12 ms·
Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter views Schiaparelli landing site
- yummybear 10y agoWhat a shame. The only consolation, if any, is that they are not the first ones to crash on Mars. If I remember correctly the historic chances of landing successfully on Mars is about 50/50.
- jackmott 10y agoIt was a trial run lander, the real one comes later. The primary purpose of the mission was the orbiter which is functioning, and lander testing, which failed but hopefully they get useful data from the failure.
- skrap 10y agoJust about! For lots of fun info, check out the interplanetary Expensive Hardware Lob League: https://www.strudel.org.uk/lob/ https://www.strudel.org.uk/lob/
- dwightgunning 10y agoHa! This deserves some credit. The tone of the writing makes me think of Starship Troopers. Very tongue in cheek and very funny.
- erjjones 10y agoThis deserves its own thread entirely! Awesome.
- jcoffland 10y agoThe chances of landing are 100%.
- analogmemory 10y agoBut not successfully...
- njharman 10y agoI believe rocket scientists make a distinction between landing and impacting.
- pmontra 10y agoSome landers failed to reach Mars and crash land. Check the list at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars
- nicholasjon 10y agoReminds of the "Seven Minutes of Terror" video that NASA put out ahead of the Curiosity landing explaining how they intended to make it safely to the surface. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ki_Af_o9Q9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ki_Af_o9Q9s (Note: I get goosebumps every time I watch this, absolutely amazing problem solving.)
- Ma8ee 10y agoI'm still amazed that it succeeded. I was prepared to bet quite a bit of money that at least one of the many quite complicated stages of the landing would fail. I'm happy I was wrong.
- pmoriarty 10y agoTo me, the air bags[1] used to land the Spirit and Opportunity rovers seemed like a saner way to go than trying to deposit them gently directly on to the surface using a sky crane. The reported reason the sky crane was used for Curiosity is that it was too heavy for the air bag approach. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRCIzZHpFtY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRCIzZHpFtY
- danbruc 10y agoIt's 185 kg vs 899 kg. I am already a bit surprised that it worked to land Spirit and Opportunity, but the lower gravity probably helps.
- Sharlin 10y agoBut the Spirit and Opportunity EDL also involved retrorockets in addition to a heatshield, a drogue chute, a parachute and the airbags - it's just that the retrorocket part didn't have to be as precise as with Curiosity.
- Coincoin 10y agoI actually laughed the first time I saw it because it looked so much like a Goldberg machine... But it cost 500M$... And they only got one try.
- Aqua_Geek 10y ago> Estimates are that Schiaparelli dropped from a height of between 2 and 4 kilometres, therefore impacting at a considerable speed, greater than 300 km/h. Ouch. It will be interesting to read the results of the investigation as to why the landing thrusters turned off prematurely.
- raverbashing 10y agoYes, it seems they made quite a dent on Mars I'm not so sure that this should be interpreted as "thrusters turning off prematurely" rather, it getting to the point of shut-off sooner (and faster) OR it stopped because they hit the ground
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoI read in some of the reports (can't remember if official ESA, news, or twitter) that they were turned on for just 3 seconds (instead of the inteded ~50), plus the parachute was cut off earlier too. So, as this report from ESA says, it fell from at least a 1000 times higher than intended (the cut off altitude was 2m or so).
- shuntress 10y agoThat is when it switched from thrusters to lithobraking.
- Sharlin 10y ago
- jcoffland 10y agoTrial run? Sounds like the spin machine at work to me. I wonder what a trial run to Mars costs these days.
- UseStrict 10y agoWell their actual mission was the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter. Since they were sending hardware to Mars orbit anyways, they decided to try and attempt a landing. The rover was not designed to last very long - 7 days battery. Their actual high quality lab on wheels will be going out in 2020.
- nixos 10y agoYes, the point wasn't the lander but the _landing_ . If the landing works, they can try an expensive rover in 2020. Now, they can fix what they think broke, but they're never sure until it (fails to) land.
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoOr if it lands they can say "see? we learned to land with the crashed Schiaparelli, so it was good sending it in the first place". But a succesful landing would've been better, now they may face a few objections arising from the failure.
- nixos 10y ago>Or if it lands they can say "see? we learned to land with the crashed Schiaparelli, so it was good sending it in the first place" Failures may not be bad, but they're still failures. Apollo 1 was a failure. Sure, it helped NASA make future spaceflight safe, and may have saved more lives in the long run (Apollo 13 makes it even) , but it didn't accomplish its goal. Especially that a successful lander is a reality check. We did it once and we can do it again. A failure doesn't say anything. It could have been a stuck thruster, it's fixed, and then the crush-zone is found to be defective. That's why first (and test) flights tend to be cheaper and failure prone.
- BurningFrog 10y agoThe main mission of this expedition is the Trace Gas Orbiter: http://exploration.esa.int/mars/46475-trace-gas-orbiter/ http://exploration.esa.int/mars/46475-trace-gas-orbiter/ "the Trace Gas Orbiter will be deployed to detect a wide range of atmospheric trace gases (such as methane, water vapour, nitrogen oxides, acetylene), with an improved accuracy of three orders of magnitude compared to previous measurements."
- beamatronic 10y agoIt is so bad ass that when we have a question about something that happened on another planet we can just point one of our other robots' cameras at the site!
- protomyth 10y agoI'm waiting for the day where someone can tell their rover to drive / fly over and find out what the heck happened.
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoOpportunity is not so far (it's actually inside a crater nearby I think), but it'd take months to get to place, and there may not be enough scientific value in doing so just to see the charred remains of Schiaparelli. But who knows, it's so over it's expected mission life that maybe someone goes "f* it, let's go take a look".
- dogma1138 10y agoOpportunity is very very far, yes technically it is close if you are thinking about traditional modes of transportation, but it traveled so far only about 40KM, and it's max speed is about 2 inches per second it is not going to get there.
- mturmon 10y agoOpportunity tried to see the descent, but it did not work: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-lakdawalla/2016/10191525-brief-update-opportunitys.html http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-lakdawalla/2016/1019152...
- smpetrey 10y agoDamn. So cosmic rays are pretty intense huh?
- 10y ago
- ythl 10y agoHigh visibility European space missions seem to have catastrophic failures a lot
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoMmmm... not so sure, the Huygens probe was a high visibility ESA mission[0] and worked fine. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens_(spacecraft)
- trothamel 10y agoWell, except for one of the two data channels being lost, and a design that had a major flaw that was overcome only with heroic engineering effort (and a major mission redesign). Both of these are discussed in the wikipedia page.
- mynameisvlad 10y agoSure, but I wouldn't consider any of those "catastrophic failures".
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoStill the only agency that landed on Titan, which was never attempted before and there was no previous data/experience on how to do it.
- Gravityloss 10y agoIt wasn't publicized anywhere near enough. :(
- TeMPOraL 10y agoRosetta was pretty much a success story.
- Sharlin 10y agoSuch as? Philae was a partial failure, certainly not catastrophic, but it was a "nice to have" addition to the Rosetta mission which as a whole was a huge success. Schiaparelli was an EDL engineering test and a landing failure was not exactly unexpected outcome. If the engineers can figure out what went wrong from the telemetry, it can probably be counted as a success. The actual beef of the mission is the Trace Gas Orbiter spacecraft that continues to function perfectly. Unfortunately, in both cases people end up thinking that the whole mission has failed when actually just a small part of it did :(
- LunaSea 10y agoOnce again, billions of euros are put into use for what is essentially scientific curiosity instead of trying to solve the very real problems Europe is facing. I love astronomy and space exploration but the amounts of money wasted into it rather than other problems with a high priority is staggering.
- pavlov 10y agoThe EU has a population of over 500 million. For a program like this (assuming it's all from public funds), each citizen paid on average less than a cup of coffee costs at Starbucks. It's real money, but what pressing pan-European problem could you really solve with such a tiny budget?
- LunaSea 10y agoLook at the economical situation of countries like Greece and Spain. That would be one starting point.
- maxander 10y agoAccording to the easily-found stats on Wikipedia [1,2], the MRO cost $720 million, whereas the Greek bailout given in 2010 (alone) was €110 ($119) billion. Notice the "m" in the first and the "b" in the second- your "starting point" is orders of magnitude beyond the resources we're talking about here. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Reconnaissance_Orbiter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Reconnaissance_Orbiter [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis#2010_revelations_and_IMF_bailout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis#2...
- Symbiote 10y agoIndeed, the entire ESA budget for this year is €5.2 billion, of which a third is Earth observation satellites. http://www.esa.int/spaceinimages/Images/2016/01/ESA_budget_2016_by_domain http://www.esa.int/spaceinimages/Images/2016/01/ESA_budget_2...
- mturmon 10y agoQuestions have come up about the landing strategy of the Schiaparelli lander. It uses a Doppler radar to get position and velocity, time deployment of parachute, and calibrate thrust for retro-rockets. The best references I was able to find are these: http://exploration.esa.int/mars/47852-entry-descent-and-landing-demonstrator-module/ http://exploration.esa.int/mars/47852-entry-descent-and-land... http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/Bayle_ExoMars_EDM_Overview-Paper.pdf http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/Bayle_ExoMars_EDM_Overview-... (solid, is undated, seems old and nonspecific in some cases) https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/7B.1_Lorenzoni_ExoMars%202016%20Entry%20Descent%20and%20Landing%20Demonstrator%20Module%20EDL%20overview.pdf https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/7B.1_Lorenzoni_ExoMars%202... (from 2013, more detail)
- pmoriarty 10y agoNow imagine there being 100 people onboard that spacecraft, as Elon Musk plans for.
- animex 10y agoSplat. Not sure if that is a landing site or a crash site.
- tangue 10y agoIn Rob Manning's book [0] : He explained how hard it is to land on Mars. It's nicely sum up in those two sentences : “There’s too much atmosphere on Mars to land heavy vehicles like we do on the moon, using propulsive technology completely,” said Manning, “and there’s too little atmosphere to land like we do on Earth. So, it’s in this ugly, grey zone.” [1] The recent success of Curiosity, Spirit and Opportunity must not shadow the fact that most Mars missions have failed. [0] "Mars Rover Curiosity: An Inside Account from Curiosity's Chief Engineer [1] http://www.universetoday.com/7024/the-mars-landing-approach-getting-large-payloads-to-the-surface-of-the-red-planet/ http://www.universetoday.com/7024/the-mars-landing-approach-...
- smackfu 10y agoAlso it's pretty dusty, so doing a controlled burn all the way down (like SpaceX does on Earth) kicks up a huge dust cloud which settles on all your nice solar panels.
- haalcion3 10y agoTo give it some context, here are the Mars failures: Soviet Union/Russia: 1M No.1, 1M No.2, 2MV-4 No.1, 2MV-3 No.1, 2M No.521, 2M No.522, Kosmos 419 (3MS No.170), Mars 96 (M1 No.520), Mars 1 (2MV-4 No.2), Zond 2 (3MV-4A No.2), Mars 2 lander (SA 4M No.171), Prop-M Rover rover (SA 4M No.172), Mars 4 (3MS No.52S), Mars 5 (3MS No.53S), Mars 6 (3MP No.50P), Mars 7 (3MP No.51P), Fobos 1 (1F No.101), Fobos-Grunt US: Mariner 3, Mariner 8, Mars Observer, Mars Climate Orbiter, Mars Polar Lander, Deep Space 2 China: Yinghuo-1 UK/Europe: Beagle 2, Schiaparelli EDM lander Japan: Nozomi (PLANET-B) Also: Soviet Mars 3 lander (SA 4M No.172) landed, so counted as partial success, but contact lost 14.5 seconds later. And Soviet Fobos 2 (1F No.102) orbited successfully then lost communications during landing, so a partial success. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars
- sathackr 10y agoI don't think the atmosphere is the problem with landing heavy landers like we do on the moon. For some reason I think gravity is the main problem. The only effect I can think of the atmosphere would have is on engine efficiency, and it's so thin I doubt it's much of a consideration at all.
- altechcode 10y agoThat 600MB of telemetry should provide extremely valuable in making that rover they are planning to land less likely to fail. Sadly you really don't get that many attempts...
- ramgorur 10y agoShould we say that the space programs in the 60s and the 70s were more successful? specially, if we consider the communication and the control technologies available at that time. For example, vikings had Honeywell 24 bit cpu with 18K memory. What about those Argon computers used in the soviet venera programs? Or may be, a very fast/accurate computation is not that necessary?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoRockets blew up all the time back in the 60s.
- Sanddancer 10y agoThe landing techniques that are being used are bringing much larger payloads to the Martian surface than were brought in previous landings. Curiosity, for example, is about twice the weight of the Viking landers. In general, we're much more successful at landing and receiving data from mars-bound craft than we were back there; the soviets sent several probes to mars and got minimal data back from them before they failed. Fast/accurate computing is needed for surface work on Mars because it means that the devices don't have to wait around for commands all the time. Giving more processor power and ability means that more flexible programs can be written to sift through the data and just send back the most interesting parts. Fast and accurate are very much needed for the kinds of lab experiments we're doing on mars.
- peter303 10y agoVikings, MERs and Curoisty/2020 each used totoally different landing technologies. Amazing they all worked.
- JoachimS 10y agoI read the headline as "shrapnel landing site"
- Too 10y agoStupid question maybe, but would it not make sense to launch multiple landers with one rocket? The hardware cost of a rover must be peanuts compared to the engineering cost, the launch cost and the time to travel? How big is the lander compared to the launch rocket?