14 ms·
How did an entire state price itself out for entry-level home buyers?
- beamatronic 10y agoThis is a fascinating and shocking number: "Typical fees in San Francisco are $72,600 per home; in Sacramento, they’re $62,000. And for the six California markets highlighted in the Zelman & Associates report, the average is $51,650. "
- twothamendment 10y agoI built a few homes in a new (didn't really exist in 1998) city in Utah. Fees were about $20,000. I thought that was high! Most of those fees went to the infrastructure that was put it so people had a lot to build on. Getting water power and gas out there isn't cheap and the city owned the power, water and gas utilities - so they had to pay the bonds with something. Since then I built in the middle of nowhere - no city, no inspections (except electrical) and it costs about $20,000 to get water (a well and equipment) and power. Anything much more than that and it seems like it is well beyond recovering the costs.
- gsnedders 10y agoThere's varying levels, though, when it comes to infrastructure—at an extreme end, you might need to expand the road network to deal with increased traffic, and if that's building a new, parallel road, or doubling an existing one, that can get pricy fast. Of course, this is unlikely to affect anyone building a single property, but at least here if you're a developer building a large number of homes you can be expected to make a contribution towards to the cost of the infrastructure associated with the development.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aplomb 10y agoStarted out with an every-man appealing headline and quickly showed its stripes of being a developer funded prop 13 hit article - totally separate from the horror show environmental impact has turned into. The examples given are completely out of whack and strawmen. prop 13 allows for effective tax increase through reassessment of value, but that reassessment is capped so when the market goes crazy people aren't driven out of their homes - the increases effectively keep pace with inflation which should handle increased outlays on part of the localities.
- landryraccoon 10y agoProp 13 creates an incentive for homeowners to oppose development, since their housing values will rise with no drawback on property taxes. It also means that the government is forced to raise sales and income taxes in order to raise revenue. It is harmful for society to have high housing prices which falls especially on younger workers and workers moving into an area, in order to benefit a small number of incumbents. No other good is treated like housing this way. We don't say it's good if your computer or cell phone goes up in price, or if cars are more expensive every year.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoThe bigger issue, IMO, is the mis-allocation of resources that happens when people aren't able to transmit information through prices and market mechanisms. Like, the empty-nester who works in downtown SF and happens to own a 4BR townhouse in Mountain View should really trade places with the family of four commuting from a 1BR condo in SF and commuting down to Mountain View. If they both bought their place at a tenth of the current price, the savings on property taxes can justify staying locked in with long commutes and incorrectly sized living spaces. Note that this sort of example is also one of the strongest arguments against rent control. If you're paying $400/mo for an apartment in downtown SF or NYC, it's worth keeping it as a place to occasionally go to on weekends or vacations or in case you decide to move back into the city. It's classic mis-allocation - even in the midst of a severe shortage, there's under-used resources that don't get used because people aren't allowed to compete on price to get them.
- nugget 10y agoThe more prohibitively expensive California (and the Bay Area in particular) becomes, the better it is for the rest of the country - entrepreneurial talent has already started to relocate elsewhere, and I expect this trend to continue, perhaps even accelerate, in the future. There are advantages to having a single, super-dense concentration of business, marketing, and engineering talent but there are also (in my opinion, greater) advantages to having multiple regions competing fiercely for that talent.
- xrange 10y ago> the better it is for the rest of the country - entrepreneurial talent has already started to relocate elsewhere It's only better if they move elsewhere and refuse to vote for the same policies that caused the problems in the first place.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThe problem is, when you move somewhere else, and you buy your home, you become the person that wants their home value maintained/protected. Are you going to vote against your own interests? If so, I applaud you. Otherwise, you're just distributing the problem across the country, as tech money flows through workers in secondary cities (inflating property prices in Austin, Denver, Boulder, Nashville, Portland, Seattle, etc).
- erikpukinskis 10y agoMoney über alles, as they say. No other way to live. Get that cash.
- xrange 10y agoYes, we are in agreement it seems. https://www.google.com/#q=%22no+californians%22 https://www.google.com/#q=%22no+californians%22
- moultano 10y agoIt isn't their home value they are protecting though. Increasing the zoning limit on a plot only causes its value to increase. It's the "character" of their neighborhood. Somehow we've gotten into a cultural state where everyone expects the place they live to stay exactly as it is for their lifetime. It's totally implausible and destructive, but people fight for it anyways, even when it isn't in their financial interest.
- chiph 10y ago> you’re in the hole by at least $50,000 before you even put a shovel in the ground So, the equivalent of people's downpayment in the rest of the country is lost to regulation. That's insane.
- cjensen 10y ago50K isn't that much if we are talking about a development where that cost is spread over dozens of homes. It's possible they just misspoke, but the quote about Chico did not say "per home." Meanwhile in my home town of Fremont, a developer is putting in hundreds of new homes in North Fremont, and the school district has no way to charge those homes enough to actually build a school for them. The four nearest elementary schools are over-capacity, so the buyers will have the fun of commuting over five miles to school. Consider the source: the linked article is from a Home Builder Industry magazine.
- talmand 10y ago>> but the quote about Chico did not say "per home." And yet the next sentences are: "Typical fees in San Francisco are $72,600 per home; in Sacramento, they’re $62,000. And for the six California markets highlighted in the Zelman & Associates report, the average is $51,650."
- StillBored 10y agoBut then it takes them a few more paragraphs to point out that is for a $600k+ house. Which doesn't make it sound all that bad after all. Particularly when they point out the land itself is about 1/2 the cost. Not that any of it is good for anyone under 40...
- talmand 10y agoThe sale price of the house doesn't matter; it could sell for $100k or $900k, the builder is still out the $50k or more they paid out in fees. Which was most likely passed on to the buyer and I bet the mortgage companies have no complaint.
- vadym909 10y agoThe problem is when Californians start to move elsewhere, they raise prices in those cities too. e.g. Portland, Bend, Seattle.
- zeveb 10y agoYup, and they tend to have the politics whose practical effects ended up driving them from California in the first place. I'd like to see an amendment to the Constitution which provided for internal immigration, such that there's a multi-year waiting period to become a state citizen after moving to a new state. The idea would be to give folks a period of time to acclimate & acculturate to their new state's politics. They would, of course, still be able to vote in their old states during that time period. This might even be good for states that people move from: as their former residents retain voting rights for a period of time while acclimating to better states, they are likely to vote for better policies, to the betterment of those net-emmigrant states.
- rconti 10y ago[citation needed]
- zeveb 10y agoThe politics of Colorado, Florida, Oregon, Virginia & Washington have all noticeably undergone this effect over the past forty years. Heck, that effect was the entire reason for Bloody Kansas, with pro- and anti-slavery people moving into the territory in order to influence its politics. It's why the Free State Project exists. It's why some politicians want to decrease immigration, and others want to increase it. I'm curious why you think it doesn't exist. It's hardly an extraordinary claim, and makes perfect sense: people from a place have the habits of mind common to that place; when they move elsewhere, they retain those habits of mind for some time. Even if they were outliers at home, they are more likely to be like their former neighbours than a random subset of their new ones (ever noticed how much you have in common with a fellow countryman you meet whilst travelling abroad? It's the same effect). And when there is a tremendous influx of people from one particular place into another particular place, then one will be more likely to find people from the former place in the latter — that's just math. Maybe you find this good, but I don't: we should try to figure out what makes a state the sort of place people move from rather than the sort of place people move to, and replicate that. (in California's case, I think it's the sort of place people move to because they must and from because they can)
- lambdasquirrel 10y agoOn the flip side, does this state have enough water for the other 10-odd million people who'd be living in those 3.6 million homes?
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThe state has plenty of water for people to drink. It doesn't have enough water for all those people, and to irrigate a gigantic desert, at the same time.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoUhh, yes. California might have to export a bit less alfalfa. The vast majority of water use is agricultural.
- Grishnakh 10y agoYes, and it's also frequently very wastefully used in agriculture. More water-efficient agricultural practices need to be mandated.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoI'd prefer a market solution - fix the supply of water at the correct level, and have the price for water go up until the wasteful, non-worthwhile uses stop happening.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> I'd prefer a market solution - fix the supply of water at the correct level You don't see any problems with this statement?
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoNot at all. Market based doesn't mean profit-maximizing from the supply side. "Correct" is just short-hand for getting what we as a society want out of our water distribution system. Like, we don't want to use so much water that a river runs dry and kills all the fish in it, even if it means selling a few million dollars more worth of water.
- sremani 10y agoCentral Valley was sort of ground zero for housing meltdown, since we are talking here about the entire state, places like Modesto which are about 2-3 hours from SFO are also out of reach for population? That is surprising, Central Valley is predominantly Agri, but when people of thinking of flying all the way to Colorado, why not move 3 hours East or South ?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ssalazar 10y agoJobs/quality of life/commute. E.g. Denver is better at all of these than Modesto or Stockton.
- dangravell 10y agoAnecdotal evidence from small scale builders suggest building to higher performance standards, even to Passivhaus, add only up to (sometimes no more than) 10℅ build cost. It's all down to design, and this is where volume builders baulk. They can't pay minimum wage to cheapest labour to throw up 'standard' builds - in the UK that's cavity wall, but in the US no doubt you have your own standard approaches with performance problems. Given that no house has ever been sold at a price based on build cost, the type of whining in the OP really boils down to "our profits are lower, can government do something about it?".
- talmand 10y agoSo, is it possible for a local government to ever reach a limit on fees necessary for building in their area before it creates a problem? >> "our profits are lower, can government do something about it?" Seems the complaint is that government is directly responsible for the problem as they see it. Isn't it reasonable for the companies to complain to the government concerning that topic? What if the local government started tacking on fees to your paycheck that reduced your take home pay to what you felt was unreasonable amount? Do you have the right to complain?
- dangravell 10y agoI'm addressing performance standards specifically so I can't speak for other fees. But regards performance targets these exist such that suitable quality housing is built - there are numerous market problems here, so leaving it to the market will not end with a high quality building stock. Performance regulations are too lax by a long way, not too strict.
- laurentoget 10y agoI do not know much about real estate cost but it is interesting to see someone blaming a $50,000 regulatory fee for the $400,000 or so difference in median house cost between CA and other states.
- pascalxus 10y agoIt's not just about the 50K. There's an additional 20% for building impact fees. And all these regulations prevent builders from using more cost effective means for building. And, by far, the worst part of it is, it makes innovation in housing a complete non-starter. It's tantamount to: if in the 1980s (before the shape of the internet was known) the government had decided to tax every page download 20 cents. Imagine how much that would have stifled innovation - everything internet would've come to a screeching halt before even seeing what's possible. Personally, I think these laws are a major crime against humanity. Housing makes up such large percentage of people's spending (50%-65% when you take into account property taxes for 50 years). It keeps you a wage slave for at least 30 years. It doesn't have to be this way - housing can cost a fraction of what it does now without all these regulations, with the right land use policy, the right building materials, using manufactured homes, etc.
- seanp2k2 10y agoLand would still cost a lot because a lot of people who make a lot of money want to live there, and most of them want single-family homes with yards and driveways and school, churches, shopping centers, parks, and residential streets nearby.
- rconti 10y agoHow did the article turn $47,000 (average for CA) and $72,600 (SF) and $62,000 (Sacramento) or $51,650 (six California cities highlighted in the report) into "$75,000 in added costs from fees and building code requirements"? They say the average fees nationwide are $21,000. If the average new home price in CA is $621,135, 73% higher than the national average of $358,200, then it seems like the $26,000 difference in average fees represents only ~10% of the $262,935 difference. It's not insignificant, and it makes a difference at the margin, but it feels like numbers are being thrown around a bit dishonestly.
- carsongross 10y agoA recent conversation with a co-worker really drove this home: what's crazy to me is how comically short-sighted folks are. We've priced our children out of the towns we raised them in but it doesn't seem to bother anyone. And we've slapped a huge amount of college debt on their backs, just to be sure.
- rhizome 10y agoSomeone in the past few months was describing this situation as a return to feudal concepts, where the only most practical way to buy a house is to live with your parents until they die and then inherit it.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoPrior to the Montgomery G.I. Bill, people lived with their parents until they got married - if they could afford it.
- closeparen 10y ago>We've priced our children out of the towns we raised them in Alternatively, "our children left behind the sprawling 2nd and 3rd-string metros we raised them in, realized what rent costs in walkable neighborhoods in destination cities, and are finally beginning to appreciate why we raised them in sleepy suburbs in flyover country and why they spent so much time in cars." Obviously some children got priced out of the Bay Area, but I think most of the rent crisis is attributable to people who grew up in low density now seeking high density.
- lsc 10y agoSo, the case that expensive housing hurts California businesses is well stated and intuitive, (and I don't disagree) But I was considering a counter point the other day. Homeownership here means mid level engineers who have lived here a decade or two often have access to seven figure credit lines. What effect does this have on the entrepreneurial side of things here? To be clear, I am not putting this fourth as a fully formed belief, but it is an interesting argument, I think, and worth talking about.
- whamlastxmas 10y ago>What effect does this have on the entrepreneurial side of things here? The effect is that an already privileged group is more privileged than they previously were (financial flexibility to try a startup), and those less privileged are driven away and forced to relocate. Here's my unformed thought from this: are startups hurting progressive/socialist movements in the US? Their benefit is that they're lean and efficient. They do more with fewer people and fewer resources. This means fewer jobs.
- lsc 10y agoCalifornia does a lot to privilege long term homeowners over new buyers, which is the reason that the problem can't be solved simply by building density. In a very real way, existing, long term homeowners are extracting value from newcomers, as the article points out, in part by pushing more of the tax burden on to new construction, and in part by restriction new construction entirely, which pushes up prices, without significantly increasing the tax burden for existing owners. Many of these existing homeowners would otherwise been displaced by the boom. I have met many people working in service jobs who live in half million dollar plus houses. The tax scheme makes doing so possible; they are still paying taxes on one tenth of that... That was the intent of prop 13. People who don't own and live outside of rent control cities have cause to complain, but the situation is set up to benefit existing owners. The second paragraph of your post is more complex, and I don't have time to address it.
- ScottBurson 10y ago“Cities will tell you that from a property tax perspective, housing is a loser,” says David Cogdill, president of the [California Building Industry Association]. I was trying to make this point a few weeks ago here on HN, in a discussion on Prop. 13, and got pushback. I take this quote as evidence that it's common knowledge among people in the housing industry. Prop. 13 disincentivizes cities from adding housing. Prop. 13 needs to be fixed. The way it should have been done is this: in a year in which property values increase by more than 2%, instead of limiting the tax to 2% more than the previous year's, we limit the payment due to 2% more than last year's payment due. The locality receives a lien on the difference, but that lien does not become due until the property is sold. So in an area in which property values have been rapidly rising, a homeowner who sells their property will have to share their windfall to some extent with the locality. But those on fixed incomes are still protected: their annual tax payments don't increase any faster than they would today. Common objections: "People will take out home equity loans that will have to be repaid at sale, leaving them with a cash loss." A property tax lien is a public record. Banks will take the liens into consideration when deciding how large a loan to offer. This is standard practice already. "The liens will accumulate to the point that they will be greater than the owner's gain on the property, giving them a strong disincentive to sell." No, this wouldn't happen, because the lien is only on 1% of the excess gain (the amount the value increased over 2%). If, for one example, the value jumped in the first year and then went flat, the payment would continue to grow at 2% annually until it caught up to the value. The only scenario that generates a lien larger than the owner's gain is if the market has been up but then drops sharply just before the owner wants to sell -- in short, if there was a bubble. Well, bubbles produce lots of dislocation; I don't think they make for a good argument against this proposal. "Prop. 13 will never be modified." Well, it certainly won't if no better alternative is put forth!
- twblalock 10y agoOf course a disincentive to sell will be created by your proposal! Any lien that comes close to offsetting or canceling out the owner's gain will do that. The lien doesn't have to exceed the gain to create a disincentive. Why would anyone sell for little to no gain? Any time the potential gain is decreased, a disincentive to sell is created. Furthermore, not only does this create a disincentive to sell, it also creates a disincentive to buy. Buying property becomes a lot less attractive when the same disincentive that applies to the current seller will apply to buyer in the future, when the buyer decides to sell the home.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoCan we just set some explosive along the fault line and end this state already? How is it possible that this largely Democrat-leaning state can be so pro-wealth/anti-middle class and poor?
- prostoalex 10y agoIf you were middle-class or poor in 1978 and happened to own some property in California, you most likely did well.
- hilop 10y agoDemocrats are neoliberal now. Baby boomers grew up
- Namrog84 10y agoI'm forever torn on this. What can a non homeowner do to help the problem? I feel compelled to not buy into overpriced homes. But I'd also like one and fear they are only going to become more overpriced in the future.
- Tempest1981 10y agoIt feels a bit like the stock market... you're trying to decide the right time to buy. Not sure anyone can answer that definitively.
- odbol_ 10y agoIs it just me, or is $50,000 out of $600,000 not that big of a deal?
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoI'd venture to guess that the fundamental drivers of prices remain founded on desirability of the state relative to other states. These policies are certainly making it worse, but they are priced in, one way or the other. You might think of it like a luxury tax. The item still sells at the total price, even though there is significant cost to acquire it. Either you can afford a $500,000 home or you can't. If you can, then consider living in California. If not, you've likely got 48* other states to choose from. * Per Zillow, Hawaii's median home price is $571,000, is higher than California's $472,000.
- Frogolocalypse 10y agoAs an Australian, I always muse at what people consider expensive. http://www.globalpropertyguide.com/most-expensive-cities http://www.globalpropertyguide.com/most-expensive-cities There is only one city from the US on that list (New York) of a hundred cities. Sydney Australia is 18th. And you want to talk about bubbles? http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/11/global-house-prices http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/11/global-hou... Australia tops the list (and Sweden, apparently). That list indicates the price of real-estate has tripled in 15 years. So yeah...
- EduardoBautista 10y agoThere is something that is not right with that list. Mexico City is on that list but not San Francisco? I have been to Mexico City and rent is about a third for a similar sized apartment in San Francisco.