5 ms·

Could you provide couple links to videos of other cars driving like this and looking for parking without the owner :)

by ddon 10y ago

aerovistae 10y ago
I too would like to see these videos.
- woodpanel 10y ago
  It's not just self-driving cars. It's features like autonomous parking, lane-assitance, cruise control that automatically keeps the distance to the car in front of you and the like. Stuff like that has been repeatedly hailed by HN'ers as revolutionary when Tesla introduced it. Neglecting that other companies had those features for years. Whenever Tesla is the topic it's almost guaranteed every negative comment on HN will be downvoted (I just see that right now with my comment above. It's constantly gaining and losing me karma). Besides that, the self-driving Tesla isn't news. That is the joke here. It's a press release that gets frenzied on HN's #1 spot.
  - lonewolf_ninja 10y ago
    True. In a way this is kind of analogous to how Apple 'fanboys'/users behave when new features are introduced in iPhones but have already been present in Android for many years prior to that.
    - takeda 10y ago
      The oldest: copy & paste. The most recent: water resistant
  - boznz 10y ago
    I guess you've never downvoted anyone who disagrees with your opinion?
    - jmcdiesel 10y ago
      Can't speak for him, but I haven't. And I know others that haven't. Doing so only reflects an insecurity in your own opinion. I downvote for ad-hominems, or blatantly (easily verifiable) false claims. Assuming that others downvote over differing opinions does paint you in the light of doing that yourself, though...
    - rifung 10y ago
      The downvote button isn't a disagree or dislike button. If I disagree (and care enough), I use the other button, reply, to try to understand their point of view and try to get them to understand mine.
      - vacri 10y ago
        The forum founders have stated that the downvote button is for disagree/dislike. If you think a comment is very bad, there's a 'flag' function if you click on the comment's timestamp (if you have the requisite karma).
        rifung 10y ago
        My understanding was that downvoting was for comments which do not contribute to the conversation. I'm both surprised and sad to hear that the downvote button's intended purpose is disagreement. This seems like it would discourage people from posting alternative points of view if their view is the minority. As much as I tried looking for it on my own, I couldn't find one, so would you mind posting a source as to where the founders stated the purpose of voting?
        grzm 10y ago
        I found this, but it's clearly Unofficial http://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#downvoted http://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#downvoted That said, the author currently has karma 111515 so he likely knows something about it. The guidelines[0] do mention "Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
  - sliken 10y ago
    I've read comparisons of tesla's system vs others. They aren't even in the same ballpark. C&D has one with Infiniti, Mercedes, Telsa, and BMW. They drove 50 miles on a fairly challenging road and recorded the number of times they had to grab the steering wheel. BMW and Mercedes were twice as often, infiniti about 3 times. The #2 BMW "City streets also foil this equipment; occasionally the BMW lost the trail on clearly marked straight sections of pavement for no obvious reason at all." The Tesla (with driving hardware 2 revisions ago, and software at least on revision ago) "the Tesla Model S locks onto the path ahead with a cruise missile’s determination and your hands resting on your lap.","The Tesla’s Autosteer performance can be distinguished from our other contenders by two words: no wobbling.", and "This system rises well above parlor-trick status to beg your use in daily driving.", "to Tesla’s credit, this is the only car capable of hands-free lane changes.", and " but by tallying only 29 interruptions in 50 miles, Tesla’s Autopilot app lives in a class of one." So do other companies have lane following and related features... yes. Do they do as well as Tesla, not from what I've seen.
sah2ed 10y ago
There's a video [1] by Mercedes from 3 years ago but they didn't demo autonomous parking like Tesla. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AihC5flC-38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AihC5flC-38
- dougmany 10y ago
  Well those roundabouts do give them an unfair advantage. All joking aside, that video was of a research vehicle. The article above is for a car you can buy right now.
  - ufmace 10y ago
    Well, you can buy the car with the hardware, but the self-driving part is still a ways out as far as public availability.
    - lazaroclapp 10y ago
      Wonder how long it will take for someone to jail break that hardware and hack up some v0.0.1alpha open source self-driving software for it. Not saying it would be wise, but it seems like the kind of thing people traditionally do for "locked up hardware, with software-enable coming in the future" (see gaming consoles, routers, etc).
      - jwagenet 10y ago
        Seems like something geohot can cook up, since he already has experience with both activities.
      - YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
        >> jail break that hardware and hack up some v0.0.1alpha open source self-driving software for it. That "someone" would have to be a world leading AI research team, to "hack" something that would be a few decades ahead of the current state of the art. But alright.

Could you provide couple links to videos of other cars driving like this and looking for parking without the owner :)

by ddon 10y ago

Could you provide couple links to videos of other cars driving like this and looking for parking without the owner :)

aerovistae 10y ago

I too would like to see these videos.

woodpanel 10y ago
It's not just self-driving cars. It's features like autonomous parking, lane-assitance, cruise control that automatically keeps the distance to the car in front of you and the like. Stuff like that has been repeatedly hailed by HN'ers as revolutionary when Tesla introduced it. Neglecting that other companies had those features for years. Whenever Tesla is the topic it's almost guaranteed every negative comment on HN will be downvoted (I just see that right now with my comment above. It's constantly gaining and losing me karma). Besides that, the self-driving Tesla isn't news. That is the joke here. It's a press release that gets frenzied on HN's #1 spot.
- lonewolf_ninja 10y ago
  True. In a way this is kind of analogous to how Apple 'fanboys'/users behave when new features are introduced in iPhones but have already been present in Android for many years prior to that.
  - takeda 10y ago
    The oldest: copy & paste. The most recent: water resistant
- boznz 10y ago
  I guess you've never downvoted anyone who disagrees with your opinion?
  - jmcdiesel 10y ago
    Can't speak for him, but I haven't. And I know others that haven't. Doing so only reflects an insecurity in your own opinion. I downvote for ad-hominems, or blatantly (easily verifiable) false claims. Assuming that others downvote over differing opinions does paint you in the light of doing that yourself, though...
  - rifung 10y ago
    The downvote button isn't a disagree or dislike button. If I disagree (and care enough), I use the other button, reply, to try to understand their point of view and try to get them to understand mine.
    - vacri 10y ago
      The forum founders have stated that the downvote button is for disagree/dislike. If you think a comment is very bad, there's a 'flag' function if you click on the comment's timestamp (if you have the requisite karma).
      - rifung 10y ago
        My understanding was that downvoting was for comments which do not contribute to the conversation. I'm both surprised and sad to hear that the downvote button's intended purpose is disagreement. This seems like it would discourage people from posting alternative points of view if their view is the minority. As much as I tried looking for it on my own, I couldn't find one, so would you mind posting a source as to where the founders stated the purpose of voting?
        grzm 10y ago
        I found this, but it's clearly Unofficial http://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#downvoted http://jacquesmattheij.com/the-unofficial-hn-faq#downvoted That said, the author currently has karma 111515 so he likely knows something about it. The guidelines[0] do mention "Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sliken 10y ago
  I've read comparisons of tesla's system vs others. They aren't even in the same ballpark. C&D has one with Infiniti, Mercedes, Telsa, and BMW. They drove 50 miles on a fairly challenging road and recorded the number of times they had to grab the steering wheel. BMW and Mercedes were twice as often, infiniti about 3 times. The #2 BMW "City streets also foil this equipment; occasionally the BMW lost the trail on clearly marked straight sections of pavement for no obvious reason at all." The Tesla (with driving hardware 2 revisions ago, and software at least on revision ago) "the Tesla Model S locks onto the path ahead with a cruise missile’s determination and your hands resting on your lap.","The Tesla’s Autosteer performance can be distinguished from our other contenders by two words: no wobbling.", and "This system rises well above parlor-trick status to beg your use in daily driving.", "to Tesla’s credit, this is the only car capable of hands-free lane changes.", and " but by tallying only 29 interruptions in 50 miles, Tesla’s Autopilot app lives in a class of one." So do other companies have lane following and related features... yes. Do they do as well as Tesla, not from what I've seen.

sah2ed 10y ago

There's a video [1] by Mercedes from 3 years ago but they didn't demo autonomous parking like Tesla. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AihC5flC-38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AihC5flC-38

dougmany 10y ago
Well those roundabouts do give them an unfair advantage. All joking aside, that video was of a research vehicle. The article above is for a car you can buy right now.
- ufmace 10y ago
  Well, you can buy the car with the hardware, but the self-driving part is still a ways out as far as public availability.
  - lazaroclapp 10y ago
    Wonder how long it will take for someone to jail break that hardware and hack up some v0.0.1alpha open source self-driving software for it. Not saying it would be wise, but it seems like the kind of thing people traditionally do for "locked up hardware, with software-enable coming in the future" (see gaming consoles, routers, etc).
    - jwagenet 10y ago
      Seems like something geohot can cook up, since he already has experience with both activities.
    - YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
      >> jail break that hardware and hack up some v0.0.1alpha open source self-driving software for it. That "someone" would have to be a world leading AI research team, to "hack" something that would be a few decades ahead of the current state of the art. But alright.