11 ms·
I say this as someone currently developing a vast space game using procedural generation: The danger with procedural generation is "remix boredom." The user can
by stcredzero 10y ago
I say this as someone currently developing a vast space game using procedural generation: The danger with procedural generation is "remix boredom." The user can feel, "Oh, this is just a remixed variation of the same stuff."
The reason why we don't feel that way about the real world, is because the real world doesn't just have "remix procedural." You have to have some player-significant emergent effects coming out of the procedural generation. You see this in Minecraft. You even see it in the 1st generation of the original Elite game. The player's interest in your procedural world is directly dependent on how deep these emergent effects are. (So the emergent effects can be shallow or deep, with the corresponding amount of interest from the user.) (Which is why my procedural generated world primarily exists to support a procedural generated technology tree.)
- chrisfosterelli 10y agoI definitely know what you mean by remix boredom. Can you elaborate a bit on specific instances of what you mean by "player-significant emergent effects" for example in Minecraft?
- stcredzero 10y agoI'll instead answer you in regards to the original Elite. In the original elite, there was a simple emergent effect with regards to highly profitable but short "milk run" trade routes. Pretty shallow. (I may add to this answer later.)
- Walf 10y agoAnd if it wasn't for them, you couldn't improve your ship and be able to explore the galaxies.
- problems 10y agoFor minecraft: finding a cave or a trench that results in easy mining of "valuable" resources is often pretty exciting, especially for new players. No Man's Sky sort of just had everything everywhere so special features didn't seem so special.
- jsingleton 10y agoI remember reading that in the original Elite they artificially limited the procedural content. They could have had more but worried that people would get bored or just see it for what it was.
- vidarh 10y agoIt was the number of galaxies. Braben and Bell wanted a huge number (something like 2^48) but AcornSoft thought it'd make it too obvious that the content was generated, so they settled for "just" 8.
- s_kilk 10y ago> remix boredom A sentiment captured perfectly by: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2016/08/17/infinite-and-infinitesimal https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2016/08/17/infinite-and-i...
- stcredzero 10y agoRight, but if that gooey puke colored special snowflake was the only source of a power coupling compatible with a laser amplifier that could work with your rare Blatovian power generator that only has the 0.025 inertial penalty and enables your new fighter's super hit and run tactic, then you would totally give a bunch of !@$%&#. EDIT: That sounds snide but I'm actually being sincere. I'm planning on including items in my game from a procedurally generated tech tree with location-dependent item availability.
- reddytowns 10y agoSo, how do you create benefits that stack like that, without making the game too easy? With a procedural generator, it's difficult to determine what accomplishments will be hard and what will be easy. All those components you mentioned could appear right near the users spawn point, or they could all be impossibly hard to gather, due to procedural randomness.
- stcredzero 10y agoSo, how do you create benefits that stack like that, without making the game too easy? With a procedural generator, it's difficult to determine what accomplishments will be hard and what will be easy. There are geometrical properties that let me tune how hard certain combinations will be to find, statistically. EDIT: Also, almost all benefits will come with some kind of penalty or incompatibility. It will be impossible to build a perfect ship that does everything well. Instead, you will be able to easily build a ship that does one very narrow thing rather well, one thing badly, but generally sucks otherwise. Also, you should be able to make something that does 2 things above average, one thing non-sucky, but otherwise sucks.
- VickBear 10y agoDefinitely agree. Binding of Isaac does procedural generation great because of its mass amount of items. Seeing the "same room" and enemies doesn't bother most people since there will be something different gameplay-wise when encountering that again and again.
- ufo 10y agoSame thing with Spelunky. Its impressive how much emergent behavior you can get by putting some mario-style platforming on top of the procedural generation.
- monk_e_boy 10y agoIf you liked spelunky, then try rouge legacy. I liked it a lot.
- tiglionabbit 10y agoI played through that game so many times that I got to New Game + + and all enemies were minibosses. Remix boredom set in at that point though, since with the majority of enemies gone things got a little samey.
- imtringued 10y agoBeyond New Game + + it's just about finding the bosses with your invisible ninja and teleporting with your favorite class to defeat them.
- tiglionabbit 10y agoSpeaking of procedurally generated platformers, there's Cloudberry Kingdom. I can see how you could experience remix boredom in Cloudberry Kingdom. However, every so often it produces novel gameplay that actually feels new. And it's so good at tuning the difficulty to gradually escalate that it manages to achieve flow quite effectively.
- 0xdada 10y agoWhat do you think about using Gaussian distribution for random generation to make it possible to discover rare species (or whatever you generate randomly)? Could a Gaussian distribution "spice things up"?
- monk_e_boy 10y agoWell if you are going to do that you may as well give them a reward every 10th planet they reach.
- biot 10y agoOne could take the Dwarf Fortress mechanism of generating a complete history and take it to the extreme: simulate the formation of entire solar systems based on seed values that effect randomly generated planetary masses (and resulting gravity), atmosphere, tectonic events, ice ages, warming periods that carve valleys/lakes/rivers into the landscape, biological events influencing the creation of life based on the planet's properties and the landscape, insect swarms that ravage an area, and so on. Simulate meteor impacts which might destroy life, visits from alien species, etc. Then simulate the effects of any emergent properties on the landscape. So instead of: p(tree_goes_here) > random() And then randomly placing various tree models according to the RNG output, your random events produce a story. You should be able to look at a series of mountains and trace it back to tectonic events, then if one mountain has a patch of trees missing, you should be able to see that there were various events that either removed the trees (eg: some local civilization) or a Tunguska-like meteor strike cleared a path and made the soil infertile for growing more trees. If one did this, such a game would have value not only from the game itself but it might open up a whole subculture of archaeologists who go from planet to planet studying the evidence to piece together the events that led to the planet's present state. Otherwise, you're right. Each world would end up being different much in the same way that listening to static noise is different each time you hear it.
- stcredzero 10y agoOne could take the Dwarf Fortress mechanism of generating a complete history and take it to the extreme I'm going to do something like this, but for one specific class of enemies: The dire "it's time to do your best to survive" encounter. Specifically, I'm going to see if I can't use genetic algorithms to evolve "kill the crap out of the player" combat groups. You can't write a fitness function for fun or player involvement. But you can write a fitness function for "kill the crap out of a player" -- even equalized for level. So the trick is to hand-balance the timing/opportunities for a player to encounter the dire situation. I'm going to let players post-mortem the genetic algorithm tuned AIs and ship/item configurations. So instead of archaeologists, there would be hackers and xenobiologists.
- saulrh 10y ago
- empath75 10y agoI think it's really about the appropriate scale and density. It doesn't matter if there's only 4 or 5 distinct areas of you only need to visit those 4 or 5 to have a complete experience. That's really what minecraft got right. You have a fun game even if you never leave the first biome. You don't have to necessarily move around enough that you get bored. NMS, otoh forces you to go from planet to nearly identical planet.
- hyperpallium 10y agoCould you expand on the (1) player-significant (2) emergent effects in Minecraft and in Elite? One review damned NMS for lack of player-significant effects, but appreciated the prettiness of some of the results. There's a property I enjoy, of a kind of global dependence (though mediated locally), instead of isolated randomness. e.g. instead of trees appearing randomly, they are dependent on rain, sunlight, latitude, altitude, soil coarseness and nutrients. And they are dependent on other trees. This is surely includes under "emergent", but that term seems unnecessarily broad to me. Rainfall in turn depends on local and wider topography (mountains, evaporation water sources), and wind patterns... which in turn depend on local topography and latitude etc. Even a river's path is affected by its watershed (and rainfull etc), and all the preceding terrain, especially steepness (higher velocity carries more sediment, which abrasively erodes even faster) and soil finer-grained erodes more than coarser). River change course from time to time due to erosion. It seems iteration is the only way to capture these dependent effects, but its computationally very expensive. NMS already has very long planet-generation times ("travelling"), so it's probably not feasible for that style of game. Earth is a computer after all.
- CannisterFlux 10y agoOne thing that springs to mind for me in vanilla Minecraft: encountering a cool cave. It might have a mob spawner in there, or a lava pool maybe with some diamonds that will require careful mining, or an "old" mineshaft. The emergence here I guess is that the cave feels "real", with lava in the depths and coal/iron higher up as rewards. I imagine that caves originally were an emergent factor from the world generation, then got their own hard coded cave-specific generation paths added to make something much more playable. Much like rogue-like games that have hard-coded rooms in them that are randomly spread through the dungeon, the caves have hard-coded set-pieces that can join together in new and interesting ways. Elite is really primitive compared to today's games, but it had a huge galaxy to explore (even if all the systems were essentially the same 1-star-and-planet), then eventually you find out there are 8 such galaxies. It was fun to find good trade routes between the worlds, risk going to a slightly more lawless planet to beef up your credits or ranking. The emergence here would be the fact that the economic type of a planet was dependent on its seed value, and together with other nearby generated planets created "trade routes". These routes were not coded into the game, they emerge as a property of the way the procedural generation works out. I think the problem with making so much procedural is that it misses the point that the game should be fun to play. What's the game-play difference in having random trees or dependent on sunlight and rain? In the end, they are just a bunch of trees :-P
- baby 10y agoSomething I wish they would have done with minecraft: let players structure across the world influence each other games. Players are already constructing crazy structures in the game. Why not implement that in the game for everyone?
- Deestan 10y agoBecause of the huge logistical challenge of filtering out all the swastika penises spelling out "kill urself" Minecraft has a very young demographic, and griefing is a common pastime among bored kids hungry for attention and relevance.
- baby 10y agoYou could have had a webpage were users would have upvoted structures : o
- stcredzero 10y agoIf you can't enforce against it, then as an MMO dev, the transcendent move is to co-opt it! Everything offensive can be flagged, and if it's a legit flag, then that item or location will become "infected" by one of the most hated, but most profitable to kill, enemies in the game. But my plan is to rig the spawning of player installations, such that players will only be able to do this by their own creations. So young people making penises in my game? Inevitable and co-opted to be a mechanic!
- Deestan 10y ago> the transcendent move is to co-opt it! …which is a large logistical challenge that most game devs can't fit into their game or don't want to spend resources dealing with. Specifically "if it's a legit flag" is a requirement that implies a large team of people working around the clock. But I completely agree with you - figuring out a way of working with the grain would be so much better. I would love to see more attempts toward it.
- baby 10y agoAlso. I think young people find penis and swastika funny. This is mostly us grown up who start finding that offensive for "reasons".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smegel 10y ago> The danger with procedural generation is "remix boredom." Surely AI could solve that problem...oh wait, there is no such thing yet.
- imtringued 10y agoProcedural generation still depends on how many game elements are designed by hand. If you have X game elements and add a layer of random noise, given enough measurements you will arrive back at X game elements. It's kind of like adding a random delay to an algorithm that is vulnerable to timing side-channel attacks.
- pYQAJ6Zm 10y ago>The reason why we don't feel that way about the real world, is because the real world doesn't just have "remix procedural." Coming from a non-game developer this may be completely out of reason, but it occurs to me, what if you could determine the fit of creatures and evolve them in accordance with their environment? Perhaps not a lot of generations would be required to get a plausible, not completely random-looking scenario. Granted, we might still be talking about thousands of iterations, and so this would be too computationally demanding for a game design such as No Man’s Sky. But perhaps for a pre-computed (vast) world it would be viable.
- anchpop 10y agoThe issue is mainly generating the different creatures automatically in a way that doesn't look repetitive.
- foxhedgehog 10y agoNaive question: one of the things that makes a game like Dark Souls so strong is how tightly-integrated the map is. It feels crafted. How difficult would it be to procedurally create something like that (I assume it would be very)?
- wnevets 10y ago> The danger with procedural generation is "remix boredom." The user can feel, "Oh, this is just a remixed variation of the same stuff." aka no man's sky.