5 ms·
We have bases on Antarctica, and they're not self sustaining. Consider that Antarctica is far more liveable and closer than Mars.
by goatlover 10y ago
We have bases on Antarctica, and they're not self sustaining. Consider that Antarctica is far more liveable and closer than Mars.
- jboggan 10y agoFacilities for re-supply are so close and economical there is no incentive to make them self-sustaining. But it could be done.
- mikeash 10y agoNobody has tried to make them self-sustaining. It's not as if people have tried and failed.
- Alupis 10y ago>Nobody has tried to make them self-sustaining. It's not as if people have tried and failed. I'm certain folks have tried on Antarctica (we've had constant human presence there for decades). However, we still failed even under a much more controlled and hospitable environment - Biosphere 2. Biosphere 2[1] failed because of our lack of understanding of our own ecosystems on earth. A minute imbalance led to the entire ecosystem failing. The issue with Mars isn't getting there (or back) - government's have been doing this for more than a decade. The issue with Mars is getting people there, alive... and keeping them alive for the duration of the mission, and then returning them home alive. We're only now starting to explore the effects of microgravity on the human body - and having not figured out how to mitigate some serious issues (such as your eyes losing shape, causing you to go blind[2]), we're not going to be able to seriously consider long duration space travel, let alone inhabit another planet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2 [2] http://www.space.com/25392-manned-mars-mission-astronaut-vision.html http://www.space.com/25392-manned-mars-mission-astronaut-vis...
- mikeash 10y agoWhy are you certain folks have tried to make a self-sustaining Antarctic colony? I don't see why anyone would bother. You can get supplies from the outside. Activity on the continent transitioned directly from exploration to scientific outposts. Biosphere 2 was in many ways more challenging than Mars. It was intended to be totally self-contained with all water and oxygen recycled. On Mars, water can be found outside, and oxygen can be made from the atmosphere industrially. The transit time to Mars with this system is 3-4 months. Astronauts have already spent far more time in orbit than that. There are negative effects, yes, but blindness isn't one of them (and your link doesn't even list blindness as a potential consequence, just impaired vision). It's possible that the reduced gravity on Mars would continue to cause harm, but I rather doubt that it would be so bad as to make the whole venture impossible. Maybe Martians have bad eyesight and shortened lives, but nobody's doing this for their health anyway.
- Alupis 10y ago> Why are you certain folks have tried to make a self-sustaining Antarctic colony? I don't see why anyone would bother. You can get supplies from the outside. Activity on the continent transitioned directly from exploration to scientific outposts. Nobody said they _had_ to, but I'm sure someone has tried over the years out of a scientific interest. (Although I have no source for this, so it's unsubstantiated unless someone digs something up). > The transit time to Mars with this system is 3-4 months Travel time depends on trajectory, however safe estimates usually are around 6 months each way.[1] > It's possible that the reduced gravity on Mars would continue to cause harm, but I rather doubt that it would be so bad as to make the whole venture impossible Well, the effects we're observing now (for the first time!) are largely from Scott Kelly[2]'s year in microgravity. Going to mars and back takes around 1 year's time (6 months approximately each way), plus we assume they'll stay on the surface longer than a few hours... so these may prove to be serious complications. The scary thing is, few talk about these issues when dreaming about traveling to Mars (Musk included, apparently). [1] http://www.universetoday.com/14841/how-long-does-it-take-to-get-to-mars/ http://www.universetoday.com/14841/how-long-does-it-take-to-... [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Kelly_(astronaut) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Kelly_(astronaut)
- friendlygrammar 10y agoBiosphere 2 didn't succeed because it wasn't run by scientists.