5 ms·
Looks like a pr stunt. But, here is another point of view (perhaps it can help, i'd love to see html 5 support improve on iOS). Internet Access is a "human ri
by NicoJuicy 10y ago
Looks like a pr stunt.
But, here is another point of view (perhaps it can help, i'd love to see html 5 support improve on iOS).
Internet Access is a "human right" and according to the United Nations ( https://www.article19.org/data/files/Internet_Statement_Adopted.pdf https://www.article19.org/data/files/Internet_Statement_Adop... ) , they condemn countries that intentionally take away or disrupt its citizens’ internet access.
Perhaps by not allowing "basic internet access" ( html 5 is part of the web), Apple is a distrupter of a basic human right.
The platform, where we could least of all platforms, use our basic human right to browse the web is iOS. So Apple is, in it's own way, a company that blocks a basic human right. And the block it because of own financial gain ( using the app store instead of the browser earns them money)
- kbart 10y agoI really doubt you could pass HTML5 compatibility as a "basic internet access".
- NicoJuicy 10y agoHTML 5 IS part of the web, so why shouldn't it? By not having several html 5 functions, you actually disallow access/usage to certain websites.
- madeofpalk 10y agoLets be honest here, are you saying that a web-based real-time-communications API is a basic human right? > Apple has no reason to "not" include it, except financial gain. The reason they have not to include it is that they have different priorities than browser vendors who want to jam mobile browsers full of every unripe API under the sun (like those that dangerously leak user's real connection info even when behind a VPN).
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI'm saying that yes, webrtc is part of the HTML 5 web and so should be a basic human right. I'm not saying that it is though.
- madeofpalk 10y agoExcept when WebRTC actually isnt a part of HTML5 (yet), it's only a draft specification.
- kbart 10y agoApple doesn't provide Internet access -- ISPs do. Nobody forces you to choose Apple's products, there are plenty of others to choose from.
- Esau 10y agoThis is the answer. If you have a problem with the product, don't buy it.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoFor basic internet access to the general public you need: - broadband - a browser Broadband is by ISP's and a browser is in this case by Apple. And yeah, i don't buy Apple ( obviously). "Add to homescreen" is probably my most used functionality :p .
- dogma1138 10y agoYou are confusing the internet with the World Wide Web, Apple does not support Flash do you want to claim that a flash plugin is a human rights issue? Because I can guarantee that the amount of content you cannot access due to lack of flash is orders of magnitude greater than what you cannot access due to lackluster HTML5 support. In fact I can't think of any HTML5 content which you would not be able to view, it might not be formatted properly but it will be accessible.
- efdee 10y agoCalling HTML5 a basic human right erodes the concept of basic human rights. Please don't do it.
- briandear 10y agoCould you argue that developers using HTML 5 are violating human rights because not every browser fully supports it? Developers are fully aware that not every feature is available on every browser -- yet they willingly use those technologies anyway. It's clear we should drag developers in front of a UN Tribunal to account for their willingness to deny the world basic human rights. This has gotten beyond absurd. I can't remember when I voted to make HTML 5 a human right. I can think of a lot more important things that might ought to be addressed (and enforced) first.
- cowsandmilk 10y agoobviously the standards process moves slower than innovation on web technologies, but many of the things that iOS doesn't support are not yet standards. E.g. WebRtc, which Nexedi's link shows had an update to the draft in September, so clearly it is not yet stabilized. The legal basis for requiring compatibility seems much thinner for complying with working drafts (or a working group note, edited August 31, September 7, and September 15, in the case of the webm link). I mean, what level of compatibility should you have with a document that says: > Implementors who are not taking part in the discussions are likely to find the specification changing out from under them in incompatible ways.
- lucozade 10y agoCurrently in the UK there is some controversy about human rights legislation and it being used inappropriately. I think human rights legislation is fundamental. As such I really, really hope no-one ever uses it for something like this, even worse to win a case. It demeans it to use it to save someone having to write a bit extra code to have their commercial application sell better in China.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI understand your point of view and you are probably right. But to my opinion, everyone here knows Apple is blocking HTML 5 somewhat and there is almost nothing we can do about it. PS. General public/buyers don't know and i already changed from iOS, because "add to homescreen" doesn't work as well as on Android
- kbart 10y ago"Apple is blocking HTML 5 somewhat and there is almost nothing we can do about it." Sure we can! Vote with your wallet and don't buy Apple's products. Or at least write a complaint to one of their support centers..
- Svenskunganka 10y agoThe problem is that this approach is perfectly fine when it comes to us programmers or more technical people, but for "normal" users this approach won't work, simply because they don't know the possibilities an up-to-standards iOS Safari would bring. There's a saying; "What you don't know can't hurt you", and that can be applied for these users - whom make up the majority of iOS device users - since they don't know what they're missing out on. While you and me on the other hand knows what we're missing out on, both as programmers and users, we at least have the chance to vote with our wallets. I do, perhaps even you do, but as you can clearly see it's still not enough to even make a dent in Apple iOS device sales.
- paulcole 10y ago
- st3fan 10y agoThere is not a single browser that implements 100% of all HTML standards out there. Lets sue them all for violating human rights. The browser landscape is complicated. Firefox is ahead in some ways, behind in others. WebKit has fantastic support for some things that Edge does not do. Chrome lacks some things that Firefox does. Does any browser lack "basic internet access"? Nope. They all provide a solid foundation that lets everyone use the web. Are some experimental standards missing? Sure. It's complicated.
- briandear 10y agoHTML 5 as a human right? How about JavaScript? This argument is just absurd. Apple isn't denying anyone access to the web. Could we argue that a company forcing IE 6 on employees is violating human rights?
- smetsjp 10y agoWe were suggested for the lawsuit an approach quite similar to what you describe. However, it seemed less likely to succeed quickly.