17 ms·
Brain training exercises might just make you better at brain training exercises
- trendia 10y agoCommenting on HN just makes you better at commenting in HN.
- lfowles 10y agoPerfect^W Purposeful practice makes perfect.
- tonystubblebine 10y agoHere's a mystery to me: the failure of brain training games vs. the success of meditation. The science for brain training games is not encouraging. A number of studies have found that they do not produce generalizable mental improvements. Meanwhile, every time I turn around I run into a study of mindfulness meditation that did produce a generalizable improvement to mental abilities. For example, I was just reading one about how meditation can reduce pain perception by 40% and that measurement was backed up by MRI imaging of reduced brain activity in pain centers. Let's call meditation a brain game that works. The mystery then is why is there only one game that works? Will we ever find a second?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andreyk 10y agoWell, I think there are different types and methodologies of meditation that are believed to work. My guess is studies tend to focus on one format to be consistent and build on each other. Meditation at its core is nothing but practicing focus and self control, so my guess is a whole range of 'games' is possible to achieve the same effect but sitting down and focusing on your breath is basically the most practical. I have not played the brain games and so can't comment on why they appear not to achieve the same effect - perhaps they put too much focus into the abstractions and visuals of the game, and not the introspection of meditation.
- diyseguy 10y ago> Meditation at its core is nothing but practicing focus and self control You nailed it. Mental acuity is all about the ability to remain focused. Probably most of what gets written off as stupidity is really just an untrained mind that can't stay focused on a subject, task, conversation, etc. Meditation has the benefit of being restful as well as enhancing focus. Intensive game playing, while not necessarily relaxing, does inspire a greatly increased measure of focus. I am not convinced that brain games are ineffective. Weren't there recently numerous studies asserting that video game playing provided cognitive benefits?
- vidar 10y agoI would suggest that focus and self-control are not the core of meditation. It can profoundly influence the way you see the world, way beyond what you describe.
- fsloth 10y agoAs a person who loves games and has some experience of mindfullness/zen meditation: Games are about reasoning and reacting to external stimuli. Meditation usually involves more passive observation of self's inner self. To put it another way - games are dissociative, while meditation (the mindfulness kind anyway) aims to be anti-dissociative. One more point of view: I can play a game hours without being aware of the time that has gone by. When meditating I'm aware of each breath I take. I have no vocabulary to exactly specify how games and meditation are different - I can only state that the experience is different.
- bharath28 10y agoI'd be hesitant to call meditation a game in the same sense that other brain training exercise seem to be. Those games tend to have distinct end points (or multiple)/goals or something you are ambling towards. Meditation on the other hand, is based on focused observation of how your mind works. When done right, there is no goal or judgement - no end state that you are uneasily pushing towards.
- dhimes 10y agoBut is that the important part of meditation that leads to the results? I don't think we understand it well enough yet to know.
- goldfeld 10y agoWe have in fact understood it for millenia, but scientific instrumentation can't probe it like human inquiry has.
- cJ0th 10y agoAnd this is what I find worrying concerning the time we are living in. Society by and large moved from rejecting science to demanding scientific studies on everything. While this has certainly been a move in the right direction it led many people to having a very limited perception of the real world. There is more than words and numbers and I am not talking about some bullshit magical powers but this stuff has to be experienced. And why do I say this? Because I believe that this stuff which exists besides words and numbers is, like words and numbers, a subset of the resources that enable intelligence. So there is nothing wrong with brain training games and perhaps they do increase intelligence but don't be surprised if training only a tiny portion of what enables intelligence does not lead to enormous results. In my opinion meditation can be an overwhelming perhaps even painful experience and thus it challenges you more seriously than, say, finding the next number in a sequence. No pain, no gain.
- mamon 10y agoMeditation is about focus, that's it. A person is born with some innate intelligence, but, thanks to things like television, email, Facebook, etc. we are far from our full potential, because we are constantly distracted. Once you regain your focus you hit the ceiling of your possible IQ. Meditating further will not do you much good past that point.
- coldtea 10y agoPeople meditated far before there were "things like television, email, Facebook, etc.". It's not just about "quiet time".
- dhimes 10y agoBut there were other distractions. We can always find distractions. This is as good of a hypothesis as any I've seen, but I agree that we don't really know yet why meditation works. Does walking meditation do the same thing? Meditative Tai Chi? Playing basketball "in the zone?" Or even playing video games "in the zone?"
- tonystubblebine 10y agoEmotions are the universal distraction.
- bharath28 10y agoYes, agreed. Distractions don't have be television, email, Facebook... We spend a lot of time thinking about hypothetical situations that may occur in the future & how we'll react to them. Or reliving our versions of past events over and over. All of these distract from the present moment. Meditation still helps in these situations.
- languagewars 10y agoYour referenced study on meditation doesn't suffer from decontextualization.. While you are meditating you are acutely aware of senses like pain and you are managing them. I currently do language learning and music apps, AFAIK I am actually learning things that are directly applicable to the real world and that supposedly have cognative benefits correlated with having learned them traditionally. Do those benefits evaporate when I learn them in "games"?
- hannob 10y agoI think I can explain the mystery to you: You have a skewed view of the scientific evidence. The evidence for mindfulness and meditation is questionable at best. There's a lot of bad science, undeclared conflicts of interest and weak studies in that space. > For example, I was just reading one about how meditation can reduce pain perception by 40% and that measurement was backed up by MRI imaging of reduced brain activity in pain centers. This is a completely meaningless statement. What kind of study is that based on? An RCT or observational data? How many participants? A single study or a metaanalysis? Has it been replicated? Was it preregistered? All of that matters to decide whether that's just "a study" or reliable science. There are plenty of studies showing that brain games work, too. They're just of low quality.
- gf263 10y agoHave you ever meditated?
- CoryG89 10y agoI guess it depends on your definition of meditation, since it's not an actual physical or mental state someone can be definitively in or not in. I might say that I meditate every night when I sleep for 5-8 hours.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> since it's not an actual physical or mental state someone can be definitively in or not in How do you know that?
- CoryG89 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability I cannot know that, and neither can anyone else. The reasons being that meditation does not have a good scientific definition and is not falsifiable. We shouldn't consider it as science until both of those reasons change.
- hypertexthero 10y agoBrain training games use too much of the left, 'linear', analytical side of the brain. Meditation brings the right, 'rich', creative side to bear on a problem. I recommend drawing as a meditative activity. The following books have been helpful: Pragmatic Thinking and Learning by Andy Hunt Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain by Betty Edwards Search Inside Yourself by Chade-Meng Tan
- prostoalex 10y agoThe practices focus on different parts of the brain. The games usually focus on the frontal cortex development (http://www.webmd.com/balance/features/believe-it-or-not-computer-games-can-be-healthy http://www.webmd.com/balance/features/believe-it-or-not-comp..., admittedly with with mixed success https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20407435 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20407435) while meditation seems to lead to an increase of brain cells in hippocampus https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3004979/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3004979/
- westoncb 10y agoThere's actually a simple explanation for this: meditation trains brain functions that operate at a sufficiently general level to see cross-domain impacts, while brain training games don't (or at least the range of domains is much smaller). Let me give you an example of a popular form of meditation: You sit up straight in a comfortable place, not doing anything special, just listening to what's going on in your environment and tuning into sensations in your body (this happens automatically as long as you haven't 'assigned' yourself something else to do; once you get into this state, you might recognize it as familiar from when you were younger, or from a time when you were feeling particularly like "everything's okay" and you are just at home). Before starting this, you understand that you are going to watch/listen/feel your breath—and if you've had some practice, you don't try to do anything about it: you just wait and feel whatever comes up as time passes. Eventually it's like the queue of other things clears and you start tuning into your breath more and more until the sensations become very rich and relaxing. Thoughts will continue emerging for a good long while during this, and meditation teaches a certain response to noticing their arrival: you acknowledge them, as if you'd heard a small sound in the room, turned around and saw what it was, and then returned to what you were doing (often times meditators are encouraged to use a quick label for whatever mental thing comes up, e.g. 'thinking' or 'fear')—then, assuming you haven't got too wrapped up in the thought (either by following it, or by trying somehow to making it go away), the sensations of your breath return to the forefront. Two big things come from this: you become more relaxed afterward, which aids task performance in most domains directly; and, you learn all these pitfalls and techniques for maintaining focus on what you choose to focus on. One big one, for instance, is that a lot of people approach focus by seeing distractions as problems to be solved (whether they are thoughts, pains, environmental sounds—whatever), but eventually you see that what works is maintaining an equanimous attitude toward distractions, and simply returning your attention to what you're doing, while understanding you might get pulled away again shortly (and it's not enough to just 'know' this; you have to practice it). Lastly, meditators are typically encouraged to practice being in this 'aware but not trying to do anything' state while doing other things than sitting, which has got to help with generalizing. (Not to mention the desired mental state is just domain agnostic to begin with. When you're doing a task you either believe you know how to do it and go at it confidently, with little meta-thought; or you're observing/critiquing how you're doing it and trying to change routines you've stored for doing it. In the first state you're way more tuned into sense data which is relevant for actually executing the task in the present moment. Meditation helps you learn to enter the first state intentionally.)
- innerspirit 10y agoGood. Now perhaps make a study about sensationalized article titles like this one. The conclusion in the title is inaccurate. FTA: "Overall, Simons and his colleagues conclude that the evidence [...] is “inadequate”." and "it’s possible future research will provide new evidence that is more favourable to brain training"
- jmcgough 10y agoSure, but it's impossible to prove that brain training has no benefits, all we can say is that essentially every well-run study has failed to find any benefits. They're just saying that stuff to cover their bases - most neuroscience researchers don't believe that "brain training" is anything more than just wishful thinking.
- JacksCracked 10y agoIt is impossible to prove, and yet the title claims it to be true.
- scott_s 10y agoGiven the evidence, it is a reasonable conclusion. Very little is ever "proved". Rather, we make conclusions based on the available evidence. If the evidence changes, we revisit our conclusions.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoWhoever downvoted you, has probably never heard of the axiom: "Nothing can ever be proven true, because that means you would have to consider every possibility. The best that we can hope for is to prove something is not true by finding exceptions. After many failures at finding exceptions, we just state that some things are true until an exception is found."
- Naritai 10y agoThe thing is, researchers commonly put in throwaway lines like your latter quote to avoid themselves from being embarrassed by some new study that comes out in the future. The key to comprehension is appreciation which portions are fundamental to the message and which parts are throwaway.
- hamhamed 10y agoDoes this research also consider actual real Brain training games like Elevate? It teaches you techniques like how to get better at estimating, improving your WPM, your thesaurus, etc. Nothing to do with memorizing a pattern or serving coffee to customers as fast as possible.
- Naritai 10y agoI applaud your pinpoint application of the 'No True Scotsman' fallacy.
- cgag 10y agoWe've never seen truly flawed studies before right?
- unpythonic 10y agoThe article quotes the paper, which says “… learning things that are likely to improve your performance at school (e.g., reading; developing knowledge and skills in math, science, or the arts), on the job (e.g., updating your knowledge of content and standards in your profession), or in activities that are other-wise enjoyable.” Using an app to learn a new language, extend your vocabulary, or learning new arithmetic tricks would seem to fall into this category. If the Elevate app actually does any of these, then I'd call it "learning" instead of "brain training".
- grandalf 10y agoI played around with Lumosity as part of a research project a few years ago. The games were somewhat fun and it was possible to improve one's score by repeated play. So little of what humans do is similar to those games, so I don't see how "context" could possibly be similar unless those sorts of brain speed/recognition tasks were part of your day to day work. I'd be curious about scenarios like: - Practice identifying the semantic bug in a 20 line snippet of code. How effectively would practicing this help a person identify real bugs in actual code? - Chess problems with 5 pieces on the board. How helpful would practicing these be to solving problems with 6 pieces? - Essay writing. Suppose for a moment that a human essay could be judged accurately enough to create a 500 word essay trainer. How effective would training on it be to quickly being able to articulate one's thoughts? Similarly, I'd be curious about a sunk cost rationality trainer, logical proof trainer, and reading comprehension trainer. These would be harder to build than the simple video games on Lumosity, but I suspect the competency obtained could be a bit more useful in real world tests of ability. However, there are fairly few cases where specific characteristics of human intellect or rationality are measurable by longer term human performance. If your job entails long term project planning, trade-offs, etc., it's pretty hard to prepare in a meaningful way using short-term training sessions.
- Swizec 10y ago> - Essay writing. Suppose for a moment that a human essay could be judged accurately enough to create a 500 word essay trainer. How effective would training on it be to quickly being able to articulate one's thoughts? This exists. It's called an audience and publishing something every day will get you good real quick. A lot of famous authors started as journalists and more recently bloggers for exactly this reason.
- jimmaswell 10y agoMy college's placement test used some kind of algorithmic essay grader. I found it strange. It checked for typos, vocabulary use, etc. probably.
- 10y ago
- Y201K 10y agoA friend showed me Lumosity and I thought "there's no way this can work", when in life do you have to distinguish the direction moving colored arrows are pointing? The reason I so quickly came to this conclusion is because of the concept of specificity in strength training -- your exercises have to be picked so that they support your goals. I imagine that an approach like this in the brain-enhancing-games space would look a lot more like what we think of as homework.
- tux1968 10y agoWhat caught my eye in your post is that you have accumulated some useful knowledge from strength training that you just applied elsewhere in your life. Don't you think it's possible that the exact same could happen to people solving puzzles? I doubt that a scientific study would find that strength training leads to improved problem solving skills, and yet it has for you.
- EliRivers 10y agoI doubt that a scientific study would find that strength training leads to improved problem solving skill Here are some that do. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001691814001577 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001691814... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26456233 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26456233 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22155655 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22155655
- tux1968 10y agoHeh, well that'll teach me for not being more precise in my wording. Of course your fitness level will have a positive effect on your mental abilities. What i meant to highlight was his use of specific insights _about_ strength training that he then found could be abstracted and applied elsewhere. The same possibility of which he had dismissed in the puzzle solving case.
- Y201K 10y ago
- snarf21 10y agoThe weird thing is that there is an initial lift but only because you are learning something new. You have to figure it out, it takes effort and creates new pathways, etc. Once you have learned it, you tend to be on auto pilot. The thing to do is keep learning new things: photography, baking, woodworking, etc. It is the challenge and discovery that are important.
- radicsge 10y agoI believe this also, if you dont learn new things/practice exercise (something where you need to think), you will loose IQ (like in a long holiday). So in long term brain training exercises are essential.
- dhimes 10y agoI'm totally grooving on the linux bsd games like galaxies and keen that I've recently discovered. At first there was this "high" from trying to figure out the new patterns. Now even the more difficult stuff is becoming systematic (although still absorbing).
- danielweber 10y agoNothing about N-back, which is the one braintraining thing that had evidence for it.
- Sanity_ 10y agoI know people who just don't make critical thinking a part of their daily routine, and they tend to be sloppy and thoughtless when confronted with any sort of mental exercise. If these "Brain training exercises" can get people thinking critically and dedicating time of the day to using parts of their brain they wouldn't have otherwise, then it seems like a good thing to me.
- h4nkoslo 10y agoInterestingly, this is the primary explanation for the Flynn effect, and why culture-loaded questions do not show the same improvements that completely abstract, non-culture-loaded questions do.
- devy 10y agoHonest question: so if brain training exercises don't work, then what else can genuinely improve brain functions?
- coldtea 10y agoFor particular brain functions (learning guitar, coding, speaking another languages) actual practice. (This is also how training exercises work, only their particular function they improve the brain on is solving them, which makes them useless). In general, better physical workout and diet does genuinely improve brain function. Hard for the brain to function well in a 500lbs diabetic body...
- TulliusCicero 10y agoI remember reading studies about a few different video games improving cognitive performance: Rise of Nations, Starcraft, and an FPS (maybe Unreal Tournament?).
- zizzles 10y agoCould this perhaps just be a rationalization for some to play video games under a doctrine of "I'm getting smarter" when in turn it's just mindless consumption of media? I am all for FPS games improving my cognitive performance, but we should not be delusional about this. If I wanted to (at least try) improving cognition, I would spend hours reading math textbooks and doing exercises, learning languages, perhaps reading about philosophy in my off-time; not strafing left and right with my WASD keys and trashing on kids all day in Counter-Strike.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoSounds like you already made up your mind.
- sotojuan 10y agoActually learn new stuff? Learn a second language, an instrument, math, programming—anything that takes you out of your comfort zone.
- DiffEq 10y agoInstead of Games that may or may not map to some useful thing and some cognitive improvement...why not just learn more math and or a 2nd language? The time invested here will at the very least provide you with some useful skill or a better understanding of your world.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoMath and 2nd languages are brain games that work. *cough
- fsiefken 10y agoIt seems that meta-analysis confirms the usefulness of things like dual-N-back training. Does anyone disagree? https://www.gwern.net/DNB%20meta-analysis https://www.gwern.net/DNB%20meta-analysis https://www.quora.com/How-does-dual-n-back-actually-increase-IQ https://www.quora.com/How-does-dual-n-back-actually-increase... For an n-back like exercise: http://cognitivefun.net/test/22 http://cognitivefun.net/test/22
- jackcosgrove 10y agoI think this is the only proven "brain training" that works, and the effect is temporary.
- mark_kalvelage 10y agoYou need to read gwern's link more closely. Second paragraph: This indicates that the medium effect size is due to methodological problems and that n-back training does not increase subjects’ underlying fluid intelligence
- Bartweiss 10y agoMost damningly, the review didn't turn up dose-dependent results. If n-back works, I would expect either "more is better" or "flat gain past some minimum". Instead, the effect vs training graph is a shapeless cloud, which seems like a major warning sign.
- tetrep 10y agoincentives incentivize... The entire "I'll find a mental analogue that's easier/more fun than real exercise" industry smacks if an industry dedicated to perpetual motion. Extreme scientific discoveries aside, it's not going to happen.
- j2kun 10y agoMy wife teaches math at a community college level, meaning she often needs to teach students who are paralyzed by fear of fractions (or worse, negative numbers). Many of her students are also adults. She tells me things like "If I ask one of these adult students a question involving negative numbers, and I phrase it in terms of money and debt, they answer it immediately. If I ask them using just numbers, they have no clue." These students do not know how to take a concept they've used their entire lives to balance their checkbooks, and abstract it beyond money. I would conjecture that in most cases of "activities that stimulate your brain", the key to generalization requires another skill: being able to abstract a skill you have learned from one situation, and then specialize it to another situation. And this skill needs practicing. I also conjecture that a small fraction of the population actively does this, and this could explain why the results aren't statistically significant. E.g. meditation actively encourages introspection and generalized mindfulness in any situation, whereas crosswords and Chess are played for their own sake.
- gizmo686 10y ago>If I ask one of these adult students a question involving negative numbers, and I phrase it in terms of money and debt, they answer it immediately. If I ask them using just numbers, they have no clue. This doesn't just happen with students who are bad at math. If you sit in on most introductory advanced math classes (eg. introduction to abstract algebra), you will see the same thing: students imminently understand what is being asked when it is phrased in terms of something concrete, but have more difficulty answering even basic questions when they are asked in the abstract. The main difference, in my experience, is that in advanced classes, a "concrete" example would be something like the set of 2x2 real valued matrixes; so non mathamaticians do not recognize it as being simple. There is also the difference that experienced mathematicians have learned that "simple" things will become simple with enough exposure; and have honed the ability brute force their way through while they get that exposure.
- CoryG89 10y agoSo meditation is actively improving your "introspection and generalized mindfulness", but people doing crosswords and playing Chess are just being silly and wasting time? I was with you until I read that. Maybe I just don't buy into the whole meditation thing, but from where I stand, at least Chess seems like it actively improves/encourages/practices strategic thinking skills.
- kruhft 10y agoKinda like practicing math, just makes you good at math? /s
- josefresco 10y agoI had the same reaction. For example, does taking a lot of "tests" make you good at ... tests? To me it calls into question the validity of tests to measure intelligence.
- CoryG89 10y agoI would say that taking lots of tests may indeed make you better at taking tests. You may find that working under pressure or under a time limit is something that you get better at with practice.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CoryG89 10y agoPracticing math will only make you better at math. Taking the time to truly understand the math in the most general terms will make you good at truly understanding anything in the most general terms.
- jackcosgrove 10y agoI worked at an academic neuroscience software company back when Lumosity first emerged on the scene. Lumosity was spurred on by I believe statistically significant results regarding the n-back test improving working memory. There was a lot of hope that other games/tests might be designed to improve other cognitive features. However the n-back test is the only one I have ever heard of having a significant effect on cognition, and even then it's temporary. There was a lot of disappointment in these results. Nevertheless, Lumosity et al continued to market minigames as health elixirs.
- rixarn 10y agoYou're right. The amount of "exercises" that have proven to have some degree of transfer are very limited (n-back being the most typical not the only one). It's not only a problem of Lumosity et al, it's a problem on researchers too. There's an alarming amount of papers that are really bad, both methodologically and in terms of the type of tasks and training duration. No wonder the brain training industry gets bashed every now and then when a new study debunks most of the allegedly benefits. So we have a group of folks that don't understand what they are doing and are publishing bad papers, and another group of folks that read those papers without fully understanding what is going on under the hood and create a "brain training" app. The fine on Lumosity by FTC was fair and expected.
- EddieSpeaks 10y agoJust like playing chess makes you better at playing chess, no generic Intelligence boost from specific activities with narrow problem spaces
- carleverett 10y agoThis is the best article I've ever read of the subject of how you can improve intelligence: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/you-can-increase-your-intelligence-5-ways-to-maximize-your-cognitive-potential/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/you-can-incr... Kind of like how people have to be reminded that the best way to lose weight is to diet and exercise, the real answer for intelligence is challenging yourself frequently and putting yourself in uncomfortable situations that you need to think your way through. At the end of the article there's a beautiful definition: "Intelligence isn’t just about how many levels of math courses you’ve taken, how fast you can solve an algorithm, or how many vocabulary words you know that are over 6 characters. It’s about being able to approach a new problem, recognize its important components, and solve it—then take that knowledge gained and put it towards solving the next, more complex problem. It’s about innovation and imagination, and about being able to put that to use to make the world a better place. This is the kind of intelligence that is valuable, and this is the type of intelligence we should be striving for and encouraging."
- it_learnses 10y agothis article also references the Dual-N-Back study which suggested that it could be used to increase cognitive skill that was transferable. But that study was debunked. Here's a Scientific American article on that: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/brain-training-doesn-t-make-you-smarter/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/brain-training-do...
- Davidp00 10y agoI agree that according to the article you linked it seems that the Dual-N-Back game is no different than any other brain training game which seems to differ from the authors view on it. However, I don't think that debunks the main points of the authors article (the last 3/4 of the article).
- it_learnses 10y agoI think it does. If indeed Fluid Intelligence cannot be trained, then you could say that people who seek out Novelty, Challenges, etc. are actually the sort of people who have high intelligence, than the other way around. If these 5 principles he states actually did increase intelligence, then Lumosity would work for people as it exposes you to novel brain training games that are challenging.
- dschiptsov 10y agoWhy, any training, it seems, has the same nature. Highly specialized task, such as joggling will make you better only at joggling (and, perhaps, will improve coordination of your hands) while training at, say, triathlon will make one generally stronger, more coordinated, with better stamina and endurance. Similarly, mindfulness (awareness) and concentration (focusing) meditation techniques in general will make one better at variety of tasks, while specialized training, lets say, math tricks, will only affect specialized areas of the brain. The training of a musician requires a lot of listening to the classical music, not just trying to play "mechanically" . All this is known for ages by Greeks and by Indians.
- dghughes 10y agoIt wasn't my intention to train my brain but I started using DuoLingo (it's free) language learning and I find my concentration has improved. Maybe it's just because I do a different activity at a regular rate per day but I do feel brainy plus I am learning three languages.
- surrey-fringe 10y agoI don't doubt it, but people shouldn't take this to mean that there aren't any possible exercises to strengthen mental ability. You've just got to listen to people who are actually successful, and not some corporate-funded research that might be null in three years. I don't see anyone at the World Memory Championships citing Lumosity.
- taneq 10y agoA guy I used to play soccer with always said "train as you play!" Now, he was upset because on cold rainy Thursdays a lot of us were wearing tracksuit pants to training, and he felt we should be wearing shorts... and for some reason he felt that shin pads were exempt from the "train as you play" ethos. Which was funny, because he was a good lad but he was always getting injured. I think he played three matches the whole time I was at the club, and that was a few years, because the rest of the time he was sidelined by injury. But I digress. I think "train as you play" is excellent advice. We don't learn the training. We learn the playing.
- hmahncke 10y agoThe article begins from the premise that psychology has shown that brain training can not cause generalized benefits, and then goes on to review more than 130 peer-reviewed publications, meticulously finding fault with each one, and concluding that nothing can be learned from the entire field. It's as if the authors went through an entire forest, finding fault with each tree, but never noticed there was an entire forest (of evidence). I'm an author on one of the studies discussed, and for what it's worth, there are two factual errors in their review of my study alone. The authors then go on to state that people seeking to improve cognitive function would be better served by exercising or going to college. Exercising is an excellent idea, but the evidence for cognitive improvement is certainly no better than for cognitive training, and is arguably worse [1]. College is fine as well, but from a methodological perspective there's never been a randomized controlled trial showing that college improves cognitive function, and arguably all college does is select high-achievers and then further filter them with low-performers dropping out. Endorsing college (with no RCTs) over brain training (with RCTs) suggest a biased review. Disclosure: I work at Posit Science, where we make a brain training program. My work is specifically criticized in the article. [1] http://www.cochrane.org/CD005381/DEMENTIA_aerobic-exercise-to-improve-cognitive-function-in-older-people-without-known-cognitive-impairment http://www.cochrane.org/CD005381/DEMENTIA_aerobic-exercise-t...
- Gatsky 10y agoYou describe the process of meta-analysis as of there is something wrong with it. The point about exercise or college is they are guaranteed to have some benefit, unlike playing a brain training game, which has at least a 50-50 chance of being a waste of time.
- hmahncke 10y agoI like meta-analyses quite well, but the APS article was not a meta-analysis - it was more like a broad review. Here are a few meta-analyses that disagree with the APS article: Computerized Cognitive Training with Older Adults: A Systematic Review http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0040588 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.... Computerized cognitive training in cognitively healthy older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of effect modifiers. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25405755 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25405755 I liked college and benefited from it, but it the US (at least) it costs tens of thousands of dollars, and 45% of people don't complete a degree in 6 years: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/11/19/u_s_college_dropouts_rates_explained_in_4_charts.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/11/19/u_s_college_d...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SubiculumCode 10y agoOpportunity costs are damning. Even if brain training games were modestly effective, they hold an opportunity cost: The time you could have been spent doing cardiovascular exercise that has demonstrated robust positive effects on cognition.
- andrewprock 10y agoIt's possible to be both physically and mentally active. You don't need to choose.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoyes yes. Of course, but there people have only so much time...and many people are NOT physically active. Sure do your 'brain training' (if it works) AFTER you've done a decent amount of cardio, but cardio should be the goto.
- erdevs 10y agoThis is a shoddy write-up which sensationalizes the more rigorous underlying scientific work. The actual research here appears to find methodological shortcomings in many papers purporting a broader effect on intelligence or problem-solving ability from some popular brain training games. It does not, however, conclude that there is no effect. It is unfortunate (though very common) that the article oversimplifies and sensationalizes. The headline "brain training exercises just make you better at brain training exercises" is far too definitive. I'm glad the "might" qualifier at least was added here on HN. Similarly, the article saying "the same is not true", definitively, for the benefits of physical vs mental exercise games. Examples abound throughout the article and it reads as sloppy, biased, and exaggerated. Not uncommon today, but always unfortunate still. It's a shame many brain-training companies make exaggerated claims themselves. So, in some ways, it's fine to see some counterfire in online press. Unfortunate if that's what it comes down to, though.
- rixarn 10y agoI've been working on "brain training" stuff for almost 8 years and just recently (around a year ago) decided to make a startup out of it. I'm a psychologist and software engineer and my cofounder is a clinical psychologist and neuroscientist. We've done our own research (and have a published paper), read a lot of the stuff that's out there and have evaluated and kept track of the existing products for years. First thing that baffles me on most commercial products is the frequency and duration of each training session. Let's think for a minute. On average you have this short sessions that range from 5 to 15 minutes. Even in something as evident as physical activity... how fit can you get by doing 15 minutes of low intensity jogging on average 3 times a week? How fair is to say based on that example that jogging is "worthless"? That said, most critiques to Brain Fitness are correct. If I could summarize what we've learned so far: - Transfer effect (i.e. to gain benefits outside of the activity you're doing) is hard to achieve, it takes a lot of time, has to be a n-back and heavy working memory activity (is the only think I can think of having a chance to do transfer) and it doesn't work all the time. On our own experience probably 20% of the population will never benefit from something like this. Also, transfer is limited to some executive functions, not all of them. - Training duration and frequency. Think of a physical activity like jogging but instead of doing 15 minutes of low intensity jogging 3 times a week, do 35 high speed jogging 4 times a week for two months. You will get fit. - Training activity. Most n-back and working memory stuff is boring and hard to do for players. It's difficult to engage on a "game" like that and the dropout rate for users is very high. Most games out there that are part of the package of games in brain training softwares are based on stuff that has not been proved to have any transfer effect. Our mobile app will focus mostly on working memory and sustained attention games (fewer but with more complex game dynamics that current ones). And I don't think we will advertise it as a "life changer" or a way to "make you smarter". We just want to build a suite of games for people to be challenged and have fun while doing so.
- briandw 10y agoDual n-back training is the only thing that I've read about that shows transference to unrelated tasks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-back https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-back There are some good apps out there: Desktop -> http://brainworkshop.sourceforge.net http://brainworkshop.sourceforge.net Android -> https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tyrske.dualnback&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tyrske.dua... And I make a pitch for my app, IQ boost for iOS -> https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/iq-boost/id286574399?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/iq-boost/id286574399?mt=8
- natdempk 10y agoThis article actually points out that the IQ/fluid intelligence increase findings from the original Jaeggi paper about dual n-back failed to be replicated. > Finally, at the end of the study, we gave everyone different versions of the cognitive ability tests. The results were clear: the dual n-back group was no higher in fluid intelligence than the control groups. Not long after we published these results, another group of researchers published a second failure to replicate Jaeggi and colleagues’ findings. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/brain-training-doesn-t-make-you-smarter/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/brain-training-do...
- afinlayson 10y agoAnyone who has used these could tell you that. If they are mindful enough to notice.
- perseusprime11 10y agoThis has to become some kind of meme...reading books might just make you better at reading books :)
- whatup 10y agoI wonder if part of the reason brain training appears to have little benefit is similar to the reason most people who visit the gym make little gains in athleticism; because they don't push themselves hard enough. A lot of people feel like simply showing up is all that's required, and they don't break a sweat. This is supported by the fact that many of these brain training apps/games often have addictive traits, similar to other video games. This might lead to their usage being met with undue reward. I used one of them, and the goal (unduly rewarded) was simply to come back and, essentially, play each day. It didn't matter how hard I worked. This could be tested by measuring brain activity during brain training (compared to some control activity) and seeing if the delta positively correlates with increased cognitive function.
- robg 10y agoTitle change suggestion: Bad brain training has limited scope. The question remains what good brain training would is. Paired with electrical or magnetic stimulation? There's almost all fertile ground here and, I believe, our great advances as humans this century will come from better ways to grow brains. Consider mobile apps that adapt to your cognitive strengths and weakness, when you haven't slept well or are under stress or need coffee, and where learning becomes lifelong and personalized. By building our intelligence we also become good at developing artificial forms. To me it's the problem of our time, these early attempts just help to develop better approaches.
- emodendroket 10y agoWow, shocking.
- andrewguy9 10y agoJust like the SAT.
- davidgerard 10y agoNeither headline nor URL contains the word "might".
- throwawayReply 10y agoYup, hn has a rule about original headlines except where inconvenient. In this case though they slipped up, "might just make you better" means "likely to make you better" and the "just" no longer conveys "only" at all anymore.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ievahanordah 10y agoOf all the different ways you can improve your brain there is only one thing they all have in common that things that don't make your brain better have. They challenge your brain. The complexity of a problem required to challenge someone is different for every organism. A simple task would improve a bees cognition. A more challenging task would be needed to improve a retarded humans. A more challenging task than that for an average human, and continued for an above average human, well above average human, cont.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThe entire brain training market seems to be based on a willful failure to understand Goodhart's Law. The basic pitch is "performance on these games correlates with intelligence, so practice these games to become more intelligent". That's not how anything works! If you influence a metric directly, it stops being a good proxy for all the things it used to correlate with. It's like fly-by-night companies improving retention by selling at a loss, or running up user count with expensive perks for each new client. Those numbers are important as a reflection of business health, not a cause of it.
- ConfuciusSay02 10y agoThanks to fMRI and other brain scanning technologies, we now know that when we learn, our brains physically change. This fact is the basis for the claims of the "brain training" industry. The reality is that our brains are constantly changing. I could memorize a thousand fart jokes and my brain would have changed. Does that make me more intelligent? I think the "brain training" apps are only really good for older or other people who are at risk of dementia, or other cognitive diseases, and even then I'm pretty sure the science is out on most of that.
- faragon 10y agoShould be similar for IQ tests, I guess. So if new generations have better "IQ", some part of it could come just because of being more prepared/trained for those kind of tests.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoYup. Just like being great at Chess just makes someone great at Chess, and not much more. I taught my kids to play Chess early on. My first-born was beating 12 year old's when he was 6. They had to move him up the age groupings. I insisted they keep moving him up until he lost. Knowing how to deal with losing is very important. In all cases I pulled my kids from competitive Chess after a few seasons and a good balance between winning and losing. Past a certain point, getting better at Chess requires becoming a human database engine. That, for me, is when Chess demonstrates this idea that getting better at some of these games teaches nothing useful. BTW, I apply this to the type of programming puzzles typically used in interviews. It's pure nonsense that says nothing about how creative someone can be about solving new problems. Anyone can become a human database with enough effort. True creative intelligence is a quite a different matter.
- CoryG89 10y agoI would disagree. I am not much into Chess, but I used to play a fair amount and consider myself fairly good. At the very least, playing a sufficient amount of Chess against sufficiently skilled opponents will teach you things that are easily generalizable. Just one example, thinking strategically over the long term (several moves ahead), rather than short term (only thinking about your next move).
- rebootthesystem 10y agoNo, I think we agree. The level of proficiency you are describing can be attained by a kid in six months to a year. Going past that to become a human chess database is a waste of time. Example: I taught my kids to ask themselves "Is there a better move?" before making a move. I also taught them to apply that idea to non-chess situations. And they do.
- mridulmalpani 10y agoI knew it :)
- projektir 10y agoMaybe those brain training exercises are just not very good?
- sebringj 10y agoI've always found that if I want to get good at some endeavor, partaking in that endeavor does the trick. I wonder how much time and brain power is wasted on preparing. Maybe that's why the really good ones leave school early.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zump 10y agoWell, what about spaced repitition?
- thr0waway1239 10y agoA friend of mine believes that the reason she didn't do her best in academics is because the "subject was presented in a very boring way". I tried to persuade her that overcoming that feeling of boredom is already a good sign that you are learning the material well - granted, it is really hard to read poorly written stuff, but academic material isn't exactly a heart pounding thrill ride and it is quite a task to make it interesting, particularly as the material gets more advanced. But you know that you can rarely change people's views on such abstract things. I once mentioned a plan to develop a little learning app (based on spaced repetition) for her kids and asked her if she felt it was something worth paying for. She pointed out this new app called Lumosity and asked me "Why don't you make something like this? It is very interesting, and kids will actually want to use it." I sort of gave up at that point because I didn't quite believe that it was all that effective. After a little while, the topic of this article started floating around the internet and last I heard, my friend had stopped using Lumosity. On a more cheery note, I am surprised to find no one mentioned the book "Make it stick" by Peter Brown et. al. which would probably be a hard pill to swallow for the Lumosity fans. Someone should find a way to "appify" the principles in the book. It would be one seriously boring app, but very effective. :-)
- svjsdjfnskj 10y agoIf you really want to increase you intelligence just get a good night's sleep, eat well and go outside and walk
- kefka_p 10y agoBut then ... is life much more than a brain training exercise?
- Vernetit 10y agoI have schizophrenia and I create a program that combines mnemotechnics with 3d n-back and facial expression memory system to understand. http://vernetit.blogspot.com.ar/2016/10/eo-and-peo-memory-system-memorize-with.html http://vernetit.blogspot.com.ar/2016/10/eo-and-peo-memory-sy... with 15 minutes of training my mood changes and i understand the sitcom tv series emotions and the people around me intentions and emotions. I experiment also more willingness to do things. Here the program link http://competicionmental.appspot.com/tts3dnback http://competicionmental.appspot.com/tts3dnback Sorry my poor English. I am from Argentina.
- maheshs 10y agoI think this proves that If we practice anything we will make the improvement.