11 ms·
The erosion of the concept of "ownership" continues. Traditionally, goods are subject to the first sale doctrine--once I buy a shirt, it's my property, and if
by snowwrestler 10y ago
The erosion of the concept of "ownership" continues.
Traditionally, goods are subject to the first sale doctrine--once I buy a shirt, it's my property, and if I want to sell or rent it, I can. It's mine.
But software is licensed. When I buy a piece of software, I'm actually paying for a limited and revokable right to use someone else's property. And now companies are putting software into more and more goods.
As software is eating the world, it is also eating our concept of what it means to buy and own things.
Amazon in 2009 remotely deleted George Orwell books (you can't make this up) from customer Kindles without asking first. Amazon didn't need the customers' permission because a Kindle book is legally a license, not a piece of property.
John Deere tractors have been prized by farmers for their durability and flexibility. Now they come with software and a prohibition against customer modification or repair.
It sounds silly but the right to repair our own property is under threat. It's now something that we need to fight for.
And now apparently even paying $100,000 will not be enough to give full ownership rights to a car.
- daddykotex 10y ago> The erosion of the concept of "ownership" continues. > Traditionally, goods are subject to the first sale doctrine--once I buy a shirt, it's my property, and if I want to sell or rent it, I can. It's mine. > But software is licensed. When I buy a piece of software, I'm actually paying for a limited and revokable right to use someone else's property. And now companies are putting software into more and more goods. That's a pretty good summary.
- RUG3Y 10y agoIt's our responsibility to choose and support products that respect our rights and empower us. Vote with your feet.
- hood_syntax 10y agoI agree with this, and I try to follow it as much as possible, but it can be hard to find companies that produce those products.
- fucking_tragedy 10y agoVoting with your feet/dollar is hardly an option when everyone else in town is doing the same thing. Voting for representatives that will enact legislation to change the situation is still an option.
- Silhouette 10y agoVoting for representatives that will enact legislation to change the situation is still an option. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that is true either. I am probably more politically active than most, in that I will actually contact my representatives about issues I consider important. My representatives have, in some cases, been more tech savvy than most as well. And yet still there is little real change in technical fields, because the overwhelming majority of politicians are not aware of the real issues and implications and the briefings they get come from the very big businesses who stand to gain the most from additional laws and variations on the theme of regulatory capture. If the only people running in an election are all like that, who do you vote for if you want something else? I see a few plausible ways to improve the situation. Firstly, voting with our wallets works if and when there are better alternatives available, and sadly is often far more flexible, far more effective and far more quickly effective than voting in an election. Secondly, if we can raise the issues to a high enough level of public awareness that they start to become politically relevant, then the politicians will start caring enough to get better briefings and explore more points of view. The danger with this one is that with technology issues, people often only start to care when something significant and bad happens to them personally or to someone close to them, and it may be far too late to fix the underlying problems by then. One of the possibilities I find most interesting is that in the current political climate in the West, the established political classes are deeply unpopular, and in some cases rival movements are picking up serious interest even if they're a little bit crazy just because they're not the old guard. This also leaves the door open for much more savvy people to enter politics who might never have considered doing so before, and if even a few people who care deeply about some of these issues manage to get into power within national governments, we could start to see some real change. And of course, there is always the option that many people will take in real life: ignore the restrictions/laws and get away with it. I don't like this one at all personally, because it means those who work within the system are always losing out to those willing to break the rules, but there's no point denying the reality. For example, what are Tesla really going to do to someone who violates this rule? If they start routinely breaking the cars somehow then they're going to face an existential threat to their brand. If they sue the customer, there's a fair chance that they will lose after their terms are found to violate consumer protection laws in enough jurisdictions to kill their whole strategy. The sad thing is that the final option is often "good enough" for enough people that we don't build enough momentum to push for the other better ones, so the law-abiding but better-wanting citizens lose out as usual.
- elros 10y agoSure, granted, and I'm sure GP agrees. However this major subtlety between licensed and purchased goods could not be clear to the layman, so it's also arguably our responsibility as technical types to elucidate the difference.
- snowwrestler 10y agoI don't think voting with dollars will do much on its own, for two reasons. 1) Goods powered by software are frequently much better than goods without. I mean, compare a phone with software vs. without. Compare a car with software vs. without. Which one would you rather have? 2) Entire industries are converting to software-based capability. Speaking of phones and cars, try to find a new one these days without software in it. I think we have to adjust, as a society.
- tremon 10y agoI think we have to adjust, as a society. Or, we start demanding that software, when purchased as part of a physical device, does not reduce the rights customers have to their physical device.
- jmcdiesel 10y ago"Speaking of phones and cars, try to find a new one these days without software in it." Im not saying its hard to find them yet, but at this point 2 out of 3 toasters at my local grocery store have software in them - simple software, not connected, but software nonetheless, in a device that needs none, a device that has worked mechanically for decades with no issue... Everything is going that way though, becuase its easier to design something with software rather than figuring out how to make a piece of machinery make a decision mechanically - it easier to just use sensors and software...
- anexprogrammer 10y agoIt's not a matter of whether there is software or not. If it were you'd be going back to the 80s to find anything before fuel injection and third party chips. Now we can't modify playstations etc - because of IP laws not software. It's an issue of patent, copyright and rent seeking. We are so far down that rabbit hole globally, and governments have given far too much for it to be recoverable. Who do I vote for to get wholesale scaling back of IP law? What do I do knowing there's unlikely to be candidates promoting this stance?
- takeda 10y agoThis is whole reason GNU and Open Source was started. When you have source, you are getting back control of your hardware.
- zeveb 10y agoWell, voting with my feet is easy in the case of Tesla (I think that they are poorly designed and don't feel a need for an automotive status signal at this time), but what about when there are no options, or when the options are so much worse that they're not really options at all (e.g. a car without air conditioning)?
- jomamaxx 10y ago"It's our responsibility to choose and support products that respect our rights and empower us. Vote with your feet." I think you mean 'wallet'. But it's hard for consumers when as individuals they have little choice. Mobile OSs come in 2 flavours. Wherein there is lack of competition, it's nary impossible for consumers to 'vote with their wallets' because there's few other places they can go. I think this might call for some intelligent regulation.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI'm voting that I don't mind, and buying at least two Model 3s when they're in full production. I support Tesla's decision.
- FireBeyond 10y agoWhich is it, that you "don't mind", or that you "support" it? If you support it, why? Otherwise, your comment adds no more substance than me saying "I'm against this." and offering no further explanation.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI support Tesla restricting the benefits to their own ridesharing network. Why should Uber or Lyft profit by putting Tesla software into service? I don't just mind, I fully support it, and depending on the breakeven point, I'll buy several Teslas and put them in service as long as there's just a tiny bit of profit after Tesla's cut.
- FireBeyond 10y agoSoftware that vehicle purchasers have licensed for use in a vehicle that they ostensibly own. This is just the Apple iOS walled garden again. "If you want to make money using our car, we get a cut".
- toomuchtodo 10y agoA license you agreed to at purchase. Don't like it, don't buy it. And I like my iPhone walled garden just fine.
- EdHominem 10y agoA license forced on me by abusing laws my taxes pay for. No thanks. I'll "sign" the nonsense but I won't be bound by it. When our government catches up with the idea that if it looks like a purchase, it is a purchase, we'll re-evaluate that decision.
- akerro 10y ago2 weeks ago ACLU organized some actions to change this bill, looks like they failed.
- diyorgasms 10y agoTwo weeks is the blink of an eye as far as politics goes. This is going to be years, if not decades, in the making.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- oconnor0 10y agoI agree, but How do we handle software ownership? If I sell you a piece of software that you now own, you can go and resell copies of that software to whoever you want. What is the best way to handle that?
- tremon 10y agoThat is already solved, and it's called copyright: if you're not the copyright holder, you are not allowed to sell/rent other copies of the software. What you do with the copy you originally obtained, is (should be) covered by the first sale doctrine.
- irq-1 10y agoWhat about updates? Are manufactures obligated to provide: security patches? mainline updates? feature additions? source and build ability for self/after-market changes? Warranties on physical goods have a long history (in the US) of being void if the owner makes certain changes. Should that apply to software? (great comment btw)
- tremon 10y agoNormal updates (e.g. timezone rule changes, updated maps, security fixes) should be covered under warranty service, and should (imnsho) always be at the owner's discretion (even if it's a simple checkbox "yes, install updates without asking"). Additional features could be treated as an up-selling opportunity for existing customers, or could be provided for free to create brand loyalty. A critical bugfix should be treated as a product recall/replacement and communicated as such, not pushed silently: I really do not want the software attitude of "let's ship it broken, we can always patch it later if customers complain" to trickle over into other product areas. (Yes, I'm aware that part of the above means that software engineering needs to grow up and become a real engineering discipline. I'm OK with that, in fact I think it's overdue.) Warranties on physical goods have a long history (in the US) of being void if the owner makes certain changes. Should that apply to software? I'm struggling to think of an example where this doesn't apply already. Can you give an example where a software company has honoured a warranty request even with custom modification? Or even where a warranty request for a pure software product was honoured? Even Firefox, a good example of a software product that thrives on third-party modifications, requests that you try to reproduce bugs in safe mode, with all add-ons disabled, and they give no guarantees about following up on your report. The only example I can think of right now is Microsoft's support strategy: they will bill you for the support request unless you can successfully convince them that it's a genuine bug in their software. But I don't think MS support tickets are an example of product warranty, since it's provided as an additional service anyway.
- csallen 10y agoIt's very important to realize that this is a problem that our generation will have to fix, or it will never be fixed. To us, this seems completely unnatural, because we've spent so many years in a world where this type of tech could be truly "owned." However, future generations born in the world of today will be totally accustomed to renting/licensing everything. They won't have the same fiery indignation that we do when told what they can and can't do with their car, and so they won't fight as hard (or at all). This is how culture changes over time. It's up to us.
- StavrosK 10y agoIf the next generation will be fine with it, why fix it? Doesn't that just mean that we're our grandfathers, clinging to "the good old days" when we could own stuff?
- csallen 10y agoMaybe it does mean that. I can't deny it. But there's no law of physics stating that grandparents are necessarily wrong about everything. I think there's a strong argument to be made that the world really is better when consumers own instead of rent.
- snrplfth 10y agoI just don't see how this is not ownership. You aren't renting, you're paying a standard purchase price for a good which has some restrictions on its use. Do you think that Tesla should have to make sure that its self-driving software is compatible with every ridesharing app that any random person comes up with? How will that work with liability if somebody sends their self-driving Tesla out to work under a ridesharing app that feeds bad inputs to it?
- lucideer 10y agoI think this really gets to the crux of the conditions that motivate and lead to this sort of product culture: a litigious society. If people feel its desirable to combat this trend, they need to be willing to take more legal responsibility for how they choose to use their products. Otherwise, compromising on full unrestricted ownership is the price paid to cover manufacturers' insurance costs. Note: this isn't absolute - there are many cases of corporations simply abusing this outright, like snowwrestler's Amazon example - but it's certainly the case for Tesla and a lot of others.
- qb45 10y ago> But software is licensed. When I buy a piece of software, I'm actually paying for a limited and revokable right to use someone else's property. And now companies are putting software into more and more goods. OK, but how are they actually doing it? What kind of papers do they have to make such demands? I naively believe that if I just "buy a car", it is the vendor's obligation to ensure that "the car" includes a perpetual and irrevocable license to use for any purpose all of the 1st and/or 3rd party software required for the operation of the hardware. I am buying a functional car and I don't care how it's made inside, it simply must work and be legal to use in any way one would use a car. Or is it customary nowadays that buying a car involves separately (even if from the same vendor) purchasing hardware and licensing software for it, on two different pieces of paper?
- Avshalom 10y agoThis is why copyleft is necessary, it maintains traditional ownership rights with legal possession
- jomamaxx 10y ago"Now they come with software and a prohibition against customer modification or repair." This is not entirely unreasonable, they can probably justify it some way, of course it's probably just a away go guarantee their service contracts.
- FireBeyond 10y agoNo, it is. It's well established case law. If your modification or repair can be shown to contribute to a problem/ accident, you're held liable, not the manufacturer. Instead it was used, and abused by manufacturers - "Oh, your transmission blew? Horrible! It's a real shame that you put aftermarket rims on your car, those are non approved parts and void your vehicles warranty!"
- jomamaxx 10y agoThere's a difference between liability in causing accidents - and support/warranty. Think about it: some guy changes the suspension on his car, making it super tight, puts racing wheels on - and then claims an issue on 'warranty' when something happens due to his modifications? It's definitely within reason to forfeit a warranty if someone hacks up the product with their customizations. There's no way an auto-manufacturer can provide warranties for parts, which depend on other parts - that have been altered.
- Jugurtha 10y agoI agree and slightly point out a difference: John Deere tells you what you can't do to your tractor; Tesla Motors tells you what you can't do with your car, which is way worse as the forbidden use is not even diverting the primary use of the car in a way that would cause damages they wouldn't be willing to fix or something. Basically, it's a car manufacturer telling you you can't drive certain people for a certain reason from and to certain places. This is way more invasive than a lot of what I have seen, and I live in an ex socialist country where the military/intelligence powers have more influence than the political. I would understand this if they had something like a SIM lock where a carrier sells you a phone at a loss and forces you to use their SIM, but Tesla owners are paying the full amount. To be blunt: if we're in a brothel and you're not paying, you have no business telling me with whom to go upstairs.
- snrplfth 10y agoNo, it's a car manufacturer telling you that they do not want you handing over control of a vehicle to ridesharing programs that they cannot be sure are compatible with their self-driving systems. Ridesharing programs will literally be giving control inputs to the car, and Tesla has determined that those inputs should come either from licensed drivers or from their own ridesharing program. Because they're not dumb and they know that if a malfunctioning Uber or Lyft app causes a Tesla to get into an accident, they'll probably be held liable anyways.
- snowwrestler 10y agoLiability is a crucial area of the law that needs to evolve in response to software. Liability with respect to the operation of physical products is well understood. There are private standards that insurance companies and courts are familiar with (for example: Underwriter Labs, NIST, NSF, ANSI). If your product passes the relevant standard, and a customer causes harm with the product, then you've got a great argument that your company should not be held liable for that harm. Software licenses almost always just try to disclaim any and all liability entirely. "THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED AS-IS AND IS NOT FIT FOR ANY PURPOSE"--anyone who has read a software license has probably seen language like that. Then on top of that, software is increasingly networked with centralized services. Tesla's self-driving technology, as described so far, will be dependent on data made available over the network--like whether the radar return at a given location is a known billboard. So liability will attach to not just the car, not just the software, but also the real-time service run by Tesla. Companies use liability as a major reason to restrict the rights of consumers. We need industry and legal frameworks to allocate liability for software and services like we have for physical goods.
- Pica_soO 10y agoCustomercomrad, do not question the wisdom behind cooperate control of your goods and planned obsolescence. They are more and they get your workforces worth, thus they must deliver good results. The market can not fail, and if it does, it is your weak will to not decide for another product, that created this fail.
- MarkMc 10y ago> And now apparently even paying $100,000 will not be enough to give full ownership rights to a car. I think that's a good thing because it allows Tesla to receive an income that is closer to the value they have created. The value of a Blu-ray disc bought to watch at home is about $15. The value of a Blu-ray disc bought to play in a movie theatre is much higher. It's great that the movie studio can place restrictions on how you use the Blu-ray because it means the studio receives an income closer to the total value they have created. If there were no such restrictions the movie industry would be smaller and would make fewer movies. The value of an autonomous Tesla car bought for private use is about $60,000. The value of an autonomous Tesla car bought for ride-sharing is much higher. It's great that Tesla can place restrictions on how you use the car because it means they receive an income closer to the total value they have created. If there were no such restrictions the car industry would be smaller and would make fewer autonomous cars. If you feel it's wrong to place restrictions on the use of a Blu-ray, what is the benefit that outweighs having a smaller movie industry and fewer movies available to consumers? If you feel it's OK to place restrictions on the use of a Blu-ray but not on an autonomous Tesla, what's the difference?
- imgabe 10y agoBy your logic car companies should have been charging more for cars used as taxis or other commercial purposes all along. The value of a Ford Crown Vic used by the police to stop a bank robbery is clearly higher than value of a Ford Crown Vic used to drive an 80-year-old between the retirement home and the golf course, right? Oh, except that value was created by the person using the car not the car itself, which just sits there until someone does something. That person does all the work and assumes all the risk, so why should Ford be rewarded for their effort? Do you want to go to Home Depot and pay different prices for nails based on the value of the building you're going to build with them? This rabbit hole goes a long way down.
- MarkMc 10y agoWell I'm still in favour of competition, so if Ford tries to charge the police more for using their cars the police are free to switch to Toyotas. Same for taxi and courier companies. And so the general rule commodity products would be that the price would not rise much above the cost of production. But if Ford was to develop something better than any other car company - say, a car with the greatest acceleration - I would like them to be able to charge different price depending on whether the purchaser is the police force or a car racing team. Nails are very much a commodity product, so once again competition would prohibit the supplier from charging much more than the cost of production. But let's say that a chemical company developed a superior adhesive such that a carpenter could save an hour on some types of construction jobs. The value of a carpenter's time is much more in the United States than in Indonesia, so I would like the chemical company to be able to charge much more for the same adhesive in the US compared to Indonesia.
- dozzie 10y ago> When I buy a piece of software, I'm actually paying for a limited and revokable right to use someone else's property. Warning: you pay for someone else's effects of work, but it's still too early to call software property.
- awqrre 10y agoWe are going to need free open software for our cars...
- nunez 10y agoHere's the thing, though. Tesla wants their cars to be the best and most popular cars on the road. It's directly beneficial to their mission of safer and more convenient driving for everyone. our entire notion of what driving means and how it's done will change when Teslas outnumber manually-driven cars (they'll be closer to the protocols followed by planes, actually). There's only one problem. Not everyone can afford to buy or finance a $100,000 car. Many people struggle to buy or finance a $30,000 car. But many more people can afford to lease cars at those price-points. So like every luxury car brand ever, it's in Tesla's best interest to promote leasing the car to get it in as many people's garages as possible. This creates another problem: Teslas aren't sold at dealerships. You configure your car online, check out, sign some papers and wait for your car to be delivered. There's no central place for modified Teslas to be sold or traded-in and reconfigured back to stock. A modified Tesla compromises the safety features that make them so lucrative. This compromises things like their self-driving goals. What do? Maybe locking down the firmware super tight and putting scary words in the purchasing/leasing agreement that discourage any curiosities regarding changing the car is a good approach. Given the stakes they're trying to pull and given just how friggin' awesome their cars are and given that I generally don't care for repairing cars anyway, I'm totally fine with never touching the internals if it means that I can have a more boss car for less money. I think this argument applies for nearly everything, which is why SaaS products are so lucrative.
- 100ideas 10y agoRelevant article from a legal scholar: "Why Sell What You Can License? Contracting Around Statutory Protection of Intellectual Property" by Elizabeth I. Winston, George Mason Law Review, Vol. 14. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=925995 https://ssrn.com/abstract=925995 > "Historically, the transfer of goods has been through sale, a model regulated by public legislation. Increasingly, however, the transfer of goods is occurring through licensing, a model regulated by private legislation. Privately-legislated licenses - for such chattels as musical and written works and agricultural goods - are being used to circumvent publicly-legislated restrictions on intellectual property."