6 ms·
I once had it explained to me there are two kinds of happiness in the world, additive and subtractive. In subtractive, a person tries to add happiness to their
by grecy 10y ago
I once had it explained to me there are two kinds of happiness in the world, additive and subtractive.
In subtractive, a person tries to add happiness to their life by taking it away from other people around them - putting people down, criticizing, picking on people, name calling, etc. Other people are never good enough in their eyes.
In additive, a person adds happiness to their life by giving it to other people around them - compliments, fun activities, positive attitude, etc. Making those around them happier makes the person happier.
It changed my perspective on a lot of people when I viewed their actions in this way.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoYou may have a very skewed perspective if you think that anyone who is giving criticism is trying to make themselves happy at others' expense.
- pjc50 10y agoThat's .. not what that post said at all. Maybe your perspective is the skewed one? There's a difference between constructive criticism, and people for whom criticism is the dominant mode of conversation.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThat's exactly what the post said. Maybe you can provide a different interpretation? >In subtractive, a person tries to add happiness to their life by taking it away from other people around them - putting people down, criticizing, picking on people, name calling, etc.
- yequalsx 10y agoIt's clear from the "putting people down" and "name calling" part of that sentence that the criticizing is not meant in a constructive sense. The poster is clearly talking about a situation in which a person feels lifted up, happier by bringing others down. Such a person, in that capacity, is not providing constructive feedback.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoYou can argue that they are not providing constructive feedback, but the claim was: >a person tries to add happiness to their life by taking it away from other people around them
- striking 10y agoThere's an ambiguity in the comment, but reading the comment charitably can dispel the notion that the person claimed any form of criticism is a form of maliciously bringing people down. Read it however you want, but taken in context I disagree that that's their intended claim. I think that poster meant that malicious criticism is something that can make unhappy people feel a little better about themselves.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThere is little ambiguity. The space of happiness was divided into two mutually exclusive groups (subtractive & additive) with the listed qualities.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- munificent 10y agoCriticizing a person is negative. Criticizing something they have done or created can be helpful. In the sentence, there is no mention of what the person did, so the verb naturally applies to the person. Also, "criticize" as a verb tends to be more negative and imply a more direct attack than "criticism of" or, even better, "critique" which both shade towards implying giving the person more useful feedback.
- danielvf 10y agoI don't think he said that ALL people who give criticism do so for evil reasons, but that some do. That's entirely consistent with my experience in life.
- sprucely 10y agoNot necessarily anyone. Personally, I am becoming more aware myself that when I'm criticizing someone, even indirectly, it's often coming from a desire to elevate myself above them. Think about all the other idiots on the road when you're driving. They're terrible. Thank the heavens you're so much better than them.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoYou may want to look at why you desire to be elevated above others. To me, thinking about others is not criticism. Criticism requires communication with the other party whom is the object of your thought. Criticism was opposed to compliments in the lists, as if not agreeing (and actively making it known) with someone was a "negative" thing to be avoided (with the seeming implication that compliments should be given, regardless).
- recycleme 10y agoEverything we are doing right now is an attempt to find some happiness (now).
- inimino 10y agoNot really, no. Unless you redefine happiness so broadly that it loses all meaning.
- recycleme 10y agoIt's true with the normal definition of happiness. Think about it. Whatever you're doing now is an attempt to get you to a happy state. If you're already happy, it'll fade and you will take more actions to be happy again. This seems to be part of our human condition.
- cdvonstinkpot 10y agoAnd it's an 'additive' kind, being that I get an additional boost of happy neurotransmitter thinking I'm adding a beneficial comment, thus potentially helping a reader to an understanding I have & perceive that they might not have as strong a grasp of. I like to help, thus am happier. If the form button fails to submit my contribution, I feel disappointment. At having wasted the effort in trying to contribute, but moreso, at not contributing.
- fuqted 10y agoWhat are the motivations behind what you're doing? Because likely, at the very least it stems from a Pavlovian habit originally triggered by happiness. "There is nothing in goodness above pleasure, there is nothing in evil below pain" - Sefer Yetzirah (Hebrew book of creation) When it comes down to it happiness is the point of life.
- hilop 10y agoYou can experience compulsions that don't make you feel good. That mental illness, broadly defined, and very common.
- tbirdz 10y agoInteresting idea, but I think you are missing out on the category of happiness that is not related to other people. You can be happy just from your own internal thoughts, actions, accomplishments, without involving other people. I don't even know if the idea of addition and subtraction really apply to internally sourced happiness -- would you just be adding/subtracting from yourself?
- brightball 10y agoYou can be, but people are also naturally social. If you're not, you're going to be lonely or an anomaly (and yes, introverts are still social just tend to be with smaller groups). Since people are naturally social, the people around them are inevitably going to affect their state of mind - especially if we have a desire to be around them.
- MrQuincle 10y agoI'm happiest on days in which (1) I am in a flow thinking about new math, realizing new connections, (2) I am reading or hearing something beautiful, a poem, a new song, (3) I have some time away from the web, under the stars, on the beach. People, I'm happy that they are there, but no they don't make me happy. If I can't give meaning to my own life, who can give it to me?
- tempodox 10y agoI can see the “subtractive” approach work for psychopaths but all I know seems to indicate that it's doomed to failure for ordinary people.
- Kenji 10y agoLeague of Legends generates purely subtractive happiness.
- robertcarter 10y agoI mitigate this by playing Soraka support
- Jemmeh 10y agoI dunno she just sits around subtracting from other team's happiness to make your team happy. :P
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- munificent 10y agoWhen I was in my twenties, I had a similar minor epiphany: there is no law of conservation of happiness. When I do work to make others happy, it tends to make me feel better to. It's not zero-sum.
- rudolf0 10y agoWhat about people who are hybrids?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- amelius 10y agoAnd then there's the hypothesis that happiness is conserved. See e.g. [1] [1] http://unbound-rationality.blogspot.nl/2009/01/law-of-conservation-of-happiness.html http://unbound-rationality.blogspot.nl/2009/01/law-of-conser...
- oldmanjay 10y agoI expected that to make more sense. Since it started out with the notion that humans are not natural, which is one of my very favorite silly falsehoods, my expectations were shattered rather quickly.
- pazimzadeh 10y agoLuck certainly seems conserved.
- wiremine 10y agoMy mom sums it up this way: "There are givers, and there are takers. Be a giver."
- surrey-fringe 10y agoThere's a third kind. Let's call it X. It's where you spend time devising philosophies on human nature that make you feel superior to others.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoThe self referential nature of this comment is pretty funny.
- surrey-fringe 10y agoIt falls into an even rarer category, subtractive ∘ kleene(X)