2 ms·
Secret law is no law at all. Law is a contract between a people and the government. Contracts where only one party has any knowledge are by definition not contr
by titzer 10y ago
Secret law is no law at all. Law is a contract between a people and the government. Contracts where only one party has any knowledge are by definition not contracts. Instead, this body of secret law operates completely outside of public oversight, and generally grants the government powers that public, bonafide law would ban or tightly restrict. Secret law is _always_ a violation of the social contract, and we must reject it and punish actors in government who justify it, no matter the specious ends they pursue.
- DannyB2 10y agoThe law is not a contract. It's a EULA. Shut up and click I AGREE already. :-)
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoI'm not defending (nor attacking) secret law but the obvious flaw to your argument from where I'm sitting is that if one has a representative democracy then secret laws can easily be a part of an open contract. We, the demos, can contract with our MPs (MEPs, Senators, etc.) to run the country in a way that they see as benefiting the demos to the greatest extent; we can contract with them to do just that. If then that beneficence includes hidden legislation there doesn't seem to be a democratic problem. It's like if you asked your plumber to "sort your heating out" and they installed rust inhibitor without your knowledge, it's still under contract and you instructed them to act. Of course you can insist on entirely open government. Personally I'm inclined to think that's going to lose out in some ways (inability to conduct covert investigations in to actions of criminals/businesses/states for example).