9 ms·
Asides from that yes they obviously have different reputations and history, and that your comment isn't a response to my comment: Thomas could you please either
by nailer 10y ago
Asides from that yes they obviously have different reputations and history, and that your comment isn't a response to my comment: Thomas could you please either apologise or disengage as discussed earlier? Thanks.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm responding to your claim that both MRAs and feminists have "awful" reputations, which is false. MRAs do indeed have a checkered reputation. Feminism, on the other hand, is one of the more important social movements of the last 150 years. That fact is why MRAs are usually careful to refer to "third wave feminists".
- dlss 10y agoI'm really confused by your reply here. 1) I find it hard to believe you didn't understand what GP meant, even if he could have said it better. 2) sidestepping the issue of offending someone and instead arguing semantics isn't a very cool conversational move. However, perhaps #1 is the case, so I'll try to clear the air. Here's my take on what the two of you are saying: > I'm responding to your claim that both MRAs and feminists have "awful" reputations, which is false I have personally heard more complaining about feminists, though I take that to be more an indication about the relative numbers of Feminists and MRAs in the world. In my experience people with a strong ideological viewpoint have bad reputations outside of social circles dominated by that ideological viewpoint (Conservative Christians, Scientologists, Anarchists, Hard-Line Libertarians, MRAs, Feminists, etc) <-- hopefully you're not all of those, and so at least one was a good example. Which is to say I think you're saying that in the circles you personally hang out in, feminists are generally highly regarded... which is to say you mostly hang out with feminists... and that GP is saying that in the circles he hangs out in feminists are not highly regarded... which is to say there are fewer feminists per capita than in your social circle. I think both GP and you should have been more careful about misrepresenting your personal experiences as somehow universal. If you had, you would probably have avoided this back and forth. > Feminism, on the other hand, is one of the more important social movements of the last 150 years Feminism and feminists aren't the same thing. For example, Capitalism was an incredibly important idea globally, and is widely regarded as a good thing. Capitalists on the other hand are generally viewed as greedy. Incidentally, capitalists will often try to frame themselves as part of capitalism to subvert this negative impression... roughly the same thing you're doing here with respect to feminism.
- kasey_junk 10y ago> Feminism and feminists aren't the same thing...Capitalists on the other hand are generally viewed as greedy. That is a false equivalence. Anyone who supports feminism, that is equal rights for women, are feminists, the noun. Capitalists, the noun, are not just people who support capitalism, they are in fact wealthy people who take advantage of capitalism. Finally, the idea that MRA & feminism have equal historical provenance is laughable. MRA is largely attributable to the last 5 years & is plainly a recent reactionary movement.
- dlss 10y ago> Anyone who supports feminism, that is equal rights for women, are feminists, the noun. http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/07/social-justice-and-words-words-words/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/07/social-justice-and-word... ... which is to say I feel like most people understand the word feminist to mean something other than "99.9% of people living in a western democracy" > the idea that MRA & feminism have equal historical provenance is laughable Completely agree here, and am confused where I might have implied otherwise.
- tptacek 10y agoThis very long, very Scott Alexander post has essentially nothing to say about the meaning of the word "feminism", but I'll say again that the reason MRAs refer consistently to "third wave feminism" is that the other waves of feminism secured women's right to vote, outlawed overt gender discrimination in pay, criminalized marital rape, and won Roe v Wade, so demonizing "feminism" is a rhetorically risky strategy.
- dlss 10y agoYeah, in my limited experience, MRAs generally suck at distinguishing between feminism the ideology and feminism the concept, so they end up tripping over themselves trying to explain how they are for women's rights but also against feminism.
- 10y ago
- nailer 10y ago> > is male wouldn't generally want to be labelled as an 'MRA' or 'male feminist' > your claim that both MRAs and feminists I didn't claim that. Read my post again. I've included it above to help you. 'Male feminists' have a very different reputation than feminists per se. Similarly, I didn't claim there was a 'war against men'. You make up awful things I don't write and then respond to them. It's lazy and rude. Now please disengage.
- tptacek 10y agoThis would be a more compelling request if the timeline of these comments didn't clearly demonstrate that other people were talking, and that your further input wasn't required. Physician, heal thyself.
- nailer 10y agoMy further input was required because as demonstrated you, for the second time, deliberately made a false statement about what I wrote and then addressed your own straw man argument. Most rational human beings would not leave that unaddressed.