8 ms·
Tyson Foods Invests in Startup Beyond Meat
- norea-armozel 10y agoAre these products much better than say the morning star farm soy paddies? Because for me it's not so much texture as it is over all taste that affects what I eat. And most soy based products seem to taste so bland at least the ones we make here in the States.
- ianai 10y agoOptions are always good.
- BHSPitMonkey 10y agoIf these are voting shares, couldn't Tyson theoretically exercise their (albeit small) influence in favor of making Beyond Meat fail? I'm unfamiliar with safeguards against potential conflicts of interest like this, if any.
- mikeyouse 10y agoDepending on the size of the investment, they may get a board seat. Many startup boards have ~7 board members including the CEO and usually a founder if those two roles aren't the same person. The board basically sets executive compensation and votes on major decisions so a bad actor would have a very hard time messing with a company. The most damage they could cause would likely be sharing the confidential strategy and financial information that they would have access to.
- tkyjonathan 10y agoI see it a bit differently: They may be interested in integrating Beyond Meat into their distribution pipeline with this purchase in order for their investment to pay off. And why not? Growing animals for 300days in very poor conditions while paying pesky humans to take care of them, slaughter them, slice them up and transport them. You can just mix a couple plant-based ingredients and produce a decent burger instead at a fraction of the cost and time - it scales way better. Then you have all those reporters with their hidden camera of what goes on in those factory farms - why do you need all that bad publicity anyway. This is good publicity for them, cheaper to produce, healthier for humans and the environment. I cannot see a downside to this for any company or society.
- dogma1138 10y agoNo, you can't act against the interests of the company as a voting shareholder (or any for that matter, you can't buy shares and dump them at a lower price repeatedly for example effectively spending money to devalue the company). Depending on the shareholder agreement you will also be bound to additional guidelines to deal with conflict of interests and voting etiquette.
- adrianN 10y agoA malicious actor could probably do a lot of damage just by stalling and increasing bureaucracy without going "against the interests of the company" in an illegal way.
- dogma1138 10y agoNot really the SHA has clauses about that (usually under the deadlock provisions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadlock_provision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadlock_provision), in most cases if you don't show up for a vote or intentionally block it you will be removed, additionally normally shares that you buy as an investment if they come with voting rights would come tied to a voting proxy that proxy is usually the chairman so if you don't show up for a meeting the chairman would vote on your behalf. Pretty much there isn't that much mess you can do, the SHA will be defined to protect the company, you can't act against the interest of the company, you can't dump the shares since the other shareholders have the right of refusal and there are 101 other regulations. You also need to remember that in most cases there is no need of a unanimous vote of all shareholders, public companies usually follow the 51% rule which means that if you control 51% of the shares you control the company. There will not be many cases where company operate without a designated majority shareholder, this would scare of investors, the minority shareholders also don't share in any of the revenue of the company unless the company is sold or a dividend is declared so effectively minority stock is "worthless" in most cases and is only used as an investment. If you own 49% of the company you would only ever see any money if the company is sold, or the majority decided to grant dividends and you effectively can only sell that stock to the company/majority shareholder unless they refuse it and based on the specifics of the SHA they are also allowed to block sells to other parties.
- Animats 10y agoOnly 5%. It's not an exit yet. It's not very tasty meat.[1] However, it compares favorably with over-processed, over-seasoned real meat, and it's way ahead of most soy-based meat-like products. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/536296/the-problem-with-fake-meat/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/536296/the-problem-with-f...
- solipsism 10y agoUm... your link is an article describing one person's opinion about its flavor. Why even bother linking this? Couldn't you give your own instead?
- dagw 10y agoPersonally I'd rather read the considered opinion of a restaurant critic when it comes to food, rather than that of a random poster on HN.
- solipsism 10y agoThat's your choice and I disagree. Nevertheless, my main point was that it's one person's opinion. Linking to some kind of study or survey would have been useful. Linking to some restaurant critic's opinion about not-restaurant-food is silly.
- paulcole 10y agoJust curious, have you tried Beyond Meat? If so, which brands of soy-based meats are you comparing it to? And are you vegan or vegetarian?
- abawany 10y agoNot the OP but I have tried it. In the toaster oven and microwave, it was the best meat substitute burger that I had tried. Proud, I bought it to a cook-off with some carnist friends and there it met its nemesis: the open flame. I am not sure whether I overcooked it or if I got the wrong kind of Beyond Meat product but it was not good cooked on the grill. I finished it off with a brave face while my carnist friends, having tried a sample and soundly rejected it, looked on with glee mixed with pity. At that same event, I also tried Quorn burgers and they did ok but still not great.
- warmfuzzykitten 10y agoCould we stop with the links to WSJ? Very few people can get past the paywall.
- swampthinker 10y agoThe common workaround is to click "web" under the story link, then click the first result. Gets around the paywall. Or you could just pay for the WSJ.
- lukasLansky 10y agoThis doesn't work for me on mobile.
- jmknoll 10y agoYou can also copy the article title and run a google search for it. WSJ isn't paywalled for links from search engines (Google for sure at least, not sure about others).
- Noseshine 10y agoWe have come full circle. How about the submitter of the story does that?
- maggit 10y agoIt seems like WSJ inspects the Referer HTTP header, so it disables the paywall if it seems that you navigated to it from a search engine. So, it is not a property of the link. This, of course, makes sure I do not get around the paywall, since I have disabled that header in my browser. (I dislike the tracking aspect)
- icantdrive55 10y agoIts funny about paying for a site. The last site I paid for was a porn site in my 30's. They provided exactly what I needed, at the time. They didn't irritate me 99c introductory trials. I was around when everything was free. I wonder if that is my hesitation to pay, I'm cheap, or the content is just not compelling enough? If I wasen't so prudish, lazy I'd code a WallStreet/Homeclips site? It would have to be done just right. (I have gotten to used to not putting spaces between words. It used to be a pet peeve, now it's just looks normal.)
- newscracker 10y agoHere's a link from LA Times (no paywall): http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tysons-beyond-meat-20161010-snap-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tysons-beyond-meat-201...
- newscracker 10y agoThis, or something like this, was bound to happen because this is the nature of business. Hopefully Beyond Meat will not disappear but instead be able to grow bigger and become better.
- unwind 10y agoThis made me do a double take: Whole Foods Market Inc. this year began stocking them in the meat section of dozens of stores mostly in the mid-Atlantic [...] Not being from the US, I had to look this up since it sounds like they're stocking veggie burgers in the middle of the Atlantic ocean. They're not, though. :) It's a reference to the state of New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Washington, D.C., Virginia, and West Virginia (although the exact definition varies, this is from the Wikipedia page https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mid-Atlantic_states https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mid-Atlantic_states). So, I learned something today. :)
- grardb 10y agoDon't worry. I'm from New York, and I've never heard this term before. I got a huge chuckle out of your comment :D
- jlebrech 10y agothis can be a double edged sword, a company that contributes to animal suffering is profiting from the non-meat industry. but on the other hand the investment should be welcome. one compromise that may arise is the creation of a hybrid "low-meat" type product which still contributes to animal suffering but drastically disrupts the meat market.
- spodek 10y ago> "we really can’t feed a whole planet with meat.” If the food supply is limiting the population and making it more efficient increases the population, you're back where you started. Same with any limit to the population.
- Tarrosion 10y ago"if" being the key word there, and fortunately this is not borne out by data. When resources are more abundant, people have fewer children. Edit: here's a source. https://ourworldindata.org/fertility/#correlates-determinants-consequences https://ourworldindata.org/fertility/#correlates-determinant...
- imtringued 10y agoToo bad that the good "fake" meat is milk based. Is there perhaps a way to produce milk without animals? Or at least a way to make cows produce milk without pregnancy?
- snovv_crash 10y agoI've had some mycoprotein based meat replacement products, and they were pretty good. Definitely an improvement on soy. Better yet, the patent on mycoprotein production expires this year, so expect to see more fungi-burgers in your local supermarket soon.
- BvS 10y agoThe Beyond Meat products are 100% plant-based (vegan). I don't know if they are any good though (can't buy them in Germany).
- MisterBastahrd 10y agoIf you like chicken flavored modeling clay, you'll like Beyond Meat.
- abawany 10y agoTheir beef grounds are quite convincing and good, IMO though their extreme leanness gives them away. I have tried the chicken strips product as well and was not impressed. The burgers did well in the toaster oven but when I tried on a grill, possibly due to my mistakenly overcooking them, they were not good. All in all, their products have been the best substitutes that I have tried so far and I like that they are soy-free and contain the ingredients to form a fairly complete protein.
- helthanatos 10y ago"Branding is important" In other words... You're trying to get people that already eat meat to eat fake meat instead of people that already eat fake meat? I don't see why you would target a different audience. There are some benefits to meat that will take a little more work to replicate in a lab concoction. I, personally, would prefer eating something that once lived than eating lab made imitation... I also don't like when something says it's fruit but it's really somehing fake or foods that are mislabeled.
- mrfusion 10y agoWhat do you guys think about food based startups? It seems like there are lots of opportunities for disruption?
- sonar_un 10y agoMaybe Tyson can help Beyond Meat use their distribution channels to supply more stores. I find that BM products are always out of stock in Whole Foods in certain regions.
- sonar_un 10y agoMaybe Tyson can help Beyond Meat use their distribution channels to supply more stores. I find that BM products are always out of stock in Whole Foods in certain regions.
- wuschel 10y agoThat is great news! Beyond Meat is not the only player on the block, though. The challenges in the alt.ag. sector lie in the development of mass production technology. From the side of the market, consumers need an extra benefit (animal cruelty free products are not enough) in order to be converting. Outside of the startups, the time to maturity is hypothesized to be 5-15 years. Tyson is a very forward looking company, very much worried about the future of protein food supply. I had the pleasure of meeting some of their folks, and at least the top level very well outlined the problems we are going to face. Current business model in the sector is focused on high volume production with strong attrition, little regard to animal ethics (low regulations) and consolidation among manufacturers. Just the numbers make me shudder: * Livestock produces 18% of greenhouse emissions * Feed animals occupy 70% of arable land on our planet. With the classic animal protein supply chain being almost max'ed out in terms of capacity (and energy+matter conversion effiency), we have some grim perspectives here. Disclaimer: I work in the alt tag tech startup sector.
- refurb 10y agoI'm not sure why this is a scary stat: "Feed animals occupy 70% of arable land on our planet." If we didn't raise animals on that land it would just go fallow. It's not like we need more land to grow crops.
- wuschel 10y agoWell, good point, I typed my comment up fairly quickly. It is a lot of land occupied by a very recource hungry industry and less efficient industry e.g. you need 100x more water to make animal protein when compared to plant protein. We use 25% of our freshwater consumption for animal protein production - not even mentioning other recourses. With a growing number of people on the planet, efficiency is key.
- mrob 10y agoIf that water is from rain then it's a renewable resource, and if it's not used it will just flow to the sea and be wasted. There are places like Wales, with a wet climate and hilly terrain that are poorly suited to arable cultivation but ideal for livestock. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_Wales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_Wales However, freeing up more land for plants means we could grow the same amount of food using less intensive cultivation techniques, eg. rotating in nitrogen-fixing crops instead of relying on energy-intensive Haber process fertilizers.
- elif 10y agoAs an ethical V, I'm conflicted that one of the worst actors in the space would profit off of my purchase.. luckily there are many alternatives for me to buy. Perhaps they are counting on most people not knowing, or don't really understand their core market.
- jimmywanger 10y agoI've tried most alternative meat products on the market. Beyond Meat is fairly low on my list of favourite meat alternatives. The texture and taste just aren't quite right, sort of in the uncanny valley, if you will. My favourite alt-meat product would have to be Quorn.
- rebeccaskinner 10y agoI haven't found a single company that I think gets it right across their product lines. Quorn have some really good items- I really enjoy their pork roast type item, but I sometimes find their stuff to be overly dry and the texture is a bit off. Beyond's chicken strips have a closer texture in my opinion. Match has the best option for ground beef and sausage. Sweet Earth's seitan burgers are by far the best tasting veggie burger I've had, although they are not like an actual hamburger at all. I'm really looking forward to trying some of the newer alternatives that use plant-derived heme to increase the similarity to actual meat, but as far as I can tell those aren't widely available for purchase yet so who knows how good they'll actually end up being.
- rdlecler1 10y agoMargarine is a plant based alternative to butter. My concearn with alt.meat is whether or not this is just margarine 2.0.