8 ms·
I don't understand the economics of colonization. >Following the example of colonial America, let’s pick as the affordability criterion the property liquidatio
by nabla9 10y ago
I don't understand the economics of colonization.
>Following the example of colonial America, let’s pick as the affordability criterion the property liquidation of a middle-class household, or seven years’ pay for a working man (say about $300,000 in today’s equivalent terms), a criterion with which Musk roughly concurs. Most middle-class householders would prefer to get to Mars in six months at the cost equivalent to one house instead of getting to Mars in four months at a cost equivalent to three houses.
Colonization of America was extractive. You send colonists and they survive on their own and even pay taxes and you get products back. That's not what would happen on Mars. There is nothing so valuable that it would be worth carrying back to Earth. At the same time it would take huge amount of money to support high-tech colony in Mars until it can support itself.
I imagine that the cost of moving people would be insignificant compared to the "colonization kit" that would enable the colony to become self sufficient. Developing that kit would probably cost more than all technology needed to move people to Mars. Just imagine the amount of technology transfer needed to build and maintain maintain systems for breathable air (air tanks, seals, valves, inspection equipment, instrumentation, automation electronics) without help from the Earth. Until Mars settlers can build things in-house, they need constant economic support from the earth.
ps. We don't even know how to sustain biosphere in closed environment yet.
- Meegul 10y agoI believe in the use of Mars as a sort of space-hub. It's better fit for this purpose than Earth, in many ways. It has less atmosphere, allowing for easier launches. Additionally, with around 1/3 the gravity, launches and landings are even easier. It's also closer to the asteroid belt, potentially making it useful as a sort of space mining hub and providing an economic incentive other than resources found on the planet. That said, I am also doubtful. I don't foresee a trade-hub attracting 1 million people - if there are really a million people who want to go. Who the hell wants to risk their life and net worth just for the privilege of living on a rock less hospitable than Antarctica?
- narag 10y agoCeres is a much better hub for mining asteroids or as an intermediate step to gas giants. Martian atmosphere is a b as the sad yesterday news show. Also less gravity. If you're going to need living in an underground bubble, look for the practical arrangements, not for the planet status.
- kitsunesoba 10y agoCeres isn't well-suited for long term human habitation due to extremely low gravity and a surface environment much more hostile than that of Mars. You'd either have to have a sizable rotating space station nearby or do everything with remotely controlled and/or autonomous robots, and in the case of the latter you'd be much better building the robots and/or space station on Mars and launching from there than trying to get all of that out of Earth's gravity well.
- ajmurmann 10y agoIn the Expanse series they solved Ceres' gravitation issue by speeding up rotation and walking on "the being" of their tunnels.
- narag 10y agoI took for granted that you would not use surface. The rotating station can be built inside a cave. The main advantage over orbiting is mining. In other words, I believe that Mars' appeal is a mirage. Musk and company are seeing it as another Earth where people can live like here, with a little terraforming. I think it would be much more difficult. Of course I could be wrong, or I could be right but, even then, Musk could be modern Columbus.
- spc476 10y agoI would rather see the moon colonized than Mars. First, it has a resource that has economic value both there and here on earth: H3. Second, transporting that H3 would be cheap (as it's going "down hill" so to speak). There's also water, which makes it a bit cheaper to support a lunar colony. It's close by and we could certainly learn a lot about self sufficient support on alien worlds.
- snrplfth 10y agoNot that people shouldn't go to the Moon, but there are a few 'amenities' that make Mars more attractive for a lot of people: - Water and free carbon dioxide are hugely more abundant on Mars than on the Moon. These are essential supplies for increasing biomass and making fuel. - There's a nice, somewhat-protective atmosphere. - There's a 24.66 hour day. - Temperatures are relatively moderate.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThere's also the possibility of starting a greenhouse effect on Mars[1], which would make it more habitable. No such possibility on the Moon. [1] - http://www.nbcnews.com/id/6908408/ns/technology_and_science-space/t/greenhouse-effect-could-make-mars-livable/ http://www.nbcnews.com/id/6908408/ns/technology_and_science-...
- snrplfth 10y agoTrue - over the long term it has more potential.
- DennisP 10y agoI think a lunar colony would be great but helium-3 isn't a good reason for one. If you can get net energy by fusing He3, you can also do it by fusing deuterium, which is easier. And the end product of deuterium fusion is He3! (Half the time directly, the other half producing tritium which decays to He3.) So instead of sifting through millions of tons of dirt on the moon, you can just make He3 on Earth and gain energy in the process. Deuterium fusion produces neutrons but they're lower energy than D-T neutrons. Fusion startup Helion (funded in part by YCombinator) is working on a hybrid D-D/D-He3 fusion reactor, and says only 6% of the output energy would be as neutron radiation.
- Someone 10y ago"Additionally, with around 1/3 the gravity, launches and landings are even easier." Launches, yes, but landings? Athmosphere is your enemy during launches, but your friend in landing. Mars has an atmospheric pressure less than one percent of that of earth. That makes losing speed other than with rockets a problem, and that requires bringing lots of fuel. In addition, the athmosphere that's there can be windy and turbulent. That can directly affect a spacecraft, but also causes dust storms that can make it hard to measure distance to ground.
- drakonandor 10y agoyou must note mars G is also not 9.8 m/s^2
- snrplfth 10y agoMost of the cost of building a base on Mars is in the transportation. If it becomes possible to reuse the launch vehicles, then the cost falls. Ideally, it falls far enough that people (and sponsoring governments/organizations/companies) will be able to afford it on a pay-per-seat basis. That's pretty much the whole of the economics. People and governments will jump at the chance to send humans to Mars, if there's a way to do it at a reasonable price. The cost of the things that are necessary on Mars that will have to be shipped from Earth will be rolled into the ticket price. Hence the first few rounds of tickets will probably be quite expensive.
- nabla9 10y agoIf you need to replace wheel on Mars rover or take a aspirin and you need to transfer it from earth, the cost will be enormous. Colony that can't support itself economically will collapse when outsiders stop supporting it. When the honeymoon is over, people don't' want to pay. To make the colony self supporting, you need to transfer factories, chemical plants, machine industry, mining industry, etc.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> To make the colony self supporting, you need to transfer factories, chemical plants, machine industry, mining industry, etc. Like they said, most of the cost is transportation. Which gets cheaper.
- snrplfth 10y agoI mean, it has to! You simply cannot build the kind of permanent presence on Mars with disposable rockets and ships, unless you have some sort of super-advanced Von Neumann robots that can be sent once and set it up on their own.
- Teever 10y agoYou need to transport a seed factory.[1] The clever thing about the Mars Colonial Transport is that it includes solar panels to generate electricity as well as the machinery needed to produce methane and oxygen which serves as fuel for a return voyage. The really cool thing about this is that methane can be used as a feedstock to produce many plastics and the oxygen can be used for humans to breathe. The MCT is a prototype for a seed factory style Von Neumann probe. [1] https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Seed_Factories https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Seed_Factories
- olegkikin 10y agoNot everything we do is for the monetary incentive. The goal of Mars colonization is to create a second (eventually) independent base, so humanity has a chance in case of a catastrophic event. I'd say even if it costs a trillion dollars, it's worth it. US GDP is what, 18 trillion per year?
- onewaystreet 10y ago> Not everything we do is for the monetary incentive. It is when a private company is doing it.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoBut this is being driven primarily by one private individual.
- DennisP 10y agoIt is when a public company is doing it. Privately-owned companies can do whatever the heck their owners want.
- maxerickson 10y agoPublic companies can also have whatever mission they want, subject to oversight from the owners.
- DennisP 10y agoYes but the ownership is open to anyone, so it's a lot easier for activist investors to change the mission to a more profitable one. Musk is keeping SpaceX private specifically to keep this from happening.
- mortenjorck 10y agoWorst case scenario, what would that actually be like? A few hundred people who gave up their lives on earth to live in habitats on an inhospitable planet one day learn that the worst fear of the 20th century came true, and there's nobody left back home. It's just them, the only remaining sentient beings in the known universe, without 99% of the technology that got them where they are now. How could they even begin to try to rebuild civilization when they can't even go outside without an apparatus that took thousands of years of science to produce? What is the speed divisor for advancement of a society marooned on a world it didn't evolve to live on? I'm all for Mars colonization, but as a backup plan for Homo sapiens, it kind of sucks.
- marze 10y agoYou need to think of it as a retirement community for well-to-do individuals with a desire for above average adventure. There are a lot of high net worth individuals on this planet.
- nabla9 10y agoThat's not the colonization that people talk about.
- ufmace 10y agoAnd how many of them are seriously interested in going to Mars as early colonists? Maybe a handful at most. Consider how they got to be high net worth in the first place. A lot of work, a lot of risk. What for? I'd say for status and luxury. Things that they will lose if they go to Mars - living in cramped pressurized stations with a few dozen other colonists.
- hammock 10y ago>We don't even know how to sustain biosphere in closed environment yet. Isn't that what that documentary Biodome was all about?
- fudged71 10y agoWhat if earth patents/IP were invalid on Mars? Wouldn't enterprises race to mars for the chance to code/manufacture components that they are legally and financially restricted from doing on earth? >Until Mars settlers can build things in-house, they need constant economic support from the earth This is where digital manufacturing (CNC, laser cutting, 3D printing) actually makes sense. You go with the base materials and blueprints, and you can survive without transferring goods. You manufacture on-demand, and the blueprints can change based on feedback/results. Mars SHOULD have a prototype culture, the same as with explorers. With engineering/research help from earth, a fab lab on mars would be incredibly valuable. Science the shit out of it!
- gus_massa 10y agoEven is patents are invalid, when you bring they back to Earth they will be confiscated. It's like burning a pirate DVD in the middle of the sea and expecting to sell it legally in New York. (And probably the transportation cost will be still high enough to make it mot profitable.)
- fudged71 10y ago>when you bring they back to Earth they will be confiscated Nobody is talking about using Mars as a manufacturing base to transport to Earth, it's all about creating a self-sustaining colony. There has to be stronger incentives for people/companies to move there. Even on earth there are many economic zones incentivized by lack of regulation etc.
- yongjik 10y agoIf Martian colonists can manufacture something using 3D printing, Earthlings can also do it, and probably a lot more cheaply, because all the necessary ingredient and parts (and even customers) are within forty light-millisecond, instead of ~20 light-minutes. The economy is just not going to work.
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoI'm having a hard time understanding this comment. That people on Earth can do it too does not detract from people on Mars doing it. The parent comment isnt saying there will be an economy of building things on Mars and sending them to Earth, they're saying Mars can sustain itself without sharing an economy with Earth. Which I believe is true. And for what it's worth, I'm actively working to build better robots with commodity 3D printers[1] and I hope to build self sustaining communities on Earth with 3D printed micro factories that produce all the goods humans need for survival. I believe it is possible to make economically closed self sustaining communities. Both on Mars and on Earth. We've done it on Earth for a long time. [1] https://github.com/tlalexander/Flutter-Scout https://github.com/tlalexander/Flutter-Scout
- hinkley 10y agoA lot of Seattle and San Francisco were built by supplying miners, and each other (Seattle did a steady trade of wood to SF). If the real extraction happens on asteroids, then Mars or even the moon are a better base of operations just due to the smaller gravity well. And Mars isn't without its own mineral wealth. Several that would be important for growing food.
- nabla9 10y agoAsteroids near earth or diverted near earth can be economically sound but it's possible that mining nodules on the bottom of the ocean is more economic solution. If you look at the delta-v map of solar system, everything massive like planets, is not going to be hub or center of extraction of minerals for other places. Mars would sit at the bottom of gravity well and be economical sink. Deep space mining (robotic or semi automatic) of asteroids can be economically viable, but just few relatively small asteroids would provide Earth or Mars for centuries. But raw materials are not enough, you would need industry to build all stuff you need and maintain it. If you can't manufacture 3D printer or CNC milling machine by yourself, you need to buy it from Earth. Just being able to make cast iron is not enough, you need high-tech equipment and manufacturing for them to survive. Making Mars self sustaining circular economy would be massive systems engineering challenge.
- seer 10y agoI think if the cost of sending people to Mars really did fall down to those estimates, then countries themselves will try to send colonists, only because if they don't, and others will, then they will "miss out". Imagine if China insisted it wanted to send 10 000 of its people there? I'll wager europeans, americans, russians and indians will want to send at least as much, just not to be exposed as "weaker". It'll certainly be a factor in their decision making at least.