4 ms·
What I don't get is: why can't I as an app developer specify what kind of data transfer rate I need and have the phone choose which connection type it needs dep
by mschuster91 10y ago
What I don't get is: why can't I as an app developer specify what kind of data transfer rate I need and have the phone choose which connection type it needs depending on the currently running software?
Like, if I'm doing push notifications or IRC, I'd tell the phone that I only need 2G speeds, and the phone only connects to something faster than 2G if I open the web browser.
Right now, my phone books into LTE as soon as it's in coverage mode - and it stays there, eating power like nothing else, instead of dropping into the relatively quiet and strong-signal 2G/3G/HSxPA cells and saving power.
- gergles 10y agoYour phone is actually far more battery-efficient when it's able to only use LTE (i.e., if your carrier supports Voice over LTE). It's having to have both radios on (one for voice and one for data) that is hard on the battery.
- joecool1029 10y agoNot exactly. When it's on LTE and doesn't support voLTE, the signaling is used here to search, connect, and handoff to HSPA or GSM (or CDMA). It increases the call setup time, but it isn't actually a major factor in battery life. GSM will win most in battery efficiency due to it being a TDMA based standard that pulses the radio off and on. But LTE has improved a long way since the early days.
- snuxoll 10y agoUMTS and HSPA were fine on battery life and they were CDMA technologies. The big difference is the extra work basebands have to do to handle new modulation technologies as well as the extra CPU time it takes to handle more data. More efficient CMOS processes, baseband designs as well as ARM core designs have been the main cause behind power efficiency in LTE-enabled devices.
- joecool1029 10y agoMaybe you remember a different history than I do. WCDMA/HSPA was poorly designed early on to tackle smartphones and had terrible battery life and performance. To summarize pre-2012 HSPA: - Basically, HSPA phones until around 2011 or so stayed in a higher power state much longer than they should have. - People got pissy about having crap battery life. - Manufacturers responded by doing proprietary hacks to send modem into lower power state. - Cell networks essentially got DDOS'd as phones sent nonstop signaling to negotiate different power states. - Phones now not only got poor battery life, but also barely operated on the now congested network.. remember the at&t iphone monopoly days before 2012 in major cities, it was a bad time. 3GPP Rel8 came about to fix the issue for good by moving power state control to the towers. Here's an article explaining the technicals of it: http://blog.3g4g.co.uk/2010/10/fast-dormancy-in-release-8.html http://blog.3g4g.co.uk/2010/10/fast-dormancy-in-release-8.ht... Easier read: http://www.3glteinfo.com/fast-dormancy-in-3gpp/ http://www.3glteinfo.com/fast-dormancy-in-3gpp/ Would agree though that process size and baseband optimization is helping the LTE situation. Differences are very small and Apple actually quotes better LTE life on the SE than 3G. LTE really came into its own in just the past 2 years.
- taneliv 10y agoFYI, AT&T will shut down their 2G network by the end of the year: https://www.att.com/esupport/article.html#!/wireless/KM1084805 https://www.att.com/esupport/article.html#!/wireless/KM10848...
- mschuster91 10y agoThank God I'm not in the US. I wonder what will happen to all the embedded stuff using low-power 2G chipsets because they transfer data via SMS or CSD/GPRS? I'm especially thinking about car/truck theft systems. That's going to be expensive to retrofit these...
- taneliv 10y agoI don't know how comprehesive this is, but clearly AT&T is not the only one (or US the only market affected): http://www.zdnet.com/article/optus-announces-2g-network-shutdown-from-2017/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/optus-announces-2g-network-shut...
- daurnimator 10y agoAustralia is also shutting down 2G next year. They're trying to free up spectrum for more 4G and possibly 5G
- brassic 10y agoAre you in the UK? We're installing "smart" gas and electricity meters, which use 2G, but industry analysts are predicting the cessation of 2G here by 2020. Awesome!
- imtringued 10y agoMaybe it's time for swappable wireless transceivers? Something along the lines of SFP?
- mschuster91 10y agoWon't help much, because the antenna and coax cable has to meet the correct specs for the frequencies used by the transmitter.
- dboreham 10y agoBecause that would be a bad idea.
- mschuster91 10y agoWhy? The phone is idle 90% of the day and thus doesn't need high-bandwidth data in my pocket. In foreground any app could request high-bandwidth data - or, why not, high-bandwidth data while the screen is on and low-bandwidth when the device is in sleep mode.
- DiabloD3 10y agoBecause with higher speeds, it returns to idle faster. 2G is also far less power efficient per byte. The most efficient phone using today's technology would be a category 10 or higher LTE modem /w no 2/3G modems at all. Radio is on for a very short time, then switches back off.
- ryao 10y agoThings have increased in speed so much that if power usage scaled linearly with capacity, using LTE would drain your battery in less than a second. Since they did not scale linearly, you are better off going faster. See "race to idle".
- mikeash 10y agoI think you're better off bursting the data with the highest speed possible and getting off the spectrum ASAP. Doing IRC on 2G speeds, you'll be transmitting or receiving a decent chunk of the time. With LTE, you'll quickly send or receive your data, then go back to leaving the capacity available for others.
- snuxoll 10y agoThis is part of the big drive to deploy "5G" network technologies in 2020. Better spectrum efficiency means you can support more customers doing data-intensive tasks with fewer cells, that was a big drive behind LTE as well. With the bandwidth available to LTE connections already I think for the time being we're pretty much topped out on the bandwidth an individual terminal needs, just need to service more of them with less hardware.
- ryao 10y agoIf there are no incentives to get new hardware that supports technologies that service more people with less hardware, then deploying them will do nothing.
- lrem 10y agoAt least from the operator's perspective it's more efficient if you are in LTE, as you occupy fewer time slots in the spectrum. To the extent that I've seen some operators in Europe offer cheaper data on faster technologies.