4 ms·
… until the software stopped being supported and something went unpatched … until someone got tired of paying for the server and turned it off … until a hard
by acdha 10y ago
… until the software stopped being supported and something went unpatched
… until someone got tired of paying for the server and turned it off
… until a hard drive crashed or corrupted data and holes in your backup strategy were revealed
… but your friends never used it because it was hard to share things, the desktop app was hard to install, etc.
The cloud model is different. It has pros and cons, and nothing of value will come from starting a conversation on the false impression that it's universally worse but people somehow don't see that.
- tedmiston 10y ago... but you could still use the app locally even if unsupported, etc This is also why I like apps like Day One which can operate with purely client-side apps storing their data in a user's Dropbox folder. There are a lot of limitations to that approach, but benefits too.
- dahart 10y agoAlmost all the software I've purchased in my life no longer runs. When software goes unsupported, it lasts for as long as the hardware & OS version you have will work, plus anything else it depends on, it does not last forever. In my experience, that window is typically one or two years, and the longest I remember it ever going is 6 years. Given that they've committed to keeping Panoramio supported for 2 years after first announcing it was done and yet another year for migrating if you couldn't be bothered to in the first two years, it seems to me like Panoramio has outlived a typical software download's window of life. I think I've been using gmail and flickr longer than any media based software or download I've ever had.
- dmd 10y agoI've been using emacs for 29 years.
- dahart 10y agoSure, me too, but do you really compare emacs to online photo sharing and map making and collaboration services, and say that the software distribution model of emacs is somehow going to work for Panoramio or other existing cloud services? Most regular non-technical computer users can't use the software distribution model of emacs for local applications. Hell, I'd probably be safe saying most programmers can't do it either, let alone use emacs.
- dmd 10y agoOh, no, definitely not. A better comparison might be Gallery[0], which I've been using for 13 years. They stopped development in 2014, but tons of people still use it. [0] http://galleryproject.org/ http://galleryproject.org/
- dsp1234 10y agoMy experience is the polar opposite. I have Windows software that was released for windows 98 that still works today. Other than stuff that heavily relied on DRM, most of the Windows software I own still runs just fine.
- dahart 10y agoI'd love to hear more about why or whether it's really opposite. I certainly have a bunch of apps I don't care about that still run, like solitaire. But of the apps you've been running since 1998, which ones do you have a lot of data and time wrapped up in, which ones would you have a hard time living without, and which cloud services did you have the same kind of investment in that are no longer available?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIt's not universally worse, but Cloud Business As A Pay Me Until I'm Bored model has the unfixable flaw that you cannot do anything to fix it. * If the software stops being supported and isn't patched, you can still run the old version; you could even patch it yourself. * If someone turns off the server, you migrate to your own. (You're keeping backups, right?) * If the hard drive crashes, you replace it. (You ARE keeping backups, right?) * If your friends don't use it, you can try to improve the software, lobby harder, switch to something else, etc. None of these things are easy, but it's at least possible - and at the very least, you don't suffer the same sort of emotional ennui due to it being completely out of your hands.
- acdha 10y agoNone of that is wrong but I still know far more people who have lost data because their home computer failed or was compromised. I wish cloud providers had a legal requirement to export data too, but it's not like people want to leave the old status quo because it was working too well.
- amelius 10y ago> None of that is wrong but I still know far more people who have lost data because their home computer failed or was compromised. Well that's something of the past. We have things like Apple Time Machine now.
- acdha 10y agoThat's fine for the percentage of people who own something like that, have an off-site disaster recovery plan, and regularly confirm all of the previous items are still working but until that number is anywhere near 100%, it's not “something of the past”.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yardie 10y agoI was the former. Lost data because of virii, hardware failure, system failure, corruption. Now I have a TM here and there. I also have my OS9 disks in case I want to relive the horror of elementary school. When working with the cloud people just assume it will be there forever as long as you pay (or someone pays in a freemium model) money.