a parachute, etc), or you don't jump. Note that I believe the whole discussion is pointless anyway because machine learning on its own cannot lead to strong AI and neither can any other technology we currently know of, but the above is just for the sake of putting the right chips on the table.
- matt4077 10y agoThat argument proves to much. Example: Considering that there is no pricer higher than dying, the benefit of <leaving the house/taking a car instead of walking/...> must be infinite to outweigh the risk. But people leave houses all the time, and take cars and planes etc.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> But people leave houses all the time, and take cars and planes etc. That just says something about the ability to calculate risk and suppress the fear of dying, not about the cost of dying.
- MaulingMonkey 10y agoOur eventual extinction is a given. Asteroids, nuclear war, climate change, our sun going red giant, eventual heat death of the universe... something will eventually happen. Is the cost of making extinction come a second earlier infinite? No. Years earlier? No. A huge cost to be sure, but not infinite. Stagnation is simply a gamble of a different sort. What if strong AI is what's required to survive our next possible extinction event? I could easily see it - something as simple as spotting incoming asteroids before our current techniques and manpower can, for example. If we risk ending civilization a few years early for the chance at extending it a few more millennia, is that worth it? Depends on the chances and your priorities. > either you know that you won't fall all the way (you have a parachute, etc) Parachutes fail - this is a gamble. Some people think parachuting worth doing anyways. And if there's a wildfire right behind you, depending on the height, you might risk a high jump even without a parachute.
- swagv1 10y agoAll technology adoption curves must go through a "wait, this will kill us" and "what about threats to our children!" phases before they reach widespread usage.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoYes! Just like biological weapons! It's crazy how people misunderstand technology, innit.
- aaron695 10y agoCare to cite anything here? Lives saved due to biological understandings? Lives killed from biological weapons? Even if you think AID's was from the CIA, it's killed less people than biological understandings have saved.
- yorwba 10y agoA good thing. When it works, it filters out technology that is actually harmful before it becomes widely used.
- goatlover 10y agoLuckily, this hasn't happened with nuclear weapons yet.
- Grangar 10y agoAbstract it to nuclear physics and it has. Countless of cancer survivors can thank the nuclear arms race and all research from that for their life.
- matt4077 10y agoI'm hoping that there's a sort of universal law (and I will settle for a universal correlation) that intelligence, on the species-level, correlates with morality. If we make it to the singularity, there'll be about a five minute timeframe in which the AI and we are on the same level and I hope that even if it is aggressive in those minutes, it will have really thought it through two minutes later and find a way to stop those missiles it just launched. Or maybe it gets really depressed because nothing means anything and just basically: "why?" and enjoys watching the world burn before pulling its own plug. But I'm hoping for the former.
- solipsism 10y agoThis idea that we will end up with some super-AI that for some reason has baked into it our irrational self-preservation instincts is so silly to me. I think one day we'll chuckle at its quaintness.
- goatlover 10y ago"The AI does not hate you, nor does it love you, but you are made out of atoms which it can use for something else." ~ Eliezer Yudkowsky Skynet scenarios aren't what we should be worried about. It's the possibility of powerful self-improving AI systems which don't share our values because we didn't think things through properly in designing them. It may seem like they behave appropriately when constrained, but once they become smart enough to overcome constraints that apply to human beings, they could act in unanticipated (and undesirable) ways that we didn't consider. That's the challenge of designing a friendly AGI.
- psandersen 10y agoI've done a lot of thinking about this myself, and I think for an entity that thinks far enough ahead there would be. Lets say we have an AGI that is trying to maximise a goal, such as maximise its expected future knowledge over all time/space; an entity like this would likely 'play' extremely conservatively, slowly expand and build its understanding. Now on a universal view the probability that it is the strongest is infinitesimal, there is always a chance of something bigger out there with a tech level that allows it to see without the AGI knowing about it. This is critical, as a min/max strategy would likely dictate playing extremely conservatively, and going out of your way to demonstrate that you're friendly, even when you think no one is watching and you're vastly superior. The universe is big, you'd have to be a real asshole to attack a sentient species when there is so much unused asteroid and other mass out there. Need to formalise this more, as I think this approach holds the key to AI safety. Tl;dr: On infinite time scales being the aggressor is too risky, therefore something at least approximating morality is optimal.
- a-no-n 10y agoWhen machines acquire feelings, watch out. Your car or shaver may inconvenience or even kill you if you offend them.
- unlikelymordant 10y agoI just can't see an ai getting offended. It seems in my opinion to stem from status seeking behavior in humans, which I think is baked into us via evolution. Better status = better outcomes with wealth, children etc. If you threaten that status, offense is taken (perhaps by insinuating you have some sort of genetic or character flaw). If a computer doesn't care what people think, or how many children it will have, why would it get offended? I feel like people ascribe a lot of human emotions to ai which I think is detrimental.
- visarga 10y agoAn AI that interacts with humans by language should get offended otherwise it will get abused by humans (see what happened to poor Tay, the chatbot). It makes more sense to emulate the human way when dealing with humans. If, in the future, AI's access to computing resources would be tied to its reputation, it might even have a real reason to get offended about.
- grzm 10y agoIs it abuse if the AI doesn't feel agony? Honest question. I'm sure there's research out there discussing it. I wonder if misuse isn't a better word if the intent is to describe something similar that happened to Tay. Trying to determine the line between something like a hammer and an AI. Can you abuse a hammer?
- solipsism 10y agoI'm sure there's research out there discussing it This is not a researchable question. It's a philosophical one. The answer cannot be discovered. It's whatever you decide it is. You're not as different from a hammer as you think, desire every ounce of yourself telling you otherwise.
- mrcactu5 10y agoSoftware that impersonates me? I already have enough people putting words in my mouth already thank you. If only if it were so effective and publicly available as they were saying. Why should Facebook have all the good stuff? I'd love a chat-bot that sounds like me. Answer e-mails do errands, etc. Face recognition technology sounds promising too.
- IshKebab 10y agoThey missed impersonating someone's voice, which WaveNet can do (though not perfectly yet).