14 ms·
A kidney donor at 18 now regrets it
- greg7mdp 10y agoReading stories like this one, of generosity and honesty, makes it more bearable to live in a country that nominated Donald Trump for president.
- Zhenya 10y agoKeep politics out of discussions where not relevant.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoSure, blame an entire country. Edit: For all I know, the down-voters are credulous mopes who agree with you about blaming a country?
- bcherny 10y agoEvery med student I know went through a hypochondriasis phase. I wonder what Poulson will think in a few years, once he is out of school.
- delecti 10y agoThat's really what this article seems to boil down to. There doesn't seem to be any concrete data that should lead a completely objective donor to worry. The issue is that the author is not completely objective (nobody is).
- MrZongle2 10y agoTL,DR: author voluntarily donated a kidney to his stepfather's brother, against the advice of much of his family. Years later, the recipient is doing fine but the author (on his way to becoming a doctor), has reviewed the risks of being a donor and now is nervous about the whole thing.
- guelo 10y agoAlso, our worthless medical system doesn't do even the most basic data analysis to answer basic questions for common procedures and runs on half-truths and inertia.
- quadrature 10y agois that true ?, I thought there were stats on the outcomes of a lot of procedures.
- danso 10y agoAccording to the author: > The truth is, it is hard to get good numbers about what happens to donors. Hospitals are required to follow them for only two years post-donation, which does not catch such long-term complications as chronic kidney disease, cardiovascular issues or psychiatric issues. There is no national registry for kidney donors or other large-scale means of tracking long-term outcomes. That's surprising to me. Seems like it's one of the easier things to track. Though what is the status quo for health tracking beyond chronic diseases?
- zodPod 10y agoThis is an accurate summary. One thing I'd like to add is that there was nothing that the receiver did that provoked the regret. I read this assuming that something happened that caused it to not be worth it. While this is a good view on this situation, the article is basically a guy saying that his comfort and security to have a long life is more important than the other guy's life. So I assumed that the other guy had done something to bring this to light but that is not the case. The donator had simply researched more and decided he was nervous. To be clear: His interest in being secure in his life is fine and expected and I'm not judging him by what I said.
- MrZongle2 10y ago"...the article is basically a guy saying that his comfort and security to have a long life is more important than the other guy's life. So I assumed that the other guy had done something to bring this to light but that is not the case." This is how I went into the article as well. I expected seeing something about the recipient being a substance abuser or otherwise not careful with his gift, or some related drama. But it's really some light hypochondria and the recklessness of youth on display. I don't begrudge his regret; I don't know if I would have donated in the first place if I had been in his shoes. I'm just not entirely convinced of the overall worth of the article.
- kazinator 10y agoI suspect that this regret probably has quite a lot to do with the recipient being the stepfather's brother. I.e. not a blood relative; kind of distant.
- simcop2387 10y agoNot as distant as you'd think. I could actually see it being that the recipient is close enough you'll get information regularly about the person (i.e. small events that happen), rather than a complete stranger who you'd hear from only occasionally if at all. I also wonder how much pressure he was under to help because of the match, and how much he felt that he'd be disappointing the people around him if he didn't. I know as a kid that kind of pressure would have weighed on me heavily and has lead me to have some regrets about my past (though nothing nearly this large).
- Viper007Bond 10y agoSays who? I know many people personally who are closer to their step-families than they are to their blood families. Just because someone donated some of their DNA to produce you doesn't necessarily make them worthy of being family. Or hell, what about adopted children?
- danso 10y agoI admire the author's selflessness. At the same time, it seemed easier to be selfless as a teenager, probably for similar reasons for why it's easier to draft 18-year-olds than it is 28-year-olds. Given young persons willingness to sacrifice for the greater cause without realizing that life extends well past your 30s and 40s, I wonder if more shouldn't be done to let young donors think of the risks, so that their naïveté isn't something that the system takes advantage of. The author's right to ask for better data and tracking of donors. That said, his current worries are likely to be heavily informed by selection bias: > Five years after the surgery, when I was 23 and getting ready to go to medical school, I began working in a research lab that was looking at kidney donors who had gone on to develop kidney failure. For that research, I talked to more than 100 such donors. In some cases, the remaining kidneys failed; in others, the organ became injured or developed cancer. The more I learned, the more nervous I became about the logic of my decision at age 18 to donate. If you spend a lot of time talking only to donors where things have gone wrong, yeah, you'll be paranoid. Reminds me of being a cops reporter in which you strongly associate certain neighborhoods with shootings and murders because, professionally, those incidents are the only times you ever visit those neighborhoods.
- criley2 10y ago>At the same time, it seemed easier to be selfless as a teenager, probably for similar reasons for why it's easier to draft 18-year-olds than it is 28-year-olds. Given young persons willingness to sacrifice for the greater cause without realizing that life extends well past your 30s and 40s I totally agree, the biological basis of this is Pre-frontal Cortex development. "The [prefrontal cortex] isn't fully developed and won't be until the person is 25 years old or so." https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?ContentTypeID=1&ContentID=3051 https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?Con... "This brain region has been implicated in planning complex cognitive behavior, personality expression, decision making, and moderating social behaviour. The basic activity of this brain region is considered to be orchestration of thoughts and actions in accordance with internal goals." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefrontal_cortex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefrontal_cortex I can't understand any other context for drafting 18 year olds other than taking advantage of their youth and incomplete development, but avoiding Presentism and the comfort of Mutually Assured Destruction / Pax Americana, I can understand why when the cards are on the table and your entire society is at risk, why you must call all hands, young and old, into Total War a la WW1 or WW2. As far as donations go, that's got to be a morally gray area as well for all the reasons you mention.
- rcthompson 10y agoTo be fair, there's lots of other organs in your body that are already single points of failure. Regardless, there's probably a reason we evolved with two kidneys. My personal theory (i.e. I have no idea if there's any actual research on this hypothesis) is that before humans discovered cooking, agriculture, sanitation, etc., there were a lot more diseases and toxins and such in the food we ate, so the organs responsible for handling them were much more active than they are now. This is why you can get rid of your tonsils, appendix, a large fraction of your liver, and one of your kidneys and still be "fine". (To reiterate, though, I don't know how much research there is to support this theory.)
- maxerickson 10y agoKeep in mind that fish also have 2 kidneys and 1 liver. (humans have much else in common with fish: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chordate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chordate )
- JohnTHaller 10y agoThere are real risks in the actual donation, of course. And some lifelong things you need to worry about. It does affect treatment of other things. For example, if you happen to have a rotator cuff injury, you can't just take high doses of anti-inflammatory meds for a month. You have to do physical therapy and steroid injections. And, in our wonderful US healthcare system, you'll get near-zero aftercare beyond a few months worth of checkups. You'll have to advocate for yourself for later extra checks on your remaining kidney's health and often have to foot the bill yourself because your overpriced insurance will refuse to pay for it. Source: Am a kidney donor living in the US that has experienced both of the above and several similar issues
- leodeid 10y agoCan you explain the part about injury recovery? Are you not allowed to take the medications because it would stress your kidney too much? (Also, do you mean NSAID drugs, or are there issues with pretty much all anti inflammatories?) What are some of the things that you find yourself needing to advocate for yourself about? Isn't long term care just annual creatinine level tests (which looks like a simple blood draw)?
- snake117 10y agoMy physiology professor told our class to never donate, especially at our age group (18-23). His presentation included some of the complications listed in the article. However, his reasoning was straightforward: Assuming a long lifespan, if you are in the position with your only kidney failing, you're screwed. He was speaking generally of course. Not every situation has an easy solution and Poulson took a noble route, albeit when he was young and not fully informed. I have heard med students suffering from slight paranoia because they learn all kinds of diseases and their symptoms (as another comment has stated). I wish all the best to Poulson.
- labster 10y agoAssuming a long lifespan, if you are in the position with your only heart failing, you're screwed.
- buckbova 10y agoAnd the article mentioned increased risk of cardiovascular disease. >Another study that same year raised the possibility that they may face a heightened risk of dying of cardiovascular disease ... So there you go.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoSo don't donate that, either.
- clifanatic 10y ago> if you are in the position with your only kidney failing, you're screwed Well... unless you can find a kidney donor, that is...
- wbl 10y agoKidneys tend to not fail independently. Most failures are the result of systemic causes.
- SmokyBorbon 10y ago
- avar 10y agoThere's some down-thread armchair speculation about why humans have two kidneys. I found it interesting, but instead of conniving my own theory did some searching. The gist of it is that nobody seems to know, but the most simple explanation is that lateral symmetry is common in general because it's more efficiently encoded in the DNA. The organs & structures that don't come in twos are the odd exceptions, not the other way around. 1. https://www.quora.com/Why-is-it-that-humans-(and-many-animals)-have-two-kidneys-but-only-one-liver https://www.quora.com/Why-is-it-that-humans-(and-many-animal... 2. https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/po4v6/why_did_we_evolve_two_kidneys/ https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/po4v6/why_did_w...
- AstralStorm 10y agoMost probably the kidneys are vital enough yet inexpensive enough to allow a pair to exist. You do not get two hearts because that muscle is very expensive. Also because a vascular injury to a major artery will also end your life. Similar reason for the liver - too expensive and also easy to regenerate from a partial injury. The brain is well protected and partly redundant. Lungs are fully redundant and protected by the ribcage. Spleen is not critical enough, stomach can heal. The pancreas is probably an odd one.
- dexterdog 10y agoThis may be a dumb question, but why are previous kidney donors not given a free pass to the top of the recipient list if they have a problem with their remaining kidney?
- sokoloff 10y agoCame here to post exactly that question/suggestion. I could imagine that it might also be "and can put one blood relative or immediate family member into a high-priority category" to encourage donation/control for the "yeah, but I'm saving mine in case my kid needs one" objection.
- brianjolney 10y agoSeems like the way to solve this, without opening up market pricing for them. In theory, this would create a marketplace where supply outstrips demand.
- pkaye 10y agoThey do get priority. But there is still issue of compatibility. And one still needs to take a lifetime of medicines. I myself found my kidneys were failing recently and did a lot of research.
- gscott 10y ago..... or get your kidney back when the person you donated it to dies
- dexterdog 10y agoNot a doctor, but I'm guessing that it's hard to re-transplant one and you have to get the person to die the right way such that any donation is even possible.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- treehau5 10y agoReading these comments makes me believe the HN crowd no longer believes in human exceptionalism, something I believe fueled our predecessors into building mile long structures over bodies of water, landing on the moon, striving to colonize mars, and other giant leaps of technology. Makes me sad reading these comments.
- 51Cards 10y agoHonest question. It sounds like the recipient was older so if something were to happen to them (passing from old age, etc) would it be possible to move the kidney back? After all it would be a perfect match... still the same age as the donor, and as long as it hasn't been compromised in any way should still function well.
- smcnally 10y agoThe organ has had x years in a foreign environment. The new host / donee has taken an ongoing regimen of anti-rejection drugs for the duration to prevent that foreign environment from being overly hostile. The organ is not particularly suitable for re-transplantation even back to the original host.
- pdq 10y agoThis is going to rub a lot of people the wrong way as unethical, but the best way to incentivize organ donation is if the donors get paid a market price for the organ. The donor is giving up a valuable piece of their body, taking time and large medical risks in surgery, and likely reduced life expectancy. If you walk through the current process, everyone in the donation gets paid -- doctors, nurses, hospital, pharma -- except the donor. There are a number of advantages of donors getting paid: 1. The supply market would increase dramatically. Thus many more people receiving organs who would have otherwise died waiting. 2. Heirs to people who have died young, with healthy organs could get paid for donating their organs. 3. Black markets would be dramatically reduced, since people in desperate need of an organ could pay in the open, rather than secretly paying a donor. 4. People without money can legally open a Kickstarter to raise funds for an organ donation. Note Iran has partially done this, and the results have been very positive [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1819484/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1819484/
- timecube 10y agoA big issue with allowing organ markets is that impoverished people can practically be forced to sell their organs.
- chrisseaton 10y agoYes, often welfare systems won't give you aid if you have assets such as cash or a home. Would your organs be considered assets?
- bcherny 10y agoI'm not sure if it was ever verified, but reminds me of this story from 2005 - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/germany/1482371/If-you-dont-take-a-job-as-a-prostitute-we-can-stop-your-benefits.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/germany/148...
- tremon 10y ago
- london888 10y agoHas the stepfather's brother with the new kidney not made the donor feel how valuable his gesture was?
- ReallyAnonymous 10y agoAs a surgeon who is 48, I will say that on my transplant rotation ( I am not a transplant surgeon ) the theory of the safety of donation was in the Vietnam War era data that said that soldiers who lost a kidney from injury were at no increased risk of renal failure as the general public given similar risk factors. I know that if you have hypertension or diabetes, it is near impossible to donate a kidney as they have a high propensity to develop renal failure. I have not researched the literature about the war data, but that is what I was told.
- laxatives 10y agoThat isn't really a fair comparison. There's a selection bias among kidney donors (they must pass some minimal health requirements) and are at a lower risk than the general population.
- chetanahuja 10y agoI wish they had included another option in the survey. What if you were given a lifetime of free health insurance in lieu of cash? This way, some organization (the govt, AMA, some independent trust) could create a large, insurable pool of all kidney donors. This scheme would work around the problem of moral hazard in both directions. On the Donor side, donors get a substantial financial reward but not in terms of cash. And if it's true that most kidney donors will live healthy lives on par with the general population, then this pool is no riskier to insure than any large company. In fact it might be a lower risk pool than the general population because the process of selecting the donor candidate involves intensive medical checks. Basically kidney donors are likely to be a healthier sample of the general population than random selection. On the recipient/govt side, you get better outcomes for a larger number of kidney patients (and thus save lots of money on very expensive Dialysis costs). Financially, recipients (or their insurance providers) can be charged enough to cover the insurance premiums on the pool of donors without encouraging a black-market of organ donations. It's most likely a win for Insurance companies too since they have to foot a large part of the dialysis bill too.
- jimmywanger 10y agoWait, he's complaining cause there's a higher theoretical risk, even though he's experienced exactly zero consequences? What is he writing about? "Sometimes something you do has potential future consequences." Sounds like life.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoAt least he didn't waste his kidney on a fat! He seemed to make it clear that this person was slender and otherwise healthy. Fats certainly shouldn't get kidneys.
- grimmdude 10y agoHe's probably going to regret writing this article in ten years.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoWell, this article did a good job in scaring me off of donating any organs whatsoever. I currently disallow donating organs upon my death, because I think if I'm a known donor, the doctors might not try as hard to revive me. And now after this, I'm pretty certain I won't take any tests to determine if I'm compatible with anyone needing a kidney.
- cpncrunch 10y agoYou might change your mind if a first-degree relative has ESRD. (Or perhaps not).
- chimprich 10y ago> I currently disallow donating organs upon my death, because I think if I'm a known donor, the doctors might not try as hard to revive me. Sorry, but that really is such a nonsensical argument I'm not sure if you're serious. Why would a doctor not want to revive you? So another doctor somewhere could save a patient? Why would that be preferable to saving your life there and then? Why would the doctor risk their own career for that? I presume that if you're refusing to donate any organs after your death, you'd refuse one if you ever needed one (unless you're a huge hypocrite). In which case, surely scenario A is far less likely than scenario B?
- smcnally 10y agoKidneys are amazing -- filtering blood, removing excess liquid, regulating blood pressure. And they're redundant! My brother lost one kidney in an accident that also left him paralyzed and with a slew of other problems. Recurring UTI and kidney infections took the other kidney a decade later. When he started on dialysis around 1988, the machine was the size of an Asteroids arcade game. It did half the job of a fist-sized kidney maybe half as well. A few years later, we had a home machine a bit smaller than Asteroids. In 1994, I gave him one of mine (kidneys, not arcade games). The doctors said if the transplant lasted 10 years, we should be delighted, especially with all his post-accident reconfigured internals. My brother's quality-of-life improved immediately — at least he didn't have to be hooked up to a machine and stationary for several hours at a time. My quality of life was essentially unchanged. The transplant worked well for 22 years. Recurring infections -- kidney, liver, bedsores, staph/mercer -- eventually took their toll. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have done it for "my stepfather's brother" or the like, but I'm glad I did what I could for my brother when I did. I was 23 at the time and now 46. I drink plenty of liquids. My GP's a nephrologist and I have kidney function tests as part of my annual bloodwork. Maybe I'll be pissed if shit goes wrong as I age. With hope I'm still glad I did what I could when I did. And, with hope, the redundancy remains very good.
- Qantourisc 10y agoHmmm in hindsight this is logical, you got 2 kidneys of a certain size. Expected do 1 job together. And since biology doesn't like wastefulness (as it cost energy, room, and nutrients to maintain) the kidneys are dimensioned to a safe/good size. Now when you remove 1, the other one has to do twice the job. Possibly severely dipping under the safe size. In short, redundancy != excess
- seesomesense 10y ago" All-cause mortality, cardiovascular mortality, and end-stage renal disease (ESRD) was identified in 1901 individuals who donated a kidney during 1963 through 2007 with a median follow-up of 15.1 years. A control group of 32,621 potentially eligible kidney donors was selected, with a median follow-up of 24.9 years. Hazard ratio for all-cause death was significantly increased to 1.30 (95% confidence interval 1.11-1.52) for donors compared with controls. There was a significant corresponding increase in cardiovascular death to 1.40 (1.03-1.91), while the risk of ESRD was greatly and significantly increased to 11.38 (4.37-29.6). The overall incidence of ESRD among donors was 302 cases per million and might have been influenced by hereditary factors. Immunological renal disease was the cause of ESRD in the donors. Thus, kidney donors are at increased long-term risk for ESRD, cardiovascular, and all-cause mortality compared with a control group of non-donors who would have been eligible for donation." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24284516 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24284516
- jlebrech 10y agoI guess he's going to be careful with his diet and not drink.