6 ms·
There are some areas where men are disadvantaged (e.g., as already mentioned, family court, or divorce proceedings) and saying that believing that requires psyc
by nailer 10y ago
There are some areas where men are disadvantaged (e.g., as already mentioned, family court, or divorce proceedings) and saying that believing that requires psychological help is quite obviously insulting. You've been here long enough to have read the HN guidelines.
You mention that the world isn't linear, but you seem to want to replace it with a simpler black and white model.
- tptacek 10y agoAs I said, I do not believe that all MRAs are experiencing chronic anxiety. There at least one other bucket I think they can be sorted into, and maybe a few more smaller ones.
- nailer 10y ago> I mean this sincerely: if you feel like there is a war on men, or that as a man in tech you're persecuted, you should find a professional to talk to. I'm not qualified to diagnose you and if I was I wouldn't do it over the Internet, Thomas, the correct response to: - a) strawmanning me - b) being this rude is to apologize.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm unhappy about the idea that anyone is experiencing distress in reaction to anything I write here, but the best advice I can give you is not to hold your breath on this. No amount of cerebral hypoxia is going to improve the thread! I'm very comfortable with the two of us simply disengaging.
- nailer 10y agoIf it's at all unclear about why your behavior is bad, imagine me replying this to any comment you've made in the thread: > I mean this sincerely: if you feel like all men should be killed you should find a professional to talk to. I'm not qualified to diagnose you and if I was I wouldn't do it over the Internet, Obviously: - You didn't write that - It couldn't be interpreted from what you /did/ write - It looks like an attempt to change the tone of the conversation by creating a straw man and attacking that rather than actually contributing anything to the conversation - It's a thinly veiled and childish insult
- dlss 10y agoYour above comment is dead, so I can't reply to it. Replying here: > The idea that MRA's and feminists are two ends of a single spectrum is one of those cognitive line-fitting traps we nerds fall into. While I'm all about detecting and uncovering cognitive biases (hardcore LessWrong expat, reporting for duty!), I don't believe GP's analysis was wrong. Just a guess, but I expect the people you're using to mentally represent MRAs are the equivalent of tumblr feminists (who also should consider treatment options in my opinion). Here's my line based model that attempts to not straw-man either group: Fringe-MRA: war on men Reasonable-MRA: there are some men's issues worth talking about (circumcision, work related injury and fatality rates, prison over-representation, gendered divorce laws, etc). Middle: Meh, what's on TV? Reasonable-Feminist: there are some women's issues worth talking about (FGM, right to drive/vote/work, right to serve in the military, pay equality/glass ceiling, etc). Fringe-Feminist: patriarcy! I don't see why this way of arranging the data should qualify as falling in to a line fitting trap. It seems like there are genuine issues on both sides, and a significant paranoid delusional component to be found at both ends of the spectrum. What am I missing?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> I don't see why this way of arranging the data should qualify as falling in to a line fitting trap. Because its a nice, convenient, abstractly appealing linear arrangement that doesn't have any utility in describing the reality of the distribution of views on gender issues? "There is general, society-wide, active oppression of men" is a view that opposes and is mutually exclusive with the comparable view with "women" replacing "men", but "there exists issues specific to men that are worth addressing in society" is not exclusive with the comparable view toward women, and in fact they are frequently found together, but almost never among people who identify as MRA (though often, IME, among people who identify as feminist.)
- nailer 10y ago> but "there exists issues specific to men that are worth addressing in society" is not exclusive with the comparable view toward women, and in fact they are frequently found together Completely agreed. Not sure how people self label is particularly relevant: someone who understands both sets off issues and is male wouldn't generally want to be labelled as an 'MRA' or 'male feminist' either as both have awful reputations.