7 ms·
>The simple idea of idleness and staying at home to paint or draw seems to drive people crazy. It kinda does, because for you to be able to idle and sit in you
by andrepd 10y ago
>The simple idea of idleness and staying at home to paint or draw seems to drive people crazy.
It kinda does, because for you to be able to idle and sit in your home painting, somebody else has to go on the "giant treadmill" to feed you, house you, and clothe you. Do you think I wouldn't like to idle at home as I please, and paint and write and read and laze about? Only if everybody did that we would all starve to death. It seems to me to be a gigantic sense of entitlement, that you deride people who work and brag about not looking for a job and complain about being called lazy, when in fact those people are the ones paying for your food so you can lounge about your house and paint and what else. Unless you have a legitimate disability, yeah, that pisses me off.
- brookside 10y agoThis exactly.
- secstate 10y agoI think the problem with your statement is that the Information Revolution came with a philosophy that automation would end the need for 9-5 Industrial Revolution ideas of work. It hasn't, and we're still working 40 hours a week, but now it's to support the consumption machine that WWII created. Do we really need new original Netflix programming? Do we need whatever crazy-ass pumpkin and coffee flavored beverage a hard working soul at Starbucks or Tim Horton's has cooked up for the fall season? Do we need bigger, cheaper televisions? Faster computers? A new diet craze? A new exercise regime that will be better than the last? Where does this end? Not to be overly dramatic on a Monday morning, but where are we going with our hustle and drive? When you stop and meditate on that, you realize that to feed, house and clothe us requires 10% of the energy we burn every day, but not if we expect a hedonistic lifestyle where you eat something new, fresh and delicious everyday. I'm not free of that expectation either, so that's not a judgement, just an observation.
- clifanatic 10y ago> Do we really need new original Netflix programming? Do we need whatever crazy-ass pumpkin and coffee flavored beverage a hard working soul at Starbucks or Tim Horton's has cooked up for the fall season? My wife does...
- muninn_ 10y agoWell we don't need a TV at all. Or a 2,000 square foot house, or an education. We could just subsistence farm or something. Your life is what you make out of it. I work hard, think consumerism is dumb, and I generally spend my extra income by investing it. But I also enjoy getting some really great coffee (not necessarily from Starbucks) or watching a really fun TV show. Try not to worry too much about what frivolous things people spend money on, or it'll drive you crazy.
- coldtea 10y ago>Well we don't need a TV at all. Or a 2,000 square foot house, or an education. We could just subsistence farm or something. Because it's either BS consumerism or subsistence farming?
- muninn_ 10y agoWell, what's consumerism to one isn't to another. If you're going to discuss needs and say somebody doesn't "need" something, then frankly there is a lot that we don't "need". To sustain life we could probably all get by as farmers and anything else would just be more than we "need".
- eveningcoffee 10y agoWhat farmers? People used to kill other animals and pick berries, fruits and seeds.
- witty_username 10y agoThat's pretty tiring. Easier to just throw seeds into the ground and let it grow. You can just pick it much more easily.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoIt is a simplistic view of it. Hardest part of the farming is not seeding, even not land preparation and maintaining, but making sure that you are the one to pick and keep the harvest.
- johndevor 10y agoHuman desires are unlimited. So this problem isn't going anywhere anytime soon. That said, I think a lot of overconsumption originates from traumatic childhoods (people trying to fill a hole in their hearts) and the welfare state (people don't know what things truly cost).
- coldtea 10y ago>Human desires are unlimited. Actually they are quite limited on their own. And they're not usually about things either -- aside from food and shelter, people want sex, love, security, etc. That's why it takes a whole lot of convincing, advertising, conditioning etc. to get people to consume at the level modern societies do (and it took a whole lot of convincing, installment buying, easy credit etc. and nagging to jump start this trend, back in the pre-WWII days).
- logfromblammo 10y agoIn order for the economy to work, human desires have to scale to the resources that the individual humans control. For instance, Elon Musk has developed a desire to colonize Mars. Bill Gates has developed a desire to combat malaria. That is exactly the sort of thing that has to happen in everyone who acquires great wealth. After seeing to the needs of your immediate family, and possibly also your grandchildren, you have an economic duty to spend money, and not just invest it such that it comes right back to you. Ordinary folks never have quite enough socked away that the economy has to worry about their non-circulating currency. But the rich, as a class, seem to lack the vision to "throw away" their money on grand-scale consumption. The middle classes have picked up some of that slack by buying phones and game consoles and affordable vacation packages, but that has largely served to make the wealthy wealthier, still with no corresponding increase in vision. So the economy has two options. The rich start actually spending, like Gates and Musk. Or the government breaks the misers' fingers and pries the gold bars out of their grip, to spend on enormously expensive things like wars, welfare, and mega-engineering projects. The latter choice has become somewhat problematic, as the wealthy have discovered and developed ways to recycle the government spending back into their pockets before too much of it is lost to the hoi polloi--largely thanks to the military-industrial complex and corrupted political systems. So what can a non-wealthy person do to unlock those resources wasting away as the immobile savings of the wealthy, or the tight-looped investments that turn only a few economic gears before returning to the coffers? Try to get them all addicted to expensive drugs, perhaps? It would be nice if the rich folks of this era actually developed some sense of noblesse oblige, and decided to spend resources on developing the general welfare rather than increasing numbers on balance sheets. Depending on the scale of the wealth, this could be a patronage fund for local artists, or supporting donations to cultural institutions like museums and libraries, or underwriting improvements in the public transit system, or even collecting expensive items like classic cars or celebrity memorabilia. If your only desire is to be Scrooge McDuck, and swim in your vault full of money, society is far better served by inspiring your heirs to have expensive dreams, and then arranging an unfortunate accident for you. If you don't want that, then spend some of your rassafrassin' money on isht you don't need, whenever you can afford it! If that cash doesn't move, some people out there might not be able to find work.
- duaneb 10y agoJust a side note, hedonism is not the same as excess or consumerism: it is the maximization of pleasure over a lifetime. The experiences being sold are not the experiences we enjoy the most.
- secstate 10y agoAn excellent point. Thanks for the clarification! I would argue, however, that hedonism is a human philosophy that leads to pleasure maximization, which means consumerism and excess compliment it. There are other ways to live your life, that seek to maximize the impact of your effort in other's lives, which do not work was well alongside consumerism.
- VLM 10y agoAs a practical matter its like debates between people who know what "begging the question" means vs people who use it incorrectly over and over until the definition changes. Or like the old definition of "hacker" WRT computers. The ship has sailed, begging the question now means leading someone to ask a question, hacker means two minutes hate against computer criminals, and hedonism means laughably pitiful time preference problem or what is the opposite of a wise plan for the future.
- jliptzin 10y agoThere are people at Starbucks who genuinely enjoy creating those new pumpkin flavored concoctions. It's jobs for which no person enjoys doing that need to be automated, like taping up the same packing box 600 times a day.
- secstate 10y agoThat's fair enough. But a lot of business spends a lot of hours creating a value proposition for it's employees. That turns this idea into a self-fulfilling prophesy sort of work environment.
- Grishnakh 10y agoI'm sure if you look hard, you can find some people who (would) genuinely enjoy taping up boxes too, generally among people who are mentally challenged. But like the baristas, these jobs will eventually be automated because it'll be cheaper and more efficient to do so than to have humans doing them. If I'm buying crap online from Amazon, I'd rather save money and have my boxes packed by a robot than pay someone to do it, and similarly, if I'm buying a drink, I'd rather save some money and have a robot make it for me, and be much more likely to have a consistent product (human-made coffee/tea drinks are notoriously inconsistent in quality; some baristas suck, and even good baristas make mistakes). Personally, I think the only real reason to have human workers in our automated future is to have some human contact. So there's no reason to have human baristas: those people stand behind a counter and I may or may not be able to interact with them, depending on how the establishment is laid out. But if I go to a café and sit in a comfy chair and order a drink, I'd rather have a cute college girl bring it to me than a robot. So basically, until femmebots are invented and perfected, the big value that humans can provide that robots and automation cannot is sex and socialization. And if they ever invent AI robots that look and act just like people, it's all over for humans because the robots won't have our annoying flaws.
- srean 10y agoI doubt if leisure is even possible (at scale) in a free market economy. More than freedom of the market, what works against it is competition. We cant rest our laurels and say heck this is efficient enough. Someone would do it better and there goes my paycheck, to the point that profitability is small enough that it cannot sustain leisure for a significantly large population.
- taneq 10y agoI'm not that fussed about most of those things but yeah, faster computers and my nice big flat (relatively) cheap TV are nice to have. Do I need them? Nah. Am I willing to work to spend money on them? You bet! I work a certain amount to earn the basics, and everything after that is for nice things that I want. Is that bad?
- awjr 10y agoI see this differently. I see a world heading towards basic income. Adam Curtis - HyperNormalisation was released last night (http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p04b183c/adam-curtis-hypernormalisation http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p04b183c/adam-curtis-hy...). Haven't watched it yet but I do think there seems to be a certain type of crazy happening in the world and I can't put my finger on it. We have whole generations of young people that have been disenfranchised and are having to carry the financial burden of baby boomers. A group in our society, that as it ages, becomes selfish and politically more conservative in their approach. Something big needs to change and the idea "you must work to survive" within our society is beginning to sound very disjointed.
- rch 10y agoAt scale, all basic income will get you is a cot in an urban dorm somewhere (possibly not of your choosing). You'd be able to take walks, sit by the river and write in a journal, or do whatever idle activity appeals to you, but it won't be fancy.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoI think that the key factor here is the access to the knowledge (science books, papers etc) and industrial capacity. What many people fancy here based on my observation is the removal of stress to work on job with low productivity because of fear of becoming homeless and starving instead of working on some personal project that may or may not lead to success.
- VLM 10y agoYou write that as though its not a paradise?
- Grishnakh 10y agoIt's not, at least for some of us. It sounds pretty horrible really (though better than no assistance at all). I don't know about you, but living in a dorm doesn't sound like much fun to me, depending on the exact living conditions and my neighbors. Having roommates sucks; I've done it many times, and I don't like it. Now I will say that I used to live in a dorm in college and bought out my room, and that was a nice arrangement: friends down the hall, but the room all to myself (had to share the bathroom though), plenty of activities within walking distance. But here, my neighbors were all college students, not the general population, so that probably made things more bearable. So if for some reason I can't get a good-paying job and have to live on UBI, but it lets me afford my own small dorm room all to myself, plus a meal card at the cafeteria, plus healthcare, and the neighbors are decent and I don't have to worry about getting robbed or burgled, then that actually sounds like a pretty sweet setup. Force me to live in a room with 3 other roommates, though, and I'll probably be looking at how to just camp out in a tent in a park somewhere.
- EliRivers 10y ago"Do you think I wouldn't like to idle at home as I please, and paint and write and read and laze about?" So why don't you? I get that if everyone did that, it wouldn't work, but you aren't everyone. You're just you.
- neurotrace 10y agoNo offense but that seems like a rather narrow mindset. Following that logic, why don't you just toss your trash on the street? Or steal every time you get a chance? Or be a jerk to everyone you meet? Some people have the "luxury" of lazing about at home but that kind of lifestyle is not sustainable for society at large. Expecting someone else to carry your weight just because you don't want to is rather childish.
- EliRivers 10y agoThere's nothing remotely narrow about it as a mindset. That doesn't even make any sense. I didn't present a mindset. I think you didn't consider what you meant by that; it's just a stock phrase people say when other people think differently. The OP said he wanted to do something that wouldn't work if everyone did it. But he's not everyone. If he did it, it would work, and he said that's what he wanted to do. He wants to do something that will work. So why not do it? Since it will work. Expecting someone else to carry your weight just because you don't want to is rather childish. Boo hoo, cry me a river. So what? If you're the kind of person who doesn't want to be seen as childish, then there's your motivation for not mooching around at home all day, but the OP does want to mooch around at home all day, so why not do it?
- neurotrace 10y agoDefinition of mindset: "the established set of attitudes held by someone." So you're saying that this: "So why don't you? I get that if everyone did that, it wouldn't work, but you aren't everyone. You're just you." doesn't tell me anything about your mindset? You're telling me that it's okay to stay at home and be lazy because, why not, it's just you right? It could work if OP is willing to be a mooch on society, yes, but that's not the kind of thinking anyone should be condoning. To take it to an extreme, you could say "if you're the kind of person who doesn't want to go to prison, then there's your motivation for not murdering people, but OP does want to murder people, so why not do it?" The logic is the same. You're right though. If you want to be a non-contributing member of society and act like a child, that's completely your prerogative but it's an absolutely childish, selfish, and narrow mindset to have.
- matthewmorgan 10y agoThe vast majority of work being performed has nothing to do with feeding, clothing, housing people. We have huge numbers of talented people burning themselves out on things which absolutely do not matter, and are only subtracting value. Some people are just not equipped to log in day after day, doing things that don't matter.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoI think that you misinterpreted the meaning by a large margin. The question is about handling the productivity gains. One option would be to use the gains to have more (intelligent, as was proposed) leisure time. You do not have to work 8 hours a day if the job you did could be done in 30 minutes of work. You can still keep working for 8 hours (or as it common, more) to squeeze even more out you than was possible before. There is no explicit need for exponential growth of the productivity or population but for some reason industrialized word tries to maximize the first while the rest tries to maximise the last. In combination it has lead to devaluation of the human life and our ideals.
- andrepd 10y ago>You do not have to work 8 hours a day if the job you did could be done in 30 minutes of work. You can still keep working for 8 hours (or as it common, more) to squeeze even more out you than was possible before. I agree, 100%. Even if we aren't at that stage now, we will be very soon, with the automation revolution and continued optimisation of the industrial process. Many people will soon have the realistic possibility to do their same jobs, for the same value creation, in 2 or 3 hours 4 days a week. Yet free market dictates that they work 8 hours per day 5 days a week for even more productivity growth, because if you don't you will fall behind, in a capitalistic free market.
- VLM 10y ago"You do not have to work 8 hours a day if the job you did could be done in 30 minutes of work." You're confusing doing work with being at work. I suspect for bean counting reasons and putting on a really good show, we'll all have to "work" for sixteen hour days in open offices generating great departmental metrics, but we'll actually work about 30 minutes a day and goof off on social media and online shopping and complaining about how busy we are for fifteen and a half hours per day. Well sure I spent three hours eating lunch at my desk and another three hour break is coming up in an hour for dinner so lets get the planning meeting for the pre-meeting for the meeting started... You know how when you drive by a construction site and inevitably there's like six guys watching one guy operate a shovel? Same idea. Due to all the social media and online gaming, its gonna take ten programmers working together for weeks of pair programming to write fizzbuzz, but at least we'll all be putting in 16 hour days on paper. The whole business world is going to be like that. The future is here, although unevenly distributed.
- Brybry 10y agoYou paint a bit of a false dichotomy there with the starvation scenario. You can easily have a system where a large number of people are unemployed and everyone still gets fed and employed people don't feel resentment. Do you think men resented their wives for the centuries when it was normal for wives to be homemakers? I would hope not.
- Prefinem 10y agoDo you think wives were idle all day at home? It's one thing to be in the work force vs being at home and idle, and it's another to be in the work force vs at home clean / caring for children, etc.
- VLM 10y agoPeople already predisposed to being idle are already idle and always will be. People feeling the social pressure to do stuff, already do stuff and always will. Its interesting to watch retired people. Some social groups do just sit at home and watch TV and get inebriated, and no government program is going to stop them, or start them down that path. Others do all kinds of volunteer crazy work. My retired MiL has a near part time job of volunteer work, around 20 hrs week. My wife was unemployed for awhile many years ago and she did some volunteer work to pad the resume and took training and educational classes. All the classes were theoretically STEM/useful but were completely useless in practice (if there's no job, it doesn't matter if you're now a freshly minted MCSE of Excel if there's no job). My near retirement accountant neighbor can do nothing accounting like on his own, although he could have helped me a lot when I was a treasurer for a volunteer org, I was pretty lost the first few weeks. Also he spends about ten hours a week in his woodworking shop and I suspect after 40 years he's pretty tired of accounting even if he is an expert. He's a better woodworker than I (and I'm not that bad) so if we were both out of work permanently I'd probably apprentice under him for a few years. Worthless people are going to be worthless and that's always been the case. People who aren't worthless are always going to be doing something (maybe not what you like or expect, but they'll be nose to grindstone on something...) and that's always been the case. A mere economic policy isn't going to change any of that. Much like being fired or downsized usually doesn't change most people forever, merely being fired or downsized forever isn't going to change most people very much.
- tremon 10y agoDo you think I wouldn't like to idle at home as I please, and paint and write and read and laze about? So, why don't you? If you really value these things more than your current life, maybe you should pursue them and let someone else take (part of) your place on the treadmill?
- jokoon 10y ago> somebody else has to go on the "giant treadmill" to feed you, house you, and clothe you This is becoming less and less true, as there are less and less demand for labor, because of automation. You only look at the physics aspect of the economy. Meanwhile, labor is changing. A job is privilege, not a right. People consent to work. They decide that they want to get that money. The concept of "contributing to society" belongs to communism, not capitalism. The world works with self interest. I don't think people can really pretend they go to work to help others.
- return0 10y agoPerhaps you live in the future, for the rest of us who don't receive benefits its not a privilege but a necessity. We are not "contributing to society" because we are overzealous altruists, its quid-pro-quo.