10 ms·
Extreme side-effects of antidepressants
- jcoffland 10y agoSkipping a night of sleep is a better way to combat depression. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-sleep-deprivation-eases-depression/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-sleep-depriva... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7362414 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7362414
- 6nf 10y agoI don't know if you read that but '... the mood boost usually lasts only until the patient falls asleep.' and 'As an ongoing treatment, sleep deprivation is impractical'
- whiteandnerdy 10y agoSince there's a possibility people will try this, the linked article states that the benefits usually only last until the patient falls asleep. This isn't a practical treatment strategy right now, although it is interesting scientifically. If you have depression I'd urge you to take the advice of a medical professional rather than attempting to self-treat.
- jcoffland 10y agoAccording to the original article taking the advice of a medical professional could be much more dangerous. Missing a night of sleep seems to horrify some people but it's quite safe. Just don't operate heavy machinery. But thanks for the safety lesson.
- lsc 10y agoSo, uh, I'm ignoring the medication debate, but: > Missing a night of sleep seems to horrify some people but it's quite safe. Just don't operate heavy machinery. Most of us drive to work most of the time. Yes, most of us operate heavy machinery every day, often in busy areas. People worry all the time about guns and planes and other potentially dangerous things; people don't worry nearly enough about transportation accidents. If you didn't sleep, call a cab (or a rideshare, or a friend) - don't risk the lives of everyone around you.
- DanBC 10y agoWe know that sleep deprivation increases risk of attempted suicide and death by suicide. We also know that sleep hygiene helps fix sleep problems. "Skipping a night of sleep" isn't compatible with sleep hygiene. In general suggesting made up bollocks to "treat" an illness which is potentially fatal isn't a good idea.
- jacalata 10y agoFunnily enough, the moment I decided to see a doctor about my depression was when I was waiting for a bus to uni one morning after being unable to sleep all night and desperately wanted to walk into the traffic and be done with it all. So, YMMV.
- tcj_phx 10y agoSSRI drugs (sold as 'anti-depressants') have always been known to cause suicide ideation... While they do seem to help some people, it is now known that this is because of the drugs' effects on the neurosteroids [1], NOT because of 'increased serotonin'. Anti-serotonin drugs (LSD, various MAOIs, etc) are much more effective anti-depressants. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroactive_steroid#Role_in_antidepressant_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroactive_steroid#Role_in_an... There are some good articles in the Boston Globe's archives about Prozac, circa 2000. "Prozac, Revisited", etc [2]. Robert Whitaker [3] worked for the Boston Globe, before he wrote Mad in America and Anatomy of an Epidemic. [2] http://www.narpa.org/prozac.revisited.htm http://www.narpa.org/prozac.revisited.htm (the boston globe's official archives site is not so easy to use, but I've previously verified that these stories exist) [3] https://www.madinamerica.com/robert-whitaker-new/ https://www.madinamerica.com/robert-whitaker-new/ The first patient in this BBC article could also have been diagnosed as 'exhausted': > She had begun taking [SSRIs] while caring for her seriously ill mother and studying for her final exams at Cambridge University, but suffered severe side-effects after her GP prescribed a stronger dose of tablet. (emphasis added) I think 'exhaustion' is a frequent cause behind the symptoms labeled "depression". In May of this year, I watched Lexapro (an SSRI) destroy all the progress I'd made with my girlfriend... She'd asked for this drug a month after she'd escaped from her court-ordered tranquilization, because she thought it had helped her years ago. Really it just helped her relapse on cocaine then. This time it caused rapid heartbeat, and much anxiety. Her last benzodiazepine turned her into an anxious wreck... The psychiatrists got hold of her again, and they're making sure that she will never recover. About a week ago I went through videos on my phone... and found one of my girlfriend about a week before she was taken to the hospital. The video proves, beyond any doubt, that she is not "persistently" disabled, that the symptoms that originally put her in the hospital were entirely due to quitting her addictions cold-turkey, and not due to 'defective genes' or other pseudo-scientific rationalization for forcing her to use palliative drugs.
- hiram112 10y agoThere's no doubt that antidepressants are more of an art than a science, and that they are not the silver bullet the pharmaceutical companies claim. But trying to say they're all bad because they didn't work on your girlfriend, whom appears to have had some serious issues long before using an SSRIs, is disingenuous. There are millions of people who are helped with SSRIs, and even some who'd long ago have been dead were it not for the use of MAOIs and others that work when absolutely nothing else will. But I do agree that SSRIs can have powerful effects, and they're over prescribed to the general population which demands easy solutions to tough problems.
- qrybam 10y agoSome thoughts from someone who's been prescribed anti depressants in adolescence but never took them because I believed the doctor misdiagnosed: * Do these drugs genuinely help or is it just a strong placebo response? * If the anecdotal evidence increases the odds from 1 in 100 to 1 in 4, would this be considered normal in medicine? Of course the symptoms could be attributed to the wrong thing here but they sound pretty horrific. My initial reaction was that in the future we'll look back at these drugs as barbaric, similar to how we view lobotomies today. Edit: formatting
- Confusion 10y agoI take only a very small dose of paroxetine and if I don't take it for a few days, my girlfriend notices (long before withdrawal symptoms occur). Without it I'm more impatient, stubborn and less capable of self-reflection. When I take it I'm just a more pleasant person and with that my entire life becomes more pleasant, because many interactions with other people are more constructive and productive. It is my firm conviction that a lot of people would benefit from small adjustments to their brain chemistry. I'm lucky to have found something that works for me.
- hiram112 10y agoThe SSRIs have always been controversial. Some studies claim they're rarely more effective than placebos, but more often than not they're effective enough with a pretty safe profile, this article not withstanding. The safe profile is one of the reasons they're probably over prescribed, along with the high profitability. Many doctors give them out like candy, even though many people probably don't suffer from the physiological ailments that the drugs target. There is little debate, though, on the statistical efficacy of the older (less profitable, off patent) tricyclics and especially MAOI class of drugs. Unfortunately, the side effects of these drugs are far more serious. Most GPs will not even prescribe them, as only psychiatrists will have experience. But for someone with lifelong treatment resistant depression, they can be a God-send. Asd as far as barbaric, realize that the most effective treatment for depression is still electric shock therapy.
- mattmanser 10y ago
- Confusion 10y agoMany meds have extreme side-effects in part of the population. Often we call those 'allergies', but those are just the tip of the iceberg. There's nothing new here, just a reminder that a specific medication may not work for you or may work but still make things worse by causing side-effects.
- MichaelMoser123 10y ago>Many meds have extreme side-effects in part of the population My daughter was given Montelucast/singulair for treatment of asthma; now it turns out that it can have severe side effects with kids - anxiety and suicidal behavior [1]. The funny thing is that these side effects are not listed on the medication guide, as these are supposed to be 'known risks'. What exactly were they thinking when they omitted this information from the medication guide? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26620206 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26620206
- Pigo 10y agoIs there other medications she could take instead of these? Asthma is scary enough for children, I couldn't imagine having to worry about the effects of the medication as well.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agothere are inhalations if it comes to it, we do take care of her. Singulair is a preventive treatment, it is supposed to prevent asthma attacks before they happen, however the side effects of induced anxiety made it too costly for us.
- smegel 10y agoI would say becoming "happy" when the circumstances of your life would and should make any right-minded person unhappy is a pretty extreme side-effect.
- jacalata 10y agoThen, even if we assume your base framing to be valid, you'd be blatantly misunderstanding the purpose for which people take these drugs and/or the definition of side-effect.
- alfon 10y agoDr. Peter C Gøtzsche: Psychiatry gone astray. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiJcSoo3C4Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiJcSoo3C4Q
- DanielleMolloy 10y agoThanks. Here is his article that he is talking about: http://davidhealy.org/psychiatry-gone-astray/ http://davidhealy.org/psychiatry-gone-astray/ Along these lines (overprescription, overdiagnosis, disease mongering) "Saving Normal" by Frances Allen may be a good read as well.
- spangry 10y agoI've been prescribed multiple SSRIs over the last decade. 5, by my count. I've also researched them pretty extensively for about the same time. They are a crap-shoot at best. The best that a knowledgeable and well intentioned doctor can do is prescribe them in a trial and error fashion, maybe with a tiny bit of guidance from prominence of patient symptoms. But it's largely just prescribe, wait 6 weeks, rinse and repeat. I happen to be one of the 'treatment resistant' types, in that SSRIs don't do jack-squat for me (well, except for when there's a drug-drug interaction, and that's definitely not the 'good kind' of effect). The medical literature suggests SSRIs are only just barely more effective at treating depression than placebo. There's also an interesting (and in my view, plausible) explanation behind why SSRIs might cause an initial increased suicide risk. A common symptom of depression is 'psychomotor retardation': "a slowing-down of thought and a reduction of physical movements in an individual" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychomotor_retardation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychomotor_retardation). If SSRIs have any positive effect, they occur gradually. So the hypothesis goes: a patient might be suffering from suicidal depression, but the psychomotor symptoms prevent suicide. When they are prescribed SSRIs, and those SSRIs start having a positive effect, they lift the psychomotor retardation just enough that the patient is finally able to kill themself. It probably sounds a bit strange, but I can attest to how debilitating 'psychomotor retardation' can be.
- throw998away 10y agoMy wife went through a rough patch a little while ago and decided she was depressed. She had no problem getting SSRIs prescribed by the doctor. She says as soon as she started taking them, she instantly felt better. No more randomly bursting into tears. But, she is no longer the wife I had. Her conversation is so slow. She regularly forgets what she was talking about, repeats herself. Basic chores are just forgotten about. She drinks more than ever, has started smoking. Her diet is awful. If she can be bothered to eat it is probably a chocolate bar at lunch time. She has gained about 4 stones in weight. She never took up the counselling that she felt she needed before starting on the SSRIs. She tried cutting down on her medication a little while ago, but this made her incredibly paranoid. So instead she has had to increase it. All I see from it is an ever decreasing spiral into ruin.
- _98fj 10y agoJust a couple of unordered facts here, because discussions about this topic tend to get very confused: 1. Serotonin is a very basic, very old transmitter found in all bilateral animals. Humans have two sites of serotonin-production, one in the body, one in the brain. 90% of serotonin resides in the body. 2. Serotonin in general regulates "activity". It affects hunger, gut-movement, sleep, cell-growth, mood, body-temperature, blood-pressure and many other things. Any drugs changing serotonin-levels also affect these areas, that is why there are so many adverse effects. 3. SSRIs help exactly one group of people: those who have too low levels of serotonin. When their serotonin is boosted, circuits in the brain like the connection between thoughts and emotions start to work properly, hence they get more in touch with themselves. 4. People who have too little serotonin can show the exact same symptoms like people whose serotonin levels way too high (!!). Prescribing SSRIs to those people will worsen their state and may even lead to life-threatening conditions. 5. The level of serotonin can be tested properly by exactly one method: laboratory blood/urine sampling, which costs a couple hundred dollars, but is available. These doctors generally also know about amino-acid therapy, which consists of nutritional supplements which help the body in manufacture the missing transmitter. This can lower the need for medication, but needs proper testing first. 6. People can have proper serotonin levels and still be sad/angry/depressed. The question still is which brain-circuit is malfunctioning. If the problem is the connection between emotions and thought, serotonin helps. If the malfunctioning circuitry concerns attention regulation [0], like with people who have a genetic disposition towards ADHD, then dopamine helps. 7. People can have all their neurotransmitters adjusted to proper levels and still not be perfectly well. We are talking about signalling inside mutable structures here. Changes in signalling affect the structure, changing the structure affects the signalling. Fixing neurotransmitters makes someone able to use all of his brain. He still has to use it properly though, to get better. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontostriatal_circuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontostriatal_circuit
- ada1981 10y agoSome good info here, however just want to point out that feeling sad / angry is not te result of a brain circuit malfunctioning. All of our emotions are useful signals and it's often our learned responses to those emotions that are the problem.
- zby 10y agoThis is perhaps getting a bit Luddite but in other news: """ if you suffer a psychotic breakdown, your odds of complete, treatment-free recovery are much, much better if you are treated in a third-world country that cannot afford psychotropic medication """ https://aeon.co/essays/treating-acute-psychosis-with-drugs-can-prolong-the-anguish https://aeon.co/essays/treating-acute-psychosis-with-drugs-c...
- jrapdx3 10y agoThis is a subject I know well, not only as a multi-decade prescriber of antidepressants, and many other classes of medications for health/behavioral problems. I've also been prescribed such medications for my own conditions, so you could say I have a unique perspective, know the issues coming and going. Of course antidepressants can cause side-effects as do all other types of drug treatments. It's inevitable, medication effects are extremely complex and unpredictable as interaction with body systems covers a huge gamut of possibilities. Furthermore, most effects of drugs haven't studied even when they are known and a great deal more is not known than is known. Also bear in mind that drugs in the form prescribed may not be the the chemical that produces the biggest therapeutic effect. This is the phenomenon of active metabolites which are often the drivers of favorable and unfavorable effects. So we see how quickly these factors yield immense complexity and the reason behind the fact that drugs often have a huge array of side-effects common and rare. BTW a side-effect occurring in 1% of recipients is considered a common adverse event. 0.1% is infrequent. Maybe 0.01% is getting rare, but definitely not implausibly drug-related. The bottom line is that taking several drugs even one at a time for more than a few days means there's a surprisingly high probability of have an uncommon or rare side effect. It's happened to me a handful of times, including a couple of pretty serious reactions. Interesting when I tell my physicians about these reactions. There's a certain look they get on their faces, like "what are you talking about? You're kidding me, that really didn't happen, did it?" Well, yes doctor, it really did, as though I wouldn't know a bad reaction when it's there or I just made the whole thing up. This is perfectly consistent with what patients reported to me over the years. A long time ago I'd come to believe that people weren't making stuff up, unusual side-effects are ultimately an everyday reality among patients and all reports of AEs must be taken seriously, exactly my policy I put into practice. Remember this little rule, it will save everyone a lot of trouble: any drug can cause any side-effect at any time.
- vinchuco 10y ago> 1% of recipients is considered a common adverse effect Are these rates determined in the same conditions as the medications are prescribed? Are there methods put in place to continue to gather side effect data after a medication is prescribed?
- mcv 10y agoI have friends who struggle with depression and are not allowed antidepressants, exactly because they are suicidal. My wife claims she could easily get antidepressants if she wants them, because she's neither suicidal nor depressed. Makes you wonder what the point of antidepressants is, if they're dangerous only to the people who actually need them.
- koliber 10y agoI'm by no means an expert in this area, but looking at your reasoning, perhaps antidepressants are suitable for people who are depressed but not suicidal. Every medicine has side effects. Every medicine has contraindications and is not suitable to a subset of the population which may want to use it. It looks like antidepressants are no different.
- mcs 10y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2248201/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2248201/ "Since the consumption of omega-3 fatty acids from fish and other sources has declined in most populations, the incidence of major depression has increased."
- ada1981 10y agoThe current canon of legal psychiatric drugs won't ever cure the underlying issue that causes the symptoms. The only things that come close to that are the psychedelics -- psilocybin, MDMA, LSD, etc. They have been outlawed but of course, the underground therapy community has been keeping them alive and we should see legalization for the treatment of things like PTSD within the next 5 years.
- Pigo 10y agoThey talk about these uses on almost every episode of the Joe Rogan Experience. He has a lot of researchers on who describe their usage of psychedelics to treat depression in particular. They describe it as "brain reset" or more like a chance for people to stick their head out of the fog, giving them the opportunity to see how they're stuck in a negative cycle. I just wonder if it's like a Tony Robbins seminar, super motivating and informative, but with little hope for long-term effects unless you keep going to seminars or eating mushrooms. Is there no hope of genuine change in your thought patterns outside of long-term psychoanalysis or a spiritual awakening of some type?
- soundwave106 10y agoThe problem with "curing depression" as a whole is that it's a complex syndrome with multiple causes, and our understanding of the brain is very primitive at this point. I kind of think that many recreational psychedelics are both over-hyped by advocates and over-demonized by naysayers. Recreational experiences are fine and dandy, but I haven't seen much evidence so far that serotonergics do anything for depression. MDMA for PTSD remains experimental (worth a study I'm sure though). One psychedelic is an exception: the observation that ketamine actually rapidly helped some depressed patients has sparked a whole lot of research in the last decade, has led many to question the whole monoamine hypothesis behind current depression treatment, and may lead to non-psychedelic treatments that work better (or at least on a different subset) than SSRIs. (http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21708655-new-generation-drugs-could-change-way-depression-treated-novel-drugs http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2170865...). So, if you are a fan of the psychedelic experience and want to try something a bit out of the medical norms to alleviate depression, the ketamine clinic has the most medically backed potential at the moment, in my opinion (although I'll add that from what I understand ketamine clinic treatment is not at all similar to recreational usage as the dosage is much less). Alternatively, you could wait for the non-psychedelic versions or even rather unrelated derivatives (mentioned above) to progress, that for all we know might actually be better in the end. As the Economist article rightly alludes to, the brain is a seriously complex organism, and science has not reached a neat simple conclusion about depression yet.
- amelius 10y agoI'm reading this on Wikipedia: > Several plants contain serotonin [...] These compounds do reach the brain, although some portion of them are metabolized by monoamine oxidase enzymes (mainly MAO-A) in the liver. This makes me wonder: will people with a homozygous defect in the MAO-A gene (quite a large percentage of the population) end up with the problem that lots of endogenous serotonin may reach the brain?
- Unbeliever69 10y agoI can speak to this first-hand. I had written the letters and made the plans. If not for the intervention of my ex-wife, I'd be six feet under.
- inlined 10y agoAs a quick survey, do the people who believe that SSRIs have only a placebo effect also disbelieve any biological source of depression? Since the plural of anecdote is data, I'll share my story. I struggle with depression. I've kept it at bay for a long time now, but I had a big wave this year. It turns out that was ~1wk after a Rx refill and I realized the pharmacist refilled at half the dosage. Fixing the dosage got me on track in a couple of days. I know I'm not above a placebo effect. The placebo theory could explain my recovery, but I'm not sure how it could explain regressing when my dosage was messed up.
- kqr 10y agoNot saying that is what happened, but perhaps you build a tolerance for the drug? Withdrawal can be a batch even for drugs with no significant positive effects.
- inlined 10y agoI've had withdrawal effects. They can be severe and tend to be physiological. They're usually fairly easy to point to and help me catch if a change in routine made me forget to take pills (eg after travel). I found this so interesting because a half dose didn't have typical withdrawal symptoms but left me with a very warped view of life.
- inlined 10y agoI've had withdrawal effects. They can be severe and tend to be physiological. They're usually fairly easy to point to and help me catch if a change in routine made me forget to take pills (eg after travel). I found this so interesting because a half dose didn't have typical withdrawal symptoms but left me with a very warped view of life.
- khaannn 10y agoZoloft helps me live a normalish life. I'm not on a high dose and don't experience any emotional numbing. Every year or so I try dropping the dose or quitting and have a massive relapse. It seems to be a genetic issue in my maternal line. These type of articles follow a couple of archetypes: 1. I beat depression by (insert value-signaling method here). These people are usually in denial and/or in the initial positive rush of a life change. The latter produces transient changes that are far outlasted by internet posts. 2. SSRI's don't work and have horrible side-effects. The side-effects trash-talk causes a nocebo effect. Sexual or sleep related side effects are produced in the general population by gusts of wind, and now you read mainstream papers talking about them. The meds work as well as therapy for far less money and opportunity cost. Poor and even middle income people don't have therapy as an option for mental illness. Check out: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/07/ssris-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/07/ssris-much-more-than-yo...
- norea-armozel 10y agoSSRIs made me angry. Like really angry. I remember when I was so angry I wanted to kill anyone making noise. I don't know why it did that for me but when I got off of them I wasn't even nearly as angry or irritable since. So it's why I still refuse get anti-depressants again unless the doctor agrees to steer clear of SSRIs.