7 ms·
What about apple? Yes, they don't have the same market share but their product is completely closed and until recently all other browsers where crippled compare
by sschueller 10y ago
What about apple? Yes, they don't have the same market share but their product is completely closed and until recently all other browsers where crippled compared to the build in one.
All apps must come from the Apple App Store. No 3rd party allowed.
- muninn_ 10y ago> Yes they don't have the same market share Problem solved it would seem. Even so, as you mentioned you can get other browsers.
- kyrra 10y agoYou can only get wrappers on WebKit and it's JavaScript engine. No gecko, no blink.
- muninn_ 10y agobut you can get other browsers, as I pointed out: http://www.macworld.co.uk/feature/iosapps/best-iphone-web-browser-apps-2016-3621607/ http://www.macworld.co.uk/feature/iosapps/best-iphone-web-br...
- qassim 10y agoThose are all Safari underneath.
- rickhanlonii 10y agoAn under that they're all iOS
- Drakim 10y agoNo, they "aren't" iOS, iOS is the operating system that manages them. You clearly don't know how this tech work, and should avoid commenting as if you do.
- nullsocket 10y agoGet angry brah!
- rickhanlonii 10y agoEasy there, I was being hyperbolic. There's really no need to make assumptions about my technical capabilities from 6 words and ask me to stop commenting based on those assumptions. That character is unbecoming for this community.
- andy 10y agoApple should really consider supporting the use of external email clients when clicking on a mailto: link. Reminding me of a deceitful lawyer, they allowed you to remove default email client, however even if you have Gmail.app installed and tap on a mailto: link it displays a popup telling you to install Mail.app instead of allowing you to choose Gmail or another Email client. Same for http/https links. I prefer to use 1Pasword instead of Safari.
- muninn_ 10y agoYeah it would be nice of them to allow that. Personally I don't care since I would never use Gmail but I can understand how that would be frustrating.
- andy 10y agoWhat email service do you use? I think Google is secure and they have never deleted or altered an email of mine as far as I know.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI use Gmail but a common (and at the very least reasonable) complaint is that they must do at least some level of data collection to give personalized Gmail ads.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoWhat changed? I thought the other browsers still had to basically be Safari (webkit, the javascript engine, etc) underneath.
- sschueller 10y agoI thought they opened it up but maybe I am mistaken. I vaguely recall something about other browsers being slower than the built in one, maybe that was fixed?
- pcwalton 10y agoI think you're thinking of the fact that WKWebView allows you to use the JIT, whereas UIWebView didn't allow for that. There are still various ways in which third-party browsers are penalized, such as links from other applications being hardwired to open in Safari.
- melling 10y agoDo you think it might be because this has nothing to do with apps or installed browsers?
- jahewson 10y agoApple comes with Google Search as the default, and several other options. So it's a moot point.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoYou may note that Apple only put Google as the default search because Google paid them a billion dollars to do so. And Google's super mad Oracle told everyone, because it shatters the illusion that people use Google because it's better. People use Google because most people use the default, and Google pays to be the default. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-22/google-paid-apple-1-billion-to-keep-search-bar-on-iphone http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-22/google-pai...
- shagie 10y agoApple isn't forcing OEMs to include their bundled software. This reads very much like the EU vs. MS for the exact same reasons.
- AsyncAwait 10y agoBut isn't the deal that you get it for free if you include the software? i.e. there's an exchange of value there? I suspect the problem is that there's no "I'll pay you, but not include the software" option for Android, but couldn't it be applied to any FLOSS as in "there's no option to pay you, but not contribute back" in the case of the GPL or even "there's not an option to not buy a Mac with MacOS", or something like that? EDIT: If the problem is using Android's dominant position to bundle Google Search, then I get the similarities to the MS lawsuit, the difference being that people actually want to use it, which is why I think Google should be confident about including a "Bing Search" or "Google Search" option, as 99.99% of people would go with Google, since in Google's case, Search is actually a product people want to use when compared to the alternatives, whereas Explorer wasn't in the MS case. But couldn't this then also be extended to Chrome and Search on the desktop? i.e. Google used its dominant position in search to push Chrome, (try visiting google.com with Safari or Firefox, notice the top-right Chrome banner?) and once they got to a dominant position with Chrome, they used it to further the dominance of Search, by it being default in Chrome etc.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI don't think the Bing Search option would be sufficient to ward off anti-trust claims, unless you made Bing search the default or did something crazy like make phones flip a coin and then decide which search to default to.
- brianwawok 10y agoMicrosoft never made Google the default search on Windows. Just offered the option.
- 10y ago
- Analemma_ 10y ago> Yes, they don't have the same market share That's the answer, full stop. Like it or not, the rules are different for you when you have the majority of market share, and this has been true in both the EU and the US despite their different approaches to antitrust regulation.
- jmfayard 10y agoApple has a market share of 100% of the iOS platform.
- Analemma_ 10y agoWhich is like saying that Ford has 100% of the market share for Ford cars. Antitrust regulation cares about product categories, not brands.
- Steltek 10y agoBut the EU charges are about Google's tactics within the Google run Android market. Google isn't leveraging it's monopoly outside of it's own brand either. The argument hinges on Google not owning or operating Android. AOSP has been a dead dream for a while now due to carriers locking down phones and Google needing to circle the wagons.
- Esau 10y agoAndroid is bigger than Google. Other companies make Android devices.
- danieldk 10y agoGoogle can exert a large amount of control over device makers --- Android without Google Play Services and the Google Play Store is pretty useless. (Unless you have Amazon's scale and can clone all that.)
- nabla9 10y ago>Yes, they don't have the same market share but their product is completely closed There are no laws against closed products per se. Antitrust regulations apply only for products with dominant market share (Android has 87.6% market share 2016Q2 according to IDC).