3 ms·
Costco and Walmart aren't really comparable. Costco stocks about 4000 usually larger, higher margin items in each of their stores. Walmart stocks more than 10
by maxerickson 10y ago
Costco and Walmart aren't really comparable.
Costco stocks about 4000 usually larger, higher margin items in each of their stores.
Walmart stocks more than 100,000 items in their stores, many of them with very low margins.
- Zhenya 10y agoI was not comparing Costco v Walmart. I was responding to companies paying high wages in "today's environment"
- maxerickson 10y agoRight, but it isn't really clear that Costco pay's particularly high wages for the business it is operating.
- Zhenya 10y agoIt's absolutely clear. Their workers are retail employees who provide near substitutive type of labor as wal-mart employees. They consciously raise wages to retain employees. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-06-06/costco-ceo-craig-jelinek-leads-the-cheapest-happiest-company-in-the-world http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-06-06/costco-ceo...
- nickff 10y agoThat's what Costco says, but I'd be willing to bet that Costco and Walmart employees are quite different. I would bet that Costco employees had more years of education, and more successful (i.e. years not fired for cause) work experience. When you are willing to pay more, you can purchase higher quality; this is as true for labor as software or electronics.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago" I would bet that Costco employees had more years of education, and more successful (i.e. years not fired for cause) work experience." You'd loose money. I've met many Costco employees. Most were either high-school students or older people without degrees who simply applied for the job or were referred then got through an interview. They care more about whether you'll work hard than anything else. Then they tend to stick around longer since they get paid and treated really well so long as they work hard. Lots of retail workers would like a job at Costco or a similar place but there's just few openings since people don't quit often.
- nickff 10y agoNeither Costco nor Walmart will have anything near the average level of education of the average HN commenter, but I maintain that there is almost certainly a difference
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThey pull people out of high schools, retail jobs, etc. They wont hire outright idiots but there's no IQ test or anything. Think about it another way: these people are going to Costco because they lack what's needed to get higher-paying jobs requiring degrees or trade schools. Costco reps themselves already explained the extra pay was just incentive and that they believe in living wages. They also cancelled the ad bugdet specifically to give that money ("6% of revenue") to workers instead thinking good workers are better than advertising for customer retention. So, they consistently believe paying & motivating workers has highest benefits. They also pull from barely-educated sources who probably have above-average intelligence or character but still the common, low-rung pool of labor.
- adventured 10y agoIf you want Walmart to match Costco on pay, it has to fire between 1/3 and 1/2 its employee base and replace them with robotics or other automating technology. Sales per employee Costco: $550,000 Walmart: $200,000 So now you need to find low skill jobs for a million people, at a time when automation technology is aggressively seeking to (and increasingly able to) wipe out those types of jobs. Oh yeah, and Walmart is very likely in permanent contraction mode already, in which its business will perpetually shrink on a year over year basis ala Sears and other past giants of retail, as Amazon + its far greater automation eats them. Good luck.
- brianwawok 10y agoWhy does a store selling items in bigger boxes need to pay more?
- maxerickson 10y agoI don't know that they need to, but I can see where it would be beneficial to pay more if it led to better service of the more affluent customers that frequent the stores. The point about the large packages and much smaller number of items was more that they need less labor to keep the shelves full.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThen compare Walmart to Kroger and Publix. Publix charges around 10% more than Walmart per Walmart's ads in exchange for more variety, fast checkout, and high service. Kroger charges a mix of that and Walmart prices on things to attract basically every demographic with similar benefits offered to customers. Both pay workers well with benefits with Publix treating them well. The result is the two collectively sucked $135 billion a year out of Walmart's potential revenue. So, the highest profit and customer satisfaction companies in Walmart's model & market get there by providing decent pay, benefits, and job security to workers plus treating them better in Publix case. Same pattern emerges in lots of other industries. Probably better than what Walmart was doing. That Walmart keeps copying Kroger and Aldi, but not Publix which is employee-focused ;), shows they know those methods are better. Their management greed and control-freak nature makes them adopt more selectively and slowly.
- maxerickson 10y agoKroger and Publix both seem to offer ~50,000 items in their larger stores. They don't have a full department store and will thus likely have a greater variety of groceries than the Walmart, but they don't have greater variety overall. I would argue that they are a 3rd variety of big box (along with mega stores and club stores), not the same as Walmart.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoGrester variety in food. I should've specified that. Also a lot of higher-quality stuff or at least branded as such. Edit: It should be noted that Kroger is moving that direction with its Fred Meyer-style stores. They're more like Walmarts and Targets. Walmart even converted a failed store into a Walmart once although Im not sure the size of that one. Kroger is opening a Fred-style store close to me with descriptions that sounded like a Walmart. Will be interesting to see if these work and what effect they'll have on profit. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Meyer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Meyer