4 ms·
I asked about the possibility of doing this type of thing on CS Stack Exchange two years ago. http://cs.stackexchange.com/questions/22317/does-there-exist-a-da
by ilaksh 10y ago
I asked about the possibility of doing this type of thing on CS Stack Exchange two years ago.
http://cs.stackexchange.com/questions/22317/does-there-exist-a-data-compression-algorithm-that-uses-a-large-dataset-distribu http://cs.stackexchange.com/questions/22317/does-there-exist...
They basically ripped me a new one said it was a stupid idea and that I shouldnt make suggestions in a question. Then I took the suggestions and details out (but left the basic concept in there) and they gave me a lecture on basics of image compression.
Made me really not want to try to discuss anything with anyone after that.
- joantune 10y agoWell thought of, seriously, people can be too negative. It's obvious that on a theoretical standpoint a RNN can help with compression... A while ago I thought about a RNN or a NN for encryption i.e. cracking it (I had did something like post on that topic.. but saw no replies whatsoever).. gonna try to find that if someone's interested
- CamperBob2 10y agoSomebody is going to have to start something up that can replace Stack Exchange.
- dhon_ 10y agoIf it still features human responders then it will probably suffer the same issues. Maybe we can train neural networks to answer programming problems?
- baq 10y agoyeah the moderation there is getting a bit out of hand, recently they've deleted my answer (which was a direct quote, with reference link provided, formatted as a quote) because it was 'plagiarism'. before that they requested to quote from the link - the quotes were added in an edit.
- nl 10y agoExpecting 2 years of research by around 20 of the best DNN researchers on the planet to be compressed into a StackOverflow answer before it has been done seems a fairly large amount to expect. Not a huge fan of the negativity on StackOverflow, but until August 2016 (when the paper this was based on was published - or maybe 2015, with DRAW[2]) people actively working in this area didn't think it was possible. Also, the single answer there certainly didn't say anything like it was a stupid idea. I don't think the author of that answer knew much about autoencoders. Also^2, your question isn't really anything like what this addresses. Your question concentrates on the idea of compressing a large set of images, and sharing some kind of representation. That certainly is possible without using a ML approach. And yes, autoencoders have been around for a long time. But hoverboards are a great idea, too. [1] This paper has 7 authors, Gregor et al has 5 authors, DRAW has 6. [2] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1502.04623v2.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1502.04623v2.pdf
- ilaksh 10y agoIt really is like what it addresses.