4 ms·
I don't doubt that eventually our chips will be structured carbon circuits on a diamond substrate. I find it amusing that should a sentient AI arise post transi
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I don't doubt that eventually our chips will be structured carbon circuits on a diamond substrate. I find it amusing that should a sentient AI arise post transition, it could reasonably think of itself as a carbon based life form :-).
The question I have not seen addressed is how we'll pattern the circuits. The ability to convert silicon into N-type and P-type material by doping is so "simple" compared to trying to induce the formation of CNTs of a particular geometry with the precision needed to develop a particular circuit. We are at the 'Bell labs' point where we can make individual (and volumetrically large) transistors out of CNTs or Graphene. But as we know from history, the revolution didn't really get underway until we could pattern a complete circuit on a substrate in the form of an integrated circuit. I'm still watching for the folks who come up with that breakthrough.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 10y agoInteresting, not sure why shpx deleted their comment but it lead me to Max Shulaker who is figuring out how to build integrated circuits out of these things. Looks promising and I am surprised I missed it. Thanks shpx! [1] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Zuanyi_Li2/publication/261030187_Carbon_Nanotube_Circuit_Integration_up_to_Sub-20_nm_Channel_Lengths/links/00b49536d8537cb839000000.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Zuanyi_Li2/publication/...
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> I find it amusing that should a sentient AI arise post transition, it could reasonably think of itself as a carbon based life form The best of everything (X) ends up carbon-based. Life forms, computers, space towers, etc. It's just due to the carbon atom having a bunch of unusual properties. (X) - whereas "everything" is an exaggeration used to make a point
- Razengan 10y agoI'm not sure if that sentiment isn't carbon chauvinism, given that the best we know so far has been carbon-based. I'm sure the universe in its infinity has plenty of surprises in store for an species that has yet to leave their home planet.
- wtallis 10y agoThere's no reason to expect far-flung corners of the universe to have different chemistry. We already know what the periodic table is for those unexplored regions of space, and they don't have anything cheaper and more versatile than carbon.
- mcbits 10y agoMaybe I'm underestimating the field, but I suspect there is still a lot to learn about chemistry in extreme environments (ultra hot, dense, etc), which would be most of the universe. Some experimentation is possible on Earth, but how much could we really learn about, say, liquid water if all we could produce were a few molecules in very restricted environments? I guess that's all kind of irrelevant until we're ready to try building transistors inside the Sun.
- wtallis 10y agoWe already know enough about chemistry and physics to rule out the possibility of building transistors inside the sun, or any other useful permanent structure inside a star. At the opposite end of the spectrum, we're already commercially exploiting temperatures on par with deep space and extremely low pressures. Yes, there's a lot we don't know about the properties of things or conditions that are hard to keep around in large quantities in the lab. But we're not going to discover complex life or be able to engineer complex and cost-effective machines in conditions where there's so much energy that molecular bonds can't stay intact or where there's so little energy that nothing gets done at better than a glacial pace. There's surely interesting stuff left to be discovered in those fields, but we won't magically stumble across a plasma-based computing substrate that is better than what we can already do on Earth.