21 ms·
Cuomo signs bill prohibiting Airbnb listings in NYC
- gaius 10y agoKrueger noted that the legislation does not prohibit those who use sites like Airbnb from renting out a spare room while they are in their homes. So if the sharing economy is REALLY about sharing, there's no problem!
- Malician 10y agoThe last Airbnb I stayed in was obviously lived in, but the fellow was temporarily out - probably with his GF. The one before that was a really nice spare cottage in the backyard of a couple grandparents. Both experiences were far better than any hotel, even fancy ones. I'm really bummed at this response to airbnb.
- ethanbond 10y agoWhat about going away for work? I don't have a spare bedroom (uh, there aren't many of those in NYC), but I do travel quite a bit. I get the gist of the law and wholeheartedly support it. I just wish there were a way for it to be a bit more targeted (say, a days/year stipulation).
- gaius 10y agoIt is - this legislation from 2010 is about lets of <30 days.
- ethanbond 10y agoYou don't take trips for less than a month at a time?
- gaius 10y agoYou would need to be away for at least 30 days and your prospective tenant would need to sign a lease for at least 30 days. Then, under this legislation, it's kosher, and would be governed by your own tenancy agreement/coop board/whatever.
- ethanbond 10y agoYeah, I'm not asking for an explanation of the law. I understand how it works, and that's the problem. It bans the usecase of allowing people to rent out while they travel, which wasn't the stated intention of the law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mamurphy 10y agoThe legislation allows you to rent a spare room in your house. What it disallows is having an apartment you rent out in full on AirBnB, either doing that exclusively as an income source or yourself staying elsewhere whenever you are renting it out. Put in that context, the legislation seems pretty well-aimed at its goal of creating more affordable housing in the city. If you are renting an entire apartment out on AirBnB full time, you are deciding to run an unregulated hotel rather than rent a traditional long-term lease. The city doesn't like that.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe tone of Airbnb's response to this law really reveal their true colors.
- kafkaesq 10y agoYep. As if we were dumb enough to believe any of the following: “In typical fashion, Albany back-room dealing rewarded a special interest — the price-gouging hotel industry — and ignored the voices of tens of thousands of New Yorkers,” Airbnb spokesman Peter Schottenfels said in a statement. “A majority of New Yorkers have embraced home sharing, and we will continue to fight for a smart policy solution that works for the the people, not the powerful."
- tragic 10y agoWhat, that their true colors are bog standard corporate PR suggesting without actually stating that their own interests are coterminous with all ordinary persons, but none of the ill defined elite? Just fancy that.
- hueving 10y ago>Put in that context, the legislation seems pretty well-aimed at its goal of creating more affordable housing in the city. At the cost of higher temporary housing costs for people that want to visit. Addressing supply by ripping supply from a different market is a bandaid. This benefits hotels much more than low income people.
- wcarron 10y agoWhile I typically would support a tech company, and this is not to say that I'm not pro-technology and want smarter legislation to keep track with technology advances, the opposition does have some good points. Having only recently become able to afford my own apartment, it appears to me that this legislation is, at its core, designed for the purpose of renter protection. Housing prices are literally insane in metropolitan areas across America. (LA here). Illegal sublets are already endemic, and were I to own property, or even have a year long lease, the ROI from AirBnBs/subletting would definitely be enticing. I won't assert I'm a moral paragon, but there are many landlords less scrupulous than I am. The problem is that, with AirBnB and sublets come ever increasing rent, eventually pricing huge numbers of people out, which drives down productivity and growth. Uninhibited illegal sublets/hotels create a weird bubble at the very bottom of the housing market, which serves to exert upward pressure on prices across the board, since if one room is now worth $800-$1000/month, a studio apt jumps from $1100 to $1300, and so on and so forth.
- twblalock 10y ago> The problem is that, with AirBnB and sublets come ever increasing rent, eventually pricing huge numbers of people out, which drives down productivity and growth. AirBnB aside, the cities with the highest housing prices, and the highest recent increases in housing prices, also have the highest economic growth by far. In theory, people like service workers will be driven out, the local economy will suffer, yadda yadda yadda. In practice, that has never happened. In San Francisco area, for example, rents have more than doubled in the past five years, the economy has boomed, thousands of new jobs were created, and there are still enough service workers, restaurant workers, municipal employees, etc. to do the jobs that need to be done. If you look at the most expensive cities worldwide, e.g. London, Paris, Moscow, Tokyo, etc., you will find similar situations. If you want to argue for affordable housing on the basis that it is a social good, that's fine. But there is no evidence that high housing prices have driven down productivity and growth.
- steveax 10y agoExcept those service workers probably now have significantly longer commutes. Their quality of life suffers. I don't know how broadly your definition of service workers goes, but this affects teachers, police officers, firefighters, etc.
- sonar_un 10y agoSo if I have to stay in NYC for 3 weeks, I am screwed. Thanks Cuomo, you just made me have to cough up double the price for a shitty hotel.
- hartard 10y agoThat is not true; you are still free to rent a spare bedroom through services like AirBnB.
- jplasmeier 10y agoOr just stay at a few different airbnbs. Which is annoying, but you get what you pay for.
- mkarazin 10y agoOr you could stay in a shared AirBnB. NYC is tough and expensive in many ways. Seems like they are trying to tackle affordable housing and consequently may also need to look at affordable hotel stays. I remember when I used to do field work in NYC, often for days at a time, and I would drive every day from Philadelphia, my home at the time. Awake at 4am and out the door to avoid getting stuck in traffic and then back down to Philadelphia at 7pm.
- sonar_un 10y agoShared BNB's are out of the question, especially if you prefer to cook or have a partner. Extended stay hotels are hundreds per night.
- fernandotakai 10y agosame with me. i can't get a spare bedroom with my wife. and i can't cook at a hotel (which makes our trips to the us less expensive, which allows us to either stay longer or spend more while in town -- and both are great for local business).
- joshcohen 10y agoWhen I visited NY recently I found that hotel pricing was competitive with AirBnB. Some people prefer AirBnB so they can feel like they live in the cities they're visiting, this certainly sucks for them.
- joering2 10y ago> This is an issue that was given careful, deliberate consideration, but ultimately these activities are already expressly prohibited by law So basically the city/state failed to respond to AirBnB illegal activities in short period of time hence letting them thrive and built a multi-billion dollar business. Would that be a key to successful startup? Same thing happened with Uber. So is there any other branch of industry one can try to disturb that would violate local/state laws but such violation would take decent amount of time to stop you in reasonable time before you are "worth" billions? (okay, other than selling drugs which most of us and Ulbritch know will put you in jail for a long time). > In typical fashion, Albany back-room dealing rewarded a special interest — the price-gouging hotel industry Wow, that's pretty strong allegations. Does he have any proof of such illegal activity? If so, did AirBnB did anything to report it? In all seriousness, I frankly doubt there is such a big monopoly so that its impossible to open your own hotel and compete price-wise with others. > and ignored the voices of tens of thousands of New Yorkers Okay well I can find millions or criminals locked in jails saying it should be fine to kill people - is that a good enough reasoning? They also claim Cuomo action infringe on 4th amendment. Can someone stretch it hard enough for me to actually see it Peter's way??
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- YuriNiyazov 10y agoI regularly go to NYC for a month with my partner and son so that the grandparents can interact with their grandson. I always AirBnB a place near the residential neighborhood that my parents live in. Because we have a young child, we prefer our own apartment, rather than staying with the grandparents, nor would the three of us be able to stay in "someone's spare room". This new bill is absolutely terrible for us, because it limits us to staying in expensive hotels, for a month! EDIT: There's no mention of 30+ days limit anywhere in the article as far I can tell.
- DanFeldman 10y agoI guess go off airbnb and contact the host directly? Does this bill make personal connections like this (especially without brokering through airbnb) illegal?
- YuriNiyazov 10y agoAre you saying I should first find a room on airbnb, and then make a deal that I am actually trying to rent the whole apartment? Or should I go on craigslist? FWIW, Craigslist is an absolute non-starter - even though there were publicized incidents with AirBnB guests trashing the place, or hosts being shady, the Verified ID system on AirBnB does ensure some amount of traceability in case of incidents or fraud.
- feedjoelpie 10y agoIf this keeps up, a lot of grandparents won't be able to afford to live in NYC in the first place.
- untog 10y agoActually, no - the legislation allows rentals with a minimum of 30 days.
- YuriNiyazov 10y agoThere's no mention of that anywhere.
- geebee 10y agoAirbnb's response: "A majority of New Yorkers have embraced home sharing, and we will continue to fight for a smart policy solution that works for the the people, not the powerful." I'd be more interested in knowing how New Yorkers feel about regulating short term apartment rentals than how they feel about sharing. I don't think I'm guilty of being a broken record if airbnb keeps misusing the word "sharing." Although I understand there can be some ambiguity in the word "sharing", the arrangement "you may rent my apartment out for a week if and only if you pay me $1,000" isn't anywhere close to this zone of ambiguity. It is commerce. It is unambiguously commerce, it is a pure quid pro quo money for services transaction. New York has passed legislation regulating commerce - in this case, the conditions under which someone may rent out property for under 30 days. Those laws aren't obsolete just because someone wrote a rails app where you can type in an address and click a "create hotel here" button. Also, commerce doesn't become sharing just because the quid pro quo financial transactions take place over the web.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> I'd be more interested in knowing how New Yorkers feel about regulating short term apartment rentals than how they feel about sharing. Around the time when AG Schneiderman first subpoenaed Airbnb's records, Airbnb had a very aggressive advertising campaign in the NYC subway stations. Certain high-traffic stations were plastered with ads proclaiming how "New Yorkers Love Airbnb" and showing "regular New Yorkers" who were using Airbnb. On my commute each morning, it was interesting to see how those ads would get defaced with graffiti... not just once, but every single day, with new messages in different handwriting. The messages weren't saying anything you wouldn't expect - mostly they were complaints from angry neighbors of people who rented out on Airbnb full-time, or people who had to move because their landlords had decided to turn their apartments into full-time Airbnb rentals[0]. But it was quite amazing to see how persistent the rancor towards Airbnb was. I took some pictures of them, though I wish I'd gotten a true time-lapse of those over the span of the weeks (months?) that the ads were up. For contrast, advertising campaigns in NYC subways commonly get defaced, but usually over a much longer period of time. And it's rare for it to be in retaliation towards the advertising company - usually it's people drawing beards on women or making off-brand remarks. [0] Yes, no matter how much Airbnb tries to deny it, this does happen.
- djyaz1200 10y agoI am disgusted but not surprised. When I was commuting back and forth between SFO and PDX I had apartments in both cities. I was able to dramatically offset my costs by Airbnb'ing the apartment I wasn't in at any given time... this helped me launch my business and I'm so thankful for that! The first time this worked out it was an obvious win/win for me and the renter. Right after being excited my next thought was... "wow this really let's the little guy do a little better"... I'm sure this won't last...
- untog 10y agoAt the risk of stating the obvious, if you're commuting back and forth between SFO and PDX to launch a business you are not the "little guy". The "little guy" earns minimum wage and can barely afford to keep their own apartment, let alone rent out a spare one when they're travelling regularly between two cities. All AirBnB does is raise the "little guy"'s rent when the other apartments in their building become short-term hotels for tourists.
- djyaz1200 10y agoYou should have seen these apts. Not fancy. You're right I'm not working at Taco Bell, but you almost certainly make more money than I do. I was able to live a multi-city life on a shoestring budget thanks to a narrow window provided by AirBnb. I'm disappointed others may not have that opportunity.
- unethical_ban 10y agoPerhaps, if zoning laws weren't so strict and new high rise apartments were legal to build, areas like SFO might have more affordable housing?
- torpfactory 10y agoThe way I see it is: you can either have a city where ALL the residents of the city can afford to live (esp. service workers, teachers, elderly folks on a fixed income, etc), or you can have one where those with the expendable capital buy up most of the available housing to use a short term rentals to increase their income further. I'd rather live in a city where many different kinds of people can find a place to live than one where only those with the most money can stay. To be clear: I'd support density limits for AirBnBs without an outright ban and am totally fine with people renting out extra rooms on a short or long term basis. Unrestrained short term rentals seem to clearly drive up the price of property and end up benefiting mostly those who already have the means to own a place to live.
- colmvp 10y ago> “For too long companies like Airbnb have encouraged illegal activity that takes housing off the market and makes our affordability crisis worse,” she said. “They have sat idly by while unwitting ‘hosts’ are evicted for breaking their leases, unscrupulous landlords drive out tenants to profit off the short-term market, and tourists are put in danger by staying in unregulated, unaccountable, and often dangerous illegal hotels.” I think the danger is exaggerated but otherwise, I tend to agree that Airbnb is perfectly happy to profit off of tenants who break agreements set by their city or community organization and play innocent about the legality. And now, in my city at least, units that are owned and operated purely as short-term rentals which in addition to making it less affordable for people who actively want to purchase a place, also disrupt residents. One condo building for example is pretty much known as a Airbnb hotel as residents often see visitors clogging the lobby with luggage and/or endure loud parties. There's something to be said when residents are delighted when Airbnb'ers have a crap experience so that they stop coming to the building.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cheriot 10y agoI've still not been able to figure out how in many cities I can rent a room in an apartment for less than a room in a hotel. How does the hotel industry not have huge economies of scale? Are the hotel taxes and cost of extra fire codes impacting the price that much?
- epc 10y agoAirBnb can't be surprised, NYC is one of the most contentious markets for renters and landlords. There's far more tenants than potential AirBnb landlords. While the hotel industry may well have made campaign contributions to sway the legislature & governor, the fact is that rental regulations are the third rail of NY/NYC politics and anything that screws tenants, as the rise of AirBnb has, is bound to get slapped down.
- epc 10y agoLOL. Down voting. Look, if you come into a highly regulated and highly personal market as AirBnb did in NYC, you simply can't be surprised at the reaction by politicians, if you are then you are incredibly naive.
- throwaway420 10y agoWhat is the proper amount of short term rentals in a city? Should a particular building be used for housing or rentals? I know I don't know the exact answer, but the reality is that politicians don't either. These questions are better solved by pricing, the mechanism that actually directs resources to their most valued ends rather than political edict (which as we all know is influenced heavily by whoever is able to grease the most politicians). Politicians can't react accurately and quickly to rapidly changing supply and demand. The market has an actual signal that does this rapidly and provides incentive to do so. Anything that disrupts this is just another example of corrupt government benefiting their contributors to the detriment of real prosperity.
- jjbiotech 10y agoAgree 100%. I think that the city of New York has no business putting limitations on how a property (that you own) can be used and leased. If you have a community/association that's making those rules, fine... that's fair. It's fair because you agree to their terms prior to purchasing the property. If you rent a property and the lease explicitly disallows subletting, fine. That's fair too. Rules and laws should be granular, specific to their locality, rather than vast sweeping blankets. I'm also in favor of zoning for residential and business, that makes sense. But there's a big difference between someone operating a high foot-traffic business out of their home, and seeing an occasional stranger walk into a residence every other day or so. If there are no specific rules that a localized community has agreed on, then Airbnb should be fair game. Why should the municipal government make the rules?
- RickS 10y agoIt's a shame it's come to this, but I'm sympathetic to NYC here. AirBnB had the time, resources, and advance notice to modify their policies and offerings in ways that allowed real homeowners to use the system but keep greedy land owners from running unregulated hotel chains. AirBnB chose to keep the money hose pouring instead. They implicitly encouraged owners to operate in a way that violated the spirit of moderate, sensible couch sharing. This is well deserved.
- apaprocki 10y agoAgreed -- I even tried to contact them as the legal representative for our building to give them a chance to "fix" the situation and they refused to take down rental ads in our building after we stated it was both against building by-laws and NYC law.
- tptacek 10y agoWow. That's crazy. What did they tell you?
- apaprocki 10y ago"Although we are unable to evaluate private contract terms and cannot arbitrate these disputes, we will share your letter with the user responsible for the listing." Gee, thanks. Notice -- no mention of violation of NYC law in the response.
- apaprocki 10y agoEveryone usually frames this debate as compensating the little man instead of lining the rich pockets of the hotel industry. I have personally not seen this. I am a NYC condo owner and I do not know a single other condo owner that I have met that welcomes illegal short-term renters in their buildings. We enacted a $1000/day fine in our building against the owner on record if we catch someone doing this. We invested in real estate in this city and all signed contracts agreeing that only long-term subleases would be allowed (>= 12 months), and so we are upholding those contracts. Just because someone wants to visit the city and not stay in a hotel does not mean that all the other unit owners in a particular building want you there. It is not just a transaction between you and whoever hands you the keys. The last 2 Airbnb cases in our building were legal long-term subletters themselves listing the apartment on Airbnb without the owner's knowledge. There is so much straight-up illegal activity going on it's not even funny.
- joshcohen 10y agoI'm curious why you desire 12 month leases over, say, 4 month leases. What's the major difference from an owner's perspective?
- apaprocki 10y agoIt's extra work for the management company / Board, but one of the primary drivers is that all the people in the building don't want a constant stream of people moving in/out. Expanding it to minimum 12-month leases means less disruption to people living in the building.
- doublerebel 10y agoShort-term renters do NOT treat the property the same as long-term renters, and renters in general treat property much worse than owners. It lowers the quality of life in the building when residents aren't on the same page. I don't mean that I support NYC's blanket regulation, but any condo owner would have known the situation before they bought the unit. If they desired a income property they could have purchased elsewhere.
- cortesoft 10y ago
- specialp 10y agoIf Airbnb had rules regarding non-share rentals that restricted repeated listings of them they wouldn't have this problem. Yes this law is slightly heavy-handed in that it blocks someone that goes on a trip from time to time from booking their places out, but that is not the majority of listings on Airbnb. The majority of full apartment rentals are people that are running illegal hotels basically. This is hurting real hotels that have much more regulation, and decreasing availability of housing in a city that is getting more residents every year than the entire population of most other places in the USA. Also when you are living in Manhattan, you do not want to have someone different in the place down the hall or above you every day. These people staying short term have no onus to respect neighbors. Airbnb knows that professional illegal sub-letters are the bulk of their business and is not stopping it. Renting a ski cabin out weekly is a lot different than renting out an apartment in the most densely populated city in the USA.
- iamleppert 10y agoWasn't there a study done that shows Airbnb hosts actually account for a small fraction of the homes? I'd really like to see these politicians back up these claims with some data. Where do they get this information from? It seems highly suspect that this could cause a decrease in units on the market that is anywhere close to affecting the housing problems in NYC. Whenever I see a politician throw out the word "senior" and "quiet enjoyment" I smell a rat. The more obvious answer is the hotels don't like this kind of competition (staying in an Airbnb is infinitely better than a Hotel) and have bribed these politicians. Wasn't Andrew Cuomo in the center of all the mortgage scandal stuff years back? Can this guy just go away?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- james_niro 10y agoI love how liberals wants to control everything in your life. Soon they will decided who should stay alive and who should die wait that is Obamacare
- sctb 10y agoYou can't post like this here. Please comment civilly and substantively or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- yuhong 10y agoI wonder what would happen if there was a spot and contract market for housing like there is for DRAM.
- JDiculous 10y agoAs someone who's spent the last 3 months living in AirBnB units and sublets in NYC and doesn't have any desire to commit to a year-long rental lease, this is disappointing. AirBnB makes the market more efficient by increasing the supply of housing that otherwise wouldn't be available and provides more alternatives to signing a lease and wading through scams on Craigslist. If NYC is serious about providing affordable housing, then this would at best be a temporary band-aid patch while they actually tackle the real problem - building more affordable housing. Of course the government isn't actually interested in solving the problem, so blaming AirBnB is more convenient.
- mancerayder 10y agoI agree with this. AirBNB is being used for politicians to add to their perception of support for affordable housing. Yes, there are landlords that amass units to rent them out short-term because they profit more. But when it comes to a short-term rental versus a hotel, are we going to shed a tear for the hotel rooms not rented out that cost 300+ a night? The city had 8M residents in 2000, it has 8.5 today. AirBNB's impact on affordability is grossly exaggerated, given the host of other factors that lead to a high demand to live in New York City: the economy and quality of life being a main one. If anything, the law should apply to people who do this on large scale. I find it frustrating that New York housing regulations, from the DOB regulations, procedure and housing code, to laws like these, sweep the little guy in with laws and threats of fines when the 'popular discourse' criticizes big landlords and large operations. Without going into any detail, sometimes it's just easier to rent to friends and family or leave units vacant than it is to deal with some of the BS regulations that cost you as a landlord. One example is that tenant protections can cost you, a landlord, 6-9 months of unpaid rent legally if you have a professional con (which some tenants know how to be, milking a system while they await to be evicted). As another example, 2008 and esp. 2014 housing code requires sprinkler systems in buildings with three units and above. If you have a building that is large enough to have more than two units, you're better off keeping only two units because it'll be cost-prohibitive. That's one less apartment to help fix the undersupply. And the city makes this expensive by forcing you to use architects, contractors, plumbers, expediters and then getting all the various inspections; meanwhile you're subject to the same requirements as a big developer with large staff. So you're out 100K, what do you do? You either go the illegal route, or you have a 'storage area', or a 'recreation area'. I'm not really thrilled about this decision. I honestly feel the real winner here is the hotel industry. We'll continue to face the pain of a lack of supply and a high demand.
- wyager 10y agoAirbnb is great because it allows people to circumvent stupid, expensive, and counterproductive government regulation on hotelling. Airbnbing is vastly superior to traditional hotelling per dollar spent. This is what people are talking about when they refer to "common sense" regulation or regulation to "protect consumers"; they mean taking economic and social autonomy away from people. Even if a given bill doesn't cost much when amortized over tens of millions of people, they cost a lot to society as a whole, and they start to add up. I don't care what your political theory about regulation is; it is extremely apparent from comparing Airbnbs to hotels that, at least in this area, regulations have made society worse, not better. I hope Airbnb beats this.
- mancerayder 10y agoAnyone know if this applies to two-family houses? As far as I know, the Multiple Dwelling Law applies limits to 3 and 4-family homes, limiting specifically rentals that are less than 30 days. Now, it seems that one and two-family homes are excluded?
- marketanarchist 10y agoGreat, another government overreach. Hopefully someone finds a clever solution around it that protects this peaceful and voluntary economic activity.
- swingbridge 10y agoThere are laws in New York City that say (with good reason) that you can't just turn your home into a hotel. New York is simply enforcing the law. If Airbnb really has the public support they claim then it should be easy to change the law. The reality is a lot (likely vast majority) of New Yorkers really don't want the status quo to change. The politicians know this and hence why they took this path.
- willholloway 10y agoMaybe this is good law in New York City because its so dense and everyone is stepping on one another, but its not good law for the entire, gigantic state of New York. My cousin does cleaning and management of vacation rentals in the Catskills, in parts of New York that used to be vibrant but are now extremely economically depressed and taxed exorbitantly. Forbid vacation rentals that violate noise ordinances, don't cast generalization blankets and act out of prejudice.
- tedunangst 10y agoWhat are you talking about? The law only affects the city, not the whole state.
- whiddershins 10y agoProhibiting some Air Bnb listings. Which were already illegal. Mine would still be just fine.
- transfire 10y agoI hear they'll make an exception for veterans. You have to house soldiers. Says so right in the constitution. ;)
- peterkshultz 10y agoThe title seems like clickbait, especially given the fact that the legislation isn't targeting those who use Airbnb to rent out a spare room.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- herlitzj 10y agoIf anyone is interested, the Attorney General did study this and the report is freely available http://www.ag.ny.gov/pdfs/Airbnb%20report.pdf http://www.ag.ny.gov/pdfs/Airbnb%20report.pdf
- losteverything 10y agoOur tiny town had creative citizens stop the only ab&b house on a residential street. Tell an&b tenants they are not wanted and to state that in their reviews Take all their street parking spaces Call the police nightly to say strangers are in neighbors house and she is away Eventually the city council ruled against the homeowner due to zoning (not a business) The situation was very ugly. Perhaps there should be an an&b companion list where potential an&b renters can see if the property is "friendly neutral or hostile" I would have used that
- 9935c101ab17a66 10y agoThat sounds a lot like harassment.
- Tempest1981 10y agoWhat city was this? Just curious. Sounds like a lot of work for everyone involved, and could defocus the police.
- EGreg 10y agoWait a sec, can homeowners still rent out their primary residence when they are away? I thought the law only prohibited hotel-like stuff.
- davidf18 10y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/22/technology/new-york-passes-law-airbnb.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/22/technology/new-york-passes... > '“In typical fashion, Albany back-room dealing rewarded a special interest — the price-gouging hotel industry — and ignored the voices of tens of thousands of New Yorkers,” said Josh Meltzer, head of the company’s New York public policy.' > 'New York City is the company’s largest market in the United States. The city’s hosts generated about $1 billion in revenue last year, and the company took a cut of that amount in fees.' From this article, AirBnB wasted millions of dollars lobbying to go against the will of the people. Amazing. The quote is wrong. New Yorkers value their safety. They don't want transients in their buildings. There are children, there are elderly, there are women. Perhaps AirBnB should have hired someone who lives in a NYC apartment. They would have explained the importance of safety to the AirBnB executives. It seems impossible that executives of AirBnB do not understand that safety in apartment buildings is important. Perhaps their vision is blurred by the fees they make on the $1 billion in annual revenues.
- shawnee_ 10y agoAirbnb profits from high volume and turnover, just as landlords and Realtors get their cut every time there's a turnover in occupancy. Interestingly, this is the root problem at both ends -- from people living in poverty (Portland's sidewalk tent campers who get shuffled around), those suburbanites affected by the housing "crisis", and those who can afford to own in any upscale hip-n-trendy neighborhoods where Airbnb rentals are desperately sought. Those rooting for turnover are usually those who profit the most from it. Sure, people travel and need to rent rooms once in a while. People like to rent while they're young and mobile, but the two use cases need very serious and separate delineation from each other. Airbnb is pushing them more into "overlap" territory. Airbnb's expansion into "subletting" was the kicker. So, long story made short: it's an interesting economics problem I've been working on solving in my spare time, as a very long and iterated side project with Ecosteader (ecosteader.com). Some of the details emerging need a better format for communication; however, the most clear thing to come from my research is that people need to _own_, and they need to be able to transact with each other directly. Middlemen (Airbnb is the middleman here) taking significant commissions is part of the problem. But the middlemen problem has sort of an obvious solution: to tax rental income so aggressively that it's just not an appealing source of investment to people who invest in rentals. Use the tax generated from over-inflated rents to build properties for sale, and/or figure out a way to use that money to grant-deed land on which people can build. This last option seems the more fun opportunity to me, and is what I originally had in mind building an eco- site. The homesteading movement needs to come back, adapted a bit for the 21st century.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- willholloway 10y agoI escaped NYC and moved to a neighboring state, along the coast, in a tourist town in a relatively economically depressed area. I grew up in this town, and it used to be vibrant and vital and full of young families. It has gotten older, as the younger generation has not been able to afford to take on the homes of their parents, as the job market is not strong. I bought a waterfront three family house, a house that used to be one owner, and one or two tenants on the other floors. I renovated the house, and furnished the other floors. It took me all summer, doing the work myself. I have been renting the other two floors out on airbnb and other sites. I love it. I feel like I have reclaimed my house from other tenants. I own the whole house, yes I let in guests for a few days on the other floors, but they leave, and I can go back into the floors when they are not booked. I can have a change of scenery, and I get income from this whole thing. I love this. I don't want to rent to long term tenants. Its a house, but divided into apartments for each floor. I want to control it. I like taking guests but I dont want to sell a floor for a year. It books well on these sites because its waterfront and in a tourist area. Its a lot of work. A lot of work. I have to scrub showers and toilets and make beds, and I only get a few hours in between guests many days. But the money is good and its a form of early retirment for me. I don't see any externalities to the neighbors, in fact the neighbors are better off living next to a vacation rental than a multi family house. In a multi family investment propery the incentives are all about putting in as little money as possible. In a vacation rental its all about making it look as nice as possible. The extra margin of the vacation rental makes all the difference. Now I care about reviews, so now I want the outside to be professionally landscaped. Now I want the lawn to be perfectly manicured. I want the siding to be nice cedar shingles, I want it to look perfect. Because people rate your house on the basis of whether or not its nicer than their house at home. If its nicer, they give you 5 star reviews and that helps your listing SEO, if its less nice than their house they give you 4 stars and that hurts your listing. So if I lived in this neighborhood, I would want to live next to a vacation rental. It is a higher class of occupant. Instead of working class tenants that can afford 1000 a month, you get professionals that can put 1000 on a credit card 4 months ahead of time for their kids graduation weekend. So its a form of gentrification. But its also a service to the community. In the spring, summer and fall months where demand is high I am doing short term vacation rentals. But in the winter months I am opening up a fully furnished place to people who may be between houses. The working class renters have plenty of options in the less desirable, more inland parts of town. And those options will stay because the only reason I can get decent occupancy rates are because the house is waterfront and in a tourist area. And at the end of the day this is my house! I want to be able to do what I want to do with it, and I like having short term guests. I like meeting all of these people. Its like international travel without having to go anywhere. So I raise my middle finger to Cuomo and his lackeys, I support homeowners rights. The battle cry is My House! My House! Punish people for bad behavior, not for uses you don't like. And maybe in a city where everyone is packed in like tuna in a can its impossible but one size fits all law is unjust. There are plenty of communities in upstate new york where vacation rentals are completely appropriate. My cousin does cleaning and management for vacation rentals in upstate NY, and Cuomo just fucked her, a working class person running her own business in an economically depressed region. So Fuck you Cuomo, fuck you.
- nomad_dude 10y agoI am glad that this bill was signed because I'm tired of having people in my building who I don't know and do not trust. Everyone in my coop is vetted by the Board of Directors before living here - why should AirBnb users be any different?
- FireBeyond 10y agoAnd yet the people your coop vetted are the very ones bring in AirBnB'ers...
- nomad_dude 10y agoNot necessarily. Many buildings including my own have rent-stabilized/controlled units that are still managed by the original owner of the building. The Board of Directors has little influence over these units. Additionally, some of the people who have been caught AirBnBing are original members of the coop, so no vetting was required 30+ years ago. Interestingly, instances of Airbnbing went down significantly after all residents were sent reminders that they could lose their proprietary leases if they were caught running hotels out of their respective apartments.
- rednerrus 10y agoHow many posters in this thread work, in some capacity, for the hotel lobby?
- Symbiote 10y agoLikely none, but plenty of us seem to live in apartment buildings in appealing areas of cities.
- davidf18 10y agoI live in NYC and I can tell you that New Yorkers do not want AirBnB. We do not want transients in our apartment buildings. We want our safety. Many of us have doormen that keep people out. There are children, there are elderly. The executives and the VC firms that fund them show absolutely no respect for New Yorkers who value our safety. > "Cuomo’s signature underscores a concern from companies that operate within the “sharing economy” that New York remains unreceptive to newer technologies that threaten some within certain industries, such as the hospitality and taxi industries." This quote from the article is false. We highly value Uber/Lyft/Gett. New Yorkers love high technology: we have the only 24/367 Apple Store in the nation. We have a 24 hour Best Buy. Same Day Delivery from a number of different vendors. ClassPass, MealPal, MoviePass, CUPS, the list is a long one and some of these firms were first started in NYC. What seems clear to New Yorkers is that AirBnB executives do not value safety.
- mancerayder 10y agoThere's no way to not come off as snarky here, but you keep saying 'New Yorkers want this' and 'clear to New Yorkers' that. Do you have polls to back this up? Otherwise this rhetoric reads like a quote from a politician or talk radio. My question is, how do you know the majority of people agree with you?
- tedunangst 10y agoAirbnb doesn't seem to mind saying that New Yorkers want airbnb because "thousands" of them say so. Doesn't seem hard to imagine there are a thousand New Yorkers who don't, justifying the opposite claim.
- davidf18 10y agoWe all value our safety. Many, many buildings have doormen to keep people out to help protect safety. There is a lot of crime in big cities. I don't know anyone that wants transients in their building. The people AirBnB is referring to are simply those who want to rent their places out for additional money. I think AirBnB could care less about the safety of children, elderly, women, and others. I have seen no acknowledgement that people living in apartment buildings value their safety.
- Apofis 10y agoHow the fuck does Cuomo have the power to ban Airbnb only in NYC? isn't he a state governer?
- travisby 10y agoNYC has in the past pushed state laws that just affect NYC. Gun laws in particular I'm more familiar with [state preemption - except for NYC where they can enact their own gun laws], but some taxing is specially allowed for NYC too. It's not unheard of for state-level legislators (from NYC) to push for something to the state either because 1) the state constitution doesn't allow a city to do XYZ, or 2) because the city government doesn't see eye to eye with the state representatives living there
- epc 10y agoNew York City has very little direct authority, most (not all) City legislation must be passed separately by the State legislature and signed by the Governor to be effective law. For example, the City had to request the State to lower the speed limit on City streets to 25 mph from 30 mph last year.
- drusepth 10y agoVery surprised to see all the (or any) Airbnb negativity here. I've been living in an Airbnb for about 2 months now (as a tenant, not a host) and plan to continue doing so indefinitely. The experience is infinitely better than renting from your typical rental company (and at a comparable price, with Airbnb's monthly discounts), and I don't think I could ever go back. Unfortunately, this just sounds like NYC is making it more difficult for visitors to come check out the city, which is regrettable at best. Hopefully this bill does not also apply to long-term Airbnb rentals also.
- flycaliguy 10y agoIndefinitely? Are you sacrificing the rights and protections put in place for tenants? I'm not sure where you are located, but where I rent I have legal protection for stuff. Temperature control, eviction warning and so on. Seeking out a proper rental agreement with a landlord (not company, just a property owner) seems like a far better idea.
- drusepth 10y agoHonestly, I've never had to directly deal with the rights and protections put in place for tenants when I rented from landlords/companies (for the past ~6 years), and had experiences ranging from negative to "meh". I've only had positive experiences with Airbnb (so far at least). I rent the entire home so things like temperature control aren't an issue, and in the two instances where 1) a host was unavailable to check me in on arrival, and 2) a host needed to end a contract early, Airbnb went out of their way to rectify the situation (calling the tenant every 10 minutes until they responded for #1, and offering equal-cost-per-night lodging at a hotel of my choice for both #1 and #2). I would never expect a landlord to go through that, honestly. FWIW, I'm located in the NL but I've also stayed at Airbnbs in the US and Canada, and have the next 7 months of Airbnb rentals (3 months per place) already booked. I would definitely (honestly, not being facetious here) be interested in what rental rights I'm missing out on by renting through Airbnb, and how realistic it is that I'd actually need them outside of something crazy happening (I have insurance for most of those cases).
- mrcactu5 10y agoI don't see what the big deal is. AirBNB can turn normal citizens into landlords. The best hosts will actually take care of their apartment. So in theory the Free Market protects the interests of both hosts and renters. Maybe? That's one possible way it can play out. NYC really tries to protect the landlord's interests rather than the tents. NYC would be a different place if normal people (who aren't millionaires) actually owned their places. Free market could drive prices even higher than they are today. I don't know.
- jrockway 10y agoThis is just New York politics, right? Here's how it works. We in NYC send all our tax dollars upstate, and then as a favor, they make all the laws for us.
- aabajian 10y agoI rented my Manhattan studio for a month using a Craigslist post. It took less than 10 minutes to make the post, and the place was rented by the end of the day. I had no pictures, and five sentences describing my place. As another poster has already mentioned, Airbnb just made the process safer and more efficient. That efficiency has final affected the bottom-line on hotels, making this a political move. New York will never be "Silicon Alley" with moves like this.
- CPLX 10y ago> New York will never be "Silicon Alley" with moves like this. Tragic. Guess we'll just have to settle for being the greatest city in the history of world civilization.
- tbarbugli 10y agoAncient Rome, home of 20% world's population, is going to be hard to beat, but yes NYC is pretty cool too :)
- skizm 10y agoAnyone know if it is still legal to rent one of your rooms on airbnb if you are also staying there at the same time? Like if I have a two bedroom apartment, can I still rent out one of them on a daily/weekly basis if I am staying in the other?
- akvadrako 10y agoIt's unbelievable how many people in this thread are supporting AirBnB with ridiculous arguments like it's not a business or the government can't regulate what you do with your house. Isn't there a point where the quantity of astroturfing becomes counter-productive?