20 ms·
What I Learned About Julian Assange While Working Alongside Him
- triplesec 10y agoA well-drawn profile. Edit: see below for reasons. I accidentally posted this sentence early before finishing more of a post. Now I've instead made a response to the question below
- Jerry2 10y agoHow so? It's nothing more than character assassination.
- triplesec 10y agoI think this is a fair article, and no hatchet job. The writer has decided not to like Assange from working with him and experience. Some pull-outs that show thought over partisanship : 'Assange is routinely either so lionised by supporters or demonised by detractors that his real character is lost entirely. 'Far from the laptop-obsessed autist he’s often seen as, he’s a charismatic speaker with an easy ability to dominate a room or a conversation.' 'Assange often trusts strangers more than those he knows well: He dislikes taking advice, he dislikes anyone else having a power base, and he dislikes being challenged – especially by women. He runs his own show his own way, and won’t delegate. He’s happy to play on the conspiratorial urges of others, with little sign as to whether or not he believes them himself.' 'once you have fallen foul of Assange — challenged him too openly, criticised him in public, not toed the line loyally enough — you are done. There is no such thing as honest disagreement, no such thing as a loyal opposition differing on a policy or political stance.' ' Assange would not, in my view, ever knowingly be a willing tool of the Russian state: If Putin came and gave him a set of orders, they’d be ignored. But if an anonymous or pseudonymous group came offering anti-Clinton leaks, they’d have found a host happy not to ask too many awkward questions: He’s set up almost perfectly to post them and push for them to have the biggest impact they can.'
- rahrahrah 10y ago> But if an anonymous or pseudonymous group came offering anti-Clinton leaks, they’d have found a host happy not to ask too many awkward questions Why would he? That's the whole point of WikiLeaks, to publish information about those who have the power in so called democratic systems.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoAnd the highlight point is that someone can use that to provide a very one sided perspective if they only provide WikiLeaks one side of the story.
- rahrahrah 10y agoSomeone gets a leaks about something that the government of Haiti is doing. So they can't publish it unless they have something equally bad about every single government on the planet? You have to go find 200+ other leaks, only then you can publish them altogether, because otherwise it would be one-sided. What a stupid argument. Think, don't just repeat talking points.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoYou are ignoring the point. All I am saying is that if you're a biased actor, such as say... Russia... a party that publishes everything they get is extremely easy to abuse. Someone could even choose to send WikiLeaks only the parts of the data they gathered that support their goals. Absolute positions such as WikiLeaks against careful decision making on what to leak and when can have unintended effects. Even if entirely well-meaning, they've opened themselves up to being exploited.
- rahrahrah 10y ago> All I am saying is that if you're a biased actor, such as say... Russia... a party that publishes everything they get is extremely easy to abuse. And what I'm saying is that publishing everything as long as it's true, is not abuse, it's the actual goal.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jsf666 10y agoBuzzfeed? Like seriously? Next should be CNN with their 'technical problems'. Does someone there really think this kind of propaganda piece will make anything in the Podesta e-mails less real? Can you get anymore obvious? This is some Soviet-level shit
- akhilcacharya 10y ago> Podesta e-mails less real As we can see from the polls, if there was something damaging here people don't really care.
- jsf666 10y ago> The polls The new emails show they're rigged Besides could You show me any major news outlet that covered them really throughly (considering how damaging they are)?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- crdoconnor 10y agoPeople were distracted by the pussy thing - which was not coincidentally released on the same day. Most people have no idea what was even in those emails and most of the media I read made a point to say that there was nothing damaging in there (cherry picking the most mundane things they could). There wasn't anything too surprising to people who hate Hillary Clinton (yes, she's in the pocket of wall street) and supporters and most of the mainstream media (MSNBC, CNN, NYTimes, etc.) didn't pay any attention.
- xenadu02 10y agoI read a bunch of the emails and there wasn't anything significant in there unless you count cherry-picking quotes and willful misunderstanding. At best there are some ambiguous things that could be interpreted certain ways. tl;dr: There is no smoking gun. People say things in private emails they wouldn't discuss in public, NEWS AT 11!!!!! P.S. It wasn't "that pussy thing". It was Trump bragging that he pushes women into sexual encounters he knows they don't want and gets away with it because he's famous and rich. I like how the right pretended everyone was upset about some foul language though or that it was just "locker room" talk. If Trump had said "oh she's so hot, I'd love to fuck her" no one would have cared because that is locker room talk. What Trump said was in a different league.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>>Then it was a darling of many of the liberal left, working with some of the world’s most respected newspapers exposing the truth behind drone killing, civilian deaths in Afghanistan and Iraq, and surveillance of the top UN officials. >>Now it is the darling of the alt-right, revealing hacked emails seemingly to influence a presidential contest, claiming the US election is “rigged”, and descending into conspiracy. Just this week on Twitter, it has described the deaths by natural causes of two of its supporters as a “bloody year for WikiLeaks”, and warned of media outlets “controlled by” members of the Rothschild family – a common anti-Semitic trope. This critique curiously echoes the two main propaganda attacks on Jeremy Corbyn: 1) Insinuations and manufactured accusations of anti-semitism: * http://news.sky.com/story/damning-report-condemns-jeremy-corbyn-over-leadership-on-anti-semitism-10619435 http://news.sky.com/story/damning-report-condemns-jeremy-cor... * http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-37656197 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-37656197 2) "We used to support him but it's become clear that we can't any more": * http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/zoe-williams-brands-jeremy-corbyn-incompetent-claims-he-cant-unite-more-than-12-people_uk_57a21946e4b0ce499248f526 http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/zoe-williams-brands-je... * http://labourlist.org/2016/08/i-used-to-support-corbyn-but-owen-smith-has-the-vision-young-muslim-women-like-me-need/ http://labourlist.org/2016/08/i-used-to-support-corbyn-but-o... * http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/billy-bragg-jeremy-corbyn_uk_57b2d4dce4b02fb3274b7a2b http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/billy-bragg-jeremy-cor... I don't doubt the next anti-establishment figure will be met with the same response "yes, we used to think they were great until it became clear that they're an awful Jew hater".
- Mizza 10y ago> "Assange’s approach has taken WikiLeaks from the most powerful and connected force of a new journalistic era to a back-bedroom operation" This assumes a false dichotomy. Wikileaks was never not a bedroom operation - that's the very core component of the "information revolution" the author is pining for. A young queer kid in Boston stole some very shocking videos from his IT job and gave them to a man in a chat room, who published them online. That's all it takes to change the world now. If anything, all of WikiLeaks' problems come from trying to stray from this model.
- resfirestar 10y agoWikileaks had a chance to be more than a bedroom operation, and it would have made them far more powerful than they are now. Building a network of aligned journalists and political allies would have increased visibility, attracted more leaks with localized impact, and made it much harder to shut down discussion of contents with "this was stolen", as the Democrats are now doing with complicity of much of the US media. But as we saw with the author's NDA story, Assange is the #1 enemy of that ever happening. He reflexively accuses anyone with their own publicity approach of being a careerist or worse, then logs into twitter to align not just himself, but Wikileaks the organization, with the most extreme possible opponents of his enemies. The impact that the leaker wants to make, the stories good journalists could write, even most third party mining of leaks is ignored in favor of Julian Assange's personal agenda. I think the world would be better off with a bigger, broader Wikileaks that promotes journalism instead of mistrusting it.
- johnfjacobi 10y agoBut many people don't realize that this kind of idiosyncratic asshole-ishness is how a lot of successful rebels / revolutionaries work, cultural and political. Lenin is a great example, and the most illustrative for me because I spent so much time studying him. The man was factionalistic to the point of absurdity. Always he was dreaming of a new epithet to throw: economism, leftism, opportunism, etc. But because of this he insulated a radical minority and made them disloyal to anything but the ideology he was using to direct their political action. And in the end it worked. Steve Jobs did a similar thing, but I'm sure I don't have to explain that one here.
- avmich 10y ago> he doesn’t see the world in the way many Americans do, and has no intrinsic aversion to Putin or other strongmen with questionable democratic credentials on the world stage. These two statements can be unrelated. You can see the world differently from "average American" point of view, yet have intrinsic aversion to questionable rulers. Sorry for nitpicking.
- wslh 10y agoThis is double standards 101. I would have hoped a stronger leadership by Assange to set higher political standards. Now I feel this is just leak pornography.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DominikR 10y agoYou are on the verge of voting a women into office that is likely the most corrupt politician in US history that has ever run for this office. How on earth is exposing this bad for your country, you want to be ruled by people who steal and lie to you about what they are going to do? How did she earn $250 million dollars while in public office? Oh and Assange is not a US citizen, why would anyone expect him to think like one, let alone make it a requirement.
- wslh 10y agoI am neither an US citizen nor living in US, and have not said anything about Hillary in my reply.
- empath75 10y agoI'm not against publishing this stuff in general. And in a normal election, it would be totally disqualifying. There are mitigating circumstances, however. 1) Her opponent is totally unqualified for the presidency, and is basically a fascist, and a bigot, and obsessed with revenge. 2) The information was obtained via espionage by a foreign power, attempting to interfere in the US election. I can only imagine what kind of stuff we'd find in RNC emails. As far as I'm concerned the correct course of action here is to elect Hillary, and then have congressional hearings into both the contents of those emails, and the methods by which they were obtained. Hillary is a crooked in the usual way that politicians are. We can survive another crooked politician in the White House for four years. Trump would be the end of the republic.
- pmyjavec 10y ago"All of this is the cocktail of ingredients that produces 2016’s incarnation of WikiLeaks. Julian Assange mistrusts the US government, dislikes Hillary Clinton, and has spent years trapped in a small embassy flat in west London, in declining physical and psychological health, monitored minute-by-minute in reports filed by his wary Ecuadorian hosts." I'm not sure about Americans but I would say the majority of the the world mistrusts the US Government. While I'm not saying Assange doesn't have flaws, this isn't exactly a point in time I would believe anything I read about him, Wikileaks or his character, this is the time for character assassinations. We also need to keep in-mind (as the article states) the guy is practically in jail, him and other whistle blowers are being seriously screwed over by the US Government, so IMO most of these profile pieces are going to paint a picture of someone who isn't in a great place right now. I often here people complain about the state of Wikileaks, but what do people expect? On character assassinations, another example I could give right now is Trump, maybe it's just because he is low hanging fruit, but boy is the media giving it to that guy like I've never seen, it's to the point where I've pretty much stopped reading the news in Australia right now because there are just constant trump bashing articles, it feels like the work of "The Ministry of Truth" in 1984. Yeah he is controversial, but is he worthy of so much attention ? From what i understand Hillary is far from flawless also. To conclude my rant, I'm taking this with a grain of salt :)
- scottkduncan 10y ago> Yeah he is controversial, but is he worthy of so much attention? He is running to be the most powerful political figure in the world...so yes.
- pmyjavec 10y agoThere is a difference between quality, informative journalism which allows people to make up there own mind and endless character assassinating, speculative tabloid smut; However, I trust you know that. The reason I used Trump as an example is because from what I've read and seen of Clinton she doesn't seem much better but is largely ignored in some media outlets in Australia.
- necessity 10y ago>The WikiLeaks founder is out to settle a score with Hillary Clinton ...
- rahrahrah 10y agoI just want to remind everyone that the Clinton campaign has been proved at least twice (according to the Podesta e-mails) to plant stories in the press. Keep that in mind while reading this: you don't know how much of it was written by the person whose name it comes under.
- threeseed 10y agoYou do realize that everyone plants stories in the press. It's the corner stone of the PR industry.
- rahrahrah 10y agoThe world isn't black and white. Everyone does it but some people do it to a larger extent than others. If this is too subtle an idea for you, I'm sorry for you.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- meowface 10y agoCould you link those Podesta emails? And anyway, this article isn't really anti-Assange or pro-Clinton, as far as I can tell. It does seem to be anti-Russia, but not pro-US.
- meredydd 10y agoIf you found this interesting, you might like the (much longer) account written by the ghostwriter of an autobiography Assange backed out of: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n05/andrew-ohagan/ghosting http://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n05/andrew-ohagan/ghosting
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 10y ago>he doesn’t see the world in the way many Americans do, and has no intrinsic aversion to Putin or other strongmen with questionable democratic credentials on the world stage. Why should he? America has much more "questionable democratic credentials" than Russia. At least the latter is constrained in its immediate back yard, it doesn't invade countries to "bring democracy", getting oil and leaving behind chaos, mayhem and civil war, nor does it bully or stronghold most of the world's governments.
- rahrahrah 10y agoNumber of US overseas military bases: 600+ Number of Russian overseas military bases: 2 I wonder why people paint Russia as if it was some aggressive power like the US.
- coldtea 10y agoBecause Americans are so used to being told they are the good guys, "the shit", and the world's only saints. Their media (even "serious" media, like the NYT) is the most patriotic in the whole western world. Of course it helps that there's a trillion dollar defense industry to benefit from all of that too. So, when they meddle 10.000 miles from their borders it's their right and they do it "for democracy". But when another country (let's call it R) tries to meddle in a place where actual pro-fascists toppled a voted-for government in a country in its borders, where tons of people with R ethnic origins live -- then they don't have the right. People speak about communist countries propaganda art portraying their leaders as "heroes" -- and it's indeed idiotic. But then again, the US is the only other place where they can produce and watch movies and shows where the President is a hero fighting bad guys with his bare hands (from Air Force One to numerous tv/cable series). And people watch that with a straight face -- in any other western country this would be considered only acceptable for comedy.
- XorNot 10y agoFree speech means you can make a movie where the president is the hero as much as you can make a TV series where he is the murdering villain (House of Cards). Neither is state produced and neither got the creators thrown in jail. That's the difference.
- archagon 10y agoSadly, this is very much in line with what I've been seeing from WikiLeaks in this past year. Assange is growing increasingly vindictive and conspiratorial, and any future WikiLeaks data dumps need to be viewed in this light. (Which is to say: even if the documents are genuine, their curation and any theatrics surrounding them should be heavily scrutinized. WikiLeaks seems to no longer be an equal-opportunity leaker, but instead focuses its attention on Assange's political enemies.)
- meowface 10y agoWould it be fair to say that Assange is currently on a mission to expose the American government's dirty laundry at all costs, even if it means cooperating with other bad governments? Could we expect him to focus more heavily on the Russian and Chinese governments in the future?
- DominikR 10y agoIt doesn't work that way, he doesn't hack the US, Russian or Chinese government and he doesn't direct other hackers, he only gets to leak data that was given to him by whistleblowers. So your calls for Assange to specifically expose Russia and China to somehow "be fair" is quite senseless. I have to wonder how you think this actually works?
- meowface 10y agoI understand how Wikileaks works, but keep in mind he holds onto things for a while and waits for an opportune moment to release them. You can't doubt that the leaks of the past few months have been very politically motivated to inflict as much damage as possible (which is not necessarily a bad thing), and not just a mere passing-on of what others gave him. Are we to assume he's never been contacted by any Russian or Chinese dissidents? Maybe not, but if he has, I'd definitely like to see a proper release.
- Natsu 10y agoTheir twitter is complaining that if they had the Podesta emails earlier, this might've been Sanders vs. Trump.
- empath75 10y agoIt's sort of bizarre to describe Russian intelligence as a 'whistleblower'
- mcv 10y agoIf you don't try to distinguish between whistleblowers and government intelligence propaganda, then you end up discrediting the former and becoming a tool of the latter.
- shruubi 10y agoWhat I see when I look at the whole Wikileaks/Assange situation is a guy who started off well-meaning and really did want to make a difference who through a stroke of right-place-right-time happened to receive at the time the largest leak of classified documents in history. I honestly feel that being suddenly thrust into the spotlight as the most notorious person in the world at the time put Assange in a position he was not physically nor mentally equipped to deal with, and everything that has happened since then is a combination of not being able to deal with the fame and notoriety he gathered and an ego that prevents him from asking for help. He had isolated himself in a self-created cocoon of paranoia and ego long before he did so literally in the Ecuadorian embassy. In some ways, I feel bad for the guy, his intentions were well-meaning, and I respect the hell out of a guy who would stand up to the most powerful nation on earth and call them out for what they were doing, but Assange is his own worst enemy, and his current situation is of his own making.
- orthoganol 10y agoFYI, no proof has been given that Julian is still at the Embassy since the episodes last Sunday (no sightings at the window or balcony, no picture or clips). The WL subreddit in general believes there's been fishy activity on their twitter since then.... they just now tweeted the long awaited "prove Julian is OK" tweet, but unfortunately it is just some sentences of text. I think at the minimum there is cause to raise an eyebrow.
- idlewords 10y agoThis just seems like an attempt to generate drama.
- orthoganol 10y agoI'll remove it if it's too sensational, but there has been a steady stream of panic threads on certain subreddits over the last week, and I was trying to give an objective, short rehash. Anyways I'm not advocating a jump to conclusions, just to keep an eye on it.
- idlewords 10y agoI wasn't referring to your comment, but to the brouhaha you reference. Sorry to imply otherwise.
- FireBeyond 10y agoHelpfully fueled by some of the Wikileaks crowd, who are active tin-foilers. For example, Gavin MacFadyan, a WikiLeaks staffer, was diagnosed with an illness a while back. A few weeks ago, WikiLeaks said as much, and sent him best wishes in a Tweet. He died the other day. WikiLeaks response was to go back and delete the tweet, and now the flames of his "mysterious and sudden death" are being fanned in those subreddits - "how long before JA dies from a sudden and mysterious illness?" Not to mention the other wing nuts: "There is a wireless telephone bug .This has been caught by my bug detector. Active on the frequency 400 kilo Hertz. Other people also have verified this. This needs stopped immediately check out my timeline. This signal is all across the U.S.A." This is just after the claims of the military raid on the embassy in broad daylight that no-one could get photos of because (they couldn't decide): a) the military were telling people they'd be prosecuted if they did, or b) the military were using technology to "obfuscate" any photos people did take.
- fatdog 10y agoMore of the same political tactics. Feel dirty having read buzzfeed. There should be an Onion article titled, "Challenger to status quo is racist, anti-Semitic, transphobic, misogynist, possibly gay, rapist, pedophile, terrorist, bogeyman." Yawn. Writers like that are why people are backing the republican nominee.
- AlexB138 10y agoThis is so transparently a hit piece that it's sad. A weak attempt to divert criticisms from leaked emails with "They're just trying to settle a personal score against Hillary!".
- skilled 10y agoThe irony in all this, is that the author of this piece is likely to have been paid really well by BuzzFeed in order to secure publishing rights. It sounds nothing short of an opinion piece.