21 ms·
Where San Francisco Wants New Subway Lines
- dekhn 10y agoI totally agree with the Geary line, although I'd prefer an alternative line: one that goes all the way from downtown to ocean beach under Golden Gate Park, with stops at the major museums and other tourist attractions in the park. From the middle of the park, you can reach both Irving/Judah (major Sunset street) and Geary (although Geary is a hike from the center of the park).
- abakker 10y agoThere is already a line that runs on Irving/Judah - it's the N line. Goes from Van Ness through Cole Valley and then tracks through UCSF and the sunset. Switches from Irving to Judah on 9th ave.
- jdavis703 10y agoBut it's not a subway, it gets stuck with the cars. It's basically a glorified bus line.
- 1024core 10y agoThey should dig and bury the N line. And then put stops every, say, 6-8 blocks instead of the current 2-3.
- mcpherrinm 10y agoThat'll be a huge amount of capital. The sunset is not very dense, so surface-level transit could work fine. The real trick is keeping cars out of the way of the N, via dedicated right-of-way and transit signal priority.
- Nav_Panel 10y agoWhat about an elevated line? Less initial capital but similar benefits to an underground line, though I doubt it'd fly in the current political environment.
- sfaf 10y agoDid you hear about residents protesting that a 100% affordable housing projected blocked their view? Some San Franciscans have an entitled view that their basic rights include the right to have a nice view from their house (to the detriment of any other social issue).
- Ankaios 10y agoSeems like if they wanted to assure themselves of a permanently-good view, they shoulhd have bought up all the air rights between their windows and the ocean.
- 1024core 10y agoDig-and-cover type projects aren't as expensive as pure tunneling. Judah is ideal for it: wide and straight.
- ng12 10y agoThe N isn't that bad. I used to live near UCSF and would take it out to the beach on nice days. Now the Green Line in Boston -- that's a glorified bus line.
- dekhn 10y agoThe N line is the most dysfunctional and crowded lines. I used to depend on it, and it was terrible- you can count on it not showing for 45 minutes (outbound @ parnassus) and then stop/turn around at 19th or 37th without another train for 45 minutes. And, as mentioned, it gets horribly slowed by traffic in the busy corridors. The point of this line would be serve the park and Richmond and Sunset, without the delays of the Irving line.
- capkutay 10y agoI think it makes a lot more sense for the Geary line to terminate in GG Park or somewhere in the inner Richmond. The density in the area around Ocean Beach does not justify a 3 mile extension from inner Richmond to the beach. A 1 mile subway line from Chinatown to the Marina would serve almost the same amount of people.
- abritinthebay 10y agoThis is why you build for the future - not the present.
- capkutay 10y agoThen build a subway to Hunters Point it that's your logic. Ocean Beach is entrenched in hard line Nimbyism and any sort of high density vision for the area is nothing short of a pipe dream. Paying billions for a subway all the way to ocean beach is very low priority based on where jobs and housing are being built.
- abritinthebay 10y agoI hate to meme.. but... why not both?
- dekhn 10y agointerestingly, the N always filled up completely within a few blocks of Ocean Beach (inbound). There is a huge demand for ridership there that is being underserved. I know they put in some improvements (back when I rode it, the biggest improvement was when they had "watchers" who made sure the drivers didn't spend half an hour in the bathroom before starting their return drive.
- aetherson 10y agoHN has a completely crazy idea of SF density. http://www.sfindicatorproject.org/indicators/view/183 http://www.sfindicatorproject.org/indicators/view/183 There's a density map. The Geary corridor is quite dense, certainly as dense as any area not already well served by BART.
- pimlottc 10y agoThat makes me wonder - would routing it under the park make it easier or harder to build? Lots of factors - property ownership, construction costs, land use restrictions...
- cylinder 10y agoThe infrastructure investment is not worth it at all if you remain with low density along these lines. A land tax surcharge should be assessed on all properties that will benefit from this infrastructure.
- jdavis703 10y agoEven more specifically a parcel tax should be created. The more units you then have in your parcel, the lower the tax will be.
- nickff 10y agoThe city has already imposed various 'fees' for permitting which penalize high density development, and also uses zoning to keep density down. Now you want it to tax low density as well? An even more complex web of permits, taxes, and regulations only serves to drive the cost of housing higher than it already is. Why not just remove the barriers to high density development?
- jdavis703 10y agoIncentivizing high density development via tax policy and removing needless regulations are not mutually exclusive.
- nickff 10y agoI agree that they are not mutually exclusive, but would generally prefer a simpler policy to a more complicated one. In addition, governments are prone to create increasingly complex rules which they use to help certain preferred groups (such as neighborhoods or campaign contributors). Reducing the barriers to high density development would encourage densification without increasing corruption; if this is insufficient, more active measures could be implemented soon.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoA parcel tax is a very imperfect cousin of a Land Value Tax-- assessing all parcels the same regardless of land value is extremely inefficient and inegalitarian.
- dkopi 10y agoSubways make sense in dense urban areas - When a lot of people are within walking distance from the subway station. For SF to justify extensive subway infrastructure, it needs to start building higher density neighborhoods.
- dasil003 10y agoSF is the second highest density city in the US. I agree that as long as the NIMBYs prevent building housing, then SF won't really reap the benefits of improved transportation, but SF has pathetically bad public transport for the existing density. I live in much lower density Oakland/Berkeley, and I can get around by BART better than most city dwellers.
- grardb 10y ago>SF is the second highest density city in the US. This isn't even close to being true. It's likely only true if you only count cities with populations over a certain amount. Please see my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12754395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12754395
- dasil003 10y agoAnything outside the tri-state area?
- grardb 10y agoIt cuts the list shorter, but still not quite second place: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...
- thesmallestcat 10y agoCan you say that with a straight face after reading that list? Let's just look at the populations, no names: 11,176 66,455 49,708 50,005 4,724 8,175,133 23,594 2,406 27,395 69,781 6,707 7,137 23,805 20,832 58,114 75,754 34,399 53,926 362 146,199 805,235 Now guess which ones are central cities in their respective MSAs. Excluding those, guess which ones aren't part of the NYC or LA areas. Let's do ourselves a favor and exclude Poplar Hills, Kentucky (362). There's one city left, it's part of the Boston area (which is the next densest large city after SF), and you guessed it, Somerville has a subway with a separate light rail extension under construction. The only outlier is Sunny Isles Beach, FL (20,832), in the Miami area. And Miami? It's just after Philly, all known dense cities. So yea, it's NYC, then SF, minus a couple pockets of LA. And these are all dense places that need subways. It takes a special sort of something to claim, as the top comment did, that SF is not dense enough to warrant a subway, let alone massive large-scale investment in all modes of mass transit as NYC has.
- rubicon33 10y ago> "Expect it to be built, along with that line running under the Golden Gate Bridge, almost certainly not in your lifetime." What a buzzkil.
- dasil003 10y agoMeanwhile London builds a new high speed rail line tunneled under central London in 10 years http://www.crossrail.co.uk/construction/crossrail-construction-programme http://www.crossrail.co.uk/construction/crossrail-constructi... It's sort of pathetic how bad the US has become at public infrastructure projects over the past 40-50 years. Take a clue from cities with 1000+ years of history: you still have to keep upgrading your infrastructure, even if it means bringing in the archaeologists to sort out what you find every time.
- rubicon33 10y agoMy sentiments exactly. I've become increasingly disappointed as our infrastructure fails to keep up with the times.
- pm215 10y ago"In 10 years" is a bit misleading, because that's just the construction time. You need to also take into account the time it took to go from "this would be a good idea" to actually starting to dig, because that's where the SF situation is currently bogged down. http://www.crossrail.co.uk/route/crossrail-from-its-early-beginnings http://www.crossrail.co.uk/route/crossrail-from-its-early-be... says the idea was first seriously proposed in 1974, and was then raised, dropped and batted around at various levels of politics for another 25 years before getting to "serious funded detailed feasibility study" in 2002, which didn't get the final go-ahead until 2008 (with the construction phase then being the 10 years after that and ending 2018).
- erispoe 10y agoCrossrail (or, as it has been renamed, the Elizabeth Line) is a regional rail line, not a high speed line.
- 10y ago
- sfblah 10y agoImplement tolls to drive in SF and route the money to building this. Cities' implicit subsidies for roads are insane.
- oldmanjay 10y agoAre the "implicit subsidies" the taxes dedicated to paying for it?
- sfblah 10y agoMy understanding is that usage fees (gas taxes and the like) don't come come close to paying for upkeep of roads.
- spoonie 10y agoAnd get rid of all of the free street parking.
- DrScump 10y agoWhere are you seeing all this "free" on-street parking? Out in the Sunset, maybe, but nowhere remotely commercial. Meters are creeping all the way to Dogpatch.
- spoonie 10y agoHeh, good point. I live in Ingleside and don't go downtown much. Are the downtown meters free overnight?
- http-teapot 10y agoYes and on Sunday as well. https://www.sfmta.com/maps/parking-meter-locations-and-rates https://www.sfmta.com/maps/parking-meter-locations-and-rates
- DrScump 10y ago
- andirk 10y agoSim City subways did nothing. I heard it from one of the developers. That said, if it's people that need to move around, let's make fast moving sidewalks high above the city streets. Or tram type of technology like the zoo, but without imprisoning animals.
- ginko 10y agoTry subways in Cities:Skylines, they're REALLY useful there.
- aerbear 10y agocool.
- rsync 10y ago"let's make fast moving sidewalks high above the city streets. Or tram type of technology" This exists, sort of, in Hong Kong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central%E2%80%93Mid-Levels_escalator_and_walkway_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central%E2%80%93Mid-Levels_esc... People literally commute to work via escalator.
- tedunangst 10y agoMUNI planners respond: Good news everyone, we're extending the T line all the way down to San Mateo!
- pdx6 10y agoI've been involved in San Francisco transit planning in various capacities for 11 years now. I'm here to tell you, in my opinion, these plans will never happen for our generation. San Francisco suffers from too many small town self-inflicted political wounds. While the Central Subway will open in a couple of years with it's new subway and light rail cars, it'll likely be the last one for us, perhaps even for our children. Political power brokers, such Willie Brown and the late-Rose Pak, only rolled in their power to give Chinatown a replacement for the Central Freeway that was torn down after the 89 quake. Existing SFCTA members, which are also the Board of Supervisors, constantly squander transportation funds. Millions have been poured into funding pet political projects, such as free muni rides for youth and seniors, making Muni a system of handouts instead of pulling free ride funding from the Feds or the general fund. The latest axe swing was to delay the DTX, the Caltrain subway to the Transbay Tower, which the voters prioritized in 1999. The existing anti-transit, anti-growth cabal of Kim, Peskin, Campos, Yee, Mar, and Avalos have been able to grab too much power, and will always vote to side with NIMBYs (Not in My Back Yard) over modern urban growth and planning. Even the next cohort of supervisors will hold the same values, because the voters will put similar people into power once they term out, cutting more into the city's progress as a metropolitan powerhouse. My educated predictions on this chart are: We'll see Geary BRT, Geneva BRT, 19th Ave Rapid, and the M extension to Park Merced. Maybe some new signals and bike lanes. That's it. The SFMTA's 20 year vision does not include any subway or rail extensions otherwise. I have asked Nick Josefowitz, who's district would include a theoretical BART extension under Geary, and he says BART is too far behind on maintenance to even consider such an idea.
- wtvanhest 10y agoThe makeup of the city is changing and as it does, options that appear impossible today will work in the future. We can all make it go faster by simply ignoring that NIMBYs exist and shooting for small wins. A series of small wins over 10 years could probably get us in place to finally start subway construction out to sunset etc. It will happen and NIMBYs won't stop it.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> It will happen and NIMBYs won't stop it. At least you're thinking about future residents of SF and not yourself, because no one here is going to see any of the proposed changes to drive transit progress for at least 20-30 years.
- BurningFrog 10y agoSan Francisco doesn't like to hear it, but it's a very conservative city.
- abritinthebay 10y agoI think most residents of SF and the Bay Area would agree with that. It's NIMBY-madness here. Most people outside the Bay probably would be surprised, but here? Nah, it's "well.. yeah, duh."
- irrational 10y agoBut what kind of conservative? Obviously not socially conservative. Do you mean fiscally conservative?
- BurningFrog 10y agoI mean opposed to change.
- enraged_camel 10y agohttps://twitter.com/crushingbort/status/463132110006784000 https://twitter.com/crushingbort/status/463132110006784000
- enraged_camel 10y agoThe downvotes are pretty hilarious. I guess many people don't realize that "fiscally conservative but socially liberal" is not an internally consistent political stance.
- sfblah 10y agoQuestion: Is it possible that self-driving cars will make this kind of infrastructure less important? I've thought about this a bit, and I wonder if, outside of high-speed rail and airplanes (where you can go faster than a car can drive), self-driving cars may make mass transit outmoded. I'm curious what people think.
- abritinthebay 10y agoNot really. Transport problems don't go away with self-driving vehicles. In fact they just end up having the same issues (they're a form of mass transit if they end up shared).
- honkhonkpants 10y agoMass transit is about architecture, not transportation. What we're really talking about here is where we can make dense neighborhoods that can be served by subways. Cars can't serve dense neighborhoods because they are too big for the number of people carried, and there's nowhere to store them when they are empty. On the flip side, sparse neighborhoods can't be served by mass transit because there aren't enough people who can reach the system, and it takes to long to go anywhere. So the question really is what kind of architecture do you want? After that question is answered you can talk about whether cars or trains make more sense for that place.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoCars can serve dense neighborhoods if they are more self contained. If you can architect things so that people mostly walk or bike to everything then the car is only for special trips. In such a world public transit is only necessary for major arterial commuting. Self driving cabs can also transfer people between these arteries to maximize throughout. But milk route busses and subways stopping every other block will be unnecessary. Getting to this world would require much more communal space and stronger neighborhoods with more of a cultural center of gravity so you didn't have people flitting all over the city in rabdom directions in desperate attempts to find a place to fit in socially and professionally. Imagine small towns, packed as densely as a big city. An arterial subway like San Francisco's is adequate for that.
- trothamel 10y agoDoes it make sense to make a large capital bet on mass transit at this time? Yesterday, Telsa released a video of their new car self-driving, including dropping a passenger off and getting into a parking lot. It strikes me that a personal rapid transit system - think something like Uber, operating on lanes dedicated to self-driving cars - could provide much of the functionality of this, and be ready a lot sooner.
- jseliger 10y agoShort answer: Yes. I don't have time to dig up the studies or articles at the moment, but even optimistic-case self-driving car systems aren't going to more than double or triple existing road capacity. Good rail systems already, today, have about 5 – 10x the capacity of road systems. Self-driving cars and medium- to long-distance urban transit system are actually likely to be complements, not substitutes, especially if/when cities continue to get denser.
- alooPotato 10y agoWhat about shared self driving cars + dedicated express bus lanes? The idea being we tax cars for usage of the road and the buses become effectively free (and faster) while self driving shared ubers are $2/ride. Making roads better and taxing them right (so we can do dynamic pricing) seems so much better than huge chunky capital costs of digging tunnels and installing subway infrastructure. We already have roads, people get to go door to door, and deploying a usage based tax model on roads is just software. Seems so much better than decade long projects.
- tajen 10y agoThere's a lot of added value for the community in mass transport. It costs less per fare than car systems you can think about (even ridesharing & co), consume/pollute less, but more importantl it allows lower-class and middle-class citizen to move around the city. All the cleaning personel, food, assistance personel can afford coming to the city to provide for high-value-added workers. All high-value-added can afford to live farther away along the lines, in better appartments than the constricted downtown space. And the new density created by gathering more people in the same place during the day allow the collaboration of more people.
- niftich 10y agoOh, the irony! Geary had fixed-guideway transit from 1880 until 1956 when it was replaced by buses [1][2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geary_Street,_Park_and_Ocean_Railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geary_Street,_Park_and_Ocean_R... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geary_Boulevard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geary_Boulevard
- et-al 10y agoI can see why they switched. Above ground, busses are better than rail transit for a number of reasons: * if a bus ahead breaks down, the bus behind can still go around it, so the line's not totally clogged up * busses are quieter going through neighborhoods (have a friend who lives by Duboce Park and it rumbles) * you can share the road with regular automobiles, whereas rails depend on the implementation (yes most of the ones in SF do as well) * easier to turn a bus around than a train at the terminus An actual subway could be quicker, but again that requires money, cooperation from the neighborhood, and time.
- prodigal_erik 10y ago> you can share the road with regular automobiles This guarantees that transit will always be worse than driving oneself.
- et-al 10y agoYes, as is the case with San Francisco's N-Judah. However, when it comes to proposals, if you told residents "hey, you can no longer drive/park on the street in front of your house" they'd probably oppose the new rail line.
- sfaf 10y agowell on multi-lane roads like geary, you could just have a dedicated lane that normal traffic can't enter
- 10y ago
- encoderer 10y agoHow much of SF nimby psychology comes from the over leverage this city forces on you? Even with 200k down and a 200k salary an $800k mortgage can turn you fairly conservative I think.
- kspaans 10y agoIMO, it's rational economic thinking (if perhaps a little selfish): 90% of your net worth is in a single asset (either due to poor financial planning on your part, or because one asset has ballooned in value), so you will use your municipal voting power to protect that asset.
- sfaf 10y agoUnfortunately this is a negative feedback loop. Essentially you are saying that because housing prices are expensive and people are over-leveraged, they will vote for any legislation that will protect and increase housing prices. This legislation increases prices further, which means even more over-leveraged housing owners. We need something to break out of this negative feedback loop.
- jeremy_k 10y agoBut what about the second cohort of people (those who's houses have ballooned in price) who aren't over-leveraged (because they've owned it for a very long time) and have every reason in the world to vote to block things that may cause their greatest asset to lose value? To them, I would think there is no negative feedback loop.
- eru 10y agoIn a technical sense, that's a positive feedback loop.
- zanny 10y agoThe break out should be that, in terms of metrics of the physical world, SF is a horrible city to establish a business in. There are plenty of bubbles going around, but the "Bay Area or Bust" in tech is certainly one of them. The cost of living is so preposterously high, and the infrastructure so bad, in a rational world businesses would be throwing money at moving thousands of people out of the area to much cheaper cities instead of sucking up the ludicrous costs.
- hindsightbias 10y agoIf SF had been a little less NIMBY, we'd have been covered in freeways a few decades back and it would be lovely. http://hoodline.com/2015/03/panhandle-freeway-revolt http://hoodline.com/2015/03/panhandle-freeway-revolt The only reason BART exists is because of the NIMBYs: "Lost in the story of the Freeway Revolt is the role it played in helping BART get institutional support. After the 1959 Supervisorial defeat of freeway plans, BART advocates got surplus Bay Bridge tolls allocated to the proposed transbay tube. After the 1961 vote against the Western Freeway, Mayor George Christopher and the influential Bay Area Council both endorsed the proposed BART system." The Geary line would be something akin to Boston's Big Dig in complexity and scale.
- raldi 10y agoThe freeway revolts had nothing to do with NIMBYism. NIMBYs say, "I agree that people need a place to live -- they just shouldn't live near me" or "I agree that we need prisons -- just not near me." The freeway protesters believed that freeways shouldn't cut through any municipality. Not just theirs -- nobody's. If you think something shouldn't exist at all, you're not a NIMBY.
- dionidium 10y agoThis is why the term NIMBY doesn't really capture what's happening now. The modern NIMBYs oppose city-oriented development in cities. They, too, seem not to be saying "not near me," but, rather, "not anywhere." It's a conservative impulse against any change.
- epistasis 10y agoIMHO, there's no more self-destructive tendencies than those that oppose cities being cities. More people want to live in cities than there is space in the cities. Given that high-density living is more environmentally friendly than low-density sprawl, it's particularly bad for those in cities to not allow more people to live there. But there's two things that everybody hates in city planning: sprawl and density.
- gns24 10y agoIsn't asking people where they would like a new subway line a case of asking people what they think the solution is rather than what problem they would like to have solved? Wouldn't a survey of what journeys people want to make be better? Sure, processing the results is hard, but in the grand scheme of building new transportation in SF it's trivial.
- NickC_dev 10y agoThe favored candidate in the D1 supervisor race (Marjan) fielded a question on a Geary subway line about an hour ago. https://www.reddit.com/r/sanfrancisco/comments/58i5wa/hi_reddit_im_marjan_philhour_a_candidate_for/d90lsnb https://www.reddit.com/r/sanfrancisco/comments/58i5wa/hi_red... She confirms the general sentiment in this HN thread, that nimbyism is to blame for poor infrastructure. We have a facebook group of Richmond District residents who support housing and infrastructure. http://growtherichmond.com/ http://growtherichmond.com/
- donretag 10y ago"Expect it to be built, along with that line running under the Golden Gate Bridge, almost certainly not in your lifetime." Los Angeles has a very bullish agenda for subway/metro expansion, with some lines already under construction. Even those currently being built, the timelines are extremely long. Purple line extension is due to be finished, if everything goes to place, by 2035.
- jorblumesea 10y agoI really hope ST3 passes in Seattle and we avoid being San Fran. I love this city and would hate to see it devolve into NIMBY power plays and endless traffic jams. Things are bad enough here as it is.
- hannob 10y agoFunny, I've been to SF twice in my life, but I could've guessed which line is probably the most obvious public transport line missing in this city. I couldn't name Geary Boulevard, but I would've been able to point it out on a map.
- grogenaut 10y agoWho cares where people are drawing their lines, use the transit data to see where they're actually going and derrive them. Better yet come up with a good way to find their actual destination, not destination stop and draw those lines. like pay a % of them to let you sample their locations via their smart phones or "trick" them into it with a transit app.
- r0m4n0 10y agoCommuting from my place on Geary/Broderick to Chinatown on a bus takes around 30 to 40 minutes and costs $2.25 one way. Taking an Uber pool takes 15 min for $4.50. SF is riddled with Uber and Lift drivers for this very reason. I bet at any given moment, 80% of the cars downtown are rides for hire. The city should just subsidize with a few billion a ride as a service platform and stop wasting time and money on something that will always be sub par.