5 ms·
> I think that the authors of such technologies should also come up with political proposals on what to do with the displaced people. Did the inventors of auto
by grecy 10y ago
> I think that the authors of such technologies should also come up with political proposals on what to do with the displaced people.
Did the inventors of automobiles have to deal with all the farriers and people who tend to horses?
...or when milkmen were obsolete?
...or when switchboard operators were obsolete?
...or when telegram operators were obsolete?
(I could go on all week)
History is full of instances where certain job roles are no longer needed and are obsoleted. This is a good thing, it means we're moving forward and progressing.
I wish everyone wasn't so afraid of jobs, but that's the consequence of being up to your eyeballs in debt.
- delegate 10y agoHistory is full of examples, but there is no time in History when the world was as complex and populated - and armed - as it is today. Not even close. We're talking about tens of millions of people potentially loosing their jobs worldwide due to such 'progress'. This can lead to uprisings, revolutions and bloodshed - a lot of suffering - which can be prevented if the transition is well planned. 'Global reach' cuts both ways, both through positive and negative consequences.
- ska 10y agoBest to avoid the narcissism of the present when you can. The industrial revolution was far more disruptive than what we are currently experiencing, albeit paced slower. The idea that way can't learn nearly everything we need to know about current change from observing the past strikes me as very naive. People, after all, are just people.
- ska 10y agoThe automobile inventors didn't have to deal with it, but somebody did. It's unfortunate that Smith was particularly weak in this area (or rather, that so many people have followed him in hand waving about it) but the consequences of displaced jobs is something that a society absolutely, unavoidably, has to deal with. You only get to choose if you approach it with a realistic plan, or not.
- ska 10y agoStrange - not sure what was controversial about that.
- riskable 10y agoYou're not even close to a realistic comparison. As a percentage of jobs overall, people working with horses, milkmen, switchboard operators, etc didn't amount to the sheer enormity of the jobs that will be obsoleted or displaced by self driving vehicles. There is no comparison in history to make. Nothing has happened like this before. Never. The closest you could get would be something like the aftermath of WW2 in Europe or maybe some devastating plagues but even that isn't a good comparison because those removed the people entirely; dead people don't need to be fed or swayed from starting a violent revolution. It's not just the truckers or cab/bus drivers. It's all the industries that support them. Those will disappear too. Just think of all the truck stops we have in the US and the amount of money that truckers spend at these places to sleep, take showers, get wifi, etc. Those will go away too. The motels where travelers sleep at midway points in their travels will lose all that business. The auto body shops that rely on people making mistakes while driving will lose all that business too. You're vastly underestimating the disruption if you're bringing up switchboard operators and milkmen.
- brianwawok 10y agoHow about the luddites and looms? Very large percentage of people worked in weaving before tech rushed them out. Or say how we went from 98% of people farming to 3%. You think truck drivers going from 5% to 1% is a bigger jump?
- kasey_junk 10y agoThat switch from farming to industry was not some sort of beautiful utopia. It was dangerous & violent & chaotic. It also took hundreds of years. There is at least the possibility that the automated future will be as dangerous & violent & chaotic. It could be much worse as we will have less time to adapt.
- mdpopescu 10y agoHeh. This reminds me of Toffler's books, like "The Third Wave". He thought - in the 70s! - that the amount of information that people had to absorb was too much and people would soon be unable to adapt. This was twenty years before the web.
- Spooky23 10y agoWe'll see how you feel when you're 50 and obsolete.
- grecy 10y agoI grew up watching my parents and grandparents work guaranteed employment in companies that would keep them on for life, treat them well, offer promotions and actually come good with retirement on time and the amount promised. What a world we had in the 70s 80s and 90s. I have never lived under that delusion. I know work is not guaranteed, I know companies will always "downsize", I know I am an expense to be eliminated and I know my retirement will continue to be pushed back, and that I'll only get a fraction of what I was promised if it ever comes. That is the reality of the world I live in. Anyone that doesn't accept that reality is not living in the real world.
- kasey_junk 10y ago< I grew up watching my parents and grandparents work guaranteed employment in companies that would keep them on for life, treat them well, offer promotions and actually come good with retirement on time and the amount promised. What a world we had in the 70s 80s and 90s. If you watched that, you enjoyed a phenomenal amount of privilege. That is much more of a marketing pitch about the past than anything that actually existed. In fact, in macro terms (even adjusting for statistical differences) the 2000s were much better for employees than the 70s, 80s and early 90s. I remember my grandparents being laid off a lot, and the plant moving right before they retired while raiding the pension fund on the way out. I remember the company declaring bankruptcy and not paying their disability obligations so the tax payer had to. That was during the supposed good years you mention. The coming years are going to yield dramatic changes to what jobs even mean, and at least in the US, we've spent the last 30 years making our society more dependent on people working for a big company not less. In light of that, it seems prudent to me at least, to give some thought to how we transition whole industries to not need workers.
- refurb 10y agoWhat a world we had in the 70s 80s and 90s. I love this nostalgia for the good old days. Life in the US during the 1970's sucked hard. Google "general malaise". Line-ups for gasoline, double digit inflation with no economic growth, post-Vietnam. People thought the US' days as a superpower were numbered.
- burkaman 10y ago> History is full of instances where certain job roles are no longer needed and are obsoleted. Yeah, exactly, and we get to learn from history. That's part of moving forward and progressing. We can't ignore consequences just because similar things have happened before.