6 ms·
You can't use future events (# ratings on IMDb 10 years later) to determine what someone "should" have done. IMDb ratings in general follow a four point scale
by minimaxir 10y ago
You can't use future events (# ratings on IMDb 10 years later) to determine what someone "should" have done.
IMDb ratings in general follow a four point scale (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FourPointScale http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FourPointScale) and are also skewed toward the internet-savvy demographic. It's a good example of a homogeneous population and the problems that can cause for data analysis.
- valleyer 10y agoDo you mean "homogeneous"? If not, can you explain why a heterogeneous population is problematic?
- inopinatus 10y agoYes, this hindsight data is confirming the already well-known: 1. firefly was a fan favourite, and 2. cult classics tend to be science-fiction or mysteries. It doesn't illustrate how the decision-making was flawed at the time, and therefore does little to inform decision-making in the future. Much more interesting (and true to the title used here) would be finding the regressions between subsequent cult-classic status and data points that either were, or might've been, or would be (had it been produced today) available at the time. (I'd expect that Netflix is correlating vastly more data points about audience behaviour than we know about. Short- and long-term responses to plot elements & twists, pacing strategies, classifications of dialogue and modes of storytelling, presence of archetypes &c &c, should all be on their agenda.)
- Frenchgeek 10y agoThere goes half of the Internet's content...
- caf 10y agoIt is worth pointing out that the title used here is nothing like the title used on the original article, which makes no claims about what anyone should have done.
- forgettableuser 10y agoYeah, the title is misleading. The article is trying to quantify the properties of a cancelled cult-classic and derive a ranking. It doesn't make claims about whether it was right or wrong. Such an article would also have to look at the costs to make each show, which it does not. (I expect Firefly to be more expensive than Veronica Mars due to things like special effects, and Joey expensive due to Matt LeBlanc.) And it would have to consider monetization models for each, where shows with ads have to concern themselves more about advertiser friendly demographics vs. premium pay shows have to find a demographic that is willing to pay directly for TV.
- spdustin 10y agoOh, but Joey was awful. No chemistry. Firefly had a period table's worth of chemistry.
- sctb 10y agoWe updated the submission title from “Fox really shouldn't have canceled Firefly”.
- curun1r 10y agoAlso, viewer preferences are irrelevant when it comes to whether a show should have been canceled or not. That would presume that television networks are in business to produce quality content rather than to make money. Advertiser preferences are far more relevant. One could argue that Advertisers usually want to advertise in shows that people like to watch, but there are nuances to that and IMDB ratings aren't broken down by demo, so we can't even know in hindsight. The reality is that Fox's decision was likely based on being able to charge more for ads on some new show, which makes it correct both at the time and in hindsight.
- thrill 10y agoI think that advertisers would want a show that has a dedicated audience that returns again and again to watch as it would be a much more valuable property than something that just has a million eyeballs where no one's really paying attention. The list of shows they had really surprised me in that I enjoyed two-thirds of them myself.
- Delameko 10y agoNot to mention that Firefly's cancellation has posthumously added to its notoriety. Nearly every Firefly mention is in relation to its cancellation. Would it be as popular if it hadn't been cancelled? I really like Firefly, but the cancellation meant they didn't have the opportunity to fuck it up. Every other Whedon series has had poor seasons.
- RangerScience 10y agoI suspect that any boost gained by early cancellation would also have been gained by more episodes, and time for word of mouth to popularize it... unless Fox pulled more slow death dickery. I can't really speak to Buffy and Angel, but with regards to Firefly and Dollhouse... The indication is that Whedon wouldn't so much fuck it up, but requirements by Fox would force him to fuck it up. Compare "Train Job" to the original first episode of Firefly. Compare early episodes of Dollhouse to later ones, particularly the encore episode.
- bostik 10y agoDollhouse could have been really good. The idea of using the Big Red Reset Button as a continuous plot element, and telling the arc story through seepage across resets was a brilliant way of giving the finger to almost every other series. And it turned into a young adults' barbie show.
- jandrese 10y agoDollhouse was a misfire IMHO. I watched both seasons on Netflix and it never really found a groove. I was really annoyed that they more or less sidestepped the obvious ethical and moral issues and instead ended the show with outright supervilliany. It was just so dumb by the end that I felt kind of embarrassed to keep watching.
- pmiller2 10y agoThat's what happens when the network forces you to cram 5 years worth of story into 1 year. :/
- maxerickson 10y agoThe article doesn't go out on that limb and try to say what anyone should have done. Firefly had decent ratings when it first aired, so a lot of people were really confused that they canceled it. Those people apparently failed to understand television as a business, as in addition to those decent ratings, it was also expensive to produce, far more expensive than was justified by the decent viewership it was getting (there's a lot of shows now spending millions of dollars per episode on big name stars, but they have a lot more viewers than Firefly was getting...).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]