9 ms·
C2 wiki closed for remodeling
- tome 10y agoI love the C2 wiki and learned a lot from it. This seems a bit incoherent though. What's actually going on? None of it makes any sense.
- weinzierl 10y agoI don't know what's actually going on, but there was some discussion on HN yesterday about the C2 wiki being down. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12705774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12705774
- akavel 10y agoWhy? I don't see any problem, the message seems quite clear; wikis (similar to forums) are hard to maintain (spam, server load & costs); new inventions are hard to promote (federated wiki mentioned in the post); and maintenance work on hobby projects is gruesome and taxing (thus any chance at getting some leeway by any means available is invaluable).
- ptero 10y agoWould not it be better, as an interim state, to freeze the current content and provide it as static pages, likely with minimal server load.
- akavel 10y agoNot exactly a trivial task, and surely gruesome. And could still draw flak from some unhappy people anyway. And by the way - isn't the contents maybe available on the Web Archive already?
- tome 10y agoSurely pretty trivial to forbid all edits?
- the_duke 10y agowget --mirror. Put it into a directory. Serve the directory. Done. (I'm simplifiying here of course, but as long as you can get the server running, it's not hard to make a static copy.) But yeah, it's all on archive.com: https://web.archive.org/web/20160326180126/http://c2.com/cgi/wiki/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160326180126/http://c2.com/cgi...?
- cellularmitosis 10y agoHere's the result of running wayback_machine_downloader http://c2.com/cgi/wiki and then tarring and gzipping: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/90674827/c2.tar.gz https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/90674827/c2.tar.gz (~109MB)
- richardboegli 10y agoIt's in the post: So why close? It gives me room to work. The continuous scraping bumps up against my web throttling making all other web services useless. Even shell is painfully slow.
- startling 10y agoSo, he's developing on the same server the c2 wiki runs on? One solution is to not do that.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat was my observation. He should buy another server. Heck, he could even put it on a cheap, throwaway as the slow but available is better for static content than unavailable.
- inimino 10y agoThus turning the original wiki into something non-editable? If it can't be maintained as a wiki, the experiment is already over, right? Ward Cunningham isn't under any obligation to provide static archives, and these already exist elsewhere. Edit: turns out this was already the case. What I really want to say is that we should respect Ward Cunningham's choices in maintaining the site how he wants, in whatever way works for him.
- Karunamon 10y agoIt hasn't been editable for a long while now
- inimino 10y agoI wasn't aware of that, thanks for the clarification.
- ktRolster 10y agoI think the problem was that useful comments hadn't been added to it in a while, and most new comments were just spam of some sort or another.
- dpark 10y ago> we should respect Ward Cunningham's choices in maintaining the site how he wants, in whatever way works for him This is an unhealthy attitude and I'm continually surprised that people say things like this. Having respect for someone does not mean that they are above criticism. It doesn't mean silent obedience. You can respect someone and still say, "hey, this thing you're doing is a bad idea."
- inimino 10y agoWhere did I say "above criticism" and what does "obedience" have to do with this? (Is Mr. Cunningham bossing you around?) The attitude that actually is unhealthy is when someone graciously provides a service to the community for years, and then stops doing that, and people whine as though they are entitled to the continuation of that service. Respect in cases like this should mean to appreciate the work done to keep the thing running until now, and if someone decides to stop doing that work, respect that choice, even if you don't understand it or agree with it.
- ChoHag 10y agoEvidence suggests not.
- labster 10y agoI was afraid that they'd get taken in by this federated wiki nonsense; I fear we might have lost one of the greats to second system syndrome. Federated wiki is a cool idea and all, but I don't want to have to build my own wiki of everything, or decide what concepts should be included in my own wiki. The whole strength of wiki to me is that it massively multiplayer user curated content, where the whole state is determined by everyone working together. I don't know what happens to that curation if there's no authoritative source -- it seems like federated wiki isn't really wiki at all, and is something else entirely.
- bsilvereagle 10y ago> I don't want to have to build my own wiki for everything In the fedwiki model, you would join a neighborhood of people you trust to write good content. fedwiki has a chicken and egg problem right now - there are no good neighborhoods to join.
- vertex-four 10y agoIt's also pretty terrible UX-wise. I don't understand how to navigate it.
- pierrebeaucamp 10y agoI don't know, I like the UX of it a lot.
- TylerE 10y agoHas federated anything every really caught on?
- amsha 10y agoYes, email is federated.
- EvanAnderson 10y agoDNS, BGP, IRC, and Usenet to name a few federated systems.
- weinzierl 10y agoIn short: In the post Ward Cunningham says the C2 wiki will be converted into a federated wiki form. I think the following quote summarizes well why he thinks this is a good idea: So why close? It gives me room to work. The continuous scraping bumps up against my web throttling making all other web services useless. Even shell is painfully slow. Of course I live in a world of many options. I could be stalled just reviewing choices. Instead I build on what I've learned from federated wiki so as to preserve the original wiki in a form that can be appreciated for what it has been and will ever be. If you want to help. Learn some federated wiki. Then email me.
- nchelluri 10y ago> Smallest Federated Wiki is a software platform developed by Ward Cunningham which adds forking features found in software development tools like GitHub to wikis.[1] The project was launched at IndieWebCamp 2011.[2] The software allows its users to fork wiki pages, maintaining their own copies. > > Federation supports what Cunningham has described as "a chorus of voices" where users share content but maintain their individual perspectives.[3] This approach contrasts with the tendency of centralized wikis such as Wikipedia to function as consensus engines.[4] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallest_Federated_Wiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallest_Federated_Wiki In short I guess if I disagree with a page instead of editing it and starting an edit-war I can fork it.
- duskwuff 10y ago> In short I guess if I disagree with a page instead of editing it and starting an edit-war I can fork it. Which I'd expect to lead to less of a "chorus" and more of a cacophony of voices as every disputed change, every contentious rewrite, leads to another fork of the original. Merging software branches can be hard enough. Merging "forks" of English text is horrendous, and gets worse the further the forks are from each other. There's a good reason why no commonly used wiki software has this functionality: it's completely impractical to use.
- nchelluri 10y agoI was going originally going to post how happy I was with the Wikipedia way of one source of truth and how I really like that system, but the fact is I don't know enough about the subject to say it's the best way. I do agree with you, though.
- int_19h 10y agoSoftware doesn't stay forked all that long in practice, usually, because maintaining your fork is much more effort than creating it, and making your popular is more effort still. I would expect the same dynamics to be true here - yes, there will be plenty of short-lived forks, but hardly anyone will actually notice them; and community will effectively "bless" one fork, or maybe a few major forks for particularly debated issues, as the official one, and that's what most people will see, and where most activity will take place.
- startling 10y agoSo, where's the content? How many backups are there? How many backups are offsite? Are any publicly-available?
- memracom 10y agoRead the article. Unfortunately the content is looked up in a tangle of different character encodings and Ward needs to do a lot of work to convert it all into UTF-8. When that is done, it will all come back, better than before.
- startling 10y agoWhy does Ward need to do that before putting a tarball up somewhere? I've seen so many sites cease to exist after undertaking ambitious overhauls like this.
- csdrane 10y agoAt the very least, fortunately, archive.org seems to have it.
- maxerickson 10y agoI wonder if Unicode, Dammit would be helpful. https://www.crummy.com/software/BeautifulSoup/bs4/doc/#unicode-dammit https://www.crummy.com/software/BeautifulSoup/bs4/doc/#unico...
- cmrx64 10y agoThe Wayback Machine on archive.org has it, at least.
- cellularmitosis 10y agoHere's the result of running wayback_machine_downloader http://c2.com/cgi/wiki and then tarring and gzipping: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/90674827/c2.tar.gz https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/90674827/c2.tar.gz (~109MB)
- 1057x31337 10y agoThe part I don't understand is why they would take down a working site. They should of waited until they were ready to switch over.
- atombender 10y agoApparently this: https://twitter.com/WardCunningham/status/785960076041302016 https://twitter.com/WardCunningham/status/785960076041302016
- inimino 10y ago("should of" should be "should have") The post explains this. Closing gives space. That could be technical, psychological, social. Shutting down what's there is cleaner. If you miss it, this would be a good chance to thank the people who kept it running all this time.
- 1057x31337 10y agoGood to know, thanks.
- Camillo 10y agoThe (baffling) explanation given is that Ward Cunningham has one computer, and serving the wiki from it made it slow for other work: So why close? It gives me room to work. The continuous scraping bumps up against my web throttling making all other web services useless. Even shell is painfully slow. The other work seems to be the conversion of the original wiki into a federated wiki. The page meanders through a confusing explanation which probably makes sense if you know the history of that particular project, but the ultimate result seems to be the same: "If you want to help. Learn some federated wiki." So I guess another reason for closing the old wiki could be to take advantage of the news this generate to recruit people for this (new? old?) conversion effort.
- superkuh 10y agoRunning a web server on your home machine is the best way to be part of the internet rather than a consumer of services provided by corporations over the internet. It does sound like he needs a better QoS or bandwidth limiting mechanism though.
- dredmorbius 10y agoOr a second box. Running public services on my personal server ... is very old-school, but it gives me the heeby geebies to think of doing it now. Hardware is cheap cheap cheap. The major cost is in administering it.
- Asooka 10y agoOr, I don't know, a second box on a second ISP line. That's what I do, but then again I live in a place where an internet connection with a static public IP address and several megabytes bw both ways is like 15$/mo (unlimited, of course).
- dredmorbius 10y agoKeep in mind that for residential cable or DSL service, a given neighbourhood is very likely within a single circuit, and is subject to congestion from nearby connections (subject to their own caps). So a second line might not be quite so useful as all that, though it's almost certainly worth looking into. Multi-homing onto fully independent networks could be quite useful.
- PuercoPop 10y agoCode and Preview of the wiki rewrite at https://github.com/WardCunningham/remodeling https://github.com/WardCunningham/remodeling
- Macuyiko 10y agoSo an Ajax call loading in half a MB of data (names.txt)... This rewrite really comes of as strange.
- Kiro 10y agoSo what was this?