7 ms·
Unmanned F-16s Declared IOC
- zrail 10y agoThis is nothing new. The USAF has had unmanned F-4 phantoms for decades that are used for target practice and live fire weapons testing. The F-4 fleet is being replaced with surplus F-16s.
- jevinskie 10y agoI thought the aside in the article about unmanned "missile trucks" controlled by a latest gen manned fighter was interesting.
- zrail 10y agoThis article is where those quotes come from: https://www.flightglobal.com/news/articles/pentagon-touts-loyal-wingman-for-combat-jets-423682/ https://www.flightglobal.com/news/articles/pentagon-touts-lo... The hard part is developing a strong enough AI to do what they want. Current uncrewed vehicles all have a remote human pilot. Air Force brass wants to do away with that bit. Maybe it's six years out but I would be extremely surprised.
- sandworm101 10y agoIt's part of a rarely-discussed issue with beyond-visual range (BVR) missiles. For all the hype about technology, they have a horrifically low kill rate against live and aware target. If you look at stats against maneuvering opponents actually beyond visual range, ones with the senors to detect the radar-guided missile approaching, the kill rate is on the order of 15%. Doing the math, the fancy new fighters don't have the missile capacity to confidently down any BVR target, hence the need for a "truck".
- dfsegoat 10y agoYou are right for sure. But they have never had a 4th gen (fly by wire / designed to be aerodynamically unstable;) fighter with this capability. In my (potentially uninformed) opinion, It is definitely a big milestone because it opens the door to 5th gen fighters becoming UCAVs - almost like making the GPS guided JDAM weapon out of a 1960s dumb bomb by "bolting on" the JDAM module as a cheap aftermarket kit.
- dogma1138 10y agoThat's one of the current proposals for the A-10, since there are plenty of people in the armed forces that want to keep it for CAS, the air force doesn't like it as much since it's not "sexy" but the marines, infantry, and armor troops that are saved by CAS love the old ugly thing.
- sandworm101 10y agoLikely A-10 replacement, imho. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion Strait-winged, turbofan, six wing hardpoints and an internal bay, extended loiter time, only $20mil+$3k/hour operating costs ... this thing has serious potential.
- dogma1138 10y agoMight as well go with an F-35 then, it can carry more stuff. The A-10 can't be replaced by effectively a trainer with a light ground attack option. The A-10 is a flying tank, it's main gun is very useful for CAS and it can carry a lot of armaments and more importantly take a lot of punishment. The A-10 is simply not sexy, the air force doesn't want it, it might not even want to provide CAS roles in general. The USAF offered the US army to take the A-10 fleet in house the Army doesn't want it since logistically it can't really support fixed wing aircraft at this point, maybe the marines would take it in. The A-10 isn't expensive, it's probably the most cost efficient aircraft the US has produced since WW2, it's simply not a sexy Gen 5 FBW doodad.
- gaius 10y agoMight as well go with an F-35 then, it can carry more stuff. But is too expensive to ever risk danger-close. Whereas A-10's have had mortars fired over them in certain circumstances...
- dogma1138 10y agoThe USAF is going to have plenty of F-35's to spare, and it it can carry standoff munitions for CAS, not unlike light attack aircraft which you aren't going to be placing into direct line also. The A-10 was designed to take a beating, it has redundancies on top of redundancies, and armored cabin and fuel tanks, you can blow half of it's tail and it will still land (tho an F-15 has landed with 1 wing ;)). Light attack/trainers are OK but they aren't in the same league.
- plan6 10y ago"Where Have All the Phantoms Gone?" (2008) is a good personal story about the QF-4's: http://www.airspacemag.com/military-aviation/where-have-all-the-phantoms-gone-96320627/?preview=_page%3D5&page=1 http://www.airspacemag.com/military-aviation/where-have-all-...
- codecamper 10y agoAre we expecting an alien invasion? (and by alien, I mean little green men)
- dfsegoat 10y agoSort of puts our defense spending and progress in perspective when the USAF takes a $21M 4th gen fighter - when most of the world's air forces still have 4th gen fighters in development, mind you - and basically uses it like the cheap clay target shooting skeet you can buy at Walmart.
- ptero 10y agoProbably used not for shooting at, but rather for detection, tracking and such. Being on par or a little better than upcoming adversary systems works best for this.
- zrail 10y agoAs I understand it most of these airframes aren't fit to fly with a crew anymore because they've aged out. Airframes that don't get into this program get scrapped.
- mitchty 10y agoIndeed, the F16 was originally designed for about 8 000 hours of service time. And most airframes appear to have lasted about 20 years. Once your aircraft gets to the point it will start to fail, why not use it as a few as a target?
- sandworm101 10y agoThey are shot at with missiles, but are rarely every 'shot down'. They can use fully capable missiles without warheads. A "kill" is getting the missile to a point that it would detonate, which likely means flying very close but not actually touching the target. You don't use manned craft, but you still expect the target to survive most encounters.
- davb 10y ago"Initial operating capability or Initial operational capability (IOC) is the state achieved when a capability is available in its minimum usefully deployable form. The term is often used in government or military procurement." Military MVP? [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Initial_operating_capability https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Initial_operating_capability
- nwrk 10y agoIOC, military minimum viable product :) upvoted
- s_q_b 10y agoIOC = Initial Operating Capability FOC = Full Operating Capability Most contracts have tranches of payment released with each phase: concept, IOC, FOC. IOC has also come to mean, "This works, but we aren't sure enough we got all the bugs." So... I suppose it's more like a military Beta.
- therobot24 10y agojust went through the ACQ training this week, IOC means the plane has passed operational testing (IOT&E). Meaning there should be very few, if any, bugs left. The Full Rate Production (FRP) decision milestone was already passed and the contract should already be awarded for production - within the lifecycle of the product we are now in the Operations and Support phase, meaning fielding. FOC just means all unit lots are fielded.
- s_q_b 10y agoThe transition from IOC to FOC is outlined as part of the DoD acquisition contract, but under statute it means, "We've got at least one unit with associated services being run by the customer at at least one location." That's not a very high bar. Today, the deployment of a weapons system involves a lot of integration with the existing information technology stack, for "network centric warfare" or whatever the new buzzword is for "using high speed data links for over-the-horizon kills." In addition to the systems integration, you're usually debugging the human processes such as training and maintenance throughout. That's where the bugs shake out in the transition from IOC->FOC.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoI kind of understand why they want to develop the capability, but also am dubious of its value for a plane designed around a human pilot. So, if the plane is going to do anything useful, it needs to get to its target intact and ready, and to be honest that's more about logistics and geography than human or not pilots. Maybe it can stay on-station longer but that sounds more like a duty roster benefit than a tactical advantage The real benefit of pilotless craft I assume will come from designing it to do things that would kill a human inside it - presumably speed, manoeuvres etc. But then that means rebuilding a whole aircraft with new wings and weapons that can withstand such strain. And is that actually a win? So, I am not sure where inammgoing with this except it feels that a lot of military spend is not tied to political aims or military benefit. Air craft carriers sit in that weird zone for me too (the UK is without one right now and I am dubious it's worth getting another)
- plan6 10y agoNote that QF-16's, not F-16's, are the unmanned/drone version of the F-16. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_F-16_Fighting_Falcon_variants#QF-16 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_F-16_Fighting... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_F-16_Fighting_Falcon#/media/File:QF-16.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_F-16_Fighting... PS- I'd be worried about these being controlled by an AI or hacked. MQ-9's are small and go 300 MPH, so, while they're deadly, I wasn't worried about them as much. F-16's can go 1,350 MPH and can be "well-armed". USAF just bought 30 more QF-16's bring the fleet to 106. Then "Air Force leaders are expected to buy a total of 120 QF-16 target drones through 2019. Optionally Air Force leaders are considering buying a total of 210 QF-16 through 2022. The fleet should last until 2025." http://www.militaryaerospace.com/articles/2016/03/qf-16-target-drones.html http://www.militaryaerospace.com/articles/2016/03/qf-16-targ...
- throwanem 10y agoThese are target drones, and unlikely to be armed with anything or operated near high-value infrastructure susceptible to the relatively minor impact damage of which a QF-16 might be capable.
- plan6 10y agoF-16's can carry nukes. And why would you have a small very expensive fleet of fast moving drones that can carry bombs? Targets/training only? Wouldn't that be wasteful? Wouldn't those be expensive to just send in for recon or shooting down a plane or even a bombing run that they could use other manned aircraft for? What would they be best suited for? "...the Pentagon is also modifying Turkey’s current fleet of F-16s to carry the bomb.": http://www.f-16.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=22037 http://www.f-16.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=22037 I'm not against the USAF trying to improve its defense. But, if a remote-controlled nuclear-armed jet were controlled by an AI, or by a terrorist, that would be a big problem. I understand that it's expensive to find and train good pilots, and it takes a long time. They are a limited resource. So, I can see why you'd want to replace them with drones- you save a lot of money, could expand the fleet more quickly and with less expense, eventually. But, that expense is a safeguard. It keeps really bad things from being able to happen. We shouldn't be making anything nuclear-capable more easily remotely-controllable. And if the US does it, others will. Even if the US were to be completely safe about it, other states might not be.
- coldcode 10y agoIt doesn't say how they are flown, is it remote pilots or some kind of AI? The latter would seem a scary concept at this point. Imagine it being hackable...
- protomyth 10y agohttp://www.boeing.com/defense/support/qf-16/index.page http://www.boeing.com/defense/support/qf-16/index.page http://www.boeing.com/features/2013/09/bds-qf16-09-23-13.page http://www.boeing.com/features/2013/09/bds-qf16-09-23-13.pag...
- eternalban 10y agoOT but F-16s look great even after all these years. Did it have a principle airframe designer?
- nopzor 10y agoHarry Hillaker. He was part of the 'fighter mafia'. It's fascinating history.
- eternalban 10y agoThanks! Will look him up.