3 ms·
When I have time later, I might feed it some images from the Magnum (the agency) corpus and see what feedback I get. Once upon a time, in certain newbie photo
by mc32 10y ago
When I have time later, I might feed it some images from the Magnum (the agency) corpus and see what feedback I get.
Once upon a time, in certain newbie photo critique forums, pranksters would upload a renowned photographers image for critique... Hilarious feedback from new photographers showing off their critiquing prowess.
- razvanh 10y agoI tried it with a couple of photos that got me awards in prestigious international competitions. They were assessed as being OK (~5/10)
- willis77 10y agoI tried an Ansel Adams photo - "This landscape is good, but it could be great. Let's give it a 7.5/10"
- mc32 10y agoAdams was a pretty straight forward photographer, so I suspect his example might fare better than say a Winogrand or D'Agata, for example.
- shams93 10y agoI got it to give me a 9.7/10 but I seriously doubt I'm a better photographer than Ansel Adams I'm betting it has an unintentional bias against black and white photography.
- shams93 10y agoI got it to give me a 9.7/10 but I seriously doubt I'm a better photographer than Ansel Adams I'm betting it has an unintentional bias against black and white photography.
- someone7x 10y agoI am chuckling at the idea of an art critic version of this and feeding it famous works.
- ethanbond 10y agoWhat do you think this is? Weird to imply such a strict delineation between photography and art.
- someone7x 10y agoKeegan seems to be judging the mechanics of photographic skill and not the artistry derived from it. The humor is from imagining a robot pan great works because of implementation flaws. "Mona Lisa. Muddy and drab. 2/10" Nothing really to do with me trying to classify what is/isn't art.
- iXce 10y agoActually it likes some pictures of the famous paintings :) "Simple but it's good" https://keegan.regaind.io/p/z7gQYuFxTTWTK00kHMuaPg https://keegan.regaind.io/p/z7gQYuFxTTWTK00kHMuaPg
- mc32 10y agoThe difficulty will be understanding context. Was blurr intended for effect? Same with a fuzzy picture, or a dark one, or one with no apparent subject, or was it informational only, etc.
- theoh 10y agoSome photography is presented as contemporary art, some isn't. "Fine art photography" is usually not credible contemporary art. It's often black and white, formalistic, maybe a female nude... I can imagine an AI that only understands formal qualities becoming pretty good at rating it. What you might call conceptual photography, on the other hand, is "AI-complete". It's as hard as literature to appreciate, you definitely need a full human-equivalent AI. Roland Barthes' ideas of the studium and the punctum start to open up the intellectual depth of that kind of photo. This kind of project is possibly credible as a rater of formal quality against some ideal norm, maybe stretching to understanding composition in a crude sense. But everyone knows that it's the unexpected but visually compelling feature that makes an image good. (Or alternatively the significance of its content.) Standard strategies like the "rule of thirds" can only produce formulaic images.
- zero_iq 10y agoI just tried a famous Cartier-Bresson image... "It's not super amazing. It's…something I guess; you could do better. Try improving your colors. This is at most 3.9/10. #boring" Yeah, Henri, improve your colors you lazy hack! ;)
- mc32 10y agoPoor D'agata: https://keegan.regaind.io/p/4ez2sHM5QDOT4nR6rzqU2g https://keegan.regaind.io/p/4ez2sHM5QDOT4nR6rzqU2g and Autio: https://keegan.regaind.io/p/qzqjM1CPRxGtkL1GQ4KL0g https://keegan.regaind.io/p/qzqjM1CPRxGtkL1GQ4KL0g But I get it. It's a great tool for beginners to see their rookie faults and address the basics [1]before they can foray into more intermediate photography. And then break the basics [2] in order to know why breaking the rules work and sometimes don't. Semi-related (to the optics/mechanics) is this tool[3] [1]https://www.flickr.com/photos/msc72/3184463442 https://www.flickr.com/photos/msc72/3184463442 [2]https://www.flickr.com/groups/1271834@N25/ https://www.flickr.com/groups/1271834@N25/ [3]http://camerasim.com/apps/original-camerasim/web/ http://camerasim.com/apps/original-camerasim/web/