12 ms·
‘Sticker Shock’ in Los Angeles Housing
- surfmike 10y agoWhen people say "30% of your income is spent on housing," do they usually mean pre-tax or post-tax? The article claims you need $145K a year to afford a $2000/month apartment. But assuming that you lose 40% to taxes, you would still be left with $5,250 a month after housing. That sounds a lot higher than it should be for the lower limit of affordability. If you assume 30% of pre-tax income, and $2000/month rent, you get a required income of $80,000 -- still high, but not as outrageous as the figure he comes up with.
- wott 10y agoThe first paragraph says how much a resident would need to make to spend 30 percent of earned after-tax income on rent for a two-bedroom apartment.
- surfmike 10y agoIt sounds like he's using a different standard than is commonly used (i.e. 30% pretax is the often cited standard)
- ksenzee 10y agoFiguring this pre-tax isn't very useful. If you were in the (theoretical) 70% tax bracket and you spent 30% of your pre-tax income on housing, you'd starve.
- surfmike 10y agoSure except taxes aren't that high in California. 30-45% is a much more realistic range for income taxes (state + federal + payroll).
- dschuler 10y agoWhere are they higher, in the US? It's hard to imagine paying more than that and still not getting free healthcare and 4 weeks min. vacation, as you would in Germany, for example.
- laurencerowe 10y agoThe US spends almost as much on public healthcare as EU countries - a couple of %GDP less than Germany but the same as the UK - and then the same amount again of private healthcare. That it gets so much less for its money shows how effective the medical-insurance complex js been at lobbying. In California we enjoy US levels of public services with European levels of taxation and landowners get rich. (Taxation doesn't pay for vacation.)
- refurb 10y agoWhat's the connection between taxes and the amount of vacation you get?
- harmmonica 10y agoThe article says post tax but the standard is closer to what you're saying. For a landlord renting a property, for instance, the safe rule of thumb is typically for your tenant to have a gross annual salary of 40x the monthly rent (which for a 2k rental would be 80k gross salary). Using 145k is way too conservative. Similarly, when buying a house, the debt-to-income ratio is calculated on gross (pre tax) income as well and is 28% for housing costs (principal, interest, taxes and insurance), which lines up pretty well with the standard rental calculation.
- irrational 10y agoHuh, maybe it's time for my family to move on up since my gross annual salary is 80x my current housing payment.
- jdavis703 10y agoWell there goes your retirement savings... (Assuming that's where your extra money was going).
- cmurf 10y agoOr buy a 2nd house, or increase savings. The big problem spending more than 30% is if you're a renter, it make savings, even a rainy day fun let alone longer term or a moving budget, much harder.
- twblalock 10y agoThe scale changes as your income increases. As you pointed out, someone who makes $145k could easily spend 30%, or even 50%, of pre-tax income on housing and still have more left over than most peoples' entire monthly income. On the other hand, someone making $40k per year who spends 30% of pre-tax income on housing is going to have a pretty tight budget. So, these are all pretty rough guidelines, and the best thing to do is to spend an amount on housing that does not compromise your other financial goals, no matter what the percentage happens to be.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoYep, our days here are numbered. Every thread on our community FB group has a hordes of people fighting any new construction (including housing) tooth and nail, even on lots filled with stripmalls, decrepit crackhouses, or asphalt parking, keeping LA decidedly third-world--it boggles the mind. Our rent went up 7% this year alone.
- rcthompson 10y agoI wonder if this is a general problem, where property owners in an area have both the power to influence the local government's land use policy and an incentive to limit new construction in order to create artificial scarcity and drive up the prices of their own property. Is this guaranteed to exacerbate any housing shortage anywhere'
- spoonie 10y agoSeems like a local governance 'problem'. Are homeowners more likely to vote than renters? Or do homeowners and landlords outnumber renters and get the rational outcomes they want?
- mahyarm 10y agoRetried & unemployed people have the time to participate in local politics compared to the employed people with young families. On top of that they have the highest financial incentive to NIMBY to reduce their personal risk in their house equity since they have fewer earning years left and more value to capture. Over a large amount of people, this imbalance leads to older NIMBYs to become a naturally occurring political force in local politics.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoThis is very much true. If renters and young people were more engaged in local politics this wouldn't happen. It's baffling to me how engaged people are with Federal politics, where many of the issues are distant and may never affect peoples' lives, while at the same time they have zero interest in local politics, which affects their lives closely, directly, every day. Additionally municipal government is so approachable and citizens have incredible access. You can just email people and they'll get back to you. You can go to meetings and address council directly. In my town of 600k+ I've coincidentally came across a councillor on the street multiple times.
- geggam 10y agoLA is cheap Come to the SF Bay area...
- ksenzee 10y agoLet's not pretend because SF has problems that nobody else's problems are any big deal.
- snerbles 10y agoThis is also known as the Fallacy of Relative Privation.
- geggam 10y agoRelativity... its a thing ;)
- jfoutz 10y agoKind of a tangent, but isn't the Los Angeles area much more populous than the bay area? Sure the problem might not be quite as severe as SF, but it affects 2.5x the number of people.
- enraged_camel 10y agoLA has more people, but also much more land. The entire stretch from SF on the other hand is surrounded by water on three sides, and the valley in general is... well, a valley. Surrounded by mountains. To get a good sense of this, open Google Maps and center it on California. You'll get a sense of how different the two areas are in terms of sprawl. LA is basically one big concrete jungle from Burbank all the way to Anaheim. SF area is much more densely packed.
- jfoutz 10y agoI've visited both, but lived in neither. Yeah, SF itself isn't even a million people, LA 3.4 million. The bay area gets up to 7 million, but greater LA is 18 million. SF did feel much denser. The sort of standard answer is just build more housing, but the cities are already so congested. Building up would surely lower prices in both cities, but i think it'd make bad commutes worse. I dunno. If there was an easy answer, people would just do that. For a long time the easy answer was just drive farther. That's becoming less of an option now and it's not clear what, if anything, should be done. In any case, it's easier to convince 100,000 people than it is to convince a million, and it's easier to convince a million than it is to convince 10 million. Whatever the answer is is going to take some serious politics.
- s0uthPaw88 10y agoI love living in Los Angeles as a single, 20 something, but the thought of trying to raise a family here terrifies me. The median price of a 3 bedroom home is $865,000 which would mean that a large portion of my long term net worth would end up tied to a single asset. When it comes time to put down roots, I'll head to cheaper pastures.
- nawtacawp 10y agoColorado is calling.
- costatus 10y agoColorado is full thank you to move somewhere else and transform some other state into california.
- biocomputation 10y agoNative Washingtonian. We're also full.
- int_19h 10y agoNative? Which tribe are you from?
- biocomputation 10y agoHere's the Merriam-Webster definition in case you don't know what native means. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/native http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/native Is there a reason you raised the issue of race? Does my race matter? If so, I'd just LOVE to see you explain why.
- int_19h 10y agoYour race doesn't really matter, no. But neither does your native-born origin. You don't get to lay an exclusive claim on the arbitrarily defined geopolitical unit on the basis that you happened to be born there.
- droithomme 10y ago> What does it take to be middle class in Los Angeles? That was the question Ross DeVol started out asking himself when he began calculating how much a resident would need to make to spend 30 percent of earned after-tax income on rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Los Angeles County. I disagree with the author that this is middle class. A two bedroom apartment is the very definition of impoverished lower class loser, just above homeless. Middle class means a detached 3 bedroom in the suburbs, with biweekly maid service, two financed cars, health care to the point you don't need to worry about it at all, and buying whatever you want at the supermarket. What middle class does not include is any one of: a mansion, live in staff, a yacht, full time nannies instead of occasional baby sitters, swiss boarding school for the children, a groomsman for the horse, a pool boy, a cabana, a private plane, or zero income tax. This is what skilled factory workers and teachers had in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s. Above them, designers, engineers and lawyers, comprised the upper class, or upper middle class.
- Aloha 10y ago>Middle class means a detached 3 bedroom in the suburbs, with biweekly maid service, two financed cars, health care to the point you don't need to worry about it at all, and buying whatever you want at the supermarket. This to me is the very definition of upper middle class. Middle class (for a family) to means a 2-3 bedroom house in the suburbs, at least two cars (with one likely under financing), health care to the point you don't need to worry about it at all, and food shopping on a very large, but not unlimited budget. Plus the ability to take a vacation at least once a year to a regional destination. For someone single different rules apply.
- x3n0ph3n3 10y ago> I disagree with the author that this is middle class. A two bedroom apartment is the very definition of impoverished lower class loser, just above homeless. Apparently I'm an impoverished loser who makes more than 10% of the US population.
- wott 10y agoThat's the point.
- happytrails 10y agoI'm looking to buy in LA and everything is old as shiz and over 800k :( Oh well, at least I can rep the 323 and shout tupac lines
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoBargain hunting in Compton?
- gjolund 10y agoMy friend just bought a 2 bedroom in Compton for $600k. I didn't have the heart to tell him his mortgage will be underwater in a couple years.
- eiliant 10y agoelaborate?
- xienze 10y agoIt's a house. In Compton. That cost $600K.
- smrtinsert 10y agoIf it looks like insanity its probably genius in real estate.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> everything is old What's wrong with old? In Europe houses are regularly hundreds of years old and it's not a problem.
- carsongross 10y agoNominal interest rates are zero. We are living through the largest debt bubble in history. How is it surprising that assets are all incredibly overpriced? Yes, of course it will end in tears.
- shostack 10y agoBut what would cause it to pop? There is still insane demand in popular areas, in large part because that's where the jobs are. I could only see that becoming more true in a down market.
- atemerev 10y agoYou have answered your own question — it will pop when jobs stop growing.
- carsongross 10y agoYep. And it will be reflexive, since the debt was loaned out against future production, exacerbating the downturn. Some cities might become safe havens for Chinese wealth, not much individuals can do about that except wait it out and hope that the US government starts working in the interests of its broader population, rather than the already rich landowners in a few cities. At a higher level, this is why privately issued debt is no way to manage your money supply.
- shostack 10y agoRight, but what will be the catalyst that stops jobs growing? And would it necessarily be uniform to all geographic areas? The housing crisis was unique in that it impacted people across the nation. Likewise with the dotcom bust since that was all about the public markets. What would have a similar effect today? If tech jobs are killing other jobs/industries, wouldn't that lead to a situation where the tech market is still really strong with jobs, but other areas decline (and thus housing prices may stay the same in say, the Bay Area, but decline in another impacted area)? Just trying to extrapolate things out. Yes obviously if jobs stopped growing everywhere at once, things would crash. But what would cause that? It seems more likely that they would stop growing at different rates, and some may even grow more as a result. As such, we might see more weird fluctuations in the markets, but that isn't a popping event per se.
- sv7n 10y agoB-build A-absolutely N-nothing A-anywhere N-near A-anything
- Simaramis 10y agoIts a silly attitude to deny development. There is plenty of room for more people, on the planet, in LA.Just get organized.I live in Venice but friends in Hollywood I see maybe 4 times a year because driving is numbing. Robocars are gonna improve things greatly.That said, LA is full of itself.You will pay through the nose for property that shouldvbe torn down, yet you are not allowed to. I am a Euro transplant and I have travelled the U.S.for the past dozen years and there is hardly a bad spot anymore.You get great food, culture, people many many places. Madison WI, Bozeman, Raleigh, Detroit even, even Texas. Lot of people are stuck in LA molasses.
- mdorazio 10y agoAs someone who has been in LA for a while, I think the "sticker shock" isn't coming from the housing cost so much as from the salaries that aren't keeping up with it. If you want to live in a nice location with a short commute then you're going to be paying over 1600/mo for a 1 bedroom. But if salaries were at Bay Area level that would be a bargain, especially given the weather, beach access, night life, etc. that LA offers compared to other cities. Unfortunately, salaries here are not great, even in the small tech scene on the west side.
- taternuts 10y agoHaving just moved to the Playa Vista area, $2,000 for a 2 bedroom seems like a steal