13 ms·
To end the affordable housing crisis, Washington needs to legalize Main Street
- pkulak 10y ago> Large new apartment buildings in the Shaw neighborhood in Washington have priced out longtime residents. Really, now? Or has more demand priced out longtime residents? EDIT: That said, the rest of the article is very good. My guess is, the author didn't caption that photo.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoLarge apartments buildings are more of a symptom than an actual problem. Large apartments buildings are very expensive to build per unit, so they are only worth building where housing is very expensive. If you were able to build six story buildings instead, which have a much lower cost per unit, there would at least be a chance of keeping up with the demand.
- jessaustin 10y agoHerbert Hoover! Did he do anything right?
- ch4s3 10y agoNo, not really. Unless you count being an example of what not to do.
- Hondor 10y agoRenewable green energy before it was cool.
- rjsw 10y agoTranslated a book [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_re_metallica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_re_metallica
- Ericson2314 10y agoHe meant well....
- Ericson2314 10y agoAlso between austerity and suburban hype---man talk about mistakes we won't stop repeating.
- Ericson2314 10y agoBetter than those teapot domers
- Aloha 10y agoAs president Hoover may have not been the most successful (largely the right person, but at the wrong time) president - but as a man over his 50 years in public life, he was arguably one of the most successful figures of his era - Even some of the New Deal policy was rooted in proposals Hoover made in 1931-32. He: Was a gifted and successful mining engineer (Worked overseas in Australia and China, and later for himself. Fed Europe during and after WWI (preventing a Famine in Russia - and elsewhere). Created the foundations for the modern system of Broadcasting Regulation. Created the foundation of common regulation of Motor Vehicles and Traffic Laws. Successfully ran a relief effort for the 1927 Mississippi Flood. Delivered the "Death Knell" to the Morgenthau Plan and arguably laid the foundations for the Marshall Plan. Led the effort to modernize and reorganize the federal government post WWII. Wrote over 40 books, on such varied topics as mining, game preservation, fishing, foreign policy and a well renown book on Woodrow Wilson.
- WalterBright 10y agoHoover is clearly the best ex-President we've ever had. Carter is probably second.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- maerF0x0 10y agoThis article more or less explains what I've been saying to people for years. Part of the reason cost of living is cheaper in other countries (developing/3rd world for example) is because most of the cheaper ways are illegal in our country. Repeal the laws and we can live inexpensively and similarly to other less developed nations.
- Animats 10y agoAmerica needs more slums! The suburbs of today must become the favelas of tomorrow!
- dalke 10y agomaerF0x0's comment includes allowing secondary suites, a practice which was once more common (think Fonzie living over the Cunningham's garage or Tim O'Hara and his 'Uncle' Martin in Lorelei Brown's garage apartment), but which, quoting from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_suite#Legal_considerations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_suite#Legal_consider... : > In many North American municipalities, secondary suites are illegal because they do not conform to the zoning or land use district the property is in, they have been developed without the proper permits, or they do not meet the local building code. However, some localities only prohibit the renting out of secondary suites, and allow occupation by a relative or guest, leading to the use of the term "mother-in-law" house or apartment. Local jurisdictions may have rules regarding allowing certain relatives to live there and rules about what, if any, rent may be charged. and from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garage_apartment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garage_apartment : > The idea of integrating garage apartments into urban planning is a key aspect of new urbanism, although many jurisdictions in the U.S. prohibit new construction of or occupancy of ADUs except for relatives. These, obviously, are not favelas.
- Mz 10y agoHomelessness is on the rise. There are a lot of people who would be better off in a favela than sleeping under a bridge or behind a dumpster. But, surely, America can find some happy medium where we build actually affordable housing that is decent as well. I see no reason why it has to be slum housing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcriddle4 10y agoParking requirements repeal? Ask the residents of Portland how that works. What happens is a large apartment goes in without parking and suddenly home owners nearby cannot park their cars anywhere and everyone is angry.
- davidw 10y agoThey can park their cars in their own driveways or land they own. Where's the problem?
- Tarrosion 10y agoWhere I live (Cambridge), many people rent an apartment that doesn't come with a parking spot. Instead these people pay the city for a street parking permit. Hypothetically the city ensures that the number of permits matches available supply, though prevention of illegal parking is difficult and sporadic. Anyway, these people rely on their vehicles for transportation to work or school, and they pay for a parking spot. If a huge influx of drivers arrived without corresponding parking supply increases, I'm not sure these folks would be able to reliably park near their homes or get to work. We can imagine solutions involving increasing the street permit price, etc., but fundamentally more drivers without more supply (road* and parking) is bad for current drivers. *insert warning about Braess paradox and induced demand.
- davidw 10y agoMaybe in that case they'd be willing to pay a bit more for a more guaranteed spot - like something they actually own or something they are sure of. In a free-market-ish system, perhaps people would build more parking at that point. Seems like an example of an "economic calculation problem": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- ghaff 10y agoCambridge has also historically been pretty hostile toward building parking garages. Parking permits were pretty cheap but garage parking was very limited and very expensive. So it's not really a free-market-ish system. Agree with the basic point which is essentially how things work in areas like Manhattan where people can't generally depend on inexpensive on-street parking.
- paulsutter 10y agoThe culprit finally revealed: > Ever since Herbert Hoover’s Commerce Department helped promote the spread of model zoning codes that physically separated people and their community institutions, the federal government has poured its energy and resources into encouraging the growth of widely dispersed single-family homes and large, centralized tower blocks. To this day, FHA standards for loans, which set the market for the entire private banking sector, prohibit any but the most minimal commercial property from being included in residential development. As a groundbreaking report by New York City’s Regional Plan Association found, these standards are “effectively disallowing most buildings with six stories or less.” And depending on the program, a building could have to reach to 17 stories before it is eligible for participation in the normal housing markets. Without the FHA’s blessing, projects are granted the “nonconforming” kiss of death unless their developers can persuade a local bank to write an entirely customized loan for them, one whose risk the bank would have to keep entirely on its own books.
- api 10y agoWhy have we done this? It seems to go back very far, at least to the 30s or so. The two leading explanations I've heard are: (1) It's a jobs program in the form of a subsidy for the construction and automotive industries, both of whom are huge employers. (2) It's to disperse the cities to make them less attractive bombing targets, especially for nuclear weapons. The latter seems less likely if it goes back to the 30s but more likely as an explanation for Cold War era efforts to disperse cities. Anyone have any other potential explanations?
- ghaff 10y agoThe US has a lot of land and not everyone likes to be squeezed into a dense city.
- davidw 10y agoOk, but the question is why did the government feel it was important enough to push one way instead of just letting things sort themselves out, as they've always done? I haven't read it yet, but this book might be insightful: http://amzn.to/2dQutwR http://amzn.to/2dQutwR ( Zoned in the USA: The Origins and Implications of American Land-Use Regulation ) Other recommendations would be welcome. I'm tremendously interested in this issue. Edit: I'll add this book, too: "Zoning Rules!: The Economics of Land Use Regulation" - http://amzn.to/2dHphdJ http://amzn.to/2dHphdJ - haven't read it yet but it looks quite informative.
- h4nkoslo 10y ago"Washington" evidently isn't the barrier, since there are many locales in which there is no problem constructing affordable housing (hell, Houston has no zoning whatsoever). Almost all of the problematic regulations are state or local.
- davidw 10y agoHis point is twofold: once you get past all the zoning and other crap, you still have this problem that you can't build a very traditional type of commercial/housing because getting a loan is difficult.
- pash 10y agoLocal regulations are a big problem, but so are federal ones. In particular, the mortgage market in America is hugely distorted by the implicit subsidies offered by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored enterprises that buy and securitize a large majority of all mortgage loans nationally. Crucially, loans qualify for purchase by Fannie and Freddie (and therefore have lower interest rates) only if they meet standards set by the Federal Housing Administration. These standards have always been hugely biased towards suburban single-family homes [0], and in some ways have become even more so recently. For example, Dodd-Frank amended the FHA rules to stipulate that at least half of the units in any new multi-family condo building must be sold before any buyers can qualify for an FHA-approved mortgage on any unit in the building. This rule alone has effectively killed the market for new-construction condo buildings in most American cities, since only luxury buildings in the hottest markets can expect to pre-sell half or more of their units to cash buyers or buyers who can get spec mortgages. 0. E.g., by specific practices such as "redlining", introduced by the National Housing Act of 1934, which created the FHA (see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining), but predominantly by lending standards which have always been far more lenient for new single-family homes than for any other form of housing. Federal housing and transportation policy have also promoted suburban over urban development in myriad other ways; for a broad take, I recommend Kenneth Jackson's book Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States (1985), https://www.amazon.com/Crabgrass-Frontier-Suburbanization-United-States/dp/0195049837/ https://www.amazon.com/Crabgrass-Frontier-Suburbanization-Un....
- matt_wulfeck 10y ago> Inappropriate parking requirements, in particular, can raise the expected rent in a new development by as much as 50 percent Not only this, but why are houses required to keep a 30 foot lawn extending from the sidewalk to their home? Not only does it require considerable irrigation, but that land can be much better suited as increased living space.
- Animats 10y agoSpace for housing is a problem for only a few cities in the US - mostly New York, Washington, San Francisco, Portland, and Seattle, and Boston. The rest of the country has lots of space. Most of the Midwest, from west of Philadelphia to Kansas, is available. Those parts of the country are emptying out. The real problem is over-urbanization. People are moving to a few cities and draining out the rest of the country. The US population isn't increasing by much. The current rate of increase is 0.72%, and most of that is illegal immigration. The Internet was supposed to make it less important where you lived. What went wrong?
- saosebastiao 10y ago> The Internet was supposed to make it less important where you lived. What went wrong? The assumption was wrong. The world has organized around cities for millennia, and we're supposed to believe that a few advances in communication would change that? Since when has communication ever been so important? Until you can start teleporting physical goods and people stop caring about social needs, you won't see any change in urbanization. In fact, as resource scarcity increases, you'll likely see increases in urbanization.
- djsumdog 10y agoThe U.S. has terrible terrible rail systems. Lack of transport causes people to cluster, especially if you're disabled or need public transport. Jenna, Germany. 100k people. 4 trams. 3 intercity stations, one with an ICE line. Chattanooga, TN. 200k. The Chattanooga choo-choo from the song has no trains. Not even an AmTrak. Even talk of a train to Atlanta got everyone angry because they didn't want Atlanta commuters. I don't understand why Americans love their cars so much and hate rail.
- jschwartzi 10y agoIt's not that we like cars, it's just that we don't see why anyone else should benefit from our tax dollars. Rail seems to be a direct subsidy to the poor, even though it removes drivers from the roads. The rail projects where I live all seem to argue that it will make it more convenient for people to commute by public transit, which is the wrong argument. They should actually be arguing that it will remove other drivers from the road, making more room for people who don't have access.
- heisenbit 10y agoRecently read an article on Japan's housing market. While land is very precious over there living space (on a much smaller footprint than in the US of course) has remained affordable in Tokyo. The author pointed to the very high flexibility of land use in Japan allowing land rights and property to more flexibly serve demand from the commercial and residential sides. Over the past two decades from what I observed the office space available to software developers has decreased. Single offices and generous cubicles have been replaced by denser setups. Full time staff has been complemented by contracted staff often working in much more cramped conditions. Some have not a fixed desk and in part working from home offices not alone to save commute time. On the wholesale side margins are getting compressed as differentiates are missing and wholesale distributors like Amazon or directly distributed branded products are eating away their share and need a lot less prime real estate. There may be local markets where commercial real estate is tight. But secular trends are not looking good.