6 ms·
This is clearly an attack on the foundations of reporting and freedom of the press. Goodman tries the hardest of any reporter I know to be objective about the
by r00fus 10y ago
This is clearly an attack on the foundations of reporting and freedom of the press.
Goodman tries the hardest of any reporter I know to be objective about the facts. It's going to be a big stretch to call her a "protester".
- sitkack 10y agoSpouting facts means you have an agenda. When prosecutors wield this power and violate not just a law, but the constitution, they should be fired and jailed.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoRight on! I just wrote to my congressional representative asking for stronger laws punishing officials who act as corporate lackies.
- maxerickson 10y agoYou think the arrest will stand up to existing federal scrutiny? I sure don't. I wouldn't be real surprised if a ND state court tosses the charges.
- seiferteric 10y agoBut will there be any consequences for those who made up these bogus charges against here?
- webmaven 10y agoTo some extent, it doesn't have to stand up, that isn't the point of the arrest and prosecution (or in a civil context, suing). The point is making news orgs spend scarce resources on legal defense, or more precisely for them to FEAR such expenses, and thereby self-censor (so, you rarely have to demonstrate your willingness to do so in order to cause a widespread chilling effect). Not to mention that while she's arrested or in court she conveniently can't cover the confrontation. The civil lawsuit version of this is called a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, or SLAPP. It is quite effective, especially in states that don't have anti-SLAPP legislation (and North Dakota doesn't). In any case, the criminal version is usually called malicious prosecution, and the bar is set rather high (you have to prove that the prosecution wasn't just unjustified by the evidence, but caused actual damages beyond the ordinary costs of the defense such as lost wages, and reputational damage doesn't count), not to mention that prosecutors (and judges) are usually specifically immune to lawsuits alleging malicious prosecution in the first place.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe media can write stories about the spurious prosecutions (to wit). It's going to be hard to gin up charges to suppress those stories. So I think the media is well positioned to deal with the problem, and I think the prospect of breaking a story is a lot more top of mind for reporters than the financial resources needed to fight potential prosecution.
- webmaven 10y ago> The media can write stories about the spurious prosecutions (to wit). They can, but generally don't. To wit: http://fair.org/home/charges-dropped-against-amy-goodman-no-thanks-to-corporate-media/ http://fair.org/home/charges-dropped-against-amy-goodman-no-... > I think the prospect of breaking a story is a lot more top of mind for reporters than the financial resources needed to fight potential prosecution. True as far as it goes, but publishers (and indirectly, editors etc.) have the opposite incentives except when the story is so sensational that if they don't cover it, some other news org will. And believe me, reporters definitely get the message through such means as assignments, promotions, raises, etc.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat didn't take long. A North Dakota judge today refused to authorize riot charges against award-winning journalist Amy Goodman for her reporting on an attack against Native American-led anti-pipeline protesters. http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/breaking_riot_charges_against_amy_goodman http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/breaking_riot_charges...
- throwaway98237 10y agoSo, I was going to write mine as well, holy ish is it difficult to get all of your state's Senator's and Representative's email addresses without giving out your address, phone number, email, etc. Absurd. Hacker News could be a cooler version of AARP. An easily mobilized group of individuals able to coalesce around issues important to the group. We need an app that allows me to write out a message to my representatives and, after I pay a dollar or two to handle stamps, will auto generate physical letters to each individual representative. Imagine 5 thousand of these showing up at roughly the same time all sharing the same "RE:..." line. It would be powerful. I have other ideas as well, but right now I'm going to work on getting these email addresses available.
- douche 10y agoAt current prices, sending out physical letters isn't a cheap process. A dollar or two to handle stamps is only going to send out two to four letters, and that's before counting paper, envelopes, printing, and handling.
- throwaway98237 10y agoTrue, true. Faxes maybe? Doesn't seem like a bunch of emails really make the same impact as a bag of mail. Any way you go, though, it's kinda like a DoS attack though, ha.
- rosser 10y agoIf you want your congresscritter's attention, don't write, don't email, call. Get one of their staffers on the phone, and occupy that person's time until they squirm their way off the call, or understand your position. Source: my cousin and his wife were US Senate staffers (and now lobbyists, go figure) for many, many years.
- huxley 10y agoI totally agree that phoning is the optimal choice, but it does not have to be either/or, if it bothers someone enough, do it all. Phoning and letter mail are definitely way higher in the attention scale than email (or worse yet an online petition).
- throwaway98237 10y ago"Spouting facts means you have an agenda." Can you please explain what you mean here?
- rconti 10y agoprobably sarcasm? that's the way I read it, at least.
- throwaway98237 10y agoAh, cool then. (Sarcasm, not exactly the best conversational device for short-form plain-text, though.)
- sitkack 10y agoOnly partially sarcasm, those that are actually after the truth and not controlled by either money or political forces are dangerous. Truth is an agenda worse than politics and money, it stands by itself.
- throwaway98237 10y agoThat's quite an argument to engage in only a line. First, I say, except for logical truths every "truth" is subjective, and thus does not stand by itself but rather stands within context of the subject that holds it (i.e. bias). Second, personally I think this is so rare as to be almost always a non-issue. Everyone has an agenda, and one's argument can and should be evaluated accordingly.
- nitrogen 10y agoI find the word "agenda" overused as a slur against anyone wanting to change the status quo. Is there a more positive wors that can be used to describe, for example, someone whose "agenda" is to find and expose government corruption?
- logicallee 10y agoYou think it's a stretch to call her a "protester"? I think in ten years she might qualify for an even worse crime, "having thoughts." This is from the article: >When asked to explain the grounds for arresting a working journalist, Erickson told the Grand Forks Herald that he did not, in fact, consider Goodman a journalist. “She’s a protester, basically,” Erickson told the newspaper. Imagine in ten years where it said: "It's a huge stretch to call her a journalist. She's a thinker, basically. She came and she formed her own views, and then shared it online. She didn't just share the corporate story, this wasn't a press conference and she's not a journalist. She formed her own thoughts, and that's what she chose to share. I hope she gets locked up and the judge throws away the key." Luckily for us, the Internet doesn't work that way. :) It's a nice view on what happens if projects like Tor don't succeed, or if the agencies who rightfully backdoor them allow any crack of evidence of the same to leave outside of actual imminent terrorist plots and the like. It is super scary for anyone to use the word 'protester' as in the article or the way you've just used it. Bob Dylan just won a Nobel prize, but now protesting is grounds for arrest, apparently, as quoted from the article above. (By the way, I am outraged at this phrasing, even though I consider Democracy Now to be extremely left-leaning, it is like talking to Chomsky. That doesn't make it illegal.)
- maxerickson 10y agoThe US has a long history of county officials doing things they shouldn't. This case deserves attention, but it's hardly consequential evidence that freedom of the press is under some new threat.
- logicallee 10y agoyou rather misunderstand my point. The thing that really outraged me is that the parent comment (which I read before reading the article) wrote: >It's going to be a big stretch to call her a "protester". which is absolutely outrageous phrasing, and it happened here, on HN, not in an article comment section or youtube comments, or in some backwater county courthouse somewhere. Right here, someone says, "it's going to be a big stretch to call her a 'protestor' " as though that were any kind of crime whatsoever. Imagine if it had said nonchallantly, "It's going to be a BIG stretch to call her guilty of thinking. I checked her writing, looking through her blog and facebook, and I didn't find any contraband thoughts. If she's a criminal guilty of thinking then she's hiding it very well. To me, she seems like an actual journalists: she sat in the press conferences, wore her badge, quoted official soundbytes, and I hope got prior restraint approval from the corporations she was covering before she decided to go live with it. If they didn't like her viewpoint they should have expressed it at that point or simply asked her not to write her opinion - I'm sure she would have complied. She doesn't strike me as a criminal or thinker at all!" I'm not exaggerating. That's how bad it is to have someone here on HN write >It's going to be a big stretch to call her a "protester". It's really, really bad. We have to push back very hard against this idea here. There is absolutely nothing wrong about being a protestor. Having protestors is in a very, very real and direct sense the exact and arguably "only" thing that separates us from North Korea. (Which I just watched a documentary on.) By the way, this is despite the fact that reading Democracy Now is like reading Chomsky or, for that matter, Trotsky. I don't read Democracy Now, I don't consider it particularly objective, and I don't agree with their political views. Our country is literally, not in some metaphorical sense, founded on principles of freedom that this phrasing of calling someone a "protestor" or defending that oh no, they're not a protestor, not Amy! She's a good and loyal Citizen --- goes completely counter to.
- downandout 10y ago“Why are you letting the dog go after the protesters?” Goodman could be heard shouting at a security contractor as a woman screamed in the background. “It’s covered in blood!” While I disagree with the filing of charges in this case, it can hardly be said that she wasn't participating in the protest/riot. Impartial journalists generally don't scream at the opposition during a protest. The state believes she crossed the line from journalist to rioter, and I don't think the very specific circumstances of this particular case will have the chilling effect implied by this clearly biased article and sensational headline. If anything, the lesson to journalists is: report, don't participate - something most journalists already know.
- icebraining 10y agoShe's shouting about their use of dogs against the protesters - that's not the same as participating in the protest!
- kbenson 10y agoActually, I think a really good case could be made that asking that was specifically an act of journalism. She asked the reasoning behind their action of using the dogs. That's better than not asking and attributing an assumed reasoning. Asking a question is what journalists do. People aren't required to like those questions.
- colllectorof 10y ago> Goodman tries the hardest of any reporter I know to be objective about the facts. I think Democracy Now! is one of the most biased programs out there. However, it's in a unique position where that bias is effectively necessary to do the kind of reporting they do. Moreover, their position doesn't align well with the current "left-wing" and "right-wing" mainstreams. That's also valuable. In nay case, this has nothing to do with being arrested. Biased journalism is not grounds for arrest. She is part of an established reporting outfit. She was recording and asking questions. Shed didn't lead the crowd or yell slogans. I don't see how you can call her behavior "rioting". Am I a rioter if I ask someone a question when a riot is going on?
- hackuser 10y agoI agree they are biased. However, there are no unbiased sources covering the stories that they do, unfortunately. Editorialists are both journalists and opinionated; Bill O'Reilly and Paul Krugman are journalists too. Taking a side doesn't exempt her from first amendment protections.