7 ms·
This may seem somewhat unorthodox, but what I would strongly recommend is to start not by reading books on physics or math but read some books on history of phy
by Koshkin 10y ago
This may seem somewhat unorthodox, but what I would strongly recommend is to start not by reading books on physics or math but read some books on history of physics (and math) first. This will give you some intangible basic knowledge, or a sense, of what scientific research is all about, so that many things that otherwise may end up being puzzling to you when you come to learn the "hard science", won't. One recommendation I can make is Rhodes' The Making of the Atomic Bomb.
- dekhn 10y agoI have to agree with this. My physics education was sort of being dumped into late 20th century physics and could not understood how we got to quantum and relativity. It wasn't until recently that I went back and kind of walked through the history of physics from the natural philosophy days to the cavendish in the late 1800s that modern physics started to make sense.
- selimthegrim 10y agoYou might like this book then: https://www.amazon.com/c-Numbers-q-Numbers-Classical-Analogy-California/dp/0520078225/ https://www.amazon.com/c-Numbers-q-Numbers-Classical-Analogy...
- dekhn 10y agowhy are all the interesting books > $100 :(
- asoplata 10y agoThere's a free (legal!!!) HTML version at the "UC Press E-books Collection" http://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft4t1nb2gv&brand=ucpress http://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft4t1nb... Generally speaking, I find that the more expensive a rare academic tome is, the more likely there are legal/etc. versions online (PDFs, HTML, DjVu, etc.), indexed by Google. That seems to be much more true for STEM texts than those of the humanities, though.
- dekhn 10y agoThanks! I'd love to see that the case for this book https://www.amazon.com/Molecular-Vision-Life-Rockefeller-Foundation/dp/0195111435 https://www.amazon.com/Molecular-Vision-Life-Rockefeller-Fou...
- selimthegrim 10y agoAh, yes that's where I'd first read it but forgotten the link.
- Luc 10y agoThat book is in my top five list of best books, ever. But then I trained as a physicist and I hesitate to recommend it for a public less into that. Though I suppose it might wet someone's appetite to learn nuclear physics properly!
- healthnutter 10y agoPretty sure you meant to say, "whet"?
- Luc 10y agoSorry, yes!
- groby_b 10y agoThat book is amazing, speaking as a non-physicist. (Fine, I did study maths, so I suppose I'm almost qualified as a theoretical physicist, except I'm not good enough at maths ;) Really recommend it to anybody who's interested in that part of history. Amazing writing, and an incredible story. (You know it's gripping when you read about some of the experiments and feverishly hope they don't blow themselves up, nevermind knowing the outcome)
- thanatropism 10y agoOliver Darrigol's _Worlds of Flow_ is exactly this for fluid dynamics.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rubberstamp 10y agoHighly agree. I found that learning in sync with looking up its history, on why something was invented or why something is done in a particular way, helped we understand it better as I got more interested in the thing am studying. It may even help find a way to do it better. It gives various perspectives involved in decision making and scientific process. That kind of learning helped me to reach to solutions faster.
- pducks32 10y agoAs a physicist I completely agree. The history is the best part. And it's fun seeing how much scientists had a love/hate relationship with each other. But you also learn why they invented/discovered what they did. Which is important in advanced physics where sometimes the reason or purpose gets lost.
- acqq 10y agoI would rather recommend https://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Galaxy-Humanity-Discovered-Universe/dp/9814667161 https://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Galaxy-Humanity-Discovered-Uni... This is the right context for Newton, Einstein and quantum physics, it's written by an astrophysicist and is up to date, with beautiful illustrations and easy to read.
- Osmium 10y ago> but read some books on history of physics (and math) first. That's great advice. Do you have any more recommendations? As a working scientist myself, I find that a historical context really helps. This is especially true when a lot of quantum concepts are taught from a quasi-classical approach first, which arguably makes things harder for everyone in the long run, but feels more natural when you consider the historical thinking that led there (electron spin, I'm looking at you). Edit: Some recommendations of my own... A math teacher in school very kindly leant me a biography of James Clerk Maxwell (might have been 'The Man Who Changed Everything' but I'm not sure) and Marcus du Sautoy's 'Music of the Primes.' They were both great introductions, and definitely changed my thinking.
- XparXnoiAx 10y ago"The End of Physics" is a good one. You may also re-think your desire to learn physics. If you get through the book and still want to learn, then you will do it completely without illusions. https://www.amazon.com/End-Physics-Myth-Unified-Theory/dp/0465019765 https://www.amazon.com/End-Physics-Myth-Unified-Theory/dp/04...
- swift 10y agoI'm curious whether any physicists here have read this book and found its claims justified. I'm just a layman who enjoys reading about physics from time to time, but it seems to me that there are actually a large number of unsolved problems in physics that are experimentally accessible to us right now, and there's plenty of space for new theories to yield testable predictions. People were making claims similar to the ones in this book 100 years ago; they were unjustified then, and I expect them to turn out to be unjustified now.
- XparXnoiAx 10y agoI'm curious whether any physicists here have read this book and found its claims justified. Which claim in particular? I recommend the book, not so much because of its conclusions, but rather because of its excellent history telling.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoI'd suggest that in addition you should read at least some parts of modern translations of early scientific works starting with Aristotle. I don't mean read everything of course but try to get a sense of perspective, not everything was invented in the last hundred years. Also take a look at Carlo Rovelli's monograph: "Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look" at https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.4057 https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.4057. The kind of thinking that Rovelli describes is essential to success in science
- j2kun 10y agoAs a mathematician, I disagree, but this is probably because I already understand the math pretty well. I'd much rather have a clear picture of the most useful mathematical models for the various areas of physics (and where they fail) than slog through the centuries of failed experiments and feuds. Every time I ask a physicist for a clear picture of what light is (mathematically, what the model says it is), I get a mix of "it's a wave but also a particle" and random things that dead physicists have said about light. I honestly don't care if Einstein thought God doesn't play dice, or if someone way back when thought an atom was like plum pudding. I do want physical intuition, but I want it through clear and well-explained mathematics. That is, when I'm in the mindset to actually learn physics. Hearing about the history is fine and dandy if I want entertaining stories.
- mafribe 10y agoIt's probably a matter of taste. Once you understand the maths clearly, it becomes much easier to understand the failures of the past. For example, reading Newton and Leibniz on calculus makes it clear that it was epsilon/delta waiting to get out.
- j2kun 10y agoI guess my point is that, since most people find the math hard, writers put history in as what appears to be filler, which I find as mostly an obstacle.
- Koshkin 10y agoWell, it has to be said: a mathematician's outlook on physics is completely different from a physicist's. For a mathematician, physics is not much more than a bunch of more or less fixed mathematical models, each describing, approximately, some aspect of the physical world. For a physicist, on the other hand, not only are these models in a perpetual state of flux, but the physical world itself is seen as an indivisible whole, so that these "aspects" - the ones that are being modeled mathematically - are themselves just narrow views into the real physical world in which we live...
- 10y ago
- agumonkey 10y agoI can confirm. I just sniped a book about "pressure", the historical pathway with steps and non famous scientists gave a completely different feel than any physics textbooks with models and equations.
- plandis 10y agoI would definitely agree, partially. Intuitively classical physics makes sense but it was definitely helpful to me to understand the historical perspective for quantum mechanics. Or at least is where I think the undergrad Griffiths QM book gets it wrong. If I remember correct it just starts by basically stating the Schrodinger equation and going from there. One of the most helpful lectures I had in undergrad QM was on matrix mechanics formulation. It really helped to solidify my understanding.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wav-part 10y agoRelated Suggestion: Start with experiments, then read theories. This is very true for QM (or any other modern science). Start with older texts. Read the thought process of past giants. Avoid all "textbooks". Especially the one with >1ed/decade. These will only teach you how to pass in exams and useless "tricks". These will result in worse understanding of nature. Remember go to the source. General Recommendation: Ari Ben-Menahem - Historical Encyclopedia of Natural & Mathematical Sciences 2009 https://www.springer.com/us/book/9783540688310 https://www.springer.com/us/book/9783540688310
- kerbalspacepro 10y agolol. "Avoiding textbooks" is probably the worse advice imaginable. Now, I'm not saying go out and buy all of Pearson's catalog, but textbooks are the only books designed from the ground up to impart knowledge to a reader that meets the minimum standards described in the first few pages. Plus, the good ones describe the experiments used to develop whatever theory they're trying to impart to the reader. I will agree there are lots of bad textbooks, but the best-in-class textbooks are better than any self-learning guide you could make up yourself (within categories).
- jschwartzi 10y agoThe good lower-division textbooks will intersperse some history with the concepts. Even the Modern Physics textbook that we used had historical information in it. For sure, it's relevant, but you'll get a helping of it in every decent textbook.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoI think this is right. But the good news is that many childrens books on science are fairly historical -- at least the ones I had as a kid. One had, or example an illustrated page with Gallileo dropping weights from the leaning tower, and then another one with Newton and his apple.
- forinti 10y agoI don't know if this makes sense for someone looking for graduate-level knowledge, but it I'm sure it would make school a lot more interesting for children. It certainly helps to understand things if you know what people's motivations were and what tools they had when they made discoveries.