5 ms·
> It's being supported by the evangelicals who will not remove their vote from Trump on the grounds that they really want that supreme court seat. You make it
by paulddraper 10y ago
> It's being supported by the evangelicals who will not remove their vote from Trump on the grounds that they really want that supreme court seat.
You make it sound illogical.
As a religious conservative, I do really want that supreme court seat.
The President has to really ask for permission for everything else (laws, budgets, wars, etc.), but justice nomination is very largely his choice. Don't be surprised if that factors heavily in my decision.
- unityByFreedom 10y ago> You make it sound illogical. > As a religious conservative, I do really want that supreme court seat. That factors heavily in the decision. Sorry, that's my bias seeping in. I respect your choice. > The President has to really ask for permission for everything else (laws, budgets, wars, etc.), but justice nomination is very largely his choice. Don't be surprised if that factors heavily in my decision. Not nuclear. He could launch with approval of his self-chosen cabinet, or choose not to defend our allies, resulting in more tensions in areas prone to nuclear war. Personally I think the risks posed by Trump with his thumb on the nuclear button are greater than the lives saved by repealing abortion rights. May God bless you and all of us through these tough times.
- paulddraper 10y ago> Personally I think the risks posed by Trump with his thumb on the nuclear button are greater than the lives saved by repealing abortion rights. 10 to 1 you're wrong. https://xkcd.com/1132/ https://xkcd.com/1132/
- unityByFreedom 10y ago> 10 to 1 one you're wrong. https://xkcd.com/1132/ https://xkcd.com/1132/ What are the two scenarios you're referring to? That Trump does or does not contribute to a nuclear war? Trump trashes everyone who disagrees with him. He will likely increase tensions on the world stage.
- colemickens 10y agoBy every account, he already has. Numerous world leaders and multinational organizations have denounced him, specifically because of his dangerous rhetoric.
- jeremyjh 10y agoYes but if you are right and the world ends and he doesn't have to pay up. That's the joke.
- kabouseng 10y agoJust as a discussion point (and going off topic and being maybe too pedantic) that is not how I understood the XKCD. The difference is that the one interpretation only takes into account the odds of the machine lying, the bayesian approach also takes into account the odds of the sun actually going nova, which is still neglible. Yes as a second consideration you can also take the view of the world will end, but that is not the point of the XKCD. And then drawing it to this discussion, yes the odds that Trump would be willing to start a nuclear war might be high, but combined with the odds of an actual nuclear war occurring the odds of it happening is still neglible.
- tdkl 10y ago> He will likely increase tensions on the world stage. While Trumps opponent openly warns Russia of consequences. Lets be objective now.
- unityByFreedom 10y ago>> He will likely increase tensions on the world stage. > While Trumps opponent openly warns Russia of consequences. Lets be objective now. Yes, let's. Russia is not an ally. There are consequences to its aggression. Trump, on the other hand, has repeatedly said we should extract more money from our allies in east asia, and that we should threaten to withdraw from Japan and South Korea. These are scenarios China and Russia would love to see play out. Trump argues NATO is obsolete. He defends Russia's annexation of Crimea, and he thinks we should give up Aleppo to Russian-friendly Assad. He thinks he knows more than the generals. At the same time, he claims he never thought about this stuff during his time as a businessman. The alternative to nuclear war is the proxy wars you see playing out in the middle east. Any concessions are gobbled up by whichever side backs down.
- hueving 10y ago>Personally I think the risks posed by Trump with his thumb on the nuclear button are greater than the lives saved by repealing abortion rights. I'm not sure if this was a subtle way to imply that, although the risk of Trump using the bomb is negligible, it's still greater than zero, which is the number of lives you consider lost to abortion. Impressive accidental troll. :) Realistically, what evidence do you have that Trump has any more likelihood of using a nuclear bomb against the wishes of congress than Hillary? Has he shown an inclination towards mass murder in other scenarios? Did he vote for the Iraq war?
- artimaeis 10y ago> Did he vote for the Iraq war? No, he's never served as a politician and so has no platform record. He's never demonstrated an ability to serve his country so I don't understand why we should entrust him with our most powerful station. > Has he shown an inclination towards mass murder in other scenarios? I don't believe there's any evidence of that. > What evidence do you have that Trump has any more likelihood of using a nuclear bomb against the wishes of congress than Hillary? To me it's his lack of temperament. I'm confident he means what he says that he doesn't want to use nuclear weapons. But in dire situations which may arise, I personally do not trust his temperament or judgement in dealing with foreign powers. This is because he's shown many times that he only cares for the most short-term benefits. His tax plans demonstrate this, his inability to explain many of his plans demonstrates this, and his history in business demonstrates this.
- unityByFreedom 10y ago> Realistically, what evidence do you have that Trump has any more likelihood of using a nuclear bomb against the wishes of congress than Hillary? Has he shown an inclination towards mass murder in other scenarios? Trump reportedly asked three times why we could not use nuclear weapons in a private briefing. More importantly, he threatens to change the landscape of our deployed military so drastically that the moves would create opportunities for non-allies to take more aggressive positions against our allies. If we failed to protect our allies, the US economy would tank, due to all the outstanding treasuries. > Did he vote for the Iraq war? Obviously Trump could not have voted on the Iraq war. That's an invalid question.
- mason240 10y agoPersonally I think people pushing this level of fear mongering should be embarrassed.
- paulddraper 10y ago> greater than the lives saved by repealing abortion rights That's a tall order. To put that claim in perspective, more Americans die in abortions every year than have died in combat in the entire history of the US. (Whether a fetus is a person is of course the point debated, but anyway, those are the numbers.)
- gilleain 10y ago> Whether a fetus is a person is of course the point debated, but anyway, those are the numbers More pedantically, they are surely not Americans either, since citizenship is conferred at birth?
- paulddraper 10y agoYes, that is pedantic. I'm talking about residency, not citizenship. Citizenship is more arbitrary: * Does citizenship include Native Americans? * Does citizenship include slaves? * Which of the Revolutionary War casualties were U.S. citizens?
- jmspring 10y ago"Very largely his choice" ... then why hasn't the current nominee see a vote in congress?
- paulddraper 10y agoOkay, that's a pretty fair point. Obama's nominees have had astronomically high wait times. His average is 35 days, compared to 10-20 days for recent presidents. http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/obama-has-waited-longer-for-cabinet-confirmations-than-any-other-recent-president/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/obama-has-waited-longer-f...
- aggie 10y agoThe dataset you present conveniently does not include the 211 days and counting for Merrick Garland, the longest period of Senate inaction on a Supreme Court nomination in American history, and approaching twice as long as the next longest (Brandeis at 125 days).
- colemickens 10y agoI can't tell if you're ignorant of the fact that his current nominee has been blocked for months and will continue to be blocked for months, or if you conveniently want to avoid talking about it. I just don't understand how someone invests themselves into a conversation like this without having the first clue about the territory.
- hueving 10y agoStill his choice. Show me which supreme court justice wasn't selected by a president.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aaronbrethorst 10y agobut justice nomination is very largely their choice FTFY Does your religious conservatism mean that you support the Citizens United decision? Or does it mean that you're opposed to Loving v. Virginia? How about Shelby County v. Holder?
- colemickens 10y ago>Don't be surprised if that factors heavily in my decision. 1. How is that going to affect your decision? Who can you vote for that will ensure the SC seat goes to a conservative? 2. How do you feel about the unprecedented blocking of the President from doing this Constitutional duty of appoint SC justices for 9+ months? Or is that just a small price to pay to get your religious beliefs installed in the highest court in the land?
- unityByFreedom 10y ago> Or is that just a small price to pay to get your religious beliefs installed in the highest court in the land? I don't know why you were downvoted, but I would like to point out that many laws are based on religion, like marrying only one person, or not stealing and killing. We take these for granted because we grew up with them. So, I'm not sure the argument that they are "installing religious beliefs" does much to convince religious people that they are overreaching. Their feeling is that they are saving people, and they feel this can be done through politics as well as it can be done in person. I'm not sure I agree with those who vote this way. I just wanted to throw it out there since I doubt you'll get a reply from a religious person.
- colemickens 10y agoNah, they just don't like me pointing out facts. Like the fact that this is Constitutional obstruction and is completely unprecented. Too much cognitive dissonance for people who are probably already completely overwhelmed at this point in the cycle, given the turmoil on that side of the aisle. That's why I won't get a reply from any of the small downvoters.
- paulddraper 10y agoI agree that blocking a nominee steps way beyond the roles outline in the U.S. Constitution. Hopefully, it gets taken to the courts and they agree. Like gerrymandering and fillbustering, it's one of these stupid games that the sides play.
- matwood 10y ago> The President has to really ask for permission for everything else (laws, budgets, wars, etc.), but justice nomination is very largely his choice. Reason magazine editorial made the same argument that Bernie was the best choice for libertarians. Basically he aligns with libertarians on social issues, and everything else he could not get done anyway.
- wcummings 10y ago>The President has to really ask for permission for everything else (laws, budgets, wars, etc.), but justice nomination is very largely his choice. Apparently not, since Obama hasn't been able to make the nomination...