4 ms·
I think 11 is already too late for those blocks. I did some lessons with Blockly [0] in my son's class last years (kids of 6 and 7), and that worked fine for th
by mcv 10y ago
I think 11 is already too late for those blocks. I did some lessons with Blockly [0] in my son's class last years (kids of 6 and 7), and that worked fine for the oldest/smartest kids, though it was still a bit too hard for some. I plan to do it again this year (ages 7-9) to see how that goes.
But after that, I think it's time for some Ruby or Python. I did Basic at that age.
[0] https://blockly-games.appspot.com/ https://blockly-games.appspot.com/
- msravi 10y agoI don't have a source, but my guess is that it's much more intuitive for kids to program in an imperative style rather than anything else. So provided that the base API that you provide them is not too complicated, my guess is that even kids in the 7-9 age bracket will "get" a programming style that goes turn_right(), forward(10), turn_left(), stop(), rather than the block editing.
- mcv 10y agoBlockly actually gives the code resulting from your block program. I think block editors work fine in a very simple situation where you have a very limited set of primitives you can use, like in the blockly exercises. I think Scratch already has way too many options to get lost in. At some point, typing becomes easier than searching through several lists of blocks.
- foobarian 10y agoYou know, what way is there today to get the simple experience of a C64 or a ZX spectrum? Several things there: - Instant on with a high level language interpreter - Simple architecture/ISA one can grow into - Maybe a monitor/assembler available from the interpreter - Powerful graphics, with simple things possible from the language, and full power available from machine code This would be perfect for around 8-10 year old. I can't tell if I'm underestimating kids but it feels like starting with a Linux or comparable modern OS/machine just has too many layers of abstraction to get that "cozy" feeling of a micro.
- mcv 10y agoMost of that can be achieved with the right programming environment on a Linux or other modern system. I guess Scratch tried to be a new kind of programming environment, but it's too limited to scale to more serious use.
- DanielStraight 10y agoProcessing / p5.js? https://processing.org/tutorials/gettingstarted/ https://processing.org/tutorials/gettingstarted/ http://p5js.org/get-started/ http://p5js.org/get-started/
- jl6 10y agoWeb browser + view source + notepad is definitely the modern introduction to coding.
- david-given 10y agoMinecraft, with a computing addon?
- DanBC 10y agoMaximite? http://geoffg.net/maximite.html http://geoffg.net/maximite.html > The Colour Maximite is a small and versatile single chip computer running a full featured BASIC interpreter with 128K of working memory and eight colours on a VGA monitor. > It will work with a standard PC keyboard and because the Maximite has its own built in SD memory card and BASIC language you need nothing more to start writing and running BASIC programs. > The Colour Maximite also has 40 input/output lines including an Arduino compatible connector. These I/Os can be independently configured as analog inputs, digital inputs or digital outputs. You can measure voltage, frequencies, detect switch closure, etc and respond by turning on lights, closing relays, etc - all under control of your BASIC program. It's showing its age a bit, but still sounds useful.
- e12e 10y agoI get the nostalgia for something like the c64 - but I think Alan Kay has a point, paraphrasing Montessori - that if we want to prepare someone for (a better) future we need to place them in that environment. So we need an intuitive, powerful environment suited for parallel processing (starting small, say a thousand cores or so). That's if we want to prepare them for the future. If we're content with giving them some "best of 80s"-ideas, I think racket and/or Pharo Smalltalk is about as good as we can make it. I'm guilty of stooping down to less powerful and futuristic systems myself - I find python to a very good mix of intuitive / simple and "real world" useful. Other than that, I guess playing with forth in a boot loader is pretty good if what one really wants is "close to hardware": http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Forth_Lessons http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Forth_Lessons
- zyx321 10y agoAccording to the Calliope FAQ and Mission Statement, it's targeted at "3rd grade and up" (meaning approx. 8-10 year old) and in addition to the block editor supports mbed, with Micro-Python support planned for fall 2016.
- moron4hire 10y agoThe unfortunate thing is that there seem to be a lot of adults who think they can't learn to program without those blocks.