15 ms·
Now it’s exploding Samsung washing machines
- asimuvPR 10y agoThis seems like an odd case of defective parts leading to an early failure. I had a GE washing machine fail due to a defective pump (located under the drum and driven by the motor). There was no evidence of abnormal NHV and it is placed on level ground. The interesting thing was that the replacement pump (which cost me like $25 and took an hour to replace) was more robust. It has lasted twice as much as the original part.
- williamscales 10y ago> Some washing machines, the suit alleges, vibrate violently under heavy loads, causing the tub to “become unfastened, resulting in a dramatic centrifugal explosion that destroys the machine and nearby property.” Any washing machine, if not level and if overloaded, will shake violently. The picture in the article showed a very small, seemingly fragile washing machine. I imagine one must take extra care to not overload such a machine. In fact, I know that these machines do have warnings to not overload them. What more could reasonably be expected of Samsung?
- dr1337 10y agoWell that's just bad hazards risk analysis and engineering. It goes to show that Samsung didn't account for the possibility of the explosions bit or even worse, knowingly ignored the risk of the explosions without putting in some sort of safety mechanism to halt the progression of risk. Safety can be easily explained by the Swiss cheese model. In order for a catastrophic safety incident to occur, usually you need a series of events to align one after another like having the holes of several Swiss cheese layers match up before you can go straight through.
- Spivak 10y ago> In fact, I know that these machines do have warnings to not overload them. What more could reasonably be expected of Samsung? Standard IANAL. Unfortunately companies can't always offload all their liability to the customer in this manner. We will see with the result of this lawsuit whether this is such a case. They're likely going to argue that a reasonable person who buys a washing machine expects that it will continue to operate safely with any amount or configuration of clothing so long as the it fits in the drum and the machine isn't modified. Sure, if you 'overfill'[1] the machine one might expect the quality of the wash to degrade, but not that the machine will become dangerous. From a practical standpoint, it's perfectly possible to create a washing machine that can handle any amount and configuration of clothing simply by making a tumbler that strong enough to handle many times the weight of clothes. Or the machine could simply refuse to operate if it detects that it's over weight or off-balance. So Samsung won't get very far if they try to argue that it's not possible to manufacture such a machine and that their customers have no choice but to take precautions. But undoubtedly they will argue that it's cost prohibitive and that their customers are responsible for taking those precautions in exchange for the simpler and cheaper design. [1] I use scare quotes because for sure they will call into question Samsung's use and meaning of the term.
- ptaipale 10y agoI think it's not "offloading their liability to the customer", if company says that the washing machine can take 4 kg and the customer then loads it with 7 kg. It is perfectly reasonable to assume that if you do this, the machine will not be able to maintain its balance. (Seen that happen and customer complain, in no way specific to Samsung.)
- icebraining 10y agoNo, I don't think it's reasonable that a modern washing machine will implode due to overloading. As others have pointed out, this is a solved problem, and I would expect Samsung to have built standard safeguards.
- noja 10y agoIt's perfectly reasonable to expect the washing machine to not start if the load is too high.
- reacweb 10y agoIt's perfectly reasonable to expect the washing machine to have bad performance if the load is too high, but explosion is beyond acceptable.
- SmellyGeekBoy 10y agoI'm not sure why you're being downvoted. All it takes is a simple weight sensor, couple your suggestion with an "overweight" LED to give the user some feedback and this becomes a non-issue.
- gbog 10y agoExcept if your weight sensor if the first thing that breaks when the machine gets old. I think all this is completely over the head. Say what maybe 3 machines exploded? That's far below the "noise" you have in every thing, it is statistically irrelevant. Also, side question: when I pay for a product like a baby stroller from a western company, which part of this money is spent on "law abiding", i.e. the verbose amount of warnings sticked everywhere and all the lawyers behind? I just bought one and this kind stroller tells me loudly I'm stupid from every side of it. I had a Japanese stroller before: cheaper, lighter, just better for kids and parents in every respect, and a just a brief non-liability warning. If I put 4 ten year old fat kid is will break, OBviously. That would be my fault.
- userbinator 10y agoIndeed, this feels like it's just an attempt at riding onto the "Samsung=explosion" bandwagon. A quick search on YouTube shows plenty of washing machines spinning themselves apart, not only Samsung but LG, GE, and a few others, and going back several years too. This failure mode is not new, it's not specific to Samsung, and IMHO it's also partly operator error combined with the increased fragility of cost-down optimisation. I wouldn't even call it an explosion, as the drum itself remains intact --- all the damage is from the extreme vibrations breaking off everything else. ...and just for fun, there's also plenty of videos of deliberately unbalanced machines doing the same, for a bit of sordid entertainment and as a reminder of why you should always take care to balance the load. Here's one rather amusing example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dq6T5BojXc8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dq6T5BojXc8
- jschwartzi 10y agoTo be fair to the operators, they may not have reason to believe that their machines are overloaded or unbalanced. I've washed a lot of clothes in my life. It's been my experience that even properly loaded machines will occasionally shift the load in such a way as to become severely unbalanced. I don't think it's such a cut and dried case of operator negligence. The machines themselves provide little to no feedback to the operator. Older machines had clutches installed which would prevent the machine from spinning the drum hard enough to vibrate the machine apart. If Samsung et. al. have removed this hardware safeguard from their machine, they better have a damn good story to justify why they don't need it.
- AstralStorm 10y agoDirect drive? That said, then there should be a weighing mechanism and correct slow start procedure to balance the load. Probably an accelerometer to slow down if a vibration threshold is exceeded. I am talking about safeguards costing pennies per machine, including implementation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- schiffern 10y ago>In fact, I know that these machines do have warnings to not overload them. What more could reasonably be expected of Samsung? The question of what to "expect" is beyond my pay-grade, but this sounds like a design problem. The traditional solution to this problem is an interlock (eg microwave doors). An accelerometer might sense when vibrations exceed safe limits and limit the drum speed or cancel the cycle. As Don Norman points out, text labels are a sign of unclear design.[1] Do washing machine users and and washing machine designers have the same definition of "overloading?" Can you show it graphically? Project a laser level? Change the shape of the door or front cover? A visual line directly in the drum itself? (the drum ideally returns to a 'home' position) [1] http://99percentinvisible.org/article/norman-doors-dont-know-whether-push-pull-blame-design/ http://99percentinvisible.org/article/norman-doors-dont-know...
- maxerickson 10y agoOdds are that it does sense abnormal vibrations but that there is a corner case where it gets up to speed and a load shift causes it to blow out before the stopping mechanism kicks in.
- AstralStorm 10y agoAt least the shell should be strong enough to not turn into shrapnel.
- rayiner 10y agoWarnings only get you so far. A reasonable consumer might expect overloading the machine to cause vibration and shaking, maybe damage to the motor. But not that level of physical destruction and damage to nearby property.
- ams6110 10y agoMy mom's old Kenmore washer, from the 1960s, had a shut-off and buzzer triggered by an off-balance load. It's nothing complicated or novel.
- HillRat 10y agoSamsung (and LG) washers have design peculiarities that seem to be unique to them. For example, the bearings are actually part of the drum, so if they fail (a not-uncommon occurrence), you end up effectively having to replace the entire washer. (Ask me how I know!) So it doesn't surprise me that Samsung has other engineering issues baked into their products.
- makomk 10y agoEvery washing machine now has bearings as part of the drum, so if they fail you have to replace the entire washer (at least here in the UK). It's not a Samsung design peculiarity, it's just another example of the rise of planned obsolescence.
- fatbird 10y agoConsumers generally have a quite reasonable expectation that their products aren't dangerous in non-obvious ways. A knife might cut me if heavily used or misused, and I couldn't possibly sue in that case; if the blade leached toxins into the food I cut with it, I'd sue and so would anyone else. Much law turns on various "reasonable person" standards. A reasonable person, IMHO, does't expect a violent, potentially lethal, mechanical disintegration just for overloading the drum by 10%.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y ago"... potentially lethal." With a heavy thing that rotates at 1600min-1 you should think what you are doing and consider the thing being potentially lethal.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWe've invented consumer regulations so that you don't have to fear death or injury from a random common item you buy. Otherwise... are you keeping your smartphone in your pocket? Are you aware that this thing is basically a live grenade, held together by cheap manufacturing and good wishes of engineers who designed the battery controller?
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoYes. Accidentally (!) I have a Note 7 ;-) On a sidenote: I think physics always trumps "consumer regulations". I do not believe in the power of law above physics, e.g. IMHO a law that declares gravity illegal would not work. A heavy thing rotating at 1600/min is potentially lethal, you can put as much engineering in it as you want. Yes you can make it safer, but it remains potentially lethal. It's the physics of a heavy thing that rotates at 1600/min.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoSo is the physics of lithium-ion batteries. Just as you don't worry about your phone exploding in your pocket (the generic you; you specifically should worry given you have Note 7 :P), you shouldn't have to worry about a washing machine accidentally mauling you. Sure it may happen, but consumer regulations are written to direct manufacturing towards minimizing that kind of occurences to below "I have to consciously care about it" level.
- stonemetal 10y agoIt should be reasonable to fill the drum in the washing machine with clothes you expect it to wash. It is borderline fraud to make a washing machine that can hold 10 shirts but explodes as soon as you run it with more than 6. They have a label that says don't overload it, but without explicit markings that say a load is 6 shirts I would assume overloading meant the drum can hold 10 so don't put 14 in there. It isn't as if the user is doing something unexpected like loading it with bricks.
- AstralStorm 10y agoIt is borderline libel to imply this is the case without sources and description of the load. More than one person can play this game.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoA modern washing machine, if not level and/or overloaded, will shut off. And then you'll have to rebalance your load and turn it back on again. This has been common since decades ago. Is it too much to expect Samsung to have implemented a standard feature everyone else in the industry doesn't seem to have a problem with?
- sspiff 10y ago> In fact, I know that these machines do have warnings to not overload them. What more could reasonably be expected of Samsung? Overload detection and automatic shutdown in case of excessive loads maybe?
- joezydeco 10y agoIf it turns out that a mounting bracket or some other structure used to hold the tub in place has failed, either from corrosion or fatigue, then it should be expected that Samsung take responsibility for the problem. You design these things to handle the load and stresses seen in an imbalance before the safety mechanism can shut it down.
- limeyx 10y ago"What more could reasonably be expected of Samsung?" Goodness knows, I'm sure making a noisy beeping sound, printing "Load too heavy/unbalanced" on the LCD and refusing to run would be totally unreasonable ?
- antod 10y agoI hadn't heard of Samsung washing machines exploding before. Catching fire is what they usually do. http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/95yearold-woman-rescued-from-samsung-washing-machine-fire-in-auburn-20160813-gqrvzd.html http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/95yearold-woman-rescued-from-samsu... http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/news/81798360/Thousands-of-burning-washing-machines-still-at-large-as-another-goes-up-in-flames http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/news/81798360/Thousands...
- femto 10y ago200+ since 2010. Even "fixed" machines are bursting into flame, so Australian owners are being urged to go for a return rather than a repair. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-14/samsung-washine-machine-recall-sydney-fire-nsw-white-goods/7732858 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-14/samsung-washine-machin... https://www.choice.com.au/home-and-living/laundry-and-cleaning/washing-machines/articles/samsung-washing-machine-recall-110815 https://www.choice.com.au/home-and-living/laundry-and-cleani... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3505540/Samsung-face-coronial-inquiry-washing-machines-recalled.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3505540/Samsung-face... http://www.samsung.com/au/washingmachinerecall/ http://www.samsung.com/au/washingmachinerecall/
- userbinator 10y agoLooking at the affected models, they all seem to have one thing in common: far too much plastic. At least the cabinet is still metal, which helped contain those fires. The cause of the fires is apparently an overheated electrical connection, but on a machine with far less flammable parts all that would happen is probably a little smoke and it'd just stop working.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoIt's sad that they knew about it, which meant they calculated that: E{cost} = P(failure) * {expected lawsuit payout} < {cost of recall and actually fixing the problem} Just like in Fight Club...
- AstralStorm 10y agoExcept loss of brand image and trust is more expensive.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoLike any typical customer buying a washing machine will know about this. Like any shop selling washing machines will actually care. Like any of us will remember about this six months from now. Brand image is overrated. A lot of companies know that, and that's why they get away with all the shit they do.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoBrand image is a marketing/PR problem, not a tech/engineering problem.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoWorst case scenario, they can just rebrand themselves. Samsung does a lot of things: Cars, phones, refrigerators, TVs, life insurance... it's pretty diversified, so if there's a Samsung washing machine recall, I don't think that Koreans will cancel their life insurance policies. Did you know Kenmore washing machines are actually LG? I didn't either until now... it's all too easy to just do a rebrand or latch onto somebody else's as a supplier, if things go nuclear. To say nothing of calling in the emergency PR salvaging operation (like Lenovo did just recently with their BIOS update that locked out Linux on its consumer ultrabooks -- just have the press deflect blame on Intel for not jumping through onerous hoops to support Lenovo's crazy single-drive RAID scheme on Linux, but I digress).
- lostlogin 10y agoI was certain this was going to involve a Ford and a fuel tank.
- tellarin 10y agoIf this happens to washing machines, I guess it either was a pretty good idea for them to sell their Techwin subsidiary a couple years ago, or they miss working in that field. :)
- brownbat 10y agoReminded me of that story about IBM's Black Team: http://www.penzba.co.uk/GreybeardStories/TheBlackTeam.html http://www.penzba.co.uk/GreybeardStories/TheBlackTeam.html And wind turbine fail compilations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfzgIxMEo8g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfzgIxMEo8g Physics is mean, especially when you're trying to spin heavy things really fast.
- 0xmohit 10y agoOne might say that Samsung products are truly dynamite!
- fpgaminer 10y agoMy Samsung washing machine is already on the list of things to replace. It came along with the place I'm at, and the previous owners apparently didn't know that front loading machines need to be left open when not in use. Upon our initial load of the machine we discovered it to be filled with swathes of mold/fungus. Took a week of heavy, caustic cleaning to get it usable. Apparently it's a fairly common issue with frontloaders; only recently did manufacturers get around to including sanitizing features. Knowing that Samsung is selling machines that explode and catch fire ... I guess I'll bump our replacement up on the schedule. I do like the little ditty it plays when its done though. Reminds me of traveling through eastern Asia. Cute ditties seemed to be very common over there, from vending machines to garbage trucks. It's a small thing, but it has a way of brightening your surroundings the way an ice cream truck in America does.
- dc_gregory 10y agoGosh, the finish tone on my one goes for a solid minute or more. After the initial load, I was considering unsoldering the speaker until a search provided the secret key combination to turn the damn thing off.
- icanhackit 10y agoStill better than my old LG washer-dryer which would sound an alarm when it had finished, only the door would remain locked for the next minute or so afterwards. So you'd go to empty it, realise that it was still locked despite only being on a wash cycle, wander off to do something else and forget about it, then remember the next day that you had washing sitting in the machine. By this time it smells stale and you have to wash it again. So you set a timer slightly longer than the wash cycle to remind you to take out the washing. Success! Only then you load another pile of clothes and forget to set another timer. Fuuuuu... Purchased a Bosch washer-dryer after the LG decided it no longer wanted to pump water out of the machine, eventually flooding our hallway. The Bosch works nicely - you can open it when the alarm sounds! - but you have to reset the cycle toggle for every new load (basically set it to off then on again) otherwise it just beeps at you and won't start the cycle. If we can buy $50 touch-screen smart phones with a fully fledged OS in the supermarket, why can't we bolt similar devices to dumb microwaves, washers etc to make them smarter? I mean, why do I have to dig out a manual to figure out what the fuck error D7 means?
- Animats 10y agoIs Samsung making washing machines without out-of-balance detection? That was figured out by 1960. Today, a 3-axis accelerometer chip is $0.86, quantity 1. If a microprocessor is running the machine, the way it should operate is to back off the spin speed if it detects excessive vibration. As water drains out, the maximum speed at which vibration appears should increase. If that doesn't happen, shut down and sound the out of balance alarm.
- jpalomaki 10y agoMaybe the problem is not the missing technology but just about finding the right balance between preventing explosions and keeping the machine running. If the machine plays it too safe, consumers are likely not satisfied.
- simonh 10y agoBut if there's a bug in the software, all bets are off. This is really what concerns me about their patch for the Note 7 that attempts to reduce the chance if the battery exploding by limiting the charge to 60%. We've go no reason to trust their software engineering any more than their hardware engineering.
- devopsproject 10y agoI think the reason for the 60% limit is to "motivate" users to do the exchange, not to prevent the failure.
- marmaduke 10y agoI've a Samsung washing machine, and it usually spends about 15 minutes dicking about, spinning slowly in random directions, before actually starting to wash clothes. If it can't balance the clothes, it complains loudly. I've rarely ever heard it knocking while spinning dry. Granted, it seems European machines are smaller and faster compared to US so maybe they spend a little more effort here, becase they would explode if misbalanced and spinning at 1400 rpm.
- userbinator 10y ago
- known 10y agoIs out-of-balance relevant to driver-less cars?
- cheenwy 10y agoWhat do you mean?
- Insanity 10y agoMaybe they are slowly trying to make their way into the weapons industry :D
- AstralStorm 10y agoNah, a subsidiary already produces automated cannons that are then placed on Korean border.
- lostlogin 10y agoOdd, as they have factories on both sides.
- AstralStorm 10y agoAh yes, that has been sold and split off more strongly recently.
- lorenzhs 10y agoThey've been doing that since ~1984, but sold it to Hanwha (another South Korean conglomerate) less than two years ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_Techwin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_Techwin
- jbb555 10y agoWhile this obviously is a bad thing, the article seems overly dramatic. "... could have been hurt" "... count have damaged".... But in fact not.
- kefka 10y agoWe have a Samsung refrigerator. Worst purchase ever. The condenser coil in the fridge portion accumulates ice all over the fins and fan, and causes the fridge/freezer to gradually lose cooling. Samsung refuses to honor the warranty about this issue. I've jury-rigged 2 temp sensors with a photodiode to my existing IoT infrastructure (https://hackaday.io/project/12985-multisite-homeofficehackerspace-automation https://hackaday.io/project/12985-multisite-homeofficehacker...). As of right now, if the temp goes over a set point for more than 5 minutes with door closed, an alarm will be sent to our lights and my laptop (wherever it may be). But this alarm means I have to take out the bottom shelves, unscrew the panel, and clean out the ice with a heat gun. It's better than having spoiled food.
- userbinator 10y agoI think you meant the evaporator; ice on the condenser would mean it's running backwards! Was it advertised as having automatic defrost/"frost-free"? Not all are. If you live in a humid climate, even the auto defrost may not be sufficient to remove all the frost.
- kefka 10y agoI'll certainly not correct you! I'm not a pro by any means on HVAC and chiller technology. I just came up with a solution, albeit not a "good" one. I do know one thing; I'll never buy Samsung again. I know, whatever it's called, has copper pipes hooked up to a heatsink, with a blower fan that spreads the chilled air. It's in the bottom of the fridge side, inside the refrigerator chamber. The failure mode, which is evidently widespread online, is that condensation seizes up the fan blower, stops the fan, and temps rise gradually.
- Retric 10y agoIt sounds like a poor design, you can try some things that might keep ice from accumulating, Fridge outside temperature should be low (~72 f) and outside of direct sunlight. The evaporation coils need good airflow (a tiny fan can significantly increase efficiency.) I would verify there is a tight seal around the door and the water drip is clog free.
- theklub 10y agoI have a Samsung dishwasher and it's by far the worst large appliance I've ever had to deal with. I'll never buy Samsung again.
- merraksh 10y agoThe news of another exploding Samsung product offered the Internet plenty of fodder. I don't find it useful to reproduce sarcastic tweets in the middle of a Washington Post article. I believe it does not add any information to what the article is describing, and actually makes it look more like infotainment. The issue is already serious and interesting enough.
- redsummer 10y agoWhen buying a washing machine, there is really no point in buying anything other than a Miele or Bosch product. The same is true of most other kitchen appliances. They may seem expensive, but it's a false economy to buy anything else.
- vinay427 10y agoIf you can afford one, this is good advice in my anecdotal experience as well. A family member had a supposedly fancy Fisher and Paykel (NZ) dishwasher that cost more than the Bosch they ended up sticking with, and didn't clean dishes nearly as well even after servicing it regularly and having it inspected by a company rep. Meanwhile, the Bosch cleans far better and more quietly though it does need its filter (?) cleaned more regularly, if I recall correctly. Also, Miele vacuums are amazing for their reliability and durability compared to something like a Dyson, which has over the years evolved into an overpriced and poorly built item.
- ascorbic 10y agoHow popular are top loaders vs front loaders in the US? This seems a flaw inherent to top loading machines. Gravity stops uneven loads in front loaders.
- mirekrusin 10y agoMaybe they should pivot to be an army contractor?
- tripzilch 10y agoSo, almost all situations described in this thread would fall under legal warranty in the EU. Which is at least 2 years in the case of big appliances like washing machines. Importantly, the warranty is between the buyer and the seller, not the manufacturer. They must either repair (within reasonable time), replace with equal or better model (at no extra cost) or give your money back. The point is that the buyer reasonably can expect a certain kind of functionality from the product when they buy it, such as a washing machine actually cleaning your clothes, not destroying them and functioning properly at least 2 years. If not, buyer and seller must come to a reasonable solution (it's all very reasonable). Although the seller tends to try to point to the manufacturer and sometimes manages to convince buyer to pay some of the costs, they shouldn't have. Anyway, Samsung would be pretty stupid if they didn't pay extra care to manufacturing quality of products sold in the EU because of this. This implies that other regions that do not have this legal warranty because the free market demands it, necessarily must get slightly-less-carefully-quality-controlled items. Avoiding Samsung because of this seems like setting yourself up for the next brand to screw you over.