5 ms·
> Copyright trolling has history in Germany, where lawyers have leveraged the 'formal system of notice' for cease and desist letters (abmahnungen) into a shaked
by dahart 10y ago
> Copyright trolling has history in Germany, where lawyers have leveraged the 'formal system of notice' for cease and desist letters (abmahnungen) into a shakedown system against millions for alleged copyright infringement online.
Is this true... millions? With only 80 million people in Germany, it seems like if copyright trolls were shaking down millions of people, it would more or less involve every single organization and household in the entire country.
- germanier 10y agoI'm not sure where that number comes from. Every year around a hundred thousand of such letters get sent (with a downward trend and half of that from a single law firm). But I'd say the vast majority of internet users in Germany is aware of their existence. Edit: After looking up some more data, at the peak in 2010 there were estimated around 500k of those letters and the million bar was likely crossed.
- dahart 10y agoCrazy!! So basically it does affect every person in the country. Is the data publicly available?
- DominikR 10y agoNo, not even close to everybody. But most people do know someone who was hit by this.
- germanier 10y agoThese are estimates made by looking at data published by both the law firms that specialize in sending out those letters and those that defend users against them. The latter ones are in a parasitic relationship and also profit from the whole thing. So take this with a grain of salt as both would likely overestimate.
- Udo 10y agoI have no problem believing it's millions. I know many people who got one, some deserved, some not. Last year my mom got one. She died in 2012. It's also worth noting that these letters cost about 1000 Euros each, there is almost nothing you can do about them, and they require not the slightest bit of evidence that you actually did anything wrong.
- dahart 10y agoYikes, what a scam. Can you point me to any info in the history of this and what the German government is or is not doing about it?
- iamjeff 10y agoHere [1] is a fairly exhaustive examination of this scam...mind boggling..here is a sample "In cases involving peer-to-peer sharing of music files, the value of the claim was regularly set at €10,000 per file by the rights-holders...Recipients of Abmahnungen often pay the costs without consulting a lawyer, or negotiate a settlement themselves. There is a noticeable tendency to pay rather than challenge the claim..." and "the evidence collected about the infringement will only identify the IP...This IP address needs to be matched against the subscriber to whom it was allocated at the time of the infringement...by way of a judicial disclosure order...[in which] German courts are rather reluctant to engage in an assessment...[for instance] within 9 months in 2009, 2824 disclosure orders were sought in Cologne alone, each relating to several hundreds of IP addresses." [1]-The RedTube copyright infringement affair in Germany: shame on who? (http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13600869.2015.1012777 http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13600869.2015.10...)
- rorykoehler 10y agoThere is one thing you can do. Ignore them completely. It's been known to be a very effective strategy.
- DominikR 10y agoYes, it is absolutely correct. It happens so frequently that I actually know several friends of mine who had to pay for downloading a video or a music album. (about $800 to $1000 - but there are limits now on how much you can be charged for an illegal download - I believe it is 150€ or something like that) It's bad but on the other hand I also do understand copyright holders who see their product being used for free without receiving payment in return. It's a grey area in most countries because so many people (me including) do this that laws become basically unenforceable. It's not surprising that Germany is one of those countries where this can be enforced. One thing that these lawyers like to do is to target people downloading porn, because very few of them are going to fight back on that risking that it gets publicly known what kind of porn they are into.
- markdown 10y agoHow do they discover that your friends downloaded a particular file?
- DominikR 10y agoThey themselves seed an already existing torrent and then just log the IP's that connect to download. With these logs they approach the ISP's to give them names and addresses which the ISP's are forced to do. So it's easy to see how they automated the whole process, which is a precondition if you want to go after hundreds of thousands of file sharers.
- martinko 10y agoMany people that I know from Germany have been shaken down for thousands of euros, so I have no trouble believing this.