3 ms·
I always find it strange when people do that. I mean, it's a wiki - if there's an obvious, glaring error - just fix it? Then that particular article will be mor
by e12e 10y ago
I always find it strange when people do that. I mean, it's a wiki - if there's an obvious, glaring error - just fix it? Then that particular article will be more correct?
Wikipedia is absolutely useless as a dead book - the level of (professional) work that goes into vetting "real" encyclopedia articles is much higher - and the errors that slip through much more permanent.
The great thing about Wikipedia is the potential steady improvement. When people complain about its accuracy it often just sounds like whining.
Granted, there are a few articles that are "contested", and I understand why people don't have the time or energy to fix all of Wikipedia.
- Tomte 10y agoNo, your fix will often be reverted by those one or two authors who consider the article "theirs". If you fix it a second time, including a clear explanation in the commit message, you'll be accused of vandalism.
- e12e 10y agoDo you know if anyone's done quantitative research on that? Should be pretty straightforward to sample some articles and see if that pattern is common? (I'm not trying to passive - aggressively suggest you're wrong, I'm honestly curious) [ed: I should add that I've started to form a habit of looking at the revision history and talk pages of wp articles - in addition to references. And I really do think the added transparency is a very real added value over dead tree encyclopedia. ]
- berntb 10y agoI referenced this earlier, but got no answer. It is from 2005. I haven't seen anything after that. "Wikipedia is about as good a source of accurate information as Britannica, the venerable standard-bearer of facts about the world around us, according to a study published this week in the journal Nature." https://www.cnet.com/news/study-wikipedia-as-accurate-as-britannica/ https://www.cnet.com/news/study-wikipedia-as-accurate-as-bri... (Please Google a better source for that paper. :-) ) I am willing to believe that "sensitive" information about living (and relative unknown) people along with companies/political parties is being more gamed in Wikipedia today, than ten years ago. I'd just see some good references for that...