4 ms·
I see a lot of value in a single payer system as health care system as I fundamentally believe healthcare spending does not conform to the same rules as other p
by kasey_junk 10y ago
I see a lot of value in a single payer system as health care system as I fundamentally believe healthcare spending does not conform to the same rules as other parts of the economy and thus might make all of our (basic) understanding about economics moot.
That said, single payer does not solve the single biggest classic problem with the current healthcare system in the US and that is the agency issue. Right now I cannot make informed choices as a consumer in this market. Prices are not transparent and the people negotiating the prices are not the people receiving the care.
Further, we've coupled insurance to employment which is just insane.
Oddly McCain's health plan from a few elections back would have at least dealt with the last point. I wonder if the exchanges would be more successful if the entire population was buying insurance through them.
- alistairSH 10y agoYeah, I do wish we'd figure out a way to decouple insurance from employment. Right now, I have two choices... one from my employer, and one from my wife's employer. One is terrible ($12k/year OOP max), the other is better (but still worse on cost and benefits than the typical PPO from 15-20 years ago).
- maxerickson 10y agoIt should have been done as part of the ACA. Remove the tax incentive and encourage all those people to go to the exchanges. It would probably have to have been done in a staged manner. After that, eliminate Medicaid in favor of fully priced exchange subsidies (I say "fully priced" because as far as I can tell, much of the funding for Medicaid comes from jacking up prices that other people pay for care, creating a tax that gets hidden in insurance premiums and deductibles). Instead the ACA placed more requirements on employers and expanded Medicaid.
- bnolsen 10y agoI see no value in turning a whole industry into defacto civil servants. Doctors and nurses are people too who need to be able to choose themselves. I don't give a rip about insurance. Getting access to health care is what matters. Doctor/patient relationship is what matters. I see no need for government to get involved other than stopping ethical type (illegal) abuses.
- kasey_junk 10y ago> Getting access to health care is what matters And how do you provide access to extremely expensive health care without insurance or government? Risk sharing is the issue and in this case it seems fraught with moral hazards regardless of how it is done.
- tptacek 10y agoIf you don't give a rip about insurance, you should be especially irritated at ACA and the ACA status quo ante, because the insurance companies and hospital chains quietly negotiate the prices for health care services, collude to establish favorable prices for the insurers, and lock individual consumers out of those prices. A fun experiment I've had the pleasure of running: try to get an MRI done outside of your insurance policy --- that is, try to pay the rack rate for an MRI, out of pocket.