5 ms·
There were also CD players that could play MP3s burned on a data disc. That bridged the "capacity gap" - 640/700 MB was a lot of MP3s at the time, especially s
by paulmd 10y ago
There were also CD players that could play MP3s burned on a data disc. That bridged the "capacity gap" - 640/700 MB was a lot of MP3s at the time, especially since people used lower bitrates. Remember, the first iPod was only 5 GB.
The big problem was the interface, it really sucked to try and navigate a couple hundred MP3s on a one-line display.
- largote 10y agoTo be honest, the Nomad was fairly decent too, though the Creative brand couldn't command the premium price as well as Apple.
- delinka 10y agoThey must have offered a few versions of the Nomad, cuz mine was crap. And oh dear $deity, the software for loading it up from Windows had a terrible UI, no flexibility in organizing songs... Good riddance.
- throwaway7767 10y agoThe bundled software was always crappy. Luckily the protocol was simple and people reverse engineered it quickly. I used some linux command line tool to manage files on it.
- huxley 10y agoThe Nomad was pretty much just a rebranded Samsung Yepp YP-D40. It had 64MB of flash storage and a parallel port connector compared to the 5GB and Firewire 400 that the iPod had, the Nomad/Yepp YP-D40 was fairly decent compared to a lot of the crap that was out there, but it didn't deserve a premium price.
- sesqu 10y agoPerhaps you should compare the iPod to the Nomad Jukebox line from around the iPod's release, instead of the Nomad 1 from the 90's. Jukebox 1 had 6GB storage, USB 1.1, and came out nearly a year before iPod 1. Jukebox 2 came out the following year, had 30GB storage, and used USB 2.0.
- huxley 10y agoThe Nomad 1 came out in 1999 so it wasn't so very long before the iPod's 2001 release. But you're right, I did forget about the Jukebox and it was much more competitive.
- curun1r 10y agoCreative had an mp3 player that was shaped like a portable CD player [1]. I guess the idea was that it was a form factor that people were already comfortable with. If you're looking for a reason why Apple ended up on top of the portable mp3 market, this example always seemed to sum it up for me. Apple has its faults, but (with reference to the fake Henry Ford quote) it's never been the sort of company that sold its customers faster horses. [1] http://mikeschinkel.com/images/creative-technology.nomad-jukebox.jpg http://mikeschinkel.com/images/creative-technology.nomad-juk...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Vinkekatten 10y agoOoh, I had one of those in high school, saved up for months! I loved that thing - lots of space, it read song info from the files, supported playlists and had space for dozens of albums! DOZENS! Admittedly it ate 4 AA batteries in as many hours, but who cares? It was just as big as a discman, but SO MUCH MORE AWESOME. Used it every day on the school bus. I kinda wanted an iPod when they came out, but as I grew up in a strict Dos & Windows home, that was out of the question.
- ianlevesque 10y agoYeah that spinning click wheel was genius at the time.
- branchless 10y agoWhy? It allowed navigating up and down. And you could select. A simple plus sign like button did this.
- ChristianGeek 10y agoYou obviously never used one. It gave you full, immediate control over how fast you scrolled, which buttons could never do. It enabled you to immediately change direction without lifting your finger. You could start by placing your finger anywhere on the wheel, which made it easy to use in the dark, and moving your finger from the wheel to the button in the center was just as easy. It was, and still is, the best interface I've ever used for navigating through large, grouped lists.
- branchless 10y agoI've used one. I find them a little annoying when it comes to selecting the actual song. Not a real problem, but neither was using a regular button.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoYou could also adjust the volume through your pants, at least with some versions. It was just sensitive enough that I could do this with jeans without having to stick my hand in my pocket. Honestly this was one of my favorite features, at least until the headphone remotes.
- groby_b 10y agoThat is exactly why Apple cleaned up and previous players didn't. From a technical point, that is correct. From a usability point, it isn't - because it took a previously digital control (button pressed or not) and made it feel analog (just turn the wheel). And it's much easier to precisely navigate over large distances with an analog(-feeling) control. Of course it wasn't only the wheel that made a difference, but it was the mindset behind it: Take things that to most engineers are functionally equivalent and choose the one that makes it easier for the user. Or find something that makes it easier for the user. That is a lesson that many of the products of our industry are still missing. What matters is not only functionality, but how easily and intuitively I as a user can access that functionality.
- cm2187 10y agoAnd sound quality.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- toyg 10y ago> CD players that could play MP3s [...] bridged the "capacity gap" But collecting and (forever) burning collections was a royal pain in the ass. Plus, CD readers would struggle and skip/stop/jump all the time as they bounced in your pocket or in your bag. > The big problem was the interface Absolutely. A lot of cheap Chinese sticks wouldn't even understand filesystem structures deeper than one level. To be fair though, the iPod Shuffle was basically like that and still sold very well; the reality distortion field was in full force at that time.
- paulmd 10y ago> But collecting and (forever) burning collections was a royal pain in the ass. Plus, CD readers would struggle and skip/stop/jump all the time as they bounced in your pocket or in your bag Well, after the first generation of CD players they wised up and added high-speed drives that read into buffers ("skip-proof"/"ESP"/etc) so that skipping wasn't a big deal. Since MP3s were a smaller quantity of data, they actually worked better at this. Ideally you wanted a player that could read CD-RWs (whether full of audio tracks or MP3 files). Still a pain in the ass but less expensive. Not all players used a laser that could read RW media. And not all media used to be readable by all drives in those days - some drives were very very sensitive. I remember the horror of desperately searching DVDR-Help.com to try and find media with good compatibility ratings. The thing that always amused me as a kid was how indestructable my Sony Discman CD player was. I went through probably 4 or 5 off-brand CD and MP3-CD players that had skip-proof before I finally switched to MP3 players. Every time they'd conk out after a year or two and I'd have to fall back to that stupid skip-prone Discman. The thing was built like a tank and I wouldn't be surprised if it still worked today, 20 years later. When I replaced it with an early iRiver HDD player in 2003 I shelled out like two years of savings for it, and that iRiver ended up lasting a decade. It was an important lesson for young me: you get what you pay for. > Absolutely. A lot of cheap Chinese sticks wouldn't even understand filesystem structures deeper than one level. That too, but I was really thinking about the scroll-wheel there. I can still remember the interminable pain of scrolling through a giant list of albums at about 2 per second. The iPod scroll wheel and the Zen Vision M's touch-strip were massive improvements for how they let you scroll rapidly but also have fine control. The iRiver fixed it with firmware brute-forcing (in Rockbox). All you had was a D-pad but it would scroll exponentially faster the longer you held it down, so you could actually get where you wanted to go in a reasonable amount of time. Not elegant but it worked.
- galago 10y agoMy first MP3 player was solid state and cheap, but it only had 32MB of storage. I would put 5 or 6 songs on it in the morning and listen to them on my way to work. I think a lot of my music back then was from Napster, and I intentionally sought out low-bit rate files. The iPod seemed fantastically expensive.
- moondev 10y agoRio? I had one too. Thought it was the coolest thing ever. I coukdn't wait to get the 64mb "expansion pack"
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoThey were also quite huge. I had one of those, and it went into the recycle bin the moment I got an iPod.
- NEDM64 10y agoThe problem with those CDMP3 players were the size, they didn't really work when you trembled the player (huge), and they rarely accepted CD-RW. Remember that CD-R is write once, not synchronize many times. Also, the interface...