10 ms·
When I was first exposed to the research "environment" during my Diplom studies (undergraduate - graduate, early to mid 90ies), I immediately recognised that if
by mpweiher 10y ago
When I was first exposed to the research "environment" during my Diplom studies (undergraduate - graduate, early to mid 90ies), I immediately recognised that if you actually love research and knowledge, academia was the last thing you ever want to get into. No surer way to kill the spark.
Now that I've gone back to do my PhD, the only reason I can do something I consider meaningful is because I am not a regular PhD student. Interestingly, that's also the feedback I get, though as "helpful" advice that while what I am doing may be both good and important, it is unlikely to lead to success in academia. With the implication that I should stop doing it and concentrate on something more reasonable. Fortunately, I am not particularly interested in success in modern academia, so I get to do something I consider both good and important.
A related issue is that there really is no such thing as a senior researcher. Instead, professors are turned into research managers, responsible for helping their charges' careers, who then also turn into research managers. Actual research appears to be mostly a still not entirely avoidable side-effect. (And this seems similar to the way the only real way to advancement in industry is to switch to management, all dual-track equivalence rhetoric aside).
- HSO 10y ago> Now that I've gone back to do my PhD, the only reason I can do something I consider meaningful is because I am not a regular PhD student. Interesting, your experience matches mine very closely! I once quit a doctoral program in disgust but once I had enough money to fund myself, I could go back to become, perhaps similar to you, a "not regular PhD student" and create a more suitable situation for myself. Not only did I become free in my choice of research topic and collaborators/supervisors. More importantly, I was able to reject proposed, "faster" topics that would have led more immediately to bite-sized, publishable results. As a result, I was able to find and work on something I believe could be fundamental in my field. On a sidenote, I just started re-reading Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions. I am growing more and more convinced that the right way to do something important in today's academic environment (that's the link to OP) is the sort of half-half position that seems to be our shared experience. If you are too much of an insider, you might end up doing "normal science". If you are too much of an outsider, the risk is high that you are/become just another crank. Half-half seems like a good position. Maybe a few decades ago, it was still possible to hold an academic position and maintain one's independence. Today, a full-fledged, conventional academic career seems hard to square with a free spirit, what with all the dross of admin and the drag of teaching duties.
- d_burfoot 10y ago> you might end up doing "normal science" Note that Kuhn doesn't think that normal science is bad in general. Normal science - incremental, systematic research within a scientific community with clear, well-defined rules and solution methods - is necessary and worthwhile, IF you have a good paradigm. When Scott Aaronson publishes a new proof about some obscure or exotic quantum computational complexity class, that is valuable normal science. When the Intel researchers in the 80s or 90s came up with the umpteenth optimization trick that enabled next year's scheduled Moore's Law microprocessor speed doubling, that is valuable normal science. The problem comes when researchers try to do normal science without a good paradigm, either because they never had one to begin with, or because their old paradigm broke down. For example, it looks like the statistics-based paradigm that guided research in psychology is breaking down, because of the replication crisis. Kuhn's advice to people in this situation would be to re-examine the philosophical basis of the field, NOT to continue on doing business as usual.
- HSO 10y ago> Note that Kuhn doesn't think that normal science is bad in general. Yeah, I did not write that well. I was thinking too much about myself. From a population point of view, I agree with you (or Kuhn) that "normal science" is a necessary and valuable part of the enterprise. It would be inefficient to have everybody constantly questioning everything. You need the "normals" to milk a given paradigm for all its worth and the rebels to keep the paradigm, if you will, "on its toes" and replace it when the time has come. It seems to me commerce is not dissimilar. Not everybody can or should be a wide-eyed entrepreneur. You need people who compete within a business model (in the process wringing all the efficiencies to be had out of it) as well as entrepreneurs who create and thus compete between business models. I wonder if there is an optimal proportion between entrepreneurial/rebellious "predators" and "normals".
- hueving 10y agohttp://aaronhoos.com/2011/03/03/3-kinds-of-entrepreneurs-which-one-are-you/ http://aaronhoos.com/2011/03/03/3-kinds-of-entrepreneurs-whi...
- hyperbovine 10y agoSorry, but your argument loses serious credibility beginning with the first sentence. The last thing, really? How about, say, making cardboard boxes for a living? Flipping burgers? Don't get me wrong, I understand the point you are making, in part because it's been made more articulately by others many times already. But you are simply wrong when you say that "there is no such thing as a senior researcher". I personally know at least four -- late career academics who still engage deeply with research, have their own ideas, write single -author papers, and all the rest. It's true that many others do go the route you have described: possibly more than is optimal, though there is some value in a field having a few caretakers (or managers as you call them) which I rarely see mentioned. But the situation is not the cartoon that you make it out to be. Not by a long shot.
- barrkel 10y agoI've personally found jobs with high levels of physical tedium good for contemplation, and they don't impinge on time outside work with stress. I can see making cardboard boxes pretty rewarding for a budding philosopher with access to a good library and some peers to converse with.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoI love contemplation, and create physical busywork for myself so that I can do it. But that's slacking. To do real intellectual work I need to stop and use pen and paper, or maybe a computer. Even if contemplation is enough, most "manual" jobs require you to use your brain. Not necessarily in an interseting way, but enough to distract you from contemplation. It can't all be moving heavy objects from one pile to another.
- mpweiher 10y ago> The last thing, really? How about, say, making > cardboard boxes for a living? Flipping burgers? Or working as a patent clerk, maybe? Yes, pretty much anything outside the academic process was what I meant, so that your livelihood does not depend on the outcome of your research, because then you have to tailor your research directions towards the safe and accepted. And so your straw men actually would work, though suboptimally because the income is probably too low to allow you free time. Also, misquoting me by leaving out the "really" makes your argument disingenuous, because the "really" made clear that the statement is not a 100% but a trend (if a somewhat overwhelming one), and 4 exceptions (names?) don't exactly disprove a generalization. It would also be interesting if you see your four examples as holdouts from a different era, or general exceptions. I'd wager they're more of the former rather than the latter, and that their number is dwindling.
- return0 10y agoSame experience - i did my phd after building my business, which allowed me to be an academic "tourist". Academia is largely a bureaucratic job, with short breaks in which you do research. Just the amount of time spent on formatting papers, writing grants, catching up/organizing conferences, handling students is full time for most PIs. What's worse, funding agencies and grants sometimes explicitly promote this constant "career building" track instead of, you know, plain simple curiosity-driven research. I also have the sense that academics live in a sort of bubble, prioritizing concerns that are secondary, such as ego contests, impact factors, building CVs etc. (to me at least, this bubble is reminiscent of another microcosmic bubble sector - the army). Of course there are among them true scientists, with intact childlike curiosity and passion, but they are increasingly hard to spot in the overcrowded academia. One needs to be a part-time scientist so that he has enough time to concentrate on a subject.
- mafribe 10y agoprioritizing concerns ... impact factors Rest assured that researchers don't prioritise this because we want to, it's because society decided (by voting) that we have to if we want any sort of career progression, funding for students etc.
- dlemire 10y agoWho is this society you refer to? When did it vote anything regarding impact factors? To a very good first approximation, academics are assessed by other academics.
- mafribe 10y agoWhen did it vote It's a shorthand for saying the government that was voted in by the people. Although in reality that is also a major simplification, because funding requirements are typically written by administrators in concert with lobbyists, and then waved through by uninterested parliamentarians. academics are assessed by other academics Yes, but the narrative those other academics have to provide has changed. It is now important to show non-academic impact. It is also highly helpful to have industry funding. There are additional requirements that didn't exist in the past, like gender, ethnic and national quota. There is Goodhart's law, and scientists develop ways of hacking this system, but there is no free lunch, and the effort that goes into successful bids for funding is major now. I close with a link to a successful request for research funding from 1921: https://dirnagl.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/warburg-dfg.jpg https://dirnagl.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/warburg-dfg.jpg https://dirnagl.com/2014/01/14/otto-warburgs-research-grant/ https://dirnagl.com/2014/01/14/otto-warburgs-research-grant/
- chimprich 10y ago> A related issue is that there really is no such thing as a senior researcher. Instead, professors are turned into research managers, responsible for helping their charges' careers, who then also turn into research managers. Actual research appears to be mostly a still not entirely avoidable side-effect. Although this is a bit depressing and one of the reasons I left academia, is this not partly a reaction to the changing nature of science? With many fields well established with strong foundations there are arguably fewer revolutionary ideas required. It looks like science is going to be more evolutionary and less revolutionary, with emphasis shifting from the individual researcher to large teams. Take for example the LHC where managing the huge teams and technology is (I imagine) significantly more of a challenge than interpreting the data or deciding what experiments to run. A bit of an extreme example perhaps but large projects are probably going to become more prevalent as most of the lower-hanging fruit is claimed.
- Eridrus 10y agoBut we've seen time and time again that great ICs are not great managers, and what I understand of tenure track positions is that they are based on IC performance. This seems largely a byproduct of the funding model, which seems unlikely to change in academia.
- abecedarius 10y agoI think you're probably right that there are fewer revolutions per capita and more bureaucracy and politics, compared to before WW2 -- but how much causality there was in each direction, I don't know.
- ssivark 10y agoI am currently a PhD student. In my experience, I've had to navigate my way in unusual directions in order to work on things I'm interested in, rather than just go with the flow to collect publications. I talk with several of my peers who are unhappy with the choices academia offers, and would be open to the thought of pursuing research without being a career academic in the conventional sense. The biggest hurdle that comes up is the feeling of being alone -- not knowing other people who are trying to hack the system and do things differently. Since there seems to be some traction along the lines of independent research pursuits here, I'd like to pass out a quick survey I just created, for people currently trying to pursue academic research on their own path (or interested in doing so): https://goo.gl/forms/wLvkGPstpCCBJY513 https://goo.gl/forms/wLvkGPstpCCBJY513 It's very preliminary, but I thought it might be a good start to get some discusion going. I invite responses/comments, either here, or on the survey form.
- anbende 10y agoAlso a current PhD student, and I've definitely found myself frustrated with the way that academia seems to be at odds with my desire to work on the things that I think are not only the most interesting but the most important. I look around and see the profs working on so many projects that just seem so small and limited. I'm in psych and we have a problem where dozens of people are running competing/overlapping experiments that are all critically underpowered and/or divided into least publishable chunks with little thought to broader importance or applicability. The whole situation really makes me want to ultimately do my research outside of the establishment, but I recognize that collaborations and publications are a key part of credible science. In order to do that I figure that I will need a platform for recruiting participants and conducting experiments for the kind of research that I would want to do. Ideally the platform would be compelling enough to bring in researchers in academia (or elsewhere). So I'm working on that platform. That's the programming project that brought me to HN. I filled out your questionnaire. Not sure if my project is related to your frustrations, but it seems somewhat close. Either way I share your pain.
- jnicholasp 10y agoCan you elaborate on the platform you're building? What is it, how does it work, what problems do you think it solves, etc.?
- hilop 10y agoAre you retired and doing a PhD for fun? Or planning to return to (unrelated?) industry after your PhD?
- robotresearcher 10y agoOn the other hand, I know many happy and successful professors doing excellent work inside the system. Most of the well-known people in my field are really very good at what they do, and the work is progressing quickly. Deep learning is a big thing, yes? Hinton, Bengio, LeCun, etc. All that work originated in universities under completely conventional structures. Companies snatched it up once it was clear it would be the next big thing. Self driving cars might have some impact? Thrun, Fox & Burgard were key players in probabilistic state estimation, wrote the Book, and trained the car people at $(BigCo). At universities. Just to balance out some of the 'academia has no idea what it's doing' statements in this thread. It's not perfect but it's not ineffective.
- hueving 10y agoWell computer science seems to be in decent shape right now. Psychology though...