4 ms·
Has anyone seen a non-compete enforced? I know plenty of engineers (not of the software kind, though) that quit to work at competitors, but when there are thre
by paulddraper 10y ago
Has anyone seen a non-compete enforced?
I know plenty of engineers (not of the software kind, though) that quit to work at competitors, but when there are three companies in the world that make electron scanning microscopes or whatnot, it's practically impossible not to.
Enforcing a non-compete seems like it would be an uphill battle.
- kasey_junk 10y agoIt happens in trading fairly regularly.
- bpchaps 10y agoYep. Even in states like Illinois where NCAs are non-enforceable, they can still complicate hiring decisions. I've heard of a few cases where companies (particularly in trading) will choose not to hire someone with a NCA because of the risk/time/effort involved in dealing with it.
- kasey_junk 10y agoNCA's used to be largely nonenforceable in IL. The advice I've received is that was changed by court precedent in recent years.
- gok 10y agoAbsolutely. Several of my colleagues and friends have run into non-compete issues moving from big companies to other big companies. One high profile case was Mark Papermaster's move from IBM to Apple: http://fortune.com/2009/01/27/ibm-settles-papermaster-to-join-apple-in-april/ http://fortune.com/2009/01/27/ibm-settles-papermaster-to-joi...
- cwbrandsma 10y agoI've seen attempts made to enforce it. We call it the nuclear option because for small companies, we are talking mutually assured destruction do to lawyer fees -- and virtually guarantees the former employee will go bankrupt. And at least in my town, word gets around that you are hostile to your employees, meaning hiring grinds to a immediate halt. If you are a consulting company...good luck with the next contract. No one will want to work for you or with you, and multiple current employees will quit on principle. At least that is what I saw happen at a former company I was with. All of this was in "Right to Work" state that invalidates non-competes anyway.
- ghaff 10y agoEven when they're not enforced and not expected to be enforced, they can still cause problems for someone at a big company trying to be hired by a small company. At a former small employer, we basically wouldn't touch anyone with a non-compete if there was the slightest risk.