11 ms·
I find it ironic that the EU goes after Google for allowing third party stores (Samsung, Amazon, Nvidia, etc) and sideloaded APKs and allows you to build your o
by DiabloD3 10y ago
I find it ironic that the EU goes after Google for allowing third party stores (Samsung, Amazon, Nvidia, etc) and sideloaded APKs and allows you to build your own APKs for free...
... but Apple just randomly removes apps that people have purchased from the Apple Store (thus stealing their money and their product, doing everything short of uninstalling it, but preventing reinstallation), and the EU stays silent?
This is some bullshit.
- krschultz 10y agoI simply don't understand this either. Sure Android has the larger market share by units, but Apple has a much higher share of revenue & profit in the market. Which is really the proper measure of market power?
- mwfunk 10y agoFor antitrust purposes, market share.
- dragonwriter 10y agoFor antitrust purpose, pricing power is, as I understand, the "gold standard"; various measures of market share (which isn't itself a single measure) are sometimes evidence which supports a conclusion about the likely existence of pricing power, especially when direct evidence one way or another on pricing power is hard to find.
- coldtea 10y ago>Which is really the proper measure of market power? It's not about market power by various metrics, it's about market penetration in numbers, period.
- cageface 10y agoApple apologists will pick whichever metric suits the current argument. Suing Google for running a far more open platform while Apple continues to exert as least as much if not more control on the direction of the market is just another case of misguided European regulatory overreach.
- mmanfrin 10y agoApple also forces developers to use their payment system which charges 30%. Yet Android is the problem.
- gjolund 10y agoIts called business.
- mmanfrin 10y agoAnd in the context of this conversation it's also anti-competitive.
- spaceribs 10y ago"it's called being smart"
- copperx 10y agoWrong.
- joshstrange 10y agoI don't think the parent comment was actually agreeing but instead of mocking Donald Trump's response to Hillary's comment about him not paying federal income tax. But I could be wrong.
- joatmon-snoo 10y agoWas going to say that then I saw this!
- sangnoir 10y agoI suspect the comment you replied to was also quoting Trump, specifically a moment during the first debate when he leaned into the mic and whispered "wrong" repeatedly to counter something Hillary had said. Surprisingly, I can't find the gif right now considering how rampant it was. Atttibuting 1-word quotations is a guessing game, I might as well be...wrong
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mrsteveman1 10y agoTypically when they remove something from the App Store, people who already downloaded or bought it can still download it again. In the past, even things that were blatantly against the TOS for the App Store were simply removed from sale, including emulators, proxy/tethering apps, etc. So if Apple really leaves Dash off of the Purchases tab (I can't find it here), it would be the first time I'm aware they've done this. Hopefully they'll work things out soon one way or another.
- eridius 10y agoBeing removed for fraudulent activity is one of the times where it makes sense for Apple to remove the download completely from the store, because you don't want the fraudulent activity to continue. Obviously it was a mistake in this case though. But I bet Apple's done this before, just not with any app that people actually gave a shit about.
- andy_boot 10y agoThe EU is a large multi country bureaucracy - they need time to consider things like this and I expect they have bigger problems to worry about. Basically don't expect an organisation that large to jump up the same day a solo developer gets banned even if it was unfair.
- DiabloD3 10y agoThis is not the first time, nor will it be the last time. Stories like these have been hitting the HN front page for years. When was the last time you saw a story about Google fucking an Android developer over? I sure as hell can't remember one.
- st3v3r 10y agoHead over to /r/androiddev sometime. You'll see constant wailing and gnashing of teeth from people because Google banned their account or sent them a warning over their app.
- hayksaakian 10y agoMarket share is the most relevant factor for monopoly regulations
- coldtea 10y ago>... but Apple just randomly removes apps that people have purchased from the Apple Store (thus stealing their money and their product, doing everything short of uninstalling it, but preventing reinstallation), and the EU stays silent? Because it's not a monopoly, and they can do whatever the damn they like while not one? How is that difficult to parse?
- nol13 10y agoWhile not a monopoly, there position is large enough that any serious software or service is forced to comply.
- jakub_g 10y agoCan you put some link regarding the Google case in EU?
- latj 10y agoNo one is going after Google for allowing third party stores. Google's trouble in Europe is about: 1. Not paying taxes 2. Using their dominance in Search to promote their other products and services while obscuring competitors 3. Using their dominance in mobile to promote their search and web browser 4. Not allowing third parties to use the Play Store which is the default and dominate store for android devices. Allowing third party stores is not just a great feature for third parties. Its also a good excuse for not letting them into the real store.
- DiabloD3 10y agoNot allowing third party stores in the Store is a security feature because they can install APKs that have not passed through Google's security scanner. Google does not prohibit you from installing third party stores. Also, how are they using their dominance for search and browsers to do something? I can install Firefox on Android, I cannot install Firefox on iOS. I can do "Hey, Cortana" if I install Cortana on my Android phone and do Bing searches, but not with iOS. I can install the Bing app and get a launcher widget to perform searches with, just like I can with the Nexus Launcher's integration, but not with iOS. I can change the launcher out entirely, I can't on iOS. I can replace the lockscreen, but not with iOS. And as for taxes, Google paid the taxes that was required of them by Ireland. The EU thinks that they can post-facto change the law to effect Irish companies. This is illegal and immoral. This is also what the founders of Google have complained about, that US companies can do this, and are forced to do this by their shareholders. They are being punished by the EU for not following the status quo and being made an example of. So, explain to me, again, how Apple is the bastion of user freedom? Android is a shit OS, but at least it allows me to run whatever I damned please.
- tptacek 10y agoYou're setting the bar in a weird place with "bastion of user freedom", which is not a claim I see anyone making.
- Tomte 10y agoNo, the EU commission believes that Ireland gave Google an illegal tax break, which is almost self-evidentiary. There was no post-facto change of the law. It is simply very normal for illegal acts to be discovered after they were perpetrated. Anything else would border on precognition.
- colechristensen 10y agoThere's some logic too it. On one hand you have outright banning competition. On the other hand you have allowing but discriminating against competition. You can argue that outright banning isn't as bad as creating a marketplace and then punishing participants that aren't you. The outright banning is wrong too, but it's a really complex issue that doesn't necessarily have a clear correct path.
- izacus 10y agoThing is that laws haven't really followed the state of the market. You hear the excuse commonly here - "They don't have a monopoly so it's ok!". It's not and it's damaging the basic way how free markets do and should function - essentially the integrated, DRMed, lockeddown systems prevent choice which is the basic driving force of market innovation. Right now we're in a state where a few companies (mostly Apple, Amazon, Google) pretty much funnel and lock you into a narrow choice of products and then lock them down in a way to basically make choosing a product that helps you the most as hard as possible. Which means they just made "voting with the wallet" infinitely harder - you can't choose a phone with headphone jack, because you're locked into iOS ecosystem which means that your choice of phone has resulted in your choice of communication platform (iMessage), house appliances (HouseKit), TV (AppleTV), source of media (iTunes), car (CarPlay and iPod integration) and others. If you want to exercise your choice as a consumer, you're essentially forced to give a lot of things to get a feature you want and that also hides consumer wishes to the corporations themselves. The state of electronics market is getting pretty dire, sometimes I'm starting to feel like we're back in 1985 on the eastern side of Iron Curtain with a single item of each type on the store shelf.
- redial 10y agoThey still sell the iPhone 6S and the SE.
- izacus 10y agoWell, I'm afraid you kinda missed my larger point due to a nitpick into an example. Please replace it with something else appropriate (physical keyboard? USB-C or microUSB port? whatever really) and argue about that :/
- heartbreak 10y agoHow about we just don't argue at all, because you're clearly misinformed if you think iTunes is the only way to get music on iOS. Or pretty much any of your other assertions.
- 10y ago
- st3v3r 10y ago"... but Apple just randomly removes apps that people have purchased from the Apple Store (thus stealing their money and their product, doing everything short of uninstalling it, but preventing reinstallation), and the EU stays silent?" That's never been true. If you bought it, you can still download it.